Effect of a unilateral hind limb orthotic lift on upper body movement symmetry in the trotting horse

Quantitative gait analysis before and after a cross-country test in a population of elite eventing horses

Early recognition of lameness is crucial for injury prevention. Quantitative gait analysis systems can detect low-grade asymmetries better than the human eye and may be useful in early lameness recognition. The aims of this study were 1) to investigate the frequency of gait asymmetries based on head and pelvic movement in elite eventing horses using inertial mounted measurement units and 2) to assess the association between asymmetries and muscle enzymes and blood lactate (LA) levels post exercise. Movement asymmetry of the head, wither, and pelvis were quantified in 33 elite eventing horses prior to and one day after the cross-country test of three Concours Complet International (CCI3* and CCI4*) events held three weeks apart. The effects of LA concentration immediately after completion of the cross-country course and of serum levels of creatine kinase (CK) and aspartate amino-transferase (AST) four hours post-exercise on gait asymmetry parameters were tested with linear models. A total of 58% and 77% of the 33 horses exhibited gait asymmetries that exceeded published threshold values before and after the cross-country course, respectively. The magnitude of pre-existing gait asymmetries was not significantly increased after the cross-country test and no associations with post-exercise levels of CK, AST, or LA were detected. The stride duration was significantly shorter the day following the cross-country test and was associated with LA, the age and the weight of the horses. In conclusion, a majority of the horses studied presented gait asymmetries and strenuous exercise resulted in decreased stride duration but did not worsen gait asymmetries.

The effect of horseshoes and surfaces on horse and jockey centre of mass displacements at gallop

Horseshoes influence how horses' hooves interact with different ground surfaces, during the impact, loading and push-off phases of a stride cycle. Consequently, they impact on the biomechanics of horses' proximal limb segments and upper body. By implication, different shoe and surface combinations could drive changes in the magnitude and stability of movement patterns in horse-jockey dyads. This study aimed to quantify centre of mass (COM) displacements in horse-jockey dyads galloping on turf and artificial tracks in four shoeing conditions: 1) aluminium; 2) barefoot; 3) GluShu; and 4) steel. Thirteen retired racehorses and two jockeys at the British Racing School were recruited for this intervention study. Tri-axial acceleration data were collected close to the COM for the horse (girth) and jockey (kidney-belt), using iPhones (Apple Inc.) equipped with an iOS app (SensorLog, sample rate = 50 Hz). Shoe-surface combinations were tested in a randomized order and horse-jockey pairings remained constant. Tri-axial acceleration data from gallop runs were filtered using bandpass Butterworth filters with cut-off frequencies of 15 Hz and 1 Hz, then integrated for displacement using Matlab. Peak displacement was assessed in both directions (positive 'maxima', negative 'minima') along the cranio-caudal (CC, positive = forwards), medio-lateral (ML, positive = right) and dorso-ventral (DV, positive = up) axes for all strides with frequency ≥2 Hz (mean = 2.06 Hz). Linear mixed-models determined whether surfaces, shoes or shoe-surface interactions (fixed factors) significantly affected the displacement patterns observed, with day, run and horse-jockey pairs included as random factors; significance was set at p<0.05. Data indicated that surface-type significantly affected peak COM displacements in all directions for the horse (p<0.0005) and for all directions (p≤0.008) but forwards in the jockey. The largest differences were observed in the DV-axis, with an additional 5.7 mm and 2.5 mm of downwards displacement for the horse and jockey, respectively, on the artificial surface. Shoeing condition significantly affected all displacement parameters except ML-axis minima for the horse (p≤0.007), and all displacement parameters for the jockey (p<0.0005). Absolute differences were again largest vertically, with notable similarities amongst displacements from barefoot and aluminium trials compared to GluShu and steel. Shoe-surface interactions affected all but CC-axis minima for the jockey (p≤0.002), but only the ML-axis minima and maxima and DV-axis maxima for the horse (p≤0.008). The results support the idea that hoof-surface interface interventions can significantly affect horse and jockey upper-body displacements. Greater sink of hooves on impact, combined with increased push-off during the propulsive phase, could explain the higher vertical displacements on the artificial track. Variations in distal limb mass associated with shoe-type may drive compensatory COM displacements to minimize the energetic cost of movement. The artificial surface and steel shoes provoked the least CC-axis movement of the jockey, so may promote greatest stability. However, differences between horse and jockey mean displacements indicated DV-axis and CC-axis offsets with compensatory increases and decreases, suggesting the dyad might operate within displacement limits to maintain stability. Further work is needed to relate COM displacements to hoof kinematics and to determine whether there is an optimum configuration of COM displacement to optimise performance and minimise injury.

Asymmetries of horses walking and trotting on treadmill with and without rider

BACKGROUND

Left-right movement symmetry is a highly desirable characteristic in sport horses.

OBJECTIVES

This study compared movement symmetry in well-trained dressage horses in unridden and unrestrained position and ridden in a dressage frame, and investigated possible associations between gaits.

STUDY DESIGN

Experimental study.

METHODS

Seven sound, high-level dressage horses were measured at walk and sitting trot on a treadmill at several speeds under two conditions: with and without rider. Left-right differences in stance duration, stance protraction and retraction based on longitudinal hoof positions, ipsilateral limb tracking, minimum and maximum vertical positions of the dorsal spinous processes of the sixth thoracic (T6), third sacral vertebrae (S3) and wing of atlas, and vertical ground reaction forces were calculated and analysed in mixed models.

RESULTS

At walk, five body variables indicated increased asymmetry in the ridden condition compared with unridden condition: forelimb stance duration (unridden/ridden left-right differences 9 vs 13 ms; P = .008), forelimb stance protraction (P = .004), stance retraction (P = .001) and first force peak (P = .003), and hindlimb stance retraction (P = .01). At trot, six body variables were more asymmetrical in the ridden condition: forelimb stance duration (2.5 vs 3.8 ms, P = .004); hindlimb stance protraction (P < .0001) and retraction (P = .01), T6 minimum (4 vs 6 mm, P = .001), T6 maximum (9 vs 11 mm, P = .01) and S3 maximum (6 vs 12 mm, P < .001). Five variables had significant associations between asymmetries at walk and trot, but only three demonstrated a positive slope.

MAIN LIMITATIONS

A limited number of horses and riders were studied. Measurements were performed on a treadmill.

CONCLUSIONS

High-level horses moved slightly more asymmetrically when ridden in a dressage frame than in the unridden condition.

The Effect of Tungsten Road Nails on Upper Body Movement Asymmetry in Horses Trotting on Tarmac

Tungsten road nails are commonly used by farriers to increase grip between the hoof and the ground surface. There is limited evidence relating the use of road nails to the fundamental mechanics of movement. Grip is important for efficient deceleration on landing and subsequent propulsion, but this must be balanced against an amount of slip to divide the landing force into horizontal as well as vertical subcomponents. Here, we conducted an intervention study to quantify the effect of lateral heel road nail placement on weight bearing and propulsion in 10 horses trotting on tarmac. Wireless inertial measurement units measured vertical movement asymmetry. Differences in head and pelvic movement asymmetry before/after subsequent application of laterally placed road nails to forelimb and hindlimb hooves in a randomized order were compared to zero value (no change) with a one-sample t-test, P < .05. Left-to-right tuber coxae movement amplitude difference was significantly more negative (-3.25 mm, P = .03), suggesting more right than left tuber coxae movement amplitude, after application of a road nail to the left hindlimb. No movement asymmetries at the poll, withers, or sacrum were detected after nail placement (all P > .055). Pelvic movement indicates a very small increase in weight bearing and propulsion provided by the hindlimb with a laterally placed road nail compared to the contralateral hindlimb. Further work is needed to investigate slip- and grip-related parameters at the level of the hoof and to investigate the long-term consequences of very small changes in movement asymmetry.

Effect of induced hindlimb length difference on body-mounted inertial sensor measures used to evaluate hindlimb lameness in horses

This study has investigated the immediate effect of induced hindlimb length difference on hindlimb lameness measured as differences in minimum (Pmin) and maximum (Pmax) pelvic heights in 16 horses trotting in a straight line and lungeing on both hard and soft surfaces with body-mounted inertial sensors. Hindlimb length differences were induced by applying an Easyboot Glue-on shoe to one hindlimb. Changes in Pmin and Pmax with induced hindlimb length difference were assessed with a two-way repeated-measures ANOVA with trial (straight, lunge with inside limb elevation, lunge with outside limb elevation) and surface (hard, soft) as within-subject factors. Change in Pmin, indicating an impact-type lameness, in the hind limb with the elevation, was significant in both the straight line and while lunging on both hard and soft surfaces. Change in Pmax, indicating pushoff-type lameness, in the opposite, non-elevated hind limb, was significant when trotting in a straight line but not while lunging.