Ullrich-Turner syndrome: relevance of searching for Y chromosome fragments

OCT4 immunohistochemistry may be necessary to identify the real risk of gonadal tumors in patients with Turner syndrome and Y chromosome sequences

BACKGROUND

The aim of this study was to investigate the frequency of gonadal tumors among patients with Turner syndrome (TS) carrying Y-derivative sequences in their chromosomal constitution.

METHODS

Six out of 260 patients with TS were selected based on mosaicism of the entire Y chromosome; 10 were included because Y-derivative sequences have been detected by PCR with specific oligonucleotides (sex-determining region on the Y, testis specific-protein, Y and DYZ3) and further confirmed by FISH. The 16 patients were subjected to bilateral gonadectomy at ages varying from 8.7 to 18.2 years. Both histopathological investigation with hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) and immunohistochemical analysis with anti-octamer-binding transcription factor 4 (OCT4) antibody were performed.

RESULTS

Gonadal neoplasia was not detected in any of the 32 gonads evaluated by H&E; however, four gonads (12%) from three patients (19%) had positive OCT4 staining in 50-80% of nuclei, suggesting the existence of germ cell tumors (gonadoblastoma or in situ carcinoma).

CONCLUSIONS

Evaluation of the real risk of development of gonadal tumors in TS patients with Y-derivative sequences in their chromosomal constitution may require a specific histopathological study, such as immunohistochemistry with OCT4.

Y chromosome in Turner syndrome: review of the literature

Turner syndrome (TS) is one of the most common types of aneuploidy among humans, and is present in 1:2000 newborns with female phenotype. Cytogenetically, the syndrome is characterized by sex chromosome monosomy (45,X), which is present in 50-60% of the cases. The other cases present mosaicism, with a 45,X cell line accompanied by one or more other cell lines with a complete or structurally abnormal X or Y chromosome. The presence of Y-chromosome material in patients with dysgenetic gonads increases the risk of gonadal tumors, especially gonadoblastoma. The greatest concern is the high risk of developing gonadoblastoma or other tumors and virilization during puberty if chromosome Y-specific sequences are present. The role of the Y chromosome in human oncogenesis is still controversial. Even though gonadoblastoma is a benign tumor, it can undergo transformation into invasive dysgerminoma in 60% of the cases, and also into other, malignant forms of germ cell tumors. Although some authors have questioned the high incidence of gonadoblastoma (around 30%), the risk of developing any kind of gonadal lesion, whether tumoral or not, justifies investigation of Y-chromosome sequences by means of the polymerase chain reaction (PCR), a highly sensitive, low-cost and easy-to-perform technique. In conclusion, mosaicism of both the X and the Y chromosome is a common finding in TS, and detection of Y-chromosome-specific sequences in patients, regardless of their karyotype, is necessary in order to prevent the development of gonadal lesions.

Clinical implications of the detection of Y-chromosome mosaicism in Turner's syndrome: report of 3 cases

OBJECTIVE

To determine the clinical implications of the presence of a Y chromosome in Turner's syndrome patients with karyotype abnormalities.

DESIGN

To investigate the presence of Y-chromosome sequences in different tissue samples.

SETTING

Endocrinology outpatient clinic of a federal university in Brazil.

PATIENT(S)

Five Turner's syndrome patients with karyotype abnormalities such as marker chromosomes, additional material, or ring chromosomes.

INTERVENTION(S)

Peripheral blood, oral epithelial cells, and hair root samples were collected.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

The SRY gene and the DYZ3 repeat region were amplified by polymerase chain reaction followed by gel electrophoresis mobility of amplified genomic DNA, and ultraviolet visualization. Prophylactic gonadectomy was offered to the Y-positive patients.

RESULT(S)

The analysis of the different tissues revealed that three of the five patients studied presented Y-chromosome mosaicism. These three patients underwent prophylactic gonadectomy, and in one of them, the histopathologic study of the gonads disclosed hilus cell hyperplasia and stromal luteoma with contralateral nodular hyperthecosis.

CONCLUSION(S)

A systematic search for Y-chromosome mosaicism in Turner's syndrome patients is justified by the risk of developing gonadal tumors or androgen-producing lesions.

Detection of hidden Y mosaicism in Turner's syndrome: importance in the prevention of gonadoblastoma

The presence of Y chromosome fragments in patients with Turner's syndrome (TS) is known to increase the risk of gonadoblastoma. The investigation of Y sequences is usually performed only in the presence of marker chromosomes and therefore does not rule out the presence of hidden mosaicism in patients with 45,X TS without any marker.

AIMS

1. To investigate the presence of hidden Y mosaicism in non-mosaic 45,X patients with TS, using samples from different tissues, and its association with the development of gonadoblastoma.

STUDY DESIGN

Twenty patients with a 45,X karyotype were studied. The SRY and DYZ3 sequences were amplified by PCR, using genomic DNA from peripheral blood, oral epithelial cells and hair roots. Prophylactic gonadectomy was offered to the Y-positive patients.

RESULTS

The analysis of the different tissues revealed that seven (35%) out of the 20 patients studied presented hidden chromosome Y mosaicism. Four of these patients underwent prophylactic gonadectomy, and bilateral gonadoblastoma was found in one of them.

CONCLUSIONS

A systematic search for hidden Y chromosome mosaicism in patients with TS and 45,X karyotype is justified by the possibility of developing gonadoblastoma.

Histologic analysis of gonadal tissue in patients with Ullrich-Turner syndrome and derivative Y chromosomes

To identify patients who had Ullrich-Turner syndrome (UTS) and were at risk for gonadoblastoma or associated germ cell tumors, molecular genetic analysis was carried out to detect Y chromosomal sequences. From peripheral blood samples of 5 patients who had cytogenetically confirmed UTS, genomic DNA was extracted and screened for Y chromosomal sequences by polymerase chain reaction. The morphology of the gonadal tissues was compared with results from polymerase chain reaction. Three phenotypic females showed UTS mosaicism with normal X chromosome accompanied by Y chromosomal material, and 2 patients showed marker chromosomes. Molecular analysis represented loci PABY, SRY, ZFY, TSPY, DYZ3, DYZ1 DXYS, 19Y, DYS-273, DYS-148, DYS218, DYS224, and DYZ1. Three patients showed gonadal tumors (1 with unilateral gonadoblastoma, 1 with unilateral dysgerminoma, and 1 patient had both tumors in 1 gonad). Molecular genetic screening for Y chromosomal sequences may be useful as an additional tool for the identification of patients at risk for a gonadal tumor. Careful, complete processing, including step sectioning, of the gonadectomy specimens to detect small lesions is recommended.

Detection of Y-specific sequences in 122 patients with Turner syndrome: nested PCR is not a reliable method

The incidence of Y chromosome sequences in patients with Turner syndrome has been evaluated in several studies, and its frequency varied from 0% to 61%, depending on the molecular methodology used. The aim of our study was to screen for Y chromosome sequences in 122 patients with Turner syndrome without cytogenetic evidence of this chromosome. DNA of 100 normal women was also screened and it was used as a negative control. To identify cryptic Y mosaicism, eight regions of Y chromosome were amplified by PCR. In order to increase the sensitivity of Y sequence detection, a nested PCR of the SRY and TSPY genes was also performed. All patients had several stigmata of Turner syndrome and none of them presented with signs of virilization. The most frequent karyotype was 45,X (54.1%), followed by mosaicism involving structural aberration of the X chromosome. There were 12 patients who carried a marker or ring chromosome. First-round PCR identified Y chromosome sequences in only four patients (3%), and all of them had a chromosome mosaicism with at least one cell lineage with a marker chromosome. After nested PCR, 25% of the patients and 14% of the normal women were positive for the presence of Y sequences. Contamination with extraneous genomic DNA was ruled out by microsatellite studies, but we cannot eliminate the possibility of contamination with PCR products, despite careful handling. We conclude that nested PCR overestimated the frequency of Y sequences in patients with Turner syndrome and should be avoided to prevent false positive results, which lead to unnecessary surgical treatment of these patients.