Novel pharmacological targets and progression of new antitussive drugs

Where are the new cough treatments: a debriefing of recent clinical proof-of-concept trials with the NOP agonist SCH 486757

Cough continues to be one of the top reasons why patients seek medical attention from health care providers. The prescription antitussive market is dominated by opioids, such as codeine that produces inconsistent efficacy and is often accompanied by significant side effect liabilities. Consequently, cough represents an unmet medical need and an underserved market. Yet, against the backdrop of increasing cough research, the development of novel treatments has been exceptionally challenging with dextromethorphan being the last US drug approved for cough almost a half century ago. We support the position that an unambiguous and actionable 'road map' that clearly delineates the pathway forward for new cough suppressants from basic research to and beyond clinical proof-of-concept studies will be an important aspect for future success of this pharmacological class of drug. Pivotal to the establishment of such a road map will be the review of lessons learned from antitussive agents that have been recently progressed to proof-of-concept trials. In the present commentary, we briefly discuss observations and challenges pertaining to SCH 486757, a selective orally active NOP agonist that has recently advanced to human antitussive testing.

The efficacy of a NOP1 agonist (SCH486757) in subacute cough

Currently, opiates are widely used as antitussives but have substantial side effects. Recently, it has been proposed that NOP1 receptor agonists may be useful as a novel approach to cough suppression. Therefore, we compared the effect of NOP1 receptor agonist SCH486757 with matched placebo and codeine in a multicentre, double-blind, parallel-group study in patients with subacute cough. The primary outcome was change in cough severity scores, with the key secondary outcome change in objective daytime cough counts. We studied 91 subjects with subacute cough [59 (65%) female, median age = 41(range = 18-64) years, and median cough duration = 33 (range = 16-99) days]. Subjects were randomised to receive either SCH486757 100 mg, codeine 30 mg, or matched placebo twice daily for 5 days. Cough severity was scored throughout using a diary card and objective cough frequency recorded for 8 h at baseline and on the first and last treatment days. There were no significant differences in changes in average cough severity scores from baseline to treatment between SCH486757 and placebo [mean change = -0.57 (-30.1%) vs. mean change = -0.49 (-19.7%); P = 0.56] or between codeine and placebo [mean change = -0.72 (-33.2%); P = 0.07 compared to placebo). Changes in objective cough counts also showed no differences between the three treatment groups. There were some hints of possible limited antitussive efficacy with SCH486757. Unfortunately, the maximum clinical dose is limited by its tendency to produce somnolence. If the therapeutic ratio of NOP1 agonists could be improved, these drugs may still prove to contain effective antitussives.

Pharmacological profile of the NOP agonist and cough suppressing agent SCH 486757 (8-[Bis(2-Chlorophenyl)Methyl]-3-(2-Pyrimidinyl)-8-Azabicyclo[3.2.1]Octan-3-Ol) in preclinical models

We describe the pharmacological and pharmacokinetic profiles of SCH 486757, a nociceptin/orphanin FQ peptide (NOP) receptor agonist that has recently entered human clinical trials for cough. SCH 486757 selectively binds human NOP receptor (K(i)=4.6+/-0.61nM) over classical opioid receptors. In a guinea pig capsaicin cough model, SCH 486757 (0.01-1mg/kg) suppressed cough at 2, 4, and 6h post oral administration with a maximum efficacy occurring at 4h equivalent to codeine, hydrocodone, dextromethorphan and baclofen. The antitussive effects of SCH 486757 (3.0mg/kg, p.o.) was blocked by the NOP receptor antagonist J113397 (12mg/kg, i.p.) but not by naltrexone (10mg/kg, p.o.). SCH 486757 does not produce tolerance to its antitussive activity after a 5-day BID dosing regimen. After acute and chronic dosing paradigms, SCH 486757 (1mg/kg) inhibited capsaicin-evoked coughing by 46+/-9% and 40+/-11%, respectively. In a feline mechanically-evoked cough model, SCH 486757 produces a maximum inhibition of cough and expiratory abdominal electromyogram amplitude of 59 and 61%, respectively. SCH 486757 did not significantly affect inspiratory electromyogram amplitude. We examined the abuse potential of SCH 486757 (10mg/kg, p.o.) in a rat conditioned place preference procedure which is sensitive to classical drugs of abuse, such as amphetamine and morphine. SCH 486757 was without effect in this model. Finally, SCH 486757 displays a good oral pharmacokinetic profile in the guinea pig, rat and dog. We conclude that SCH 486757 has a favorable antitussive profile in preclinical animal models.

TRPV1 antagonists as potential antitussive agents

Cough is an important defensive pulmonary reflex that removes irritants, fluids, or foreign materials from the airways. However, when cough is exceptionally intense or when it is chronic and/or nonproductive it may require pharmacologic suppression. For many patients, antitussive therapies consist of OTC products with inconsequential efficacies. On the other hand, the prescription antitussive market is dominated by older opioid drugs such as codeine. Unfortunately, "codeine-like" drugs suppress cough at equivalent doses that also often produce significant ancillary liabilities such as GI constipation, sedation, and respiratory depression. Thus, the discovery of a novel and effective antitussive drug with an improved side effect profile relative to codeine would fulfill an unmet clinical need in the treatment of cough. Afferent pulmonary nerves are endowed with a multitude of potential receptor targets, including TRPV1, that could act to attenuate cough. The evidence linking TRPV1 to cough is convincing. TRPV1 receptors are found on sensory respiratory nerves that are important in the generation of the cough reflex. Isolated pulmonary vagal afferent nerves are responsive to TRPV1 stimulation. In vivo, TRPV1 agonists such as capsaicin elicit cough when aerosolized and delivered to the lungs. Pertinent to the debate on the potential use of TRPV1 antagonist as antitussive agents are the observations that airway afferent nerves become hypersensitive in diseased and inflamed lungs. For example, the sensitivity of capsaicin-induced cough responses following upper respiratory tract infection and in airway inflammatory diseases such as asthma and COPD is increased relative to that of control responses. Indeed, we have demonstrated that TRPV1 antagonism can attenuate antigen-induced cough in the allergic guinea pig. However, it remains to be determined if the emerging pharmacologic profile of TRPV1 antagonists will translate into a novel human antitussive drug. Current efforts in clinical validation of TRPV1 antagonists revolve around various pain indications; therefore, clinical evaluation of TRPV1 antagonists as antitussive agents will have to await those outcomes.

Sulfur-dioxide exposure increases TRPV1-mediated responses in nodose ganglia cells and augments cough in guinea pigs

The objective of the present experiments was to study the effects of pulmonary inflammation induced by subacute Sulfur-dioxide (SO(2)) exposure on capsaicin-induced responses in isolated primary vagal sensory neurons and cough. Additionally, we examined the effects of SO(2) exposure on respiratory function and lung histology. All experiments were conducted 24 h after 4 days of subacute SO(2) (1000 ppm, 3 h/day for 4 days) exposure. In in vitro experiments, intracellular Ca(2+) concentrations were measured in single nodose ganglia cells isolated from SO(2) treated and control guinea pigs, using a fluorescence-based methodology. In nodose ganglia cells from SO(2)-exposed animals, intracellular Ca(2+) responses evoked by capsaicin (1 x 10(-7) and 1 x 10(-6) M) were significantly augmented (87% and 59%, respectively) compared to nodose ganglia from control animals. In vivo experiments, cough responses induced by a submaximal dose of aerosolized capsaicin (30 microM) were increased approximately 50% in SO(2) exposed animals compared to control animals. The enhanced cough response produced by SO(2) was inhibited by the corticosteroid, dexamethasone (10 mg/kg, p.o. b.i.d for 4 days and 10 mg/kg, p.o. once on day 5). In separate experiments, guinea pigs exposed to SO(2) displayed a decrease in respiratory frequency and minute ventilation and an increase in enhanced pause (PenH), a surrogate measure for pulmonary obstruction. Associated with the SO(2)-induced increase in cough and changes in respiratory parameters was an increase in BAL neutrophils. BAL neutrophil counts were 5+/-4 and 691+/-141 cells x 10(3)/ml for air and SO(2)-exposed animals, respectively. The neutrophillic inflammation induced by SO(2) was attenuated by dexamethasone treatment. Finally, staining for collagen, smooth muscle and goblet cells showed inflammation, remodeling and goblet cell metaphasia in the SO(2)-exposed animals. Our results demonstrate that SO(2) exposure enhances TRPV1 receptor function at the level of the nodose ganglia. This effect occurs in parallel with an increase sensitivity of the cough response to capsaicin.