Acute apnea and white blood cell count: A biphasic response formal comment on 'Hematologic changes after short term hypoxia in non-elite apnea divers under voluntary dry apnea conditions'

Six weeks of static apnea training does not affect Hbmass and exercise performance

PURPOSE

Acute apnea is known to induce decreases in oxyhemoglobin desaturation (SpO₂) and increases in erythropoietin concentration ([EPO]). This study examined the potential of an apnea training program to induce erythropoiesis and increase hematological parameters and exercise performance.

METHODS

Twenty-two male subjects were randomly divided into an apnea and control group. The apnea group performed a 6-week apnea training program consisting of a daily series of 5 maximal static apneas. Before and after training, subjects visited the lab on three test days to perform 1) a ramp incremental test measuring V̇O_2peak, 2) CO-rebreathing for Hb mass determination and a 3-km time trial and 3) an apnea test protocol with continuous finger SpO₂ registration. Venous blood samples were drawn before and 180 minutes after the apnea test for analysis of [EPO].

RESULTS

Minimal SpO₂ reached during the apnea test protocol was 91 ±7% pre and 82 ±7% post apnea training. The apnea test protocol did not elicit an acute increase in [EPO] (p=0.685) before nor after the training program. Consequently, resting [EPO] (p=0.170), Hbmass (p=0.134), V̇O_2peak (p=0.796) and 3-km cycling time trial performance (p=0.509) were not affected either.

CONCLUSION

The apnea test and training protocol, consisting of 5 maximal static apneas, did not induce a sufficiently strong hypoxic stimulus to cause erythropoiesis and therefore did not result in an increase in resting [EPO], Hbmass, V̇O_2peak or time trial performance. Longer and/or more intense training sessions inducing a stronger hypoxic stimulus are probably needed to obtain changes in hematological and exercise parameters.