Detection of drug-resistant clones in chronic myelogenous leukemia patients during dasatinib and nilotinib treatment

[Recommendations from the French CML Study Group (Fi-LMC) for BCR-ABL1 kinase domain mutation analysis in chronic myeloid leukemia]

In the context of chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) resistant to tyrosine kinase inhibitors (TKIs), BCR-ABL1 tyrosine kinase domain (TKD) mutations still remain the sole biological marker that directly condition therapeutic decision. These recommendations aim at updating the use of BCR-ABL1 mutation testing with respect to new available therapeutic options and at repositioning different testing methods at the era of next generation sequencing (NGS). They have been written by a panel of experts from the French Study Group on CML (Fi-LMC), after a critical review of relevant publications. TKD mutation testing is recommended in case of treatment failure but not in case of optimal response. For patients in warning situation, mutation testing must be discussed depending on the type of TKI used, lasting of the treatment, kinetic evolution of BCR-ABL1 transcripts along time and necessity for switching treatment. The kind and the frequency of TKD mutations occasioning resistance mainly depend on the TKI in use and disease phase. Because of its better sensitivity, NGS methods are recommended for mutation testing rather than Sanger's. Facing a given TKD mutation, therapeutic decision should be taken based on in vitro sensitivity and clinical efficacy data. Identification by sequencing of a TKD mutation known to induce resistance must lead to a therapeutic change. The clinical value of testing methods more sensitive than NGS remains to be assessed.

Next-generation sequencing for sensitive detection of BCR-ABL1 mutations relevant to tyrosine kinase inhibitor choice in imatinib-resistant patients

In chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) and Philadelphia-positive (Ph+) acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) patients who fail imatinib treatment, BCR-ABL1 mutation profiling by Sanger sequencing (SS) is recommended before changing therapy since detection of specific mutations influences second-generation tyrosine kinase inhibitor (2GTKI) choice. We aimed to assess i) in how many patients who relapse on second-line 2GTKI therapy next generation sequencing (NGS) may track resistant mutations back to the sample collected at the time of imatinib resistance, before 2GTKI start (switchover sample) and ii) whether low level mutations identified by NGS always undergo clonal expansion. To this purpose, we used NGS to retrospectively analyze 60 imatinib-resistant patients (CML, n = 45; Ph+ ALL,n = 15) who had failed second-line 2GTKI therapy and had acquired BCR-ABL1 mutations (Group 1) and 25 imatinib-resistant patients (CML, n = 21; Ph+ ALL, n = 4) who had responded to second-line 2GTKI therapy, for comparison (Group 2). NGS uncovered that in 26 (43%) patients in Group 1, the 2GTKI-resistant mutations that triggered relapse were already detectable at low levels in the switchover sample (median mutation burden, 5%; range 1.1%-18.4%). Importantly, none of the low level mutations detected by NGS in switchover samples failed to expand whenever the patient received the 2GTKI to whom they were insensitive. In contrast, no low level mutation that was resistant to the 2GTKI the patients subsequently received was detected in the switchover samples from Group 2. NGS at the time of imatinib failure reliably identifies clinically relevant mutations, thus enabling a more effective therapeutic tailoring.

Incidence of Bcr-Abl kinase domain mutations in imatinib refractory chronic myeloid leukemia patients from South India

Mutations in the Bcr-Abl kinase domain (KD) are a major cause for acquired resistance to imatinib (IM) treatment and have been associated with progression and poor prognosis in chronic myeloid leukemia patients. The present study includes 63 patients resistant to standard imatinib dose of 400 mg according to ELN guidelines. Direct sequencing method is used for mutational analysis. The present study revealed 15 exonic mutations in 46.03 % of patients; among them, seven cases (24.13 %) had multiple mutations. Mutations were found to be higher in sokal high- (45.0 %) and intermediate- (68.42 %) compared to low-risk (29.16 %) group. Mutations were observed in 38.09 % of patients with EUTOS (European Treatment and Outcome Study) high risk and in 50.0 % with low risk. The frequency of mutations was 50.0 % in advanced phase, 47.36 % in late chronic-phase, and 43.33 % in chronic-phase patients. 42.10 % of patients with primary resistance and 52.0 % with secondary resistance had mutations. P-loop and T315I mutations were associated with poor survival in advanced phase patients (85.71 %) (P = 0.03). No significant variation was observed with Bcr-Abl transcript levels between the patients with the presence or absence of mutations (P = 0.73). Bcr-Abl levels were found to be significantly elevated in P-loop and T315I mutation carriers (P = 0.001) and also in T315I mutation-positive patients (P = 0.01). P-loop mutations and T315I are frequent in advanced phases and strongly associated with poor prognosis and survival. Hence, the identification of mutations in IM-resistant CML patients will help in treatment optimization with 2nd- or 3rd-generation tyrosine kinase inhibitors (TKIs).

Early detection and quantification of mutations in the tyrosine kinase domain of chimerical BCR-ABL1 gene combining high-resolution melting analysis and mutant-allele specific quantitative polymerase chain reaction

BCR-ABL1 point mutations are the most common cause of resistance in patients with chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) who fail or lose response to tyrosine kinase inhibitors. We have developed a rapid method to screen BCR-ABL1 mutations by high resolution melting (HRM). We designed a strategy based on amplification refractory mutational system-quantitative polymerase chain reaction (ARMS-qPCR) to identify and quantify several clinically relevant mutations. From 856 patients with CML studied during 2 years in our laboratory, we selected 32 who showed persistent levels of BCR-ABL1 transcripts (>0.1%) in at least two consecutive studies. Using our strategy, we identified mutations in 11/32 cases (34.4%), while only two of them (6.2%) were detectable by sequencing. Furthermore, we were able to estimate the timing and dynamics of mutated clones, evaluating retrospective samples from the same patient. In cases with lack or loss of molecular response this analysis might be useful for designing early therapeutic strategies.

Sensitive detection of BCR-ABL1 mutations in patients with chronic myeloid leukemia after imatinib resistance is predictive of outcome during subsequent therapy

PURPOSE

BCR-ABL1 mutation analysis is recommended to facilitate selection of appropriate therapy for patients with chronic myeloid leukemia after treatment with imatinib has failed, since some frequently occurring mutations confer clinical resistance to nilotinib and/or dasatinib. However, mutations could be present below the detection limit of conventional direct sequencing. We developed a sensitive, multiplexed mass spectrometry assay (detection limit, 0.05% to 0.5%) to determine the impact of low-level mutations after imatinib treatment has failed.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Mutation status was assessed in 220 patients treated with nilotinib or dasatinib after they experienced resistance to imatinib.

RESULTS

Mutations were detected by sequencing in 128 patients before commencing nilotinib or dasatinib therapy (switchover). In 64 patients, 132 additional low-level mutations were detected by mass spectrometry alone (50 of 132 mutations were resistant to nilotinib and/or dasatinib). When patients received the inhibitor for which the mutation confers resistance, 84% of the low-level resistant mutations rapidly became dominant clones detectable by sequencing, including 11 of 12 T315I mutations. Subsequent complete cytogenetic response rates were lower for patients with resistant mutations at switchover detected by sequencing (0%) or mass spectrometry alone (16%) compared with patients with other mutations or no mutations (41% and 49%, respectively; P < .001). Failure-free survival among the 100 patients with chronic phase chronic myeloid leukemia when resistant mutations were detected at switchover by sequencing or mass spectrometry alone was 0% and 0% compared with 51% and 45% for patients with other mutations or no mutations (P = .003).

CONCLUSION

Detection of low-level mutations after imatinib resistance offers critical information to guide subsequent therapy selection. If an inappropriate kinase inhibitor is selected, there is a high risk of treatment failure with clonal expansion of the resistant mutant.

Philadelphia-positive acute lymphoblastic leukemia patients already harbor BCR-ABL kinase domain mutations at low levels at the time of diagnosis

BACKGROUND

In patients with Philadelphia-positive acute lymphoblastic leukemia, resistance to treatment with tyrosine kinase inhibitors is frequent and most often associated with the development of point mutations in the BCR-ABL kinase domain. We aimed to assess: (i) in how many patients BCR-ABL kinase domain mutations are already detectable at relatively low levels at the time of diagnosis, and (ii) whether mutation detection correlates with subsequent response to therapy.

DESIGN AND METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed samples collected at diagnosis from 15 patients with Philadelphia-positive acute lymphoblastic leukemia who subsequently received tyrosine kinase inhibitor therapy (dasatinib) by cloning the BCR-ABL kinase domain in a bacterial vector and sequencing 200 independent clones per sample.

RESULTS

Mutations at relatively low levels (2-4 clones out of 200) could be detected in all patients--eight who relapsed and seven who achieved persistent remission. Each patient had evidence of two to eight different mutations, the majority of which have never been reported in association with resistance to tyrosine kinase inhibitors. In two patients out of six who relapsed because of a mutation, the mutation (a T315I) was already detectable in a few clones at the time of diagnosis. On the other hand, a patient who was found to harbor an F317L mutation is in persistent remission on dasatinib.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results suggest that the BCR-ABL kinase domain is prone to randomly accumulate point mutations in Philadelphia-positive acute lymphoblastic leukemia, although the presence of these mutations in a relatively small leukemic subclone does not always preclude a primary response to tyrosine kinase inhibitors.