Is oxygen availability a limiting factor for in vitro folliculogenesis?

Enhanced solute transport and steady mechanical stimulation in a novel dynamic perifusion bioreactor increase the efficiency of the in vitro culture of ovarian cortical tissue strips

Introduction: We report the development and preliminary evaluation of a novel dynamic bioreactor to culture ovarian cortical tissue strips that leverages tissue response to enhanced oxygen transport and adequate mechanical stimulation. In vitro multistep ovarian tissue static culture followed by mature oocyte generation, fertilization, and embryo transfer promises to use the reserve of dormant follicles. Unfortunately, static in vitro culture of ovarian tissue does not promote development of primordial to secondary follicles or sustain follicle viability and thereby limits the number of obtainable mature oocytes. Enhancing oxygen transport to and exerting mechanical stimulation on ovarian tissue in a dynamic bioreactor may more closely mimic the physiological microenvironment and thus promote follicle activation, development, and viability. Materials and Methods: The most transport-effective dynamic bioreactor design was modified using 3D models of medium and oxygen transport to maximize strip perifusion and apply tissue fluid dynamic shear stresses and direct compressive strains to elicit tissue response. Prototypes of the final bioreactor design were manufactured with materials of varying cytocompatibility and assessed by testing the effect of leachables on sperm motility. Effectiveness of the bioreactor culture was characterized against static controls by culturing fresh bovine ovarian tissue strips for 7 days at 4.8 × 10-5 m/s medium filtration flux in air at -15% maximal total compressive strain and by assessing follicle development, health, and viability. Results and Conclusions: Culture in dynamic bioreactors promoted effective oxygen transport to tissues and stimulated tissues with strains and fluid dynamic shear stresses that, although non-uniform, significantly influenced tissue metabolism. Tissue strip culture in bioreactors made of cytocompatible polypropylene preserved follicle viability and promoted follicle development better than static culture, less so in bioreactors made of cytotoxic ABS-like resin.

Impact of prepubertal bovine ovarian tissue pre-freeze holding duration on follicle quality

Ovarian tissue cryopreservation prior to gonadotoxic treatment is the only recommended option for fertility preservation in prepubertal girls. Due to the technical complexity of this technique, limited number of centres across the world are equipped to offer the facility. Hence, the retrieved ovarian tissue needs to be maintained at hypothermic temperature (4 °C) for long time during shipment. The time taken between tissue retrieval and cryopreservation could influence the functionality of cells during fertility restoration. This study explored the tissue integrity and follicle quality of ovarian cortical slices subjected to pre-freeze holding for various time durations in vitro. Prepubertal bovine ovarian tissue from < 12 months old animals were handled at hypothermic holding (4 °C) for 0, 24, 48 and 72 h. The tissues were assessed for follicle viability through confocal analysis of live-dead labelled samples, and follicle quality and tissue integrity through histology. Results have shown that follicle viability, and overall follicle quality were not significantly affected at the end of 72 h hypothermic holding. Though, the observation reassures extended hypothermic holding prior to freezing, findings need to be validated in human tissue prior to use in clinical fertility preservation programs.

Dynamic in vitro culture of bovine and human ovarian tissue enhances follicle progression and health

In vitro ovarian cortical tissue culture, followed by culture of isolated secondary follicles, is a promising future option for production of mature oocytes. Although efforts have been made to improve the culture outcome by changing the medium composition, so far, most studies used static culture systems. Here we describe the outcome of 7 days cultures of bovine and human ovarian cortical tissue in a dynamic system using a novel perifusion bioreactor in comparison to static culture in conventional and/or gas permeable dishes. Findings show that dynamic culture significantly improves follicle quality and viability, percentage and health of secondary follicles, overall tissue health, and steroid secretion in both species. Model predictions suggest that such amelioration can be mediated by an enhanced oxygen availability and/or by fluid-mechanical shear stresses and solid compressive strains exerted on the tissue.

Platelet-rich plasma: inconclusive evidence of reproductive outcomes in menopausal women

PURPOSE

The use of platelet-rich plasma is being investigated in reproductive medicine and clinically promoted as a fertility treatment for menopause. We aimed to review the literature on the impact of PRP on fertility in menopause.

METHODS

A literature search was performed using the PubMed and MEDLINE search engines. The search was limited to the English language. Articles studying PRP use in menopause were selected for the purpose of this review.

RESULTS

Limited case reports and case series studied fertility outcomes of PRP in menopause. Randomized controlled trials are lacking. Furthermore, no studies have been conducted to evaluate the effect of different PRP concentrations, injection techniques, or side effects on reproductive outcomes in menopausal women.

CONCLUSION

There is a dearth of data to support the routine implementation of intraovarian PRP injections for fertility restoration in menopausal women. Patients considering such therapy need to be well aware of the lack of adequate data for PRP use in menopause and should be counseled accordingly.

Effects of N-Acetyl-L-Cystein Antioxidant on Ex Vivo Culture of Vitrified Premature Mouse Ovarian Tissue

Optimization of practical ways to obtain mature follicles from cryopreserved ovarian tissues, especially in patients suffering from ovarian dysfunction, is very important. In vitro ovarian tissue culture allows faster screening of follicle development and reduces follicle isolation damage. During ovarian tissue culture, controlling oxidative stress is critical to support better follicular development and less damage. Immature Naval Medical Research Institute (NMRI) mouse ovaries (8-days-old) were randomly distributed into four cultured groups; non-vitrified, vitrified, non-vitrified N-acetyl-L-cysteine (NAC)⁺, and vitrified NAC⁺. Ovaries of vitrified groups along with non-vitrified ovaries were cultured on agar gel in the presence or absence of NAC for 5 days. Afterward, morphological evaluations, mRNA expressions of Gdf9, Bmp6, Lif, Amh, Bax, and Bcl2 genes, malondialdehyde, and total antioxidant capacities were compared between four groups at the first and last day of culture. Good preservation of tissue integrity and an increase of follicular development were observed in all groups. In addition, the expression of Gdf9, Lif, Bax, and Bcl2 genes were increased and Amh was decreased in groups cultured in the presence of NAC compared to groups cultured without NAC. Although total antioxidant capacity was not significantly different between the experimental groups, the lipid peroxidation and apoptotic index were significantly reduced in the presence of NAC. Thus, it appears that NAC antioxidant acts as a contributory factor for the ex vivo culture of ovarian tissue and reduces oxidative stress, apoptotic index, and improves follicular development, especially in non-vitrified groups.

Protective effects of a SIRT1 inhibitor on primordial follicle activation and growth induced by cyclophosphamide: insights from a bovine in vitro folliculogenesis system

Purpose

Although oncological advances have improved survival rates of female cancer patients, they often suffer a reduced fertility due to treatment side effects. In the present study, we evaluated the potential fertoprotective effects of the specific inhibitor of SIRT1, EX-527, on the gonadotoxic action exerted by cyclophosphamide (CPM) on loss of primordial follicles (PFs).

Methods

The effects of the CPM metabolite phosphoramide mustard (PM) on follicle activation, growth and viability and the protective action of EX-527 against PM effects were evaluated on bovine ovarian cortical strips in vitro cultured for 1 or 6 days. To understand whether PFs exposed to PM plus EX-527 were able to activate and grow to the secondary stage after suspension of the treatment, strips cultured for 3 days in PM plus EX-527 for 3 days were transferred to plain medium until day 6. Follicle growth and health were evaluated through histology and viability assay at a confocal microscope. In order to investigate the molecular pathways underlying the ovarian response to PM in the presence of EX-527, we analysed the protein level of SIRT1, HuR, PARP1 and SOD2 after 1 day of in vitro culture.

Results

We found that (1) PM, the main CPM active metabolite, promotes PF activation; (2) the ovarian stress response induced by PM includes a SIRT1-dependent pathway; and (3) EX-527 reduces PF activation and growth induced by PM.

Conclusion

SIRT1 can represent a candidate molecule to be targeted to protect ovarian follicles from alkylating agents and EX-527 could represent a potential fertoprotective agent for cancer patients.

Therapeutic Potential of In Vitro-Derived Oocytes for the Restoration and Treatment of Female Fertility

Considerable progress has been made with the development of culture systems for the in vitro growth and maturation (IVGM) of oocytes from the earliest-staged primordial follicles and from the more advanced secondary follicles in rodents, ruminants, nonhuman primates, and humans. Successful oocyte production in vitro depends on the development of a dynamic culture strategy that replicates the follicular microenvironment required for oocyte activation and to support oocyte growth and maturation in vivo while enabling the coordinated and timely acquisition of oocyte developmental competence. Significant heterogeneity exists between the culture protocols used for different stages of follicle development and for different species. To date, the fertile potential of IVGM oocytes derived from primordial follicles has been realized only in mice. Although many technical challenges remain, significant advances have been made, and there is an increasing consensus that complete IVGM will require a dynamic, multiphase culture approach. The production of healthy offspring from in vitro-produced oocytes in a secondary large animal species is a vital next step before IVGM can be tested for therapeutic use in humans.

Analysing culture methods of frozen human ovarian tissue to improve follicle survival

In vitro follicle growth is a potential fertility preservation method for patients for whom current methods are contraindicated. Currently, this method has only been successful using fresh ovarian tissue. Since many patients who may benefit from this treatment currently have cryopreserved ovarian tissue in storage, optimising in vitro follicle growth (IVG) for cryopreserved-thawed tissue is critical. This study sought to improve the first step of IVG by comparing different short-term culture systems for cryopreserved-thawed human ovarian tissue, in order to yield a higher number of healthy multilayer follicles. We compared two commonly used culture media (αMEM and McCoy’s 5A), and three plate conditions (300 µL, 1 mL on a polycarbonate membrane and 1 mL in a gas-permeable plate) on the health and development of follicles after 6 days of culture. A total of 5797 follicles from three post-pubertal patients (aged 21.3 ± 2.3 years) were analysed across six different culture conditions and non-cultured control. All culture systems supported follicle development and there was no difference in developmental progression between the different conditions tested. Differences in follicle morphology were evident with follicles cultured in low volume conditions having significantly greater odds of being graded as morphologically normal compared to other conditions. Furthermore, culture in a low volume of αMEM resulted in the highest proportion of morphologically normal primary and multilayer follicles (23.8% compared to 6.3-19.9% depending on condition). We, therefore, recommend culturing cryopreserved human ovarian tissue in a low volume of αMEM to support follicle health and development.

The decellularized ovary as a potential scaffold for maturation of preantral ovarian follicles of prepubertal mice

ABBREVIATIONS

GAG: glycosaminoglycan; ECM: extracellular matrix; 2D: two-dimensional; E2: estradiol; P4: progesterone; BMP15: bone morphogenetic protein 15; GDF9: growth differentiation factor 9; ZP2: zona pellucida 2; Gdf9: growth/differentiation factor-9; Bmp6: bone morphogenetic protein 6; Bmp15: bone morphogenetic protein 15.

Implications of Nonphysiological Ovarian Primordial Follicle Activation for Fertility Preservation

In recent years, ovarian tissue cryopreservation has rapidly developed as a successful method for preserving the fertility of girls and young women with cancer or benign conditions requiring gonadotoxic therapy, and is now becoming widely recognized as an effective alternative to oocyte and embryo freezing when not feasible. Primordial follicles are the most abundant population of follicles in the ovary, and their relatively quiescent metabolism makes them more resistant to cryoinjury. This dormant pool represents a key target for fertility preservation strategies as a resource for generating high-quality oocytes. However, development of mature, competent oocytes derived from primordial follicles is challenging, particularly in larger mammals. One of the main barriers is the substantial knowledge gap regarding the regulation of the balance between dormancy and activation of primordial follicles to initiate their growing phase. In addition, experimental and clinical factors also affect dormant follicle demise, while the mechanisms involved remain largely to be elucidated. Moreover, most of our basic knowledge of these processes comes from rodent studies and should be extrapolated to humans with caution, considering the differences between species in the reproductive field. Overcoming these obstacles is essential to improving both the quantity and the quality of mature oocytes available for further fertilization, and may have valuable biological and clinical applications, especially in fertility preservation procedures. This review provides an update on current knowledge of mammalian primordial follicle activation under both physiological and nonphysiological conditions, and discusses implications for fertility preservation and priorities for future research.

Effect of aging on mitochondria and metabolism of bovine granulosa cells

This study investigated the effect of aging on mitochondria in granulosa cells (GCs) collected from the antral follicles of young and aged cows (25–50 months and over 140 months in age, respectively). When GCs were cultured under 20% O₂ for 4 days, mitochondrial DNA copy number (Mt-number), determined by real-time PCR, increased throughout the culture period, and the extent of increase was greater in the GCs of young cows than in those of old cows. In a second experiment, GCs were cultured under 20% O₂ for 24 h. Protein levels of TOMM20 and TFAM in GCs were lower in aged cows than in young cows, and the amount of reactive oxygen species and the mitochondrial membrane potential were higher, whereas ATP content and proliferation activity were lower, respectively. Glucose consumption and lactate production were higher in the GCs of aged cows than in those of young cows. When GCs were cultured under 5% or 20% O₂ for 24 h, low O₂ decreased ATP content and increased glucose consumption in GCs of both age groups compared with high O₂; however, low O₂ decreased the Mt-number only in the GCs of young cows. In conclusion, we show that aging affects mitochondrial quantity, function, and response to differential O₂ tensions in GCs.

Dynamic Characterization of the Biomechanical Behaviour of Bovine Ovarian Cortical Tissue and Its Short-Term Effect on Ovarian Tissue and Follicles

The ovary is a dynamic mechanoresponsive organ. In vitro, tissue biomechanics was reported to affect follicle activation mainly through the Hippo pathway. Only recently, ovary responsiveness to mechanical signals was exploited for reproductive purposes. Unfortunately, poor characterization of ovarian cortex biomechanics and of the mechanical challenge hampers reproducible and effective treatments, and prevention of tissue damages. In this study the biomechanical response of ovarian cortical tissue from abattoir bovines was characterized for the first time. Ovarian cortical tissue fragments were subjected to uniaxial dynamic testing at frequencies up to 30 Hz, and at increasing average stresses. Tissue structure prior to and after testing was characterized by histology, with established fixation and staining protocols, to assess follicle quality and stage. Tissue properties largely varied with the donor. Bovine ovarian cortical tissue consistently exhibited a nonlinear viscoelastic behavior, with dominant elastic characteristics, in the low range of other reproductive tissues, and significant creep. Strain rate was independent of the applied stress. Histological analysis prior to and after mechanical tests showed that the short-term dynamic mechanical test used for the study did not cause significant tissue tear, nor follicle expulsion or cell damage.

Effect of increased oxygen availability and astaxanthin supplementation on the growth, maturation and developmental competence of bovine oocytes derived from early antral follicles

In vitro growth (IVG) culture of bovine oocyte-cumulus-granulosa complexes (OCGCs) is generally carried out for 12 or 14 days using conventional gas impermeable culture devices. The culture duration may be longer compared to follicular development in vivo. During follicular development, follicles receive oxygen from micro vessels; however, oxygen supply is limited under the culture using conventional gas impermeable devices. The purpose of this study was to investigate the effect of increasing dissolved oxygen availability using a gas permeable (GP) culture device with or without antioxidant (astaxanthin, Ax) supplementation on 8-day IVG culture systems for bovine OCGCs derived from early antral follicles. We cultured OCGCs in GP, GP supplemented with Ax (GP + Ax), and a conventional gas impermeable device (control) for 8 or 12 days. OCGC viability were significantly higher when cultured for 8 days than 12 days (p < 0.001) in all culture condition, but significant difference was not observed between groups (p > 0.05). Antrum formation rates of OCGCs were higher after 12 days than 8 days of culture in all culture condition (p < 0.001) and were significantly higher in the control than GP groups regardless of Ax supplementation (p < 0.05). Oocyte diameters were similar among day-8 GP + Ax, day-8 control and day-12 control groups (p > 0.05). Nuclear maturation rates of oocytes grown in vitro for 8 days were significantly higher in the GP + Ax group than in the control and the GP groups (p < 0.05) and similar to oocytes grown for 12 days regardless of the culture conditions (p > 0.05). The generation of reactive oxygen species in OCGCs on day 8 of IVG culture was significantly lower in the GP + Ax group than those of the GP and control groups (p < 0.05). IVG oocytes after eight days of culture developed into blastocysts, and the cleavage and blastocyst rates were similar in all treatment groups. However, in vivo-grown oocytes had significantly higher (p < 0.05) cleavage and blastocyst rates than the IVG oocytes in all groups. The present study demonstrates that increased oxygen availability using a GP culture device with Ax supplementation promotes oocyte growth and maturation competence but inhibits proliferation of granulosa cells and antrum formation compared with a conventional gas impermeable culture device, and that OCGCs can attain developmental competence after 8 days of IVG culture.

Effects of oxygen concentrations on developmental competence and transcriptomic profile of yak oocytes

Oxygen concentration influences oocyte quality and subsequent embryo development, but it remains unclear whether oxygen concentrations affect the developmental competence and transcriptomic profile of yak oocytes. In this study, we investigated the effects of different oxygen concentrations (5% versus 20%) on the developmental competence, reactive oxygen species (ROS) levels, glutathione (GSH) content, and transcriptomic profile of yak oocytes. The results showed that a low oxygen concentration significantly increased the maturation rate of yak oocytes (81.2 ± 2.2% vs 75.9 ± 1.3%) and the blastocyst quality of yak in vitro fertilized embryos. Analysis of ROS and GSH showed that a low oxygen concentration reduced ROS levels and increased the content of GSH (75.05 ± 7.1 ng/oocyte vs 50.63 ± 5.6 ng/oocyte). Furthermore, transcriptomic analysis identified 120 differentially expressed genes (DEGs) between the two groups of oocytes. Gene enrichment analysis of the DEGs indicated multiple cellular processes, including oxidative phosphorylation, transcription regulation, mitochondrial regulation, oestrogen signalling pathway, HIF-1 signalling pathway, TNF signalling pathway, were involved in the response to oxygen concentration alterations. Taken together, these results indicated that a low oxygen concentration improved the developmental competence of yak oocytes.

Embryo culture at a reduced oxygen concentration of 5%: a mini review

The optimum oxygen tension for culturing mammalian embryos has been widely debated by the scientific community. While several laboratories have moved to using 5% as the value for oxygen tension, the majority of modern in vitro fertilization (IVF) laboratory programmes still use 20%. Several in vivo studies have shown the oxygen tension measured in the oviduct of mammals fluctuates between 2% and 8% and in cows and primates this values drops to <2% in the uterine milieu. In human IVF, a non-physiological level of 20% oxygen has been used in the past. However, several studies have shown that atmospheric oxygen introduces adverse effects to embryo development, not limited to numerous molecular and cellular physiology events. In addition, low oxygen tension plays a critical role in reducing the high level of detrimental reactive oxygen species within cells, influences embryonic gene expression, helps with embryo metabolism of glucose, and enhances embryo development to the blastocyst stage. Collectively, this improves embryo implantation potential. However, clinical studies have yielded contradictory results. In almost all reports, some level of improvement has been identified in embryo development or implantation, without any observed drawbacks. This review article will examine the recent literature and discusses ongoing efforts to understand the benefits that low oxygen tension can bring to mammal embryo development in vitro.

Do Bioreactor Designs with More Efficient Oxygen Supply to Ovarian Cortical Tissue Fragments Enhance Follicle Viability and Growth In Vitro?

Background: Autotransplantation of cryopreserved ovarian tissue is currently the main option to preserve fertility for cancer patients. To avoid cancer cell reintroduction at transplantation, a multi-step culture system has been proposed to obtain fully competent oocytes for in vitro fertilization. Current in vitro systems are limited by the low number and health of secondary follicles produced during the first step culture of ovarian tissue fragments. To overcome such limitations, bioreactor designs have been proposed to enhance oxygen supply to the tissue, with inconsistent results. This retrospective study investigates, on theoretical grounds, whether the lack of a rational design of the proposed bioreactors prevented the full exploitation of follicle growth potential. Methods: Models describing oxygen transport in bioreactors and tissue were developed and used to predict oxygen availability inside ovarian tissue in the pertinent literature. Results: The proposed theoretical analysis suggests that a successful outcome is associated with enhanced oxygen availability in the cultured tissue in the considered bioreactor designs. This suggests that a rational approach to bioreactor design for ovarian tissue culture in vitro may help exploit tissue potential to support follicle growth.

Enhancing oxygen delivery to ovarian follicles by three different methods markedly improves growth in serum-containing culture medium

Invitro ovarian follicle culture systems are routinely used to study folliculogenesis and may provide solutions for infertility. Mouse follicles are typically cultured in standard gas-impermeable culture plates under gas phase oxygen concentrations of 5% or 20% (v/v). There is evidence that these conditions may not provide adequate oxygenation for follicles cultured as non-attached intact units in medium supplemented with serum and high levels of FSH. Three different methods of enhancing follicle oxygenation were investigated in this study: increasing the gas phase oxygen concentration, inverting the culture plates and using gas-permeable culture plates. Follicles cultured under 40% O2 were significantly larger (P P P 2 . These effects were associated with reduced secretion of vascular endothelial growth factor (P P P invivo -matured follicles (~500μm in diameter). Such follicular development is not possible under hypoxic conditions.

Slush nitrogen vitrification of human ovarian tissue does not alter gene expression and improves follicle health and progression in long-term in vitro culture

OBJECTIVE

To study whether slush nitrogen (SN) vs. liquid nitrogen (LN) vitrification affects human ovarian tissue gene expression and preserves follicle health during extended in vitro culture.

DESIGN

Randomized experimental study.

SETTING

University research laboratory.

PATIENT(S)

Ovarian biopsies collected by laparoscopic surgery from patients with benign gynaecologic conditions.

INTERVENTION(S)

None.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Ovarian strips were vitrified with LN or SN, warmed, and analyzed before or after culture for 9 days (d9) in gas-permeable dishes. Expression of genes involved in stress and toxicity pathways was analyzed in fresh and warmed strips by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) array and quantitative real-time-PCR. Fresh and vitrified/warmed strips were analyzed for follicle quality, progression, and viability before or after culture.

RESULT(S)

The SN vitrification preserved follicle quality better than LN (% grade 1 follicles: fresh control, 54.2; LN, 29.3; SN, 48.8). Quantitative reverse transcription-PCR demonstrated a noticeable up-regulation of 13 genes in LN samples (range, 10-35) and a markedly lower up-regulation of only 5 genes (range, 3.6-7.8) in SN samples. Long-term in vitro culture evidenced worse follicle quality and viability in LN samples than in both fresh and SN samples (% grade 1 follicle: fresh d0, 51.5; fresh d9, 41; LN d9, 16.4; SN d9, 55) and a highly significant reduction of primordial follicles and a concomitant increase of primary and secondary follicles in all samples. Follicle growth to the secondary stage was significantly higher in vitrified tissue than in fresh tissue, being better in SN than in LN vitrified tissue.

CONCLUSION(S)

Follicle quality, gene expression, viability, and progression are better preserved after SN vitrification.

Update on oogenesis in vitro

INTRODUCTION

Ovarian tissue is increasingly being collected from cancer patients and cryopreserved for fertility preservation. Alternately to the autologous transplantation, the development of culture systems that support oocyte development from the primordial follicle stage represent a valid strategy to restore fertility. The aim of this study is to review the most recent data regarding oogenesis in vitro and to provide an up-to-date on the contemporary knowledge of follicle growth and development in vitro.

EVIDENCE ACQUISITION

A comprehensive systematic MEDLINE search was performed since February 2018 for English-language reports by using the following terms: "ovary," "animal and human follicle," "in vitro growth and development," "ovarian tissue culture," "fertility preservation," "IVM," "oocyte." Previous published reviews and recent published original articles were preferred in order to meet our study scope.

EVIDENCE SYNTHESIS

Over time, many studies have been conducted with the aim to optimize the characteristics of ovarian tissue culture systems and to better support the three main phases: 1) activation of primordial follicles; 2) isolation and culture of growing preantral follicles; 3) removal from the follicle environment and maturation of oocyte cumulus complexes. While complete oocyte in vitro development has been achieved in mouse, with the production of live offspring, the goal of obtaining oocytes of sufficient quality to support embryo development has not been completely reached into higher mammals despite decades of effort.

CONCLUSIONS

Over the years, many improvements have been made on ovarian tissue cultures with the future purpose that patients will be provided with a greater number of developmentally competent oocytes for fertility preservation.