The roles and experiences of informal carers providing care to people with advanced cancer in Africa-A systematic review and critical interpretive analysis

Examination of the relationship between the empathic tendencies and sleep quality of caregivers of cancer patients

PURPOSE

The present study aims to reveal the relationship between the empathic tendencies and sleep quality of caregivers of cancer patients.

MATERIAL AND METHOD

This cross-sectional study was conducted with caregivers of cancer patients registered in the oncology unit of a hospital between May and July 2024 (n = 346). The study data were collected using a sociodemographic information form, the Empathic Tendency Scale, and the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index. The data were analyzed using the Pearson correlation and hierarchical regression analyses as well as descriptive statistics.

FINDINGS

59.5% of the participants were female and 88.2% lived with patients. 62.7% of the cancer patients were male and 61.1% were partially dependent in daily life activities. The caregivers had a mean total score of 70.58 ± 16.85 on the Empathic Tendency Scale and a mean total score of 4.40 ± 3.94 on the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index. It was found that there was a negative, strong, and statistically significant relationship between the mean total scores on the Empathic Tendency Scale and the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (r = - 0.924; p < 0.001). According to the hierarchical regression model, certain sociodemographic features of the caregivers explained the variance in empathic tendency (Adj. R2 = 0.607; p < 0.001), whereas when sleep quality components were added to the model, the variance in empathic tendency was explained (Adj. R2 = 0.896; p < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

The caregivers of cancer patients were found to have high empathic tendencies, which was associated with high sleep quality. Furthermore, low empathic tendencies among the caregivers were found to be primarily associated with increasing length of care and advancing patient age. The findings underscore the pivotal role that empathic approaches play in enhancing the quality of care, underscoring the necessity for augmented interventions that prioritize a compassionate approach, and the management of empathy in caregivers of cancer patients.

Health and economic impact of caregiving on informal caregivers of people with chronic diseases in sub-Saharan Africa: A systematic review

With a disproportionate burden of chronic diseases and severe shortage of health workers in sub-Saharan Africa, the region implicitly relies on informal caregivers (ICGs) to support the patients both within and outside the health facilities. The aim of this review is to systematically summarise evidence on the health and economic impact of caregiving on informal caregivers of patients with chronic diseases in sub-Saharan Africa. Medline (Ovid), CINAHL (EBSCOhost), PsycINFO (Ovid), Embase (Ovid), Global Health, and Web of Science databases were systematically searched to identify original articles that considered the economic and/or health impacts of caregiving in sub-Saharan Africa. The results from the included studies were synthesised narratively. After screening 4,951 records, 47 studies were included for synthesis. The articles were from all sub-regions of sub-Saharan Africa with more than half (25/47) of the studies focussing on caregivers for patients with cancer. Although the primary motivation for becoming caregivers was love and responsibility, the caring responsibilities described in twenty studies, had profound effects on the caregiver's lives. Healthwise, the informal caregivers experienced changes in their physical and mental health like developing musculoskeletal problems and depression. Economically, caregiving was expensive, and financially draining. The opportunity cost of caregiving included loss of jobs, loss of income, foregoing planned important activities and missed education opportunities. Informal caregivers reported a range of mainly negative health and economic effects of the work they do. Health care systems should consider how to better support caregivers in terms of their own physical and mental wellbeing. Also, governments should develop strategies to financially support informal caregivers.

Ambivalent and heavy burdened wanderers on a road less travelled: a meta-ethnography on end-of-life care experiences among family caregivers in rural areas

BACKGROUND

As the population ages, more people will be diagnosed with cancer, and they will live longer due to receiving better treatment and optimized palliative care. Family members will be expected to take on more responsibilities related to providing palliative care at home. Several countries have expressed their vision of making home death an option, but such a vision can be more challenging in rural areas. There is a lack of synthesized research providing an in-depth understanding of rural family caregiving for people with cancer at the end of life. Thus, the purpose of this study was to synthesize and reinterpret the findings from qualitative research on rural family caregivers of adult cancer patients at the end of life.

METHODS

We conducted a meta-ethnography following Noblit and Hare's approach. A systematic literature search of four databases and extensive manual searches were completed in April 2022. The final sample included twelve studies from six different countries published in 2011-2022.

RESULTS

Based on the translation and synthesis of the included studies, four themes were developed (1) providing family care at the end of life in rural areas-a challenging endeavour; (2) the heavy responsibility of rural caregiving-a lonesome experience; (3) working on and behind the scenes; and (4) the strong and weak spots of community connectedness in rural areas. An overarching metaphor, namely, "ambivalent and heavy burdened wanderers on a road less travelled", provides a deeper understanding of the meaning of rural family caregiving at the end of life.

CONCLUSIONS

This study provides valuable insights into end-of-life cancer care for rural families on four continents. It is crucial to prepare family caregivers for the demanding role of palliative caregiving in rural areas. To address the long distances and poor access related to specialized health care services, outpatient palliative teams tailored to the families' individual needs should be provided. In addition, more telehealth services, palliative units, or beds in local nursing facilities may reduce the number of exhausting trips that need to be made by caregivers and patients. Healthcare workers in rural areas need further education in palliative care.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

The study was registered in PROSPERO.

Investigation of the health economic analysis of informal care for people living with a chronic neurological disease: A systematic review and meta-analysis of the global evidence for multiple sclerosis

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is a chronic neurological disease that causes substantial health economic impacts, however, the cost of informal care for MS is often excluded from health economic analysis. As a result there is a paucity of information for decision-making. This review aims to summarise, synthesise and where appropriate meta-analyse the global evidence regarding the health economics of informal care for people with MS. The findings will provide consolidated evidence that policymakers and other stakeholders can use to inform decisions, including the development of health economics models. This review was conducted with a pre-determined study protocol (PROSPERO- CRD42023396457). Biomedical and economic databases were searched. Costs were converted to 2022 United States dollars (USD). Mean cost was calculated and pooled with a random-effects model. Subgroup analysis and meta-regression was conducted for stratified variables such as country income level and Expanded Disability Status Scale (EDSS). Of 6,306 identified studies, 61 were retained for narrative synthesis and 50 for meta-analysis. Studies were conducted in 25 countries. Cost information was collected from the person with MS, not the caregiver. 83.6% of studies used the opportunity cost method. Average monthly caregiving time was 60.1 h. Informal care costs accounted for 15% of total societal cost of MS. Pooled mean annual cost of informal care per person was USD $6,308 (95% CI $5,022-7,594). Informal care costs were USD $6,797 and $1,478 in high- and middle-income countries. Costs for mild, moderate, and severe disability of the person with MS were $1,123, $6,643, and $15,855, respectively. Informal care cost contributes considerably to MS-related costs. Despite study heterogeneity, cost of informal care increases with MS-related disability severity, time attributed to care and country income level. These results can be used to inform health economic models for reimbursement decisions for MS. Future studies regarding the health economic burden of informal care should gather the data from the informal carers themselves.

"I am the one taking care of her and donating blood": lived experiences of role-routines of hospital-based informal caregiving in Nigeria

PURPOSE

Informal caregivers (ICs) in Africa perform a long list of tasks to support hospitalization care. However, available studies are weak in accounting for the experiences of everyday role-routines of hospital-based informal caregiving (HIC) in under-resourced settings. This article explored the experiences of role-routines among informal caregivers in a Nigerian tertiary health facility.

METHODS

The ethnographic exploratory study relied on primary data collected from 75 participants, including 21 ICs, 15 inpatients, 36 hospital staff, and 3 ad-hoc/paid carers in a tertiary health facility in Southwestern Nigeria.

RESULTS

ICs perform several essential roles for hospitalized relatives, with each role characterized by a range of tasks. An integrative narrative of everyday routines of HIC as experienced by ICs showed critical complexities and complications involved in seemingly simple tasks of assisting hospitalized relatives with hygiene maintenance, medical investigations, blood donation, resource mobilization, errand-running, patient- and self-care and others. The role-routines are burdensome and ICs' experiences of them revealed the undercurrents of how health systems dysfunctions condition family members to support hospitalization care in Nigeria.

CONCLUSION

The intensity and repetitive nature of role-routines is suggestive of "routinization of suffering". We recommend the closing of gaps driving hospital-based informal caregiving in Africa's under-resourced settings.

Experiences of family caregivers in dealing with cases of advanced breast cancer: a qualitative study of the sociocultural context in Punjab, Pakistan

BACKGROUND

Patients with advanced breast cancer require consistent help and support from family caregivers. These caregivers often endure financial burdens and psychological stress, with their experiences significantly influenced by sociocultural factors. This study aims to explore the experiences of family caregivers of advanced breast cancer patients in Punjab province, Pakistan.

METHODS

Data was collected through in-depth interviews with fifteen family caregivers of advanced breast cancer patients in three major cities of Punjab, Pakistan. Caregivers, who had been in close contact with the patient for the last two years, were purposively sampled from five major hospitals. The data was analyzed using thematic analysis.

RESULTS

The study revealed that the experiences of family caregivers are deeply rooted in the sociocultural context. Key themes identified include social responsibility and cultural reciprocity norms; limited awareness and mobility options for caregivers; financial responsibility and strain; impacts of beauty myths and shyness on caregiving attitudes and decisions; the stressful and emotional nature of caregiving; treatment perspectives influenced by social groups; challenges in consulting male physicians and associated stigma; the role of religious beliefs in caregiving; and stress management, with religion often being a coping mechanism. These factors can contribute to delayed treatment decisions for patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Family caregivers are crucial in facilitating timely treatment decisions for advanced breast cancer patients in the Pakistani context. To minimize treatment delays and alleviate caregiver stress, addressing sociocultural barriers in care-seeking is essential. A tailored approach, considering sociocultural and religious factors, is imperative for the management and early diagnosis of breast cancer, necessitating appropriate policymaking and implementation.