Cesarean section upon request: is it appropriate for everybody?

Defensive Medicine in the Management of Cesarean Delivery: A Survey among Italian Physicians

Background and Objectives: This study aims to contribute to the definition of the defensive medicine phenomenon between obstetricians and gynecologists, as well as to possible effects on the frequency of deliveries performed by cesarean sections (CS). Materials and Methods: a digital questionnaire was administered through a mail-list including 600 gynecological specialists (of these 168 doctors completed the test), both in public and private settings. It was made of twenty multiple choice questions, concerning their awareness about the practice of defensive medicine and the planning and execution of CS. All doctors involved received clear and complete information about the purpose of this study and about the organizations that received their answers. Analyses of variance and regression were performed to describe differences between groups and to estimate the relationships between variables. The value of p < 0.5 was considered statistically relevant. Results: our analysis revealed that most respondents are confident with the defensive medicine definition and characteristics. This survey confirmed that gynecologists fear legal actions promoted by their patients and therefore modulate their choices by implementing professional behaviors of so-called “defensive medicine”. This relates to a greater number of medical liability judgements, which more often concern omission or delayed execution of cesarean section, rather than unskillful surgical procedures. Conclusions: there are few data to support a relation between the high rate of CS and defensive medicine. Numerous scientific studies associated this CS rate with the phenomenon of defensive medicine. This practice is constantly growing in all medical areas, especially in high-risk specialties such as obstetrics and gynecology. Our study highlights physicians’ awareness of adopting defensive medicine behaviors in their clinical practice, affecting the choice of the type of delivery to be performed.

Hospital variation in utilization and success of trial of labor after a prior cesarean

BACKGROUND

Trial of labor after cesarean delivery is an effective and safe option for women without contraindications.

OBJECTIVES

The objective of the study was to examine hospital variation in utilization and success of trial of labor after cesarean delivery and identify associated institutional characteristics and patient outcomes.

STUDY DESIGN

Using linked maternal and newborn hospital discharge records and birth certificate data in 2010-2012 from the state of California, we identified 146,185 term singleton mothers with 1 prior cesarean delivery and no congenital anomalies or clear contraindications for trial of labor at 249 hospitals. Risk-standardized utilization and success rates of trial of labor after cesarean delivery were estimated for each hospital after accounting for differences in patient case mix. Risk for severe maternal and newborn morbidities, as well as maternal and newborn length of stay, were compared between hospitals with high utilization and high success rates of trial of labor after cesarean delivery and other hospitals. Bivariate analysis was also conducted to examine the association of various institutional characteristics with hospitals' utilization and success rates of trial of labor after cesarean delivery.

RESULTS

In the overall sample, 12.5% of women delivered vaginally. After adjusting for patient clinical risk factors, utilization and success rates of trial of labor after cesarean delivery varied considerably across hospitals, with a median of 35.2% (10th to 90th percentile range: 10.2-67.1%) and 40.5% (10th to 90th percentile range: 8.5-81.1%), respectively. Risk-standardized utilization and success rates of trial of labor after cesarean delivery demonstrated an inverted U-shaped relationship such that low or excessively high use of trial of labor after cesarean delivery was associated with lower success rate. Compared with other births, those delivered at hospitals with above-the-median utilization and success rates of trial of labor after cesarean delivery had a higher risk for uterine rupture (adjusted risk ratio, 2.74, P < .001), severe newborn respiratory complications (adjusted risk ratio, 1.46, P < .001), and severe newborn neurological complications/trauma (adjusted risk ratio, 2.48, P < .001), but they had a lower risk for severe newborn infection (adjusted risk ratio, 0.80, P = .003) and overall severe unexpected newborn complications (adjusted risk ratio, 0.86, P < .001) as well as shorter length of stays (adjusted mean ratio, 0.948 for mothers and 0.924 for newborns, P < .001 for both). Teaching status, system affiliation, larger volume, higher neonatal care capacity, anesthesia availability, higher proportion of midwife-attended births, and lower proportion of Medicaid or uninsured patients were positively associated with both utilization and success of trial of labor after cesarean delivery. However, rural location and higher local malpractice insurance premium were negatively associated with the utilization of trial of labor after cesarean delivery, whereas for-profit ownership was associated with lower success rate.

CONCLUSION

Utilization and success rates of trial of labor after cesarean delivery varied considerably across hospitals. Strategies to promote vaginal birth should be tailored to hospital needs and characteristics (eg, increase availability of trial of labor after cesarean delivery at hospitals with low utilization rates while being more selective at hospitals with high utilization rates, and targeted support for lower capacity hospitals).

Examining the influence of maternal bradycardia on neonatal outcome using automated data collection

BACKGROUND

Due to the increasing number of caesarean sections, we investigated the influence of maternal bradycardia during general and regional anaesthesia on seven standard paediatric outcome parameters using our online recorded data.

METHODS

Data from 1154 women undergoing caesarean section were investigated prospectively. Bradycardia was defined as a heart rate below 60 beats/min. The matched-pairs method was used to evaluate the impact of bradycardia on Apgar scores at 1, 5, and 10 min, umbilical artery pH and base excess, admission to paediatric intensive care unit, and seven-day mortality. Matched references were automatically selected among all patients from the data pool according to anaesthetic technique, sensory block height, urgency, maternal age and body mass index. Stepwise regression models were developed to predict the impact of intra-operative bradycardia on outcome variables with differences between matched pairs assessed using univariate analysis.

RESULTS

Bradycardia was found in 146 women (12.7%) for whom a control could be matched in 131 cases (89.7%). Mean 5-minute Apgar score was 9.2+/-1.1 for study patients and 9.3+/-1.1 for controls. pH and base excess were not significantly different between groups. In cases of urgent surgery, neonates had an increased risk of 1.8 (95% CI 1.36-2.44, P<0.01) for an Apgar score <or= 8 at 1 min and a 2.6-fold risk (95% CI 1.64-4.06, P<0.01) of umbilical arterial pH of <or= 7.2 compared to infants undergoing non-urgent procedures.

CONCLUSIONS

Using matched-pairs analysis we were unable to demonstrate that episodes of maternal bradycardia below 60 beats/min were associated with a poorer neonatal outcome regardless of anaesthetic technique.

Challenges in small animal parturition--timing elective and emergency cesarian sections

Given the societal emphasis placed on the deliberate breeding of purebred animals, the practitioner today is faced with issues relative to successful parturition in these animals. Today, the serious hobby breeder expects to use planned breeding management to result in a high conception and pregnancy rate and survival rates of offspring that may exceed published parameters. These clients may elect to schedule cesarean section to maximize puppy survival and assure that they have access to quality veterinary care. Using a combination of hormone assays, temperature changes in the dam and carefully timed and documented breeding management, a cesarean section can be planned. Emergency cesarean sections will still be required for the bitch that experiences dystocia or a medical condition that warrants intervention. Timed cesarean section results in a favorable medical outcome for the dam and litter and a better financial outcome for the owner.

Factors associated with postpartum urinary/anal incontinence in primiparous women in Quebec

OBJECTIVE

To identify the factors associated with urinary incontinence (UI), anal incontinence (AI), and combined UI and AI (UI/AI) in primiparous women in Quebec at six months postpartum.

METHODS

A questionnaire was mailed to 2492 primiparous women at six months postpartum to collect data on incontinence status, sociodemographic characteristics, elimination habits, lifestyle, and severity index scales. Obstetric characteristics were obtained via Quebec's Med-Echo databank. Pearson chi-square, t test, analysis of variance, univariate regression, and stepwise modelling techniques were used for data analysis.

RESULTS

The prevalence of UI in responders was 29.6%, of AI, 20.6%, and of combined UI/AI, 10.4%. Significant adjusted odds ratios were (1) for UI, English spoken (2.04 [95% confidence intervals 1.13-3.69]) and shoulder dystocia (2.90 [1.09-7.69]); (2) for AI, age > 35 years (2.13 [1.12-4.03]), duration of second stage of labour (1.67 [1.11-2.51]), and third or fourth degree tears (4.00 [2.32-6.89]); and (3) for UI and AI, age (2.00 [1.04-3.83]), English spoken (2.55 [1.25-5.19]), shoulder dystocia (4.91 [1.76-13.71]), instrumental delivery (2.28 [1.30-3.99]), third or fourth degree tears (3.58 [1.95-6.57]), and episiotomy (2.24 [1.162-4.33]). Caesarean section was associated with less UI (0.45 [0.28-0.72]), and smoking was associated with less AI (0.38 [0.19-0.76]).

CONCLUSION

Combined UI/AI is associated with several obstetrical factors. The association of UI and AI is observed more frequently after complicated delivery (requiring the application of forceps) or involving perineal damage and episiotomy. As most of the identified factors are modifiable, a preventive treatment policy is advisable.

Psychosocial factors and mode of delivery

Childbirth is a substantial physical and emotional endeavor. Because emergency Cesarean and instrumental vaginal delivery impose a greater mortality and physical and emotional morbidity on both the mother and the infant than normal vaginal delivery, it is important to identify factors that are associated with the risk of operative delivery. In previous investigations, some associations have been found, but the effect of psychosocial factors is not clear. In this study we examined several factors which could be associated with the risk for instrumental and surgical delivery. In addition to biomedical factors we included psychosocial factors such as depressive symptoms, quality of the relationship of the woman with her partner, personality, lifestyle and educational level. We assessed 354 healthy nulliparous pregnant women with a child in vertex presentation and spontaneous onset of term labor using validated questionnaires. We found that social support from the woman's partner in pregnancy, lack of depressive symptoms and specific personality traits are not protective against instrumentally assisted vaginal delivery or emergency Cesarean section. Predictive factors for operative delivery after spontaneous onset of labor are higher fetal weight, non-occiput anterior presentation and advanced gestational age, and foremost fetal distress during parturition.