Power-laws and the use of pluripotent stem cell lines

Recent Trends in Research with Human Pluripotent Stem Cells: Impact of Research and Use of Cell Lines in Experimental Research and Clinical Trials

The human pluripotent stem cell (hPSC) research landscape is rapidly evolving. To assess possible novel trends in hPSC usage, we analyzed experimental hPSC research published from 2014 to 2016 and compared our data with those of earlier periods. The number of papers describing experimental work involving hPSCs increased further with clear differences in the scientific impact of publications from different countries. Our results confirm the leading position of US-based hPSC research, although to a lesser degree than observed previously. Our data reveal that research into human induced pluripotent stem cells alone surpassed human embryonic stem cell (hESC) research by 2015 and rapidly grew after that. We also report on continuing and even slightly growing research activities in the hESC field as well as on a generally declining rate of the generation of new hESC lines. An increasing portion of new hESC lines represents disease-specific and clinical-grade cell lines. The previously noted usage of only a few early established hESC lines in the vast majority of scientific work is sustained. We also provide a comprehensive overview on clinical trials on the basis of hPSCs. We find that the vast majority of those trials are based on hESC-derived cell products that were generated from an only limited number of relatively old cell lines.

Human embryonic and induced pluripotent stem cell research trends: complementation and diversification of the field

Research in human induced pluripotent stem cells (hiPSCs) is rapidly developing and there are expectations that this research may obviate the need to use human embryonic stem cells (hESCs), the ethics of which has been a subject of controversy for more than 15 years. In this study, we investigated approximately 3,400 original research papers that reported an experimental use of these types of human pluripotent stem cells (hPSCs) and were published from 2008 to 2013. We found that research into both cell types was conducted independently and further expanded, accompanied by a growing intersection of both research fields. Moreover, an in-depth analysis of papers that reported the use of both cell types indicates that hESCs are still being used as a “gold standard,” but in a declining proportion of publications. Instead, the expanding research field is diversifying and hESC and hiPSC lines are increasingly being used in more independent research and application areas.

•

Research in hESCs and hiPSCs has recently expanded, but to different extents

•

Research in hESCs and hiPSCs partially overlaps, but is also diversifying

•

The “gold standard” use of hESCs is relatively declining

•

Only a few hESC lines are predominantly used as a benchmark in hiPSC research

Xenogeneic-free defined conditions for derivation and expansion of human embryonic stem cells with mesenchymal stem cells

The potential applications of human embryonic stem cells (hESCs) in regenerative medicine and developmental research have made stem cell biology one of the most fascinating and rapidly expanding fields of biomedicine. The first clinical trial of hESCs in humans has begun, and the field of stem cell therapy has just entered a new era. Here, we report seven hESC lines (SEES-1, -2, -3, -4, -5, -6, and -7). Four of them were derived and maintained on irradiated human mesenchymal stem cells (hMSCs) grown in xenogeneic-free defined media and substrate. Xenogeneic-free hMSCs isolated from the subcutaneous tissue of extra fingers from individuals with polydactyly showed appropriate potentials as feeder layers in the pluripotency and growth of hESCs. In this report, we describe a comprehensive characterization of these newly derived SEES cell lines. In addition, we developed a scalable culture system for hESCs having high biological safety by using gamma-irradiated serum replacement and pharmaceutical-grade recombinant basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF, also known as trafermin). This is first report describing the maintenance of hESC pluripotency using pharmaceutical-grade human recombinant bFGF (trafermin) and gamma-irradiated serum replacement. Our defined medium system provides a path to scalability in Good Manufacturing Practice (GMP) settings for the generation of clinically relevant cell types from pluripotent cells for therapeutic applications.

Globalization of stem cell science: an examination of current and past collaborative research networks

Science and engineering research has becoming an increasingly international phenomenon. Traditional bibliometric studies have not captured the evolution of collaborative partnerships between countries, particularly in emerging technologies such as stem cell science, in which an immense amount of investment has been made in the past decade. Analyzing over 2,800 articles from the top journals that include stem cell research in their publications, this study demonstrates the globalization of stem cell science. From 2000 to 2010, international collaborations increased from 20.9% to 36% of all stem cell publications analyzed. The United States remains the most prolific and the most dominant country in the field in terms of publications in high impact journals. But Asian countries, particularly China are steadily gaining ground. Exhibiting the largest relative growth, the percent of Chinese-authored stem cell papers grew more than ten-fold, while the percent of Chinese-authored international papers increased over seven times from 2000 to 2010. And while the percent of total stem cell publications exhibited modest growth for European countries, the percent of international publications increased more substantially, particularly in the United Kingdom. Overall, the data indicated that traditional networks of collaboration extant in 2000 still predominate in stem cell science. Although more nations are becoming involved in international collaborations and undertaking stem cell research, many of these efforts, with the exception of those in certain Asian countries, have yet to translate into publications in high impact journals.

LULL(ed) into complacency: a perspective on licenses and stem cell translational science

The US has had a very successful model for facilitating the translation of a basic discovery to a commercial application. The success of the model has hinged on providing clarity on ownership of a discovery, facilitating the licensing process, providing adequate incentive to the inventors, and developing a self-sustaining model for reinvestment. In recent years, technological, political, and regulatory changes have put strains on this model and in some cases have hindered progress rather than facilitated it. This is particularly true for the nascent field of regenerative medicine. To illustrate this, I will describe the contributing practices of several different entities, including universities, repositories, patent trolls, and service providers. It is my hope that the scientific community will be motivated to coordinate efforts against these obstacles to translation.

Scope and impact of international research in human pluripotent stem cells

In a recent study published in this journal it was claimed that the rate of publications from US-based authors in the human embryonic stem cell (hESC) research field was slowing or even declining from 2008 to 2010. It was assumed that this is the result of long-term effects of the Bush administration’s funding policy for hESC research and the uncertain policy environment of recent years. In the present study, we analyzed a pool of more than 1,700 original hESC research papers published world-wide from 2007 to 2011. In contrast to the previous study, our results do not support the hypothesis of a decline in the productivity of US-based research but rather confirm a nearly unchanged leading position of US research in the hESC field with respect to both publication numbers and impact of research. Moreover, we analyzed about 500 papers reporting original research involving human induced pluripotent stem cells (hiPSCs) published through 2011 and found a dominant position of US research in this research field as well.