Characteristics and diagnostic significance of wheezes during exercise-induced airway obstruction in children with asthma

Lung sound analysis for wheeze episode detection

Listening and interpreting lung sounds by a stethoscope had been an important component of screening and diagnosing lung diseases. However this practice has always been vulnerable to poor audibility, inter-observer variations (between different physicians) and poor reproducibility. Thus computerized analysis of lung sounds for objective diagnosis of lung diseases is seen as a probable aid. In this paper we aim at automatic analysis of lung sounds for wheeze episode detection and quantification. The proposed algorithm integrates and analyses the set of parameters based on ATS (American Thoracic Society) definition of wheezes. It is very robust, computationally simple and yielded sensitivity of 84% and specificity of 86%.

Respiratory noises: how useful are they clinically?

Although clinicians place considerable weight on the identification of the various forms of noisy breathing, there are serious questions regarding both the accuracy (validity) and the reliability (repeatability) of these noises. To avoid diagnostic errors, clinicians need to consider the whole constellation of symptoms and signs, and not focus on the specific "type" of noise. Given the high error rate with "parent-reported wheeze" there is a need to reexamine the extensive literature on the epidemiology of wheeze in infants and young children, because parent-reported wheeze is unconfirmed by a clinician. It is obvious we need more high-quality research evidence to derive better evidence on the clinical utility of these noises, and their natural history.

Perceptions of asthma by adolescents at home

OBJECTIVES

To test symptom perception in asthma under natural circumstances and to establish relationships between changes in airway obstruction as indicated by wheeze, dyspnea, general sensations, and emotional state.

DESIGN

Continuous in vivo monitoring.

METHOD

Symptom perception was tested in 30 adolescents with severe, unstable asthma. They were continuously monitored in their homes for 72 h. Symptom perception was defined as the relation between self-reported dyspnea and airway obstruction as evident from audible wheeze. Tracheal sounds were continuously recorded with wireless telemetry for wheeze assessment. Dyspnea was assessed four times per day on a Likert-type 10-point scale, as well as four times randomly after pager remote command. The subjects kept records of use of medication, daily activities, general symptoms, and mood state in a diary.

RESULTS

There were nine subjects with one or two wheeze episodes, another three subjects with three or four episodes, and one subject with almost continuous wheeze. The presence of wheeze in general related significantly to a rise (from individual baseline) in dyspnea of > 2.5 scale points. Acute wheeze was the best predictor of a rise in dyspnea, but prolonged wheeze correlated significantly with negative mood and general symptoms.

CONCLUSION

Patients with prolonged airway obstruction perceived symptoms less well and were more vulnerable to negative effects of asthma than patients with acute onset airway obstruction.

Classification of asthmatic breath sounds: preliminary results of the classifying capacity of human examiners versus artificial neural networks

For continuous monitoring of the respiratory condition of patients, e.g., at the intensive care unit, computer assistance is required. Existing mechanical devices, such as the peak expiratory flow meter, provide only with incidental measurements. Moreover, such methods require cooperation of the patient, which at, e.g., the ICU is usually not possible. The evaluation of complicated phenomena such as asthmatic respiratory sounds may be accomplished by use of artificial neural networks. To investigate the merit of artificial neural networks, the capacities of neural networks and human examiners to classify breath sounds were compared in this study. Breath sounds were in vivo recorded from 50 school-age children with asthma and from 10 controls. Sound intervals with a duration of 20 seconds were randomly sampled from asthmatics during exacerbation, asthmatics in remission, and controls. The samples were digitized and related to peak expiratory flow. From each interval, two full breath cycles were selected. Of each selected breath cycle, a Fourier power spectrum was calculated. The so-obtained set of spectral vectors was classified by means of artificial neural networks. Humans evaluated graphic displays of the spectra. Human examiners could not clearly discriminate between the three groups by inspecting the spectrograms. Classification by self-classifying neural networks confirmed the existence of at least three classes; however, discrimination of 11 classes seemed more appropriate. Good results were obtained with supervised networks: as much as 95% of the training vectors could be classified correctly, and 43% of the test vectors. The three patient groups, as discriminated in advance, do not correspond with three sharply separated sets of spectrograms. More than three classes seem to be present. Humans cannot take up the spectral complexity and showed negative classification results. Artificial neural networks, however, are able to handle classification tasks and show positive results.

Characteristics and diagnostic significance of spontaneous wheezing in children with asthma: results of continuous in vivo sound recording

The characteristics and diagnostics of wheezing during induced airway obstruction are well documented. The present study addressed (a) the characteristics of spontaneous wheezing with respect to a possible distinction between wheezes during in vivo versus induced airway obstruction, and (b) the relationship between in vivo wheezing and fluctuations in peak expiratory flow (PEF). Tracheal sounds were continuously recorded from 50 children and adolescents with asthma and 10 without asthma in the home environment. Wheezes underwent a qualitative analysis, including their concomitant sound frequencies. Presence of wheezing was scored by two examiners independently and was related to PEF. Spontaneous wheeze varied from solitary rhonchi to prolonged rhythms of loud stridor, and resembled the "induced" wheezes recorded previously. Power spectra showed that the spectral contents (frequency distribution) were comparable, although the in vivo patterns were more prolonged in duration. The diagnostic sensitivity and specificity of wheezing for a reduction in PEF of >20% were 88% and 92%, respectively. It was concluded that in vivo wheeze resembled induced wheeze and was a diagnostically reliable symptom with respect to asthma exacerbations.

Cough as the ambiguous indicator of airway obstruction in asthma

This study tested the hypothesis that cough frequency during induced airway obstruction in children and adolescents with asthma relates significantly to other symptoms. The second hypothesis was that cough during remission may often be a conditioned or voluntary response. In experiment 1, tracheal sounds were recorded from 30 participants with asthma during a histamine challenge test. In experiment 2, tracheal sounds were recorded from 30 participants with and 30 without asthma during a standardized physical exercise task. Cough and respiratory wheeze were assessed from the sound records by two examiners independently. The results showed that cough during airway obstruction did not relate to other variables. Only the second hypothesis was supported. In both experiments the frequency of cough was independent of lung function (forced expiratory volume in 1 sec [FEV1]), wheezing, dyspnea, and severity of asthma. The percentage of participants with asthma who coughed in experiment 1 increased from 21% (baseline) to 71% after histamine inhalation. During experiment 2, the cough percentage increased from 52% to 69% in asthmatics, and from zero to 57% in controls. It was concluded that cough in asthma is not diagnostically useful for assessment of airway obstruction. Excessive baseline cough among asthmatics could be the result of acquired responses to anticipated exercise-induced symptoms.

Symptom perception in asthma: a multidisciplinary review

Clinical observations and research show that symptom perception in asthma is, at worst, inaccurate or often biased in two directions: (1) blunted perception, (2) overperception (both involving airway obstruction manifested in low or high breathlessness). Theoretically breathlessness occurs during respiratory labor or blood gas changes. However, pathophysiological factors and asthma severity are inconsistently related to perceptual accuracy. Consequently, symptom perception within the biomedical perspective is not well understood. Possible psychological influences, varying from the stimulus level to emotions and high-order reasoning, are discussed.

Diagnostics of spontaneous cough in childhood asthma: results of continuous tracheal sound recording in the homes of children

Spontaneous cough is a symptom with diffuse diagnostic significance for childhood asthma. Information on the interrelations between presence/frequency of cough and other symptoms of asthma are not available to the physician. Tracheal sounds were continuously recorded in the homes of 60 children with and 30 without asthma, at 72 and 24 h, respectively. Presence and frequency of cough and presence of wheeze were scored by trained examiners. Wheeze was used to indicate airway obstruction during hours when peak expiratory flow (PEF) values were not available. PEF and self-reported dyspnea were assessed every 4 h. Results showed that asthmatics coughed significantly more often than control subjects during exacerbations, but not during remission. The highest diagnostic sensitivity percentages of cough were 72% for wheeze and 69% for a reduction in PEF > 20%. However, the diagnostic specificity was poor, 41% for wheeze and 34% for a reduction in PEF > 20%. Cough and dyspnea were independent. Three children did not cough during exacerbations. Persistent, isolated cough was observed in two children. It was concluded that spontaneous cough is modestly predictive of asthmatic exacerbations, but not of a diagnosis of asthma or severity of asthma.