Tin filter compared to low kV protocols - optimizing sinonasal imaging in computed tomography

Ultra-low-dose photon-counting CT of paranasal sinus: an in vivo comparison of radiation dose and image quality to cone-beam CT

PURPOSE

This study investigated the differences in subjective and objective image parameters as well as dose exposure of photon-counting CT (PCCT) compared to cone-beam CT (CBCT) in paranasal sinus imaging for the assessment of rhinosinusitis and sinonasal anatomy.

METHODS

This single-centre retrospective study included 100 patients, who underwent either clinically indicated PCCT or CBCT of the paranasal sinus. Two blinded experienced ENT radiologists graded image quality and delineation of specific anatomical structures on a 5-point Likert scale. In addition, contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) and applied radiation doses were compared among both techniques.

RESULTS

Image quality and delineation of bone structures in paranasal sinus PCCT was subjectively rated superior by both readers compared to CBCT (P < .001). CNR was significantly higher for photon-counting CT (P < .001). Mean effective dose for PCCT examinations was significantly lower than for CBCT (0.038 mSv ± 0.009 vs. 0.14 mSv ± 0.011; P < .001).

CONCLUSION

In a performance comparison of PCCT and a modern CBCT scanner in paranasal sinus imaging, we demonstrated that first-use PCCT in clinical routine provides higher subjective image quality accompanied by higher CNR at close to a quarter of the dose exposure compared to CBCT.

Ultra-low dose CT scanning for PET/CT

BACKGROUND

The use of computed tomography (CT) for attenuation correction (AC) in whole-body PET/CT can result in a significant contribution to radiation exposure. This can become a limiting factor for reducing considerably the overall radiation exposure of the patient when using the new long axial field of view (LAFOV) PET scanners. However, recent CT technology have introduced features such as the tin (Sn) filter, which can substantially reduce the CT radiation dose.

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to investigate the ultra-low dose CT for attenuation correction using the Sn filter together with other dose reduction options such as tube current (mAs) reduction. We explore the impact of dose reduction in the context of AC-CT and how it affects PET image quality.

METHODS

The study evaluated a range of ultra-low dose CT protocols using five physical phantoms that represented a broad collection of tissue electron densities. A long axial field of view (LAFOV) PET/CT scanner was used to scan all phantoms, applying various CT dose reduction parameters such as reducing tube current (mAs), increasing the pitch value, and applying the Sn filter. The effective dose resulting from the CT scans was determined using the CTDIVol reported by the scanner. Several voxel-based and volumes of interest (VOI)-based comparisons were performed to compare the ultra-low dose CT images, the generated attenuation maps, and corresponding PET images against those images acquired with the standard low dose CT protocol. Finally, two patient datasets were acquired using one of the suggested ultra-low dose CT settings.

RESULTS

By incorporating the Sn filter and adjusting mAs to the lowest available value, the radiation dose in CT images of PBU-60 phantom was significantly reduced; resulting in an effective dose of nearly 2% compared to the routine low dose CT protocols currently in clinical use. The assessment of PET images using VOI and voxel-based comparisons indicated relative differences (RD%) of under 6% for mean activity concentration (AC) in the torso phantom and patient dataset and under 8% for a source point in the CIRS phantom. The maximum RD% value of AC was 14% for the point source in the CIRS phantom. Increasing the tube current from 6 mAs to 30 mAs in patients with high BMI, or with arms down, can suppress the photon starvation artifact, whilst still preserving a dose reduction of 90%.

CONCLUSIONS

Introducing a Sn filter in CT imaging lowers radiation dose by more than 90%. This reduction has minimal effect on PET image quantification at least for patients without Body Mass Index (BMI) higher than 30. Notably, this study results need validation using a larger clinical PET/CT dataset in the future, including patients with higher BMI.

Dose development in sinonasal imaging over the last decade - a retrospective patient study

BACKGROUND

Computed tomography (CT) has become the primary imaging modality for visualization of the paranasal sinuses. In this retrospective, single center patient study the radiation dose development in the past 12 years in CT imaging of the paranasal sinuses was assessed.

METHODS

The computed tomography dose index (CTDIVol) and dose length product (DLP) of a total of 1246 patients (average age: 41 ± 18 years, 361 females, 885 males) were evaluated, who received imaging of the paranasal sinuses either for chronic sinusitis diagnostic, preoperatively or posttraumatically. Scans were performed on three different CT scanners (Somatom Definition AS, Somatom Definition AS+, Somatom Force, all from Siemens Healthineers) and on one CBCT (Morita) ranging from 2010 to 2022. Reconstruction techniques were filtered back projection and three generations of iterative reconstruction (IRIS, SAFIRE, ADMIRE, all from Siemens Healthineers). Group comparisons were performed using either parametrical (ANOVA) or non-parametrical tests (Kruskal-Wallis Test), where applicable.

RESULTS

Over the past 12 years, there was a 73%, 54%, and 66% CTDIVol reduction and a significant (p < 0.001) 72%, 33%, and 67% DLP reduction in assessing the paranasal sinuses for chronic sinusitis, preoperatively and posttraumatically, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Technological developments in CT imaging, both hardware and software based, have led to a significant reduction in dose exposure in recent years. Particularly in imaging of the paranasal sinuses, the reduction of radiation exposure is of great interest due to the often young patient age and radiation-sensitive organs in the area of radiation exposure.