A global approach to describe retinal defocus patterns

The induced defocus by Defocus Incorporated Soft Contact lenses is dependent on visual distance and ambient illuminance

PURPOSE

Defocus Incorporated Soft Contact (DISC) lenses, a commonly used type of multifocal lens in clinical practice, may slow down myopia progression by inducing myopic retinal defocus. The purpose of this study was to explore whether the induced defocus across the retina could be affected by visual environments encountered in the real world, such as differences in viewing distance and ambient illuminance.

METHODS

In this cross-over trial, 30 myopic adults wore both DISC lenses and single vision contact (SVC) lenses in random order. An open-view Hartmann-Shack scanning wavefront sensor was used to measure defocus at different retinal locations along the horizontal meridian under four experimental conditions: far target (3 m) and near targets (0.33 m) under scotopic (<1 lux) or photopic (~300 lux) conditions.

RESULTS

The results showed that DISC lenses induced more myopic retinal defocus than SVC lenses in all conditions (all p < 0.05), except for the scotopic near target. In addition, for DISC lenses, the defocus was greater in the photopic than the scotopic conditions for both the far and near targets (both p < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, the retinal defocus induced by these multifocal lenses was dependent on both visual distance and ambient illuminance, indicating that the visual conditions might affect the anti-myopia efficacy of these devices.

Characteristics of Peripheral Retinal Refraction and Its Role in Children with Different Refractive States

Introduction

Peripheral retinal refraction plays a crucial role in myopia, but the specific mechanism is not clear. We refined the retinal partitions to explore the characteristics of peripheral retinal refraction and its role in emmetropic, low, and moderate myopic children aged 6 to 12 years.

Methods

A total of 814 subjects (814 eyes) were enrolled in the study. The participants were divided into three groups according to the central spherical equivalent refraction (SER), which were emmetropia group (E), low myopia group (LM) and moderate myopia group (MM). Multispectral refractive topography (MRT) was used to measure the retinal absolute and relative refractive difference value (RDV) in different regions. The range was divided into superior, inferior, temporal, and nasal RDV (SRDV, IRDV, TRDV, and NRDV) on the basis of several concentric circles extending outward from the macular fovea (RDV15, RDV30, RDV45, RDV30-15, RDV45-30, and RDV-45). Kruskal-Wallis test was used to analyze the differences of peripheral refraction for all the regions among the three groups. Spearman rank correlation was performed to explore correlations between SER and RDV, axial length (AL) and RDV.

Results

The absolute value of RDV decreased with increasing degree of myopia in all regions (P < 0.01). Subjects with different refractive degrees had different relative value of RDV. In nasal position within 45° and temporal position within 30°, the peripheral retina exhibited significantly different relative hyperopic refractive status among Group E, Group LM, and Group MM (P < 0.05). SER was negatively correlated with NRDV within 30° (especially in the range of NRDV30-15) (r = -0.141, P < 0.01), positively correlated with TRDV within 15° (r = 0.080, P = 0.023), and not significantly correlated with SRDV and IRDV when the retina was divided into four parts. AL was positively correlated with NRDV within 30° (especially in the range of NRDV30-15) (r = 0.109, P = 0.002), negatively correlated with TRDV within 15° (r = -0.095, P = 0.007).

Conclusions

The peripheral defocus has significant implications for the genesis of myopia. The peripheral defocus of the horizontal direction, especially within the range of NRDV30, has greater effect on the development of myopia in children. Higher NRDV30 is associated with lower SER and longer AL.

Widefield wavefront sensor for multidirectional peripheral retinal scanning

The quantitative evaluation of peripheral ocular optics is essential in both myopia research and the investigation of visual performance in people with normal and compromised central vision. We have developed a widefield scanning wavefront sensor (WSWS) capable of multidirectional scanning while maintaining natural central fixation at the primary gaze. This Shack-Hartmann-based WSWS scans along any retinal meridian by using a unique scanning method that involves the concurrent operation of a motorized rotary stage (horizontal scan) and a goniometer (vertical scan). To showcase the capability of the WSWS, we tested scanning along four meridians including a 60° horizontal, 36° vertical, and two 36° diagonal scans, each completed within a time frame of 5 seconds.

Objective Quantification and Topographic Dioptric Demand of Near-Work

Purpose

The assessment of myopigenic environmental risk factors such as near-work relies on subjective data. Although diaries and questionnaires on near-work show correlation to some degree, it remains unknown how they may correspond to ground truth. This is an important consideration because valid estimates of near-work have great utility for understanding the mechanisms by which dioptric demand drives excessive eye-growth, which is not yet entirely understood. To this end, we assessed a novel eye-tracking system to quantify near-work.

Method

We compared subjective entries from diaries to objective data on accommodative demand acquired with a three-dimensional eye-tracker in 20 participants. Each test involved approximately one-hour exposure to ecological near-work environments. Furthermore, topographical dioptric demand maps were computed in retinal coordinates.

Results

Our study suggests a frequent mismatch between objectively and subjectively labeled data of near-work tasks (concordance 74.6%). Objective and subjective estimates of dioptric demand showed a moderate correlation and were not significantly different (R2 = 0.59, P = .35). Instead, accommodative demand with an agreement between objective and subjective near-work labels showed a high correlation and were significantly different (R2 = 0.79, P = .016). The accumulated topographical dioptric demand of ecological near-work environments did not present myopigenic defocus stimuli to the retina periphery. Thus extreme close-up near-work presented peripheral defocus stimuli that have been proposed to curb excessive eye growth.

Conclusions

The proposed objective measurement method may provide improvements over subjective methods for estimating near-work parameters.

Translational Relevance

The topographic dioptric demand maps highlight a possible conflict of causal mechanisms of the two myopia models: "excessive near-work" and "peripheral optical defocus."

Peripheral Defocus and Myopia Management: A Mini-Review

Myopia is the most common refractive error in the world, and its' prevalence continually increases. The potential pathological and visual complications of progressive myopia have inspired researchers to study the sources of myopia, axial elongation, and explore modalities to arrest progression. Considerable attention has been given over the past few years to the myopia risk factor known as hyperopic peripheral blur, the focus of this review. The primary theories currently believed to be the cause of myopia, the parameters considered to contribute and influence the effect of peripheral blur, such as the surface retinal area or depth of blur will be discussed. The currently available optical devices designed to provide peripheral myopic defocus will be discussed, including bifocal and progressive addition ophthalmic lenses, peripheral defocus single vision ophthalmic lenses, orthokeratology lenses, and bifocal or multifocal center distance soft lenses, as well as their effectivity as mentioned in the literature to date.

The effect of spatially-related environmental risk factors in visual scenes on myopia

Myopia, the most common refractive error, is estimated to affect over two billion people worldwide, especially children from East Asian regions. Children with early onset myopia have an increased risk of developing sight threatening complications in later life. In addition to the contribution of genetic factors, of which expression is controversially suggested to be subject to environmental regulation, various environmental factors, such as near-work, outdoor, and living environment, have also been determined to play significant roles in the development of refractive error, especially juvenile myopia. Cues from daily visual scenes, including lighting, spatial frequency, and optical defocus over the field of visual stimuli, are suggested to influence emmetropisation, thereby affecting myopia development and progression. These risk factors in visual scenes of the everyday life may explain the relationship between urbanicity and myopia prevalence. This review first summarises the previously reported associations between myopia development and everyday-life environments, including schooling, urban settings, and outdoors. Then, there is a discussion of the mechanisms hypothesised in the literature about the cues from different visual scenes of urbanicity in relation to myopia development.

The diversified defocus profile of the near-work environment and myopia development

Purpose

To quantify the defocus characteristics in the near‐work environment at home and investigate the relationship with subsequent myopia progression.

Methods

Fifty subjects (aged 7–12 years) were recruited and followed for 1 year. The home near‐work environment (writing desk) was measured at a baseline home‐visit using the Kinect‐for‐Windows to capture a 3‐dimensional image. The depth values of the image were then converted into scene defocus with respect to the subject’s viewpoint. The defocus characteristics were quantified as the dioptric volume (the total amount of net defocus, or DV) and standard deviation of the defocus values (SD_D). Information on home size, time spent outdoors, and in front of a desk were also obtained. Univariate correlation, and multivariate regression were used to assess the association between myopia progression, defocus characteristics, and other co‐variates.

Results

The baseline spherical equivalent refraction (M) and refraction change over 1 year (∆M) were − 1.51 ± 2.02 D and − 0.56 ± 0.45 D respectively. DV was not significantly correlated with ∆M (Spearman’s ρ = −0.25, p = 0.08), while SD_D was negatively correlated to ∆M (Spearman’s ρ = −0.42, p = 0.003). Although SD_D was not a significant predictor in multivariate analysis, the regional DV at 15°–20° eccentricity was significant (p = 0.001). Home size (F_2,50 = 7.01, p = 0.002) and time spent outdoors (Independent t = −2.13, p = 0.04) were also associated with ∆M, but not time spent in front of desk (Independent t = 0.78, p = 0.44).

Conclusion

The defocus profile in the home environment within the para‐central field of view is associated with childhood refractive error development.

2-D Peripheral image quality metrics with different types of multifocal contact lenses

To evaluate the impact of multifocal contact lens wear on the image quality metrics across the visual field in the context of eye growth and myopia control. Two-dimensional cross-correlation coefficients were estimated by comparing a reference image against the computed retinal images for every location. Retinal images were simulated based on the measured optical aberrations of the naked eye and a set of multifocal contact lenses (centre-near and centre-distance designs), and images were spatially filtered to match the resolution limit at each eccentricity. Value maps showing the reduction in the quality of the image through each optical condition were obtained by subtracting the optical image quality from the theoretical physiological limits. Results indicate that multifocal contact lenses degrade the image quality independently from their optical design, though this result depends on the type of analysis conducted. Analysis of the image quality across the visual field should not be oversimplified to a single number but split into regional and groups because it provides more insightful information and can avoid misinterpretation of the results. The decay of the image quality caused by the multifocal contacts alone, cannot explain the translation of peripheral defocus towards protection on myopia progression, and a different explanation needs to be found.