Forced Ambiguity of the Leucine Codons for Multiple-Site-Specific Incorporation of a Noncanonical Amino Acid

Codon decoding by orthogonal tRNAs interrogates the in vivo preferences of unmodified adenosine in the wobble position

The in vivo codon decoding preferences of tRNAs with an authentic adenosine residue at position 34 of the anticodon, the wobble position, are largely unexplored because very few unmodified A34 tRNA genes exist across the three domains of life. The expanded wobble rules suggest that unmodified adenosine pairs most strongly with uracil, modestly with cytosine, and weakly with guanosine and adenosine. Inosine, a modified adenosine, on the other hand, pairs strongly with both uracil and cytosine and to a lesser extent adenosine. Orthogonal pair directed sense codon reassignment experiments offer a tool with which to interrogate the translational activity of A34 tRNAs because the introduced tRNA can be engineered with any anticodon. Our fluorescence-based screen utilizes the absolute requirement of tyrosine at position 66 of superfolder GFP for autocatalytic fluorophore formation. The introduced orthogonal tRNA competes with the endogenous translation machinery to incorporate tyrosine in response to a codon typically assigned another meaning in the genetic code. We evaluated the codon reassignment efficiencies of 15 of the 16 possible orthogonal tRNAs with A34 anticodons. We examined the Sanger sequencing chromatograms for cDNAs from each of the reverse transcribed tRNAs for evidence of inosine modification. Despite several A34 tRNAs decoding closely-related C-ending codons, partial inosine modification was detected for only three species. These experiments employ a single tRNA body with a single attached amino acid to interrogate the behavior of different anticodons in the background of in vivo E. coli translation and greatly expand the set of experimental measurements of the in vivo function of A34 tRNAs in translation. For the most part, unmodified A34 tRNAs largely pair with only U3 codons as the original wobble rules suggest. In instances with GC pairs in the first two codon positions, unmodified A34 tRNAs decode the C- and G-ending codons as well as the expected U-ending codon. These observations support the "two-out-of-three" and "strong and weak" codon hypotheses.

Expansion of the genetic code through reassignment of redundant sense codons using fully modified tRNA

Breaking codon degeneracy for the introduction of non-canonical amino acids offers many opportunities in synthetic biology. Yet, despite the existence of 64 codons, the code has only been expanded to 25 amino acids in vitro. A limiting factor could be the over-reliance on synthetic tRNAs which lack the post-transcriptional modifications that improve translational fidelity. To determine whether modified, wild-type tRNA could improve sense codon reassignment, we developed a new fluorous method for tRNA capture and applied it to the isolation of roughly half of the Escherichia coli tRNA isoacceptors. We then performed codon competition experiments between the five captured wild-type leucyl-tRNAs and their synthetic counterparts, revealing a strong preference for wild-type tRNA in an in vitro translation system. Finally, we compared the ability of wild-type and synthetic leucyl-tRNA to break the degeneracy of the leucine codon box, showing that only captured wild-type tRNAs are discriminated with enough fidelity to accurately split the leucine codon box for the encoding of three separate amino acids. Wild-type tRNAs are therefore enabling reagents for maximizing the reassignment potential of the genetic code.

Directed Evolution Pipeline for the Improvement of Orthogonal Translation Machinery for Genetic Code Expansion at Sense Codons

The expansion of the genetic code beyond a single type of noncanonical amino acid (ncAA) is hindered by inefficient machinery for reassigning the meaning of sense codons. A major obstacle to using directed evolution to improve the efficiency of sense codon reassignment is that fractional sense codon reassignments lead to heterogeneous mixtures of full-length proteins with either a ncAA or a natural amino acid incorporated in response to the targeted codon. In stop codon suppression systems, missed incorporations lead to truncated proteins; improvements in activity may be inferred from increased protein yields or the production of downstream reporters. In sense codon reassignment, the heterogeneous proteins produced greatly complicate the development of screens for variants of the orthogonal machinery with improved activity. We describe the use of a previously-reported fluorescence-based screen for sense codon reassignment as the first step in a directed evolution workflow to improve the incorporation of a ncAA in response to the Arg AGG sense codon. We first screened a library with diversity introduced into both the orthogonal Methanocaldococcus jannaschii tyrosyl tRNA anticodon loop and the cognate aminoacyl tRNA synthetase (aaRS) anticodon binding domain for variants that improved incorporation of tyrosine in response to the AGG codon. The most efficient variants produced fluorescent proteins at levels indistinguishable from the E. coli translation machinery decoding tyrosine codons. Mutations to the M. jannaschii aaRS that were found to improve tyrosine incorporation were transplanted onto a M. jannaschii aaRS evolved for the incorporation of para-azidophenylalanine. Improved ncAA incorporation was evident using fluorescence- and mass-based reporters. The described workflow is generalizable and should enable the rapid tailoring of orthogonal machinery capable of activating diverse ncAAs to any sense codon target. We evaluated the selection based improvements of the orthogonal pair in a host genomically engineered for reduced target codon competition. Using this particular system for evaluation of arginine AGG codon reassignment, however, E. coli strains with genomes engineered to remove competing tRNAs did not outperform a standard laboratory E. coli strain in sense codon reassignment.

The Influence of Competing tRNA Abundance on Translation: Quantifying the Efficiency of Sense Codon Reassignment at Rarely Used Codons

A quantitative understanding of how system composition and molecular properties conspire to determine the fidelity of translation is lacking. Our strategy directs an orthogonal tRNA to directly compete against endogenous tRNAs to decode individual targeted codons in a GFP reporter. Sets of directed sense codon reassignment measurements allow the isolation of particular factors contributing to translational fidelity. In this work, we isolated the effect of tRNA concentration on translational fidelity by evaluating reassignment of the 15 least commonly employed E. coli sense codons. Eight of the rarely used codons are reassigned with greater than 20 % efficiency. Both tRNA abundance and codon demand moderately inversely correlate with reassignment efficiency. Furthermore, the reassignment of rarely used codons does not appear to confer a fitness advantage relative to reassignment of other codons. These direct competition experiments also map potential targets for genetic code expansion. The isoleucine AUA codon is particularly attractive for the incorporation of noncanonical amino acids, with a nonoptimized reassignment efficiency of nearly 70 %.

Mapping the Plasticity of the Escherichia coli Genetic Code with Orthogonal Pair-Directed Sense Codon Reassignment

The relative quantitative importance of the factors that determine the fidelity of translation is largely unknown, which makes predicting the extent to which the degeneracy of the genetic code can be broken challenging. Our strategy of using orthogonal tRNA/aminoacyl tRNA synthetase pairs to precisely direct the incorporation of a single amino acid in response to individual sense and nonsense codons provides a suite of related data with which to examine the plasticity of the code. Each directed sense codon reassignment measurement is an in vivo competition experiment between the introduced orthogonal translation machinery and the natural machinery in Escherichia coli. This report discusses 20 new, related genetic codes, in which a targeted E. coli wobble codon is reassigned to tyrosine utilizing the orthogonal tyrosine tRNA/aminoacyl tRNA synthetase pair from Methanocaldococcus jannaschii. One at a time, reassignment of each targeted sense codon to tyrosine is quantified in cells by measuring the fluorescence of GFP variants in which the essential tyrosine residue is encoded by a non-tyrosine codon. Significantly, every wobble codon analyzed may be partially reassigned with efficiencies ranging from 0.8 to 41%. The accumulation of the suite of data enables a qualitative dissection of the relative importance of the factors affecting the fidelity of translation. While some correlation was observed between sense codon reassignment and either competing endogenous tRNA abundance or changes in aminoacylation efficiency of the altered orthogonal system, no single factor appears to predominately drive translational fidelity. Evaluation of relative cellular fitness in each of the 20 quantitatively characterized proteome-wide tyrosine substitution systems suggests that at a systems level, E. coli is robust to missense mutations.