Benchmark Studies for Explicitly Correlated Perturbation- and Coupled Cluster Theories. javascript:filterformular(´3´)

Accurate Calculation of Isomerization and Conformational Energies of Larger Molecules Using Explicitly Correlated Local Coupled Cluster Methods in Molpro and ORCA

An overview of the approximations in the explicitly correlated local coupled cluster methods PNO-LCCSD(T)-F12 in Molpro and DLPNO-CCSD(T)F12 in ORCA is given. Options to select the domains of projected atomic orbitals (PAOs), pair natural orbitals (PNOs), and triples natural orbitals (TNOs) in both programs are described and compared in detail. The two programs are applied to compute isomerization and conformational energies of the ISOL24 and ACONFL test sets, where the former is part of the GMTKN55 benchmark suite. Thorough studies of basis set effects are presented for selected systems. These revealed large intramolecular basis set superposition effects that make it practically impossible to reliably determine the complete basis set (CBS) limits without including explicitly correlated terms. The latter strongly reduce the basis set dependence and at the same time also errors caused by the local domain approximations. On the basis of these studies, the PNO-LCCSD(T)-F12 method is applied to determine new reference energies for the above-mentioned benchmark sets. We are confident that our results should agree within a few tenths of a kcal mol-1 with the (unknown) CCSD(T)/CBS values, which therefore allowed us to define computational settings for accurate explicitly correlated local coupled cluster methods with moderate computational effort. With these protocols, especially PNO-LCCSD(T)-F12b/AVTZ', reliable reference values for comprehensive benchmark sets can be generated efficiently. This can significantly advance the development and evaluation of the performance of approximate electronic structure methods, especially improved density functional approximations or machine learning approaches.

A larger basis set describes atomization energy core-valence correction better than a higher-order coupled-cluster method

The accuracy of coupled-cluster methods for the computation of core-valence correction to atomization energy was assessed. Truncation levels up to CCSDTQP were considered together with (aug-)cc-pwCVnZ (n = D, T, Q, 5) basis sets and three different extrapolation techniques (canonical and flexible Helgaker formula and Riemann zeta function extrapolation). With the exception of CCSD, a more accurate correction can be obtained from a larger basis set using a lower-level coupled-cluster method, and not vice versa. For the CCSD(T) level, it also implies faster computations with modern codes. We also discussed the importance of moving to higher-order or all-electron methods for geometry optimizations. The present study provides the general knowledge needed for the most accurate state-of-the-art computations.

Ab Initio Rovibrational Spectroscopy of the Acetylide Anion

In this work the rovibrational spectrum of the acetylide anion HCC- is investigated using high-level electronic structure methods and variational rovibrational calculations. Using a composite approach the potential energy surface and dipole surface is constructed from explicitly correlated coupled-cluster accounting for corrections due to core-valence correlation, scalar relativistic effects and higher-order excitation effects. Previous approaches for approximating the latter are critically evaluated. Employing the composite potential, accurate spectroscopic parameters determined from variational calculations are presented. In comparison to the few available reference data the present results show excellent agreement with ground state rotational constants within 0.005% of the experimental value. Intensities determined from the variational calculations suggest the bending fundamental transition ν2 around 510 cm-1 to be the best target for detection. The rather weak CD stretching fundamental ν1 in deuterated isotopologues show a second-order resonance with the (0,20,1) state and the consequences are discussed in some detail. The spectroscopic parameters and band intensities provided for a number of vibrational bands in isotopologues of the acetylide anion should facilitate future spectroscopic investigations.

High-dimensional neural network potentials for accurate vibrational frequencies: the formic acid dimer benchmark

In recent years, machine learning potentials (MLP) for atomistic simulations have attracted a lot of attention in chemistry and materials science. Many new approaches have been developed with the primary aim to transfer the accuracy of electronic structure calculations to large condensed systems containing thousands of atoms. In spite of these advances, the reliability of modern MLPs in reproducing the subtle details of the multi-dimensional potential-energy surface is still difficult to assess for such systems. On the other hand, moderately sized systems enabling the application of tools for thorough and systematic quality-control are nowadays rarely investigated. In this work we use benchmark-quality harmonic and anharmonic vibrational frequencies as a sensitive probe for the validation of high-dimensional neural network potentials. For the case of the formic acid dimer, a frequently studied model system for which stringent spectroscopic data became recently available, we show that high-quality frequencies can be obtained from state-of-the-art calculations in excellent agreement with coupled cluster theory and experimental data.

The curious case of DMSO: A CCSD(T)/CBS(aQ56+d) benchmark and DFT study

This work addresses the pathological behavior of the energetics of dimethyl sulfoxide and related sulfur-containing compounds by providing the computational benchmark energetics of R₂E₂ species, where R = H/CH₃ and E = O/S, with bent and pyramidal geometries using state-of-the-art methodologies. These 22 geometries were fully characterized with coupled-cluster with single, double, and perturbative triple excitations [CCSD(T)], second-order Møller-Plesset perturbation theory (MP2), and 22 density functional theory (DFT) methods with 8, 12, and 12, respectively, correlation consistent basis sets of double-, triple-, or quadruple-ζ quality. The relative energetics were determined at the MP2 and CCSD(T) complete basis set (CBS) limits using 17 basis sets up to sextuple-ζ and include augmented, tight-d, and core-valence correlation consistent basis sets. The relative energies of oxygen-/sulfur-containing compounds exhibit exceptionally slow convergence to the CBS limit with canonical methods as well as significant basis set dependence. CCSD(T) with quadruple-ζ basis sets can give qualitatively incorrect relative energies. Explicitly correlated MP2-F12 and CCSD(T)-F12 methods dramatically accelerate the convergence of the relative energies to the CBS limit for these problematic compounds. The F12 methods with a triple-ζ quality basis set give relative energies that deviate no more than 0.41 kcal mol^-1 from the benchmark CBS limit. The correlation consistent Composite Approach (ccCA), ccCA-TM (TM for transition metals), and G3B3 deviated by no more than 2 kcal mol^-1 from the benchmark CBS limits. Relative energies for oxygen-/sulfur-containing systems fully characterized with DFT are quite unreliable even with triple-ζ quality basis sets, and 13 out of 45 combinations fortuitously give a relative energy that is within 1 kcal mol^-1 on average from the benchmark CCSD(T) CBS limit for these systems.

Scalable Electron Correlation Methods. 8. Explicitly Correlated Open-Shell Coupled-Cluster with Pair Natural Orbitals PNO-RCCSD(T)-F12 and PNO-UCCSD(T)-F12

We present explicitly correlated open-shell pair natural orbital local coupled-cluster methods, PNO-RCCSD(T)-F12 and PNO-UCCSD(T)-F12. The methods are extensions of our previously reported PNO-R/UCCSD methods (J. Chem. Theory Comput., 2020, 16, 3135-3151, https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.jctc.0c00192) with additions of explicit correlation and perturbative triples corrections. The explicit correlation treatment follows the spin-orbital CCSD-F12b theory using Ansatz 3*A, which is found to yield comparable or better basis set convergence than the more rigorous Ansatz 3C in computed ionization potentials and reaction energies using double- to quaduple-ζ basis sets. The perturbative triples correction is adapted from the spin-orbital (T) theory to use triples natural orbitals (TNOs). To address the coupling due to off-diagonal Fock matrix elements, the local triples amplitudes are iteratively solved using small domains of TNOs, and a semicanonical (T0) domain correction with larger domains is applied to reduce the domain errors. The performance of the methods is demonstrated through benchmark calculations on ionization potentials, radical stabilization energies, reaction energies of fragmentations and rearrangements in radical cations, and spin-state energy differences of iron complexes. For a few test sets where canonical calculations are feasible, PNO-RCCSD(T)-F12 results agree with the canonical ones to within 0.4 kcal mol^-1, and this maximum error is reduced to below 0.2 kcal mol^-1 when large local domains are used. For larger systems, results using different thresholds for the local approximations are compared to demonstrate that 1 kcal mol^-1 level of accuracy can be achieved using our default settings. For a couple of difficult cases, it is demonstrated that the errors from individual approximations are only a fraction of 1 kcal mol^-1, and the overall accuracy of the method does not rely on error compensations. In contrast to canonical calculations, the use of spin-orbitals does not lead to a significant increase of computational time and memory usage in the most expensive steps of PNO-R/UCCSD(T)-F12 calculations. The only exception is the iterative solution of the (T) amplitudes, which can be avoided without significant errors by using a perturbative treatment of the off-diagonal coupling, known as (T1) approximation. For most systems, even the semicanonical approximation (T0) leads only to small errors in relative energies. Our program is well parallelized and capable of computing accurate correlation energies for molecules with 100-200 atoms using augmented triple-ζ basis sets in less than a day of elapsed time on a small computer cluster.

Canonical and explicitly-correlated coupled cluster correlation energies of sub-kJ mol-1 accuracy via cost-effective hybrid-post-CBS extrapolation

Cost-effectiveness and accuracy are two basic pillars in electronic structure calculations. While cost-effectiveness enhances applicability, high accuracy is sustained when employing advanced computational tools. With the gold standard method of ab initio quantum chemistry at the focal point, canonical CCSD(T) and modern explicitly correlated CCSD(T)-F12 calculations are employed hand in hand to develop accurate hybrid post-CBS extrapolation schemes, which are validated using popular training sets involving a total of 130 molecules. By using raw valence-only calculations at CCSD(T)/VDZ and CCSD(T)/VQZ-F12 levels of theory, the novel scheme leads to the prediction of absolute energies that differ on average (-0.170 ± 0.224) kcal mol-1 from the highest affordable CCSD(T)-F12b/V(Q,5)Z-F12 extrapolations, but only (-0.048 ± 0.228) kcal mol-1 from the post-CBS extrapolated values based on CBS(D,T), CBS(D,Q) and CBS(T,Q) energies. From the cost-effectiveness standpoint, the approach is a kind of pseudo one-point extrapolation scheme since its cost is basically that of the highest-rung raw energy where it is based. Variants that imply no additional cost are also discussed, emerging h-pCBS(dt,dq)ab as the most effective. The approach can also be used with PNO-based local correlation methods that gained popularity due to allowing coupled-cluster calculations even for large molecules at reduced computational cost, namely local PNO-CCSD(T) and PNO-CCSD(T)-F12b. To gauge the approach performance, both the hydrogen molecule and the O-C2H5 torsion path of ethyl-methyl-ether, an extra molecule here considered with presupposed existence in astrophysical objects, are also studied. Additionally, the nonbonding interactions in the A24 test set are revisited per se. The results show that the title approach may be useful in high-accuracy quantum chemistry, with further improvements requiring the inclusion of contributions beyond the theory here employed such as the ones due to relativistic and nonadiabatic effects.

Extrapolation in quantum chemistry: Insights on energetics and reaction dynamics

Since there is no exact solution for problems in physics and chemistry, extrapolation methods may assume a key role in quantitative quantum chemistry. Two topics where it bears considerable impact are addressed, both at the heart of computational quantum chemistry: electronic structure and reaction dynamics. In the first, the problem of extrapolating the energy obtained by solving the electronic Schrödinger equation to the limit of the complete one-electron basis set is addressed. With the uniform-singlet-and-triplet-extrapolation (USTE) scheme at the focal point, the emphasis is on recent updates covering from the energy itself to other molecular properties. The second topic refers to extrapolation of quantum mechanical reactive scattering probabilities from zero total angular momentum to any of the values that it may assume when running quasiclassical trajectories, QCT/QM-[Formula: see text]J. With the extrapolation guided in both cases by physically motivated asymptotic theories, realism is seeked by avoiding unsecure jumps into the unknown. Although, mostly review oriented, a few issues are addressed for the first time here and there. Prospects for future work conclude the overview.

The Molpro quantum chemistry package

Molpro is a general purpose quantum chemistry software package with a long development history. It was originally focused on accurate wavefunction calculations for small molecules but now has many additional distinctive capabilities that include, inter alia, local correlation approximations combined with explicit correlation, highly efficient implementations of single-reference correlation methods, robust and efficient multireference methods for large molecules, projection embedding, and anharmonic vibrational spectra. In addition to conventional input-file specification of calculations, Molpro calculations can now be specified and analyzed via a new graphical user interface and through a Python framework.

Energetics and ionization dynamics of two diarylketone molecules: benzophenone and fluorenone

Single photon ionization and subsequent unimolecular ion decomposition were studied on jet-cooled benzophenone and fluorenone separately, using VUV synchrotron radiation in a photoion/photoelectron coincidence setup. Slow PhotoElectron Spectra (SPES) were recorded in coincidence with either the parent or the fragment ions for hν < 12.5 eV. Dissociative ionization is observed for benzophenone only. The full interpretation of the measurements, including the identification of the neutral and ionic species when dissociative ionization is at play, benefits from high level ab initio computations for determining the equilibrium structures and the energetics of the neutral and ionized molecules and of their fragments. Electronically excited states of the parent molecular ions were calculated also. From this analysis, an accurate experimental determination of the energetics of the benzophenone and fluorenone ions and of their fragmentation channels is available: adiabatic ionization energies of benzophenone at 8.923 ± 0.005 eV and of fluorenone at 8.356 ± 0.007 eV; and appearance energies of benzophenone fragment ions at 11.04 ± 0.02 eV (loss of C₆H₅), 11.28 ± 0.02 eV (loss of H) and 11.45 ± 0.02 eV (loss of CO). The corresponding fragmentation mechanisms are explored, showing likely concerted bonds rearrangement. Possible pre-ionizing fragmentation is discussed in light of the spectra presented. The structural rigidity of fluorenone diarylketone seems to be the origin of the inhibition of the fragmentation of its cation.

CBS extrapolation in electronic structure pushed to the end: a revival of minimal and sub-minimal basis sets

The complete basis set (CBS) limit is secluded in calculations of electronic structure, and hence CBS extrapolation draws immediate attention.

Benchmarking Quantum Chemical Methods: Are We Heading in the Right Direction?

Theoreticians and experimentalists should work together more closely to establish reliable rankings and benchmarks for quantum chemical methods. Comparison to carefully designed experimental benchmark data should be a priority. Guidelines to improve the situation for experiments and calculations are proposed.

High-level theoretical rovibrational spectroscopy beyond fc-CCSD(T): The C3 molecule

An accurate local (near-equilibrium) potential energy surface (PES) is reported for the C3 molecule in its electronic ground state (X̃(1)Σg (+)). Special care has been taken in the convergence of the potential relative to high-order correlation effects, core-valence correlation, basis set size, and scalar relativity. Based on the aforementioned PES, several rovibrational states of all (12)C and (13)C substituted isotopologues have been investigated, and spectroscopic parameters based on term energies up to J = 30 have been calculated. Available experimental vibrational term energies are reproduced to better than 1 cm(-1) and rotational constants show relative errors of not more than 0.01%. The equilibrium bond length has been determined in a mixed experimental/theoretical approach to be 1.294 07(10) Å in excellent agreement with the ab initio composite value of 1.293 97 Å. Theoretical band intensities based on a newly developed electric dipole moment function also suggest that the infrared active (1, 1(1), 0)←(0, 0(0), 0) combination band might be observable by high-resolution spectroscopy.

Ab initio studies of the Rg-NO(+)(X(1)Σ(+)) van der Waals complexes (Rg = He, Ne, Ar, Kr, and Xe)

We used the explicitly correlated variant of the coupled clusters method with single, double, and noniterative triple excitations [CCSD(T)-F12] to compute two-dimensional potential energy surfaces of van der Waals complexes formed by rare gas atoms (Rg) and NO(+)(X(1)Σ(+)) cations. We used the correlation-consistent, triple-zeta (cc-pVTZ-F12) atomic basis sets, and for Kr and Xe rare gases, we employed corresponding pseudopotential cc-pVTZ-PP-F12 atomic basis sets. These basis sets were additionally augmented with mid-bond functions. The complexes are all of skewed T-shape type with Rg atom being closer to the N-side. Using analytical representation of the potentials, we have estimated zero-point energy corrected dissociation energies from anharmonic calculations with BOUND program and also from the harmonic approximation. The binding energies increase with the polarization of the Rg atom in series from He to Xe and are 196 cm(-1), 360 cm(-1), 1024 cm(-1), 1434 cm(-1), and 2141 cm(-1), respectively. Their corresponding dissociation energies are 132 cm(-1), 300 cm(-1), 927 cm(-1), 1320 cm(-1), and 1994 cm(-1) for the complexes with He to Xe, respectively. We find good agreement with previous theoretical and experimental results. The harmonic vibrational frequencies were calculated for the bending and stretching modes of the Rg-NO(+) complexes.

VUV photoionization and dissociative photoionization of the prebiotic molecule acetyl cyanide: theory and experiment

The present combined theoretical and experimental investigation concerns the single photoionization of gas-phase acetyl cyanide and the fragmentation pathways of the resulting cation. Acetyl cyanide (AC) is inspired from both the chemistry of cyanoacetylene and the Strecker reaction which are thought to be at the origin of medium sized prebiotic molecules in the interstellar medium. AC can be formed by reaction from cyanoacetylene and water but also from acetaldehyde and HCN or the corresponding radicals. In view of the interpretation of vacuum ultraviolet (VUV) experimental data obtained using synchrotron radiation, we explored the ground potential energy surface (PES) of acetyl cyanide and of its cation using standard and recently implemented explicitly correlated methodologies. Our PES covers the regions of tautomerism (between keto and enol forms) and of the lowest fragmentation channels. This allowed us to deduce accurate thermochemical data for this astrobiologically relevant molecule. Unimolecular decomposition of the AC cation turns out to be very complex. The implications for the evolution of prebiotic molecules under VUV irradiation are discussed.

Is near-"spectroscopic accuracy" possible for heavy atoms and coupled cluster theory? An investigation of the first ionization potentials of the atoms Ga-Kr

Recent developments in ab initio coupled cluster (CC) theory and correlation consistent basis sets have ushered in an era of unprecedented accuracy when studying the spectroscopy and thermodynamics of molecules containing main group elements. These same developments have recently seen application to heavier inorganic or transition metal-containing species. The present work benchmarks conventional single reference coupled cluster theory (up to full configuration interaction for valence electron correlation and coupled cluster with up to full pentuple excitations (CCSDTQP) for core-valence correlation) and explicitly correlated coupled cluster methods [CC with single, double, and perturbative triple substitutions (CCSD(T)-F12)] for the atomic ionization potentials of the six 4p elements (Ga-Kr), a property with experimental error bars no greater than a few cm(-1). When second-order spin orbit coupling effects are included, a composite methodology based on CCSD(T) calculations yielded a mean signed error of just -0.039 kcal mol(-1) and a mean unsigned error of 0.043 kcal mol(-1). Inclusion of post-CCSD(T) correlation corrections reduced both of these values to -0.008 kcal mol(-1) and 0.025 kcal mol(-1), respectively, with the latter corresponding to an average error of just 9 cm(-1). The maximum signed error in the latter scheme was just -0.043 kcal mol(-1) (15 cm(-1)).

Spectroscopic and thermochemical properties of the c-C6H7 radical: a high-level theoretical study

The electronic ground state (X(2)B(1)) of the cyclohexadienyl radical (c-C(6)H(7)) has been studied by explicitly correlated coupled cluster theory at the RCCSD(T)-F12x (x = a, b) level, partly in combination with the double-hybrid density functional method B2PLYP. An accurate equilibrium structure has been established and the ground-state rotational constants are predicted to be A(0) = 5347.3 MHz, B(0) = 5249.7 MHz, and C(0) = 2692.5 MHz. The calculated vibrational wavenumbers agree well with the recent p-H(2) matrix IR data [M. Bahou, Y.-J. Wu, and Y.-P. Lee, J. Chem. Phys. 136, 154304 (2012)] and several predictions have been made. A low value of 6.803 ± 0.005 eV is predicted for the adiabatic ionization energy of c-C(6)H(7). Owing to a moderately large change in the equilibrium structure upon ionization, the first band of the photoelectron spectrum is dominated by the adiabatic peak (100%) and only the peaks corresponding to excitation of the two lowest totally symmetric vibrations (ν(12) and ν(11)) by one vibrational quantum have relative intensities of more than 15%. The C(6)H(6)-H dissociation energy is calculated to be D(0) = 85.7 kJ mol(-1), with an estimated error of ~2 kJ mol(-1).

Fulvenallenyl cation (C7H5(+)) and its complex with an argon atom: results of high-level quantum-chemical calculations

The fulvenallenyl cation (C(7)H(5)(+)) and its complex with an argon atom have been studied by explicitly correlated coupled cluster theory at the CCSD(T)-F12x(x = a, b) level and by the double-hybrid density functional B2PLYP-D. For the free cation, an accurate equilibrium structure has been established and ground-state rotational constants of A(0) = 8116.4 MHz, B(0) = 2004.3 MHz, and C(0) = 1606.9 MHz are predicted. The equilibrium dipole moment is calculated to be μ(e) = 1.305 D, with the positive end of the dipole at the acetylenic hydrogen site. Anharmonic wavenumbers of C(7)H(5)(+) were obtained by combination of harmonic CCSD(T*)-F12a values and B2PLYP-D anharmonic contributions. The most intense vibration is the pseudoantisymmetric CC stretching vibration at 2083 cm(-1). The potential energy surface of the complex C(7)H(5)(+)·Ar is characterized by two energy minima of C(s) symmetry which are separated by a very low energy barrier. The dissociation energy of the most stable structure is predicted to be D(0) = 530 ± 30 cm(-1).