Steely A, Worcester E, Prochaska M. Contrasting Response of Urine Stone Risk to Medical Treatment in Calcium Oxalate versus Calcium Phosphate Stone Formers.
KIDNEY360 2024;
5:228-236. [PMID:
38251931 PMCID:
PMC10914189 DOI:
10.34067/kid.0000000000000362]
[Citation(s) in RCA: 0] [Impact Index Per Article: 0] [Reference Citation Analysis] [Abstract] [Key Words] [MESH Headings] [Grants] [Track Full Text] [Subscribe] [Scholar Register] [Received: 10/13/2023] [Accepted: 01/11/2024] [Indexed: 01/23/2024]
Abstract
Key Points
Thiazide treatment successfully lowered urine calcium and both calcium oxalate and calcium phosphate supersaturations in both types of stone formers (SFs). Alkali therapy may not confer the same benefits on calcium phosphate SFs as it does on calcium oxalate SFs.
Background
Randomized controlled trials have shown that both thiazide diuretics and potassium citrate (K-Cit) can prevent calcium stone recurrence, but most participants formed calcium oxalate (CaOx) stones. While thiazides are expected to lower risk of calcium phosphate (CaP) stone formation, the effect of K-Cit on risk of CaP stone formation is unclear.
Methods
To study the effect of common calcium stone treatments, we analyzed the 24-hour urines of CaOx and CaP stone formers (SFs) by four treatment types: Lifestyle, K-Cit, Thiazide, or Both medications.
Results
Patients treated with thiazides reduced urine calcium in both CaOx (M =−74.4, SD =94.6 mg/d) and CaP (M =−102, SD =99.7 mg/d) SFs while those on K-Cit had no change in urine calcium. Among CaOx SFs, urine citrate rose in patients administered K-Cit with or without thiazide, but citrate did not rise significantly in CaP SFs. Urine pH rose in all CaOx SFs, but among CaP SFs, only rose in patients receiving K-Cit. CaOx supersaturation (SS) decreased in all patients who received Thiazide, and decreased among CaOx SFs treated with K-Cit. CaP SS decreased in both CaOx SFs (M =−0.46, SD =0.86) and CaP SFs (M =−0.76, SD =0.85) treated with Thiazide, except CaOx SFs who received Both. Patients treated with K-Cit alone increased CaP SS in CaOx SFs (M =0.25, SD =0.79).
Conclusions
Patients treated with Thiazide lowered urine calcium and SS in both stone groups. Patients treated with K-Cit had no significant changes in urine calcium and had a decrease in CaOx SS in CaOx SFs. The study raises questions about the best preventive treatment for patients with CaP stones and suggests that K-Cit may not confer the same benefits on CaP SFs as it does on CaOx SFs.
Collapse