Impact of Upper Eyelid Surgery on Symptom Severity and Frequency in Benign Essential Blepharospasm

The long-term response to botulinum toxin injections in patients with blepharospasm undergoing upper eyelid surgery

BACKGROUND

Upper eyelid surgery (UES) is a therapeutical strategy used for those patients affected by blepharospasm (BSP) who either do not respond or experience a gradual decrease in responsiveness to botulinum toxin (BoNT) injections. Nevertheless, most of them need to restart with BoNT despite the intervention.

AIM

To evaluate the long-term post-surgical response to BoNT in patients with BSP and to identify predictive factors associated to treatment outcome.

METHODS

We collected data of 60 BS patients, divided into two groups - blepharoplasty YES (8) and NO (52), collecting demographic - age, sex - and clinical data -disease duration, duration of the treatment with BoNT. Respective responses to injections - evaluated through the differences of both Jancovic Rating Scale and the Blepharospasm Disability Index pre and post BoNT (delta JRS and delta BSDI) just before their periodic three-month injection and after 1 month from it - were compared. Finally, clinical and demographics variables were included in multivariate regression and correlation analyses to assess their impact on the long-term response to injections.

RESULTS

Patients who underwent UES had significantly lower delta at both scales, showing a poorer outcome after BoNT treatment. No variable was found to be associated with the response.

DISCUSSION

Our data seem to suggest that surgery does not improve response to BoNT injections on the long run. As such, UES could be considered as an efficacious treatment in BSP just if evaluated soon after its performing. Long-term BSP management seems still difficult to be performed adequately and new therapeutical approaches are still needed.

Blepharospasm Secondary to Deep Brain Stimulation of the Subthalamic Nucleus in Parkinson Disease: Clinical Characteristics and Management Outcomes

BACKGROUND

Deep brain stimulation of the subthalamic nucleus (STN-DBS) is an effective treatment for patients with motor symptoms of Parkinson disease but can be complicated by disabling blepharospasm and apraxia of eyelid opening (ALO). Currently, there is no clear consensus on optimal management, and addressing these issues is further hindered by systemic morbidity and resistance to treatments. We aim to describe the different phenotypes of these eyelid movement disorders, to report our management approach and patient responses to treatment.

METHODS

A retrospective case series of all patients with blepharospasm/ALO secondary to STN-DBS that were treated at a tertiary center between 2011 and 2020. Data collected included date of Parkinson diagnosis, date of DBS surgery, date of development of blepharospasm/ALO symptoms, STN-DBS stimulation settings, and treatment given. Patients' symptoms before and after treatment were measured using the blepharospasm disability index and Jankovic Rating Scale.

RESULTS

Five patients were identified with eyelid movement disorders secondary to STN-DBS. All patients had moderate-to-severe symptoms at presentation. Four patients received periocular botulinum toxin injections. Three patients underwent surgery in the form of frontalis suspension or direct brow lift with or without upper lid blepharoplasty. All reported an improvement in symptoms following treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

A multimodality, patient-specific approach is required in the treatment of blepharospasm/ALO secondary to STN-DBS. Botulinum toxin injections can be effective, but patients may require surgery if toxin treatment alone becomes ineffective. Tailoring treatment to individual needs can result in a measurable improvement in symptoms.