Cortical Response Similarities Predict which Audiovisual Clips Individuals Viewed, but Are Unrelated to Clip Preference

Music-emotion EEG coupling effects based on representational similarity

BACKGROUND

Music can evoke intense emotions and music emotion is a complex cognitive process. However, we know little about the cognitive mechanisms underlying these processes, and there are significant individual differences in the emotional responses to the same musical stimuli.

NEW METHOD

We used the inter-subject representational similarity analysis (IS-RSA) method to investigate the shared music emotion responses across multiple participants. In addition, we extended IS-RSA to estimate the group cross-frequency coupling effects of music emotion. Based on the cross-frequency coupling IS-RSA, we analyzed the differences in cross-frequency coupling patterns under different music emotions using MI. Comparison of existing methods: most current IS-RSA analyses focus on within-frequency band analysis. However, the cognitive processing of music emotion involves not only activation and brain network connections differences within frequency bands but also information communication between frequency bands.

RESULTS

The results of the within-frequency band IS-RSA analysis showed that the theta and gamma frequency bands play important roles in the inter-participant consistency of music emotion. The inter-frequency band IS-RSA analysis showed that the theta-beta coupling pattern exhibited stronger inter-participant consistency compared to the theta-gamma coupling pattern, and the theta-beta coupling had significant consistent representation across various music conditions. Through the significant regions of cross-frequency coupling representation similarity analysis, we performed phase-amplitude coupling analysis on FC4-C6 and FC4-Pz connections. For the theta-beta coupling pattern, we found that the MI of these two connections exhibited different coupling patterns under different music conditions, and they showed a significant decrease compared to the baseline period.

Similar brains blend emotion in similar ways: Neural representations of individual difference in emotion profiles

Our daily emotional experience is a complex construct that usually involves multiple emotions blended in a context-dependent manner. However, the co-occurring and context-dependent nature of human emotions was understated in previous studies when addressing the individual difference in emotional experiences. The present study proposed a situated and blended 'profile' perspective to characterize individualized emotional experiences. Eighty participants watched a series of emotional videos with their EEG recorded, and the individual differences in their emotion profiles were measured as the vector distances between their multidimensional emotion ratings for these video stimuli. This measure was found to be a reliable descriptor of individualized emotional experiences and could efficiently predict classical emotional complexity indices. More importantly, inter-subject representational analyses revealed that similar emotion profiles were associated with similar delta-band activities over the prefrontal and temporo-parietal regions and similar theta-band activities over the frontal regions. Furthermore, left- and right-lateralized temporo-parietal representations were observed for positive and negative emotion profiles, respectively. Our findings demonstrate the potential of taking a 'profile' perspective for understanding individual differences in human emotions.

Natural scene representations in the gamma band are prototypical across subjects

Prototypical brain responses describe similarity in neural representations between subjects in response to a natural stimulus. During natural movie viewing, for example, inter-subject correlation (ISC) measured by fMRI is high in visual areas (Hasson et al., 2004). But the electrophysiological basis for this fMRI ISC has been controversial. Previous reports have only found ISC in low frequency bands-below 12 ​Hz (Chang et al., 2015). These findings stand in contrast to reports that gamma band oscillations-30 to 90 ​Hz-are highly stimulus-driven in visual cortex (Perry et al., 2015). To resolve this discrepancy, we carried out both ISC estimation and a novel inter-subject representational correlation analysis across six frequency bands extracted from MEG data of 24 subjects who each viewed four 5-min clips of an underwater documentary. Region-of-interest-based and vertex-based temporal ISC estimates confirmed that low-frequency bands are significantly synchronized in visual areas and that gamma band has low temporal correlation. We also found the representational geometry of movie scenes were related to structural statistics from the stimuli. Crucially, our results show that the gamma band oscillations also reflect prototypical brain response in scene representations formed in response to naturalistic stimuli as revealed by inter-subject representational correlation.

Untangling the relatedness among correlations, part I: Nonparametric approaches to inter-subject correlation analysis at the group level

FMRI data acquisition under naturalistic and continuous stimuli (e.g., watching a video or listening to music) has become popular recently due to the fact that it entails less manipulation and more realistic/complex contexts involved in the task, compared to the conventional task-based experimental designs. The synchronization or response similarities among subjects are typically measured through inter-subject correlation (ISC) between any pair of subjects. At the group level, summarizing the collection of ISC values is complicated by their intercorrelations, which necessarily lead to the violation of independence assumed in typical parametric approaches such as Student's t-test. Nonparametric methods, such as bootstrapping and permutation testing, have previously been adopted for testing purposes by resampling the time series of each subject, but the quantitative validity of these specific approaches in terms of controllability of false positive rate (FPR) has never been explored before. Here we survey the methods of ISC group analysis that have been employed in the literature, and discuss the issues involved in those methods. We then propose less computationally intensive nonparametric methods that can be performed at the group level (for both one- and two-sample analyses), as compared to the popular method of circularly shifting the EPI time series at the individual level. As part of the new approaches, subject-wise (SW) resampling is adopted instead of element-wise (EW) resampling, so that exchangeability and independence assumptions are satisfied, and the patterned correlation structure among the ISC values can be more accurately captured. We examine the FPR controllability and power achievement of all the methods through simulations, as well as their performance when applied to a real experimental dataset.