Review of recent results using computational fluid dynamics simulations in patients receiving mechanical assist devices for end-stage heart failure

Rapid Manufacturing Method of Cardiovascular Models for Experimental Flow Analysis

Physical anatomical models constructed from medical images are valuable research tools for evaluating patient-specific clinical circumstances. For example, 3D models replicating a patient's internal anatomy in the cardiovascular system can be used to validate Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) models, which can then be used to identify potential hemodynamic consequences of surgical decisions by providing insight into how blood and vascular tissue mechanics may contribute to disease progression and post-operative complications. Patient-specific models have been described in the literature; however, rapid prototyping models that achieve anatomical accuracy, optical transparency, and thin-walled compliance in a cost and time-effective approach have proven challenging. This limits their utility for modeling flows in vessels, e.g., the aorta, where compliance is particularly important. The work described herein is focused on a unique design and fabrication process implemented to produce physical patient-specific models that replicate the original anatomy dimensions and compliance with optical properties consistent with clinical imaging techniques. The patient-specific models are produced for under $150 of easily accessible consumable raw materials within 30 h using a relatively basic approach.•This method can be tuned for anatomies with different shapes and compliance.•This method can produce models to investigate medical device performance in vitro.

Sensitivity of Left Atrial Flow Dynamics to Echocardiographic and Computed Tomography Data

Computational simulations are a powerful tool in the understanding, diagnosing, and treatment of cardiovascular diseases. Incomplete clinical data often limits computational assessment, which may lead to inaccuracies. This study aims to assess the sensitivity of left atrial flow dynamics to echocardiographic and computed tomography data. Models of the LA were reconstructed at the E-wave(Geometry 1)and end-diastolic(Geometry 2)phases from CT scans. CFD simulations were carried out using 3 different sets of BCs. BC2 and BC3 presented similar results that were significantly different from BC1. The effect from the choice of geometry was significant with BC2 and BC3 but minor with BC1. Differences in parameters across the simulated cases highlight the importance of using consistent BCs and geometries for CFD studies. Acquiring the pressure in the LA does not seem to be necessary for the accuracy of CFD simulations. Validation of all simulations indicates reliable patient-specific results.

Numerical assessment of hemodynamic perspectives of a left ventricular assist device and subsequent proposal for improvisation

Due to the unavailability of donors, the use of left ventricular assist devices has emerged to be a reliable line of alternative treatment for heart failure. However, ventricular assist devices (VAD) have been associated with several postoperative complications such as thrombosis, hemolysis, etc. Despite considerable improvements in technology, blood trauma due to high shear stress generation has been a major concern that is largely related to the geometrical feature of the VAD. This study aims to establish the design process of a centrifugal pump by considering several variations in the geometrical feature of a base design using the commercial solver ANSYS-CFX. To capture the uncertain behavior of blood as fluid, Newtonian, as well as non-Newtonian (Bird-Carreau model), models are used for flow field prediction. To assess the possibility of blood damage maximum wall shear stress and hemolysis index have been estimated for each operating point. The results of the simulations yield an optimized design of the pump based on parameters like pressure head generation, maximum shear stress, hydraulic efficiency, and hemolysis index. Further, the design methodology and the steps of development discussed in the paper can serve as a guideline for developing small centrifugal pumps handling blood.

Hemodynamic analysis for stenosis microfluidic model of thrombosis with refined computational fluid dynamics simulation

Disturbed blood flow has been increasingly recognized for its critical role in platelet aggregation and thrombosis. Microfluidics with hump shaped contractions have been developed to mimic microvascular stenosis and recapitulate the prothrombotic effect of flow disturbance. However the physical determinants of microfluidic hemodynamics are not completely defined. Here, we report a refined computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulation approach to map the shear rate (γ) and wall shear stress (τ) distribution in the stenotic region at high accuracy. Using ultra-fine meshing with sensitivity verification, our CFD results show that the stenosis level (S) is dominant over the bulk shear rate (γ₀) and contraction angle (α) in determining γ and τ distribution at stenosis. In contrast, α plays a significant role in governing the shear rate gradient (γ^′) distribution while it exhibits subtle effects on the peak γ. To investigate the viscosity effect, we employ a Generalized Power-Law model to simulate blood flow as a non-Newtonian fluid, showing negligible difference in the γ distribution when compared with Newtonian simulation with water medium. Together, our refined CFD method represents a comprehensive approach to examine microfluidic hemodynamics in three dimensions and guide microfabrication designs. Combining this with hematological experiments promises to advance understandings of the rheological effect in thrombosis and platelet mechanobiology.

Application of physics-based flow models in cardiovascular medicine: Current practices and challenges

Personalized physics-based flow models are becoming increasingly important in cardiovascular medicine. They are a powerful complement to traditional methods of clinical decision-making and offer a wealth of physiological information beyond conventional anatomic viewing using medical imaging data. These models have been used to identify key hemodynamic biomarkers, such as pressure gradient and wall shear stress, which are associated with determining the functional severity of cardiovascular diseases. Importantly, simulation-driven diagnostics can help researchers understand the complex interplay between geometric and fluid dynamic parameters, which can ultimately improve patient outcomes and treatment planning. The possibility to compute and predict diagnostic variables and hemodynamics biomarkers can therefore play a pivotal role in reducing adverse treatment outcomes and accelerate development of novel strategies for cardiovascular disease management.

How to evaluate the outflow tract of LVAD after minimally invasive implantation by 3D CT-scan

During a minimally invasive implantation technique, the outflow graft of left ventricular assist device (LVAD) is tunnelled blindly through the pericardium or left pleura, with an inability to assess for twisting or malposition. Three-dimensional computed tomography scan (CT-scan) has a role in qualitative evaluation of the different outflow tract configurations. The different surgical minimally invasive approaches include: (a) mini-sternotomy and left mini-thoracotomy, (b) right mini-thoracotomy and left mini-thoracotomy, (c) subclavian artery access and left mini-thoracotomy. The outflow graft could be anastomosed to the left axillary artery or the ascending aorta. CT-scan reconstruction using syngo InSpace4D (Siemens, Muenchen, Germany) was used to provide fast segmentation and high-resolution images. The 3D reconstructions permit an evaluation of different anastomosis configurations and to assess the route of outflow graft.

Evaluating medical device and material thrombosis under flow: current and emerging technologies

This review highlights the importance of flow in medical device thrombosis and explores current and emerging technologies to evaluate dynamic biomaterial Thrombosis in vitro.

Computational modeling of bicuspid aortopathy: Towards personalized risk strategies

This paper describes current advances on the application of in-silico for the understanding of bicuspid aortopathy and future perspectives of this technology on routine clinical care. This includes the impact that artificial intelligence can provide to develop computer-based clinical decision support system and that wearable sensors can offer to remotely monitor high-risk bicuspid aortic valve (BAV) patients. First, we discussed the benefit of computational modeling by providing tangible examples of in-silico software products based on computational fluid-dynamic (CFD) and finite-element method (FEM) that are currently transforming the way we diagnose and treat cardiovascular diseases. Then, we presented recent findings on computational hemodynamic and structural mechanics of BAV to highlight the potentiality of patient-specific metrics (not-based on aortic size) to support the clinical-decision making process of BAV-associated aneurysms. Examples of BAV-related personalized healthcare solutions are illustrated.

Intermittent Aortic Valve Opening and Risk of Thrombosis in Ventricular Assist Device Patients

The current study evaluates quantitatively the impact that intermittent aortic valve (AV) opening has on the thrombogenicity in the aortic arch region for patients under left ventricular assist device (LVAD) therapy. The influence of flow through the AV, opening once every five cardiac cycles, on the flow patterns in the ascending aortic is measured in a patient-derived computed tomography image-based model, after LVAD implantation. The mechanical environment of flowing platelets is investigated, by statistical treatment of outliers in Lagrangian particle tracking, and thrombogenesis metrics (platelet residence times and activation state characterized by shear stress accumulation) are compared for the cases of closed AV versus intermittent AV opening. All hemodynamics metrics are improved by AV opening, even at a reduced frequency and flow rate. Residence times of platelets or microthrombi are reduced significantly by transvalvular flow, as are the shear stress history experienced and the shear stress magnitude and gradients on the aortic root endothelium. The findings of this device-neutral study support the multiple advantages of management that enables AV opening, providing a rationale for establishing this as a standard in long-term treatment and care for advanced heart failure patients.

LVAD Outflow Graft Angle and Thrombosis Risk

This study quantifies thrombogenic potential (TP) of a wide range of left ventricular assist device (LVAD) outflow graft anastomosis angles through state-of-the-art techniques: 3D imaged-based patient-specific models created via virtual surgery and unsteady computational fluid dynamics with Lagrangian particle tracking. This study aims at clarifying the influence of a single parameter (outflow graft angle) on the thrombogenesis associated with flow patterns in the aortic root after LVAD implantation. This is an important and poorly-understood aspect of LVAD therapy, because several studies have shown strong inter and intrapatient thrombogenic variability and current LVAD implantation strategies do not incorporate outflow graft angle optimization. Accurate platelet-level investigation, enabled by statistical treatment of outliers in Lagrangian particle tracking, demonstrates a strong influence of outflow graft anastomoses angle on thrombogenicity (platelet residence times and activation state characterized by shear stress accumulation) with significantly reduced TP for acutely-angled anastomosed outflow grafts. The methodology presented in this study provides a device-neutral platform for conducting comprehensive thrombogenicity evaluation of LVAD surgical configurations, empowering optimal patient-focused surgical strategies for long-term treatment and care for advanced heart failure patients.

Effect of Outflow Graft Size on Flow in the Aortic Arch and Cerebral Blood Flow in Continuous Flow Pumps: Possible Relevance to Strokes

One of the most devastating complications of continuous flow left ventricular devices (CFLVADS) is stroke, with a higher incidence in HeartWare Ventricular Assist Device (HVAD) as compared with HEARTMATE II. The reason for the observed difference in stroke rates is unclear. Because outflow graft diameters are different, we hypothesized that this could contribute to the difference in stroke rates. A computational fluid-structure interaction model was created from the computed tomography (CT) scan of a patient. Pressures were used as the boundary condition and the flow through the cerebral vessels was derived as outputs. Flow into the innominate artery was very sensitive to the anastomosis angle for a 10 mm as compared with a 14 mm graft, with the net innominate flow severely compromised with a 10 mm graft at 45° angle. Aortic insufficiency seems to affect cerebral blood flow nonlinearly with an 80% decrease at certain angles of outflow graft anastomosis. Arterial return in to the arch through a narrow graft has important jet effects and results in significant flow perturbations in the aortic arch and cerebral vessels and stasis. A 10 mm graft is more sensitive to angle of insertion than a 14 mm graft. Under some conditions, serious hypoperfusion of the innominate artery is possible. Aortic incompetence results in significant decrease of cerebral blood flow. No stasis was found in the pulsatile flow compared with LVAD flow.

Hemodynamic analysis of outflow grafting positions of a ventricular assist device using closed-loop multiscale CFD simulations: Preliminary results

Subclavian arteries are a possible alternate location for left ventricular assist device (LVAD) outflow grafts due to easier surgical access and application in high risk patients. As vascular blood flow mechanics strongly influence the clinical outcome, insights into the hemodynamics during LVAD support can be used to evaluate different grafting locations. In this study, the feasibility of left and right subclavian artery (SA) grafting was investigated for the HeartWare HVAD with a numerical multiscale model. A 3-D CFD model of the aortic arch was coupled to a lumped parameter model of the cardiovascular system under LVAD support. Grafts in the left and right SA were placed at three different anastomoses angles (90°, 60° and 30°). Additionally, standard grafting of the ascending and descending aorta was modelled. Full support LVAD (5l/min) and partial support LVAD (3l/min) in co-pulsation and counter-pulsation mode were analysed. The grafting positions were investigated regarding coronary and cerebral perfusion. Furthermore, the influence of the anastomosis angle on wall shear stress (WSS) was evaluated. Grafting of left or right subclavian arteries has similar hemodynamic performance in comparison to standard cannula positions. Angularity change of the graft anastomosis from 90° to 30° slightly increases the coronary and cerebral blood flow by 6-9% while significantly reduces the WSS by 35%. Cannulation of the SA is a feasible anastomosis location for the HVAD in the investigated vessel geometry.

Computational fluid dynamics modelling in cardiovascular medicine

This paper reviews the methods, benefits and challenges associated with the adoption and translation of computational fluid dynamics (CFD) modelling within cardiovascular medicine. CFD, a specialist area of mathematics and a branch of fluid mechanics, is used routinely in a diverse range of safety-critical engineering systems, which increasingly is being applied to the cardiovascular system. By facilitating rapid, economical, low-risk prototyping, CFD modelling has already revolutionised research and development of devices such as stents, valve prostheses, and ventricular assist devices. Combined with cardiovascular imaging, CFD simulation enables detailed characterisation of complex physiological pressure and flow fields and the computation of metrics which cannot be directly measured, for example, wall shear stress. CFD models are now being translated into clinical tools for physicians to use across the spectrum of coronary, valvular, congenital, myocardial and peripheral vascular diseases. CFD modelling is apposite for minimally-invasive patient assessment. Patient-specific (incorporating data unique to the individual) and multi-scale (combining models of different length- and time-scales) modelling enables individualised risk prediction and virtual treatment planning. This represents a significant departure from traditional dependence upon registry-based, population-averaged data. Model integration is progressively moving towards ‘digital patient’ or ‘virtual physiological human’ representations. When combined with population-scale numerical models, these models have the potential to reduce the cost, time and risk associated with clinical trials. The adoption of CFD modelling signals a new era in cardiovascular medicine. While potentially highly beneficial, a number of academic and commercial groups are addressing the associated methodological, regulatory, education- and service-related challenges.