In situ Infrared Reflection Absorption Spectroscopy Studies of the Interaction of Nafion® with the Pt Electrode Surface

Spectroscopic Investigation of Catalyst Inks and Thin Films Toward the Development of Ionomer Quality Control

As the production of polymer electrolyte fuel cells expands, novel quality control methods must be invented or adapted in order to support expected rates of production. Ensuring the quality of deposited catalyst layers is an essential step in the fuel cell manufacturing process, as the efficiency of a fuel cell is reliant on the catalyst layer being uniform at both the target platinum loading and the target ionomer content. Implementing a quality control method that is sensitive to these aspects is imperative, as wasting precious metals and other catalyst materials is expensive, and represents a potential barrier to entry into the field for manufacturers experimenting with novel deposition processes. In this work, we analyzed catalyst inks to determine if their ionomer content could be quantized spectroscopically. Attenuated total reflection (ATR) Fourier transform infrared spectroscopic technique was investigated producing a signal proportional to the ionomer content. ATR spectroscopy was able to quantitatively differentiate samples in which the ionomer to carbon mass ratio (I/C) varied between 0.9 and 3.0. The I/C ratio was correlated to the measured ATR signal near the CF₂ vibrational bands located between 1100 cm^-1 and 1400 cm^-1. The experimental results obtained constitute a step toward the development of novel quality control methodologies for catalyst inks utilized by the fuel cell industry.

Progress on highly proton-conductive polymer thin films with organized structure and molecularly oriented structure

Several current topics are introduced in this review, with particular attention to highly proton-conductive polymer thin films with organized structure and molecularly oriented structure. Organized structure and molecularly oriented structure are anticipated as more promising approaches than conventional less-molecular-ordered structure to elucidate mechanisms of high proton conduction and control proton conduction. This review introduces related polymer materials and molecular design using lyotropic liquid crystals and hydrogen bond networks for high proton conduction. It also outlines the use of substrate surfaces and external fields, such as pressure and centrifugal force, for organizing structures and molecularly oriented structures.

Interesting Facets of Surface, Interfacial, and Bulk Characteristics of Perfluorinated Ionomer Films

Ion-containing perfluorinated polymers possess unique viscoelastic properties, excellent proton conductivity, and nanophase-segregated structure all arising from the clustering of hydrophilic sulfonic acid groups within a matrix of hydrophobic fluorocarbons. When these ionomers are confined to nanothin films, a broad swathe of structural organization imparting a rich variety of surface, interfacial, and bulk characteristics can be expected. However, our understanding of perfluorinated ionomer thin film behavior is still in a rudimentary stage, and much of the research focus to date has been on its hydration-related structure and properties pertinent to electrochemical applications. Thus, many hidden gems-their interesting surface and interfacial properties-have been overlooked. In this Invited Feature Article, which is a summary of the key contributions by the author's group, including several collaborative publications on ionomer thin films, we unravel many of these facets. In addition, the article attempts to integrate knowledge acquired from a variety of investigations of different aspects of the ionomer thin films to refine and develop a consistent picture of their structure and behavior. First, we focus on the self-assembly of ionomers and show that dispersion media and hydrophobicity/hydrophilicity of the substrate can result in partial or even no coverage of substrates, shedding light on the complexity of polymer-substrate, polymer-solvent, and polymer-polymer interactions, an insight completely obscured when the spin-coating method is adopted for film creation. We demonstrate that the same ionomer can be used to create a variety of surfaces ranging from superhydrophilic to highly hydrophobic by controlling the film thickness or through the choice of substrate material. The ultrathin, hydrophilic surfaces of self-assembled Nafion ionomer films exhibit wettability switching behavior which opens the door to creating stimuli-responsive smart surfaces. The thermoresponsive behavior of the films is discussed in the context of surface (wettability) and bulk (thermal expansion) characteristics as well as a newly discovered vibrational mode. The substrate- and film thickness-dependent thermal expansion coefficients reinforce the importance of interfacial interactions and confinement on the structure/properties of these films. They also open up the potential of tuning ionomer bulk properties via substrate chemistry. The discovery of a vibrational mode that becomes thermally activated at high temperature has provided new insights into the origins of the molecular motions responsible for the α-relaxation of the Nafion ionomer as well as the underlying reason for wettability switching. Our recent neutron reflectometry study of different ionomers varying in side-chain composition/length on a platinum substrate shows that the interfacial hydration level is correlated to the side-chain length, which opens up the possibility of the controlling the interfacial electrochemistry. Finally, a systematic analysis of factors affecting proton conduction is presented to elucidate the yet-unresolved origins of the suppressed conduction of nanothin ionomer films compared to that of the bulk membrane. By revealing these interesting yet poorly understood facets of ionomer thin films, the article aims to stimulate further scientific pursuit on this topic.

Vibrational Spectroscopy for the Determination of Ionizable Group Content in Ionomer Materials

An approach based on vibrational spectral measurements is described for determining the ionizable group content of ion conducting polymer membrane materials. Aimed at supporting the assessment of membrane stability and wear characteristics, performance is evaluated for attenuated total reflection Fourier transform infrared (ATR FT-IR) spectroscopy, confocal Raman microscopy, and ATR FT-IR microscopy using perfluorinated ionomer membrane standards. One set of ionomer standards contained a sulfonic acid ionizable group and the other a sulfonyl imide group. The average number of backbone tetrafluoroethylene (TFE) units separating the ionizable-group containing side chains was in the range of 7.2-2.1 (sulfonic acid set) and 10.5-4.6 (sulfonyl imide set). A poly(tetrafluoroethylene) (PTFE) sample was included as a blank, representing the limit of zero ionizable group (and maximum TFE) content. Calibration relationships were derived from area-normalized vibrational spectra. For all three methods, calibration models applied to independent spectral measurements of samples predicted the ratio of backbone TFE groups to ionizable groups in the repeat unit ( m) with a standard error of ≤ ±0.3. The confocal Raman and ATR FT-IR microscopy techniques achieved ideal blank responses and the lowest prediction errors, down to m ± 0.1 at the 90% confidence level. With its relative simplicity, low sample size requirements, and potential for quantitative micron-scale spatial mapping of the ionizable group content within a membrane, the approach has application to advancing materials development, including exploratory synthesis, durability and wear assessment, and in situ studies of membrane process.

Proton-Conductivity Enhancement in Polymer Thin Films

Highly proton conductive polymers have long attracted the attention of researchers for use in energy conversion, sensors, catalysts, and other applications. From the viewpoint of the scientific history of the creation of highly proton conductive polymers, one fundamental approach is based on the strategy of phase-segregated structures with strong acid groups. This Feature Article presents a new approach to enhancing the proton conductivity of the polymer thin films using an interface that can modify the degrees of freedom for a polymer structure through interaction between the substrate surface and polymers. I introduce suppressed proton conductivity into Nafion thin films and then specifically examine the enhancement in proton conductivity by the molecular orientation of the polymers. As the last topic, a highly proton conductive organized polyimide thin film is demonstrated using the lyotropic liquid-crystal property. Both molecular ordering and the in-plane oriented structure can enhance proton conductivity. Moreover, the optical domain and degree of molecular ordering derived from the molecular weight can contribute strongly to the proton transport property.

Signal Enhanced FTIR Analysis of Alignment in NAFION Thin Films at SiO2 and Au Interfaces

Spin-cast NAFION samples were prepared on silicon native oxide and gold substrates with film thicknesses ranging from 5 to 250 nm. The influence of NAFION film thickness on the infrared spectrum of the polymer was investigated in substrate overlayer attenuated total reflection (SO-ATR) geometry at incident angles between 60° and 65°. In the grazing angle SO-ATR geometry, the thickness of the film significantly affected the position and absorbance of characteristic peaks in the FTIR spectrum of NAFION. Two major peaks in the NAFION spectrum at 1220 cm^-1 (predominantly v_as(CF₂) and v_as(SO₃^-)) and 1150 cm^-1 (predominantly v_as(CF₂)) appeared to systematically blueshift to 1256 and 1170 cm^-1, respectively, as the thickness of the film decreased from 250 to 5 nm. The changes in the NAFION thin film FTIR spectrum can be attributed to two factors; (1) ordering of NAFION at the interface during spin coating and film formation and (2) the increase in the p-polarization character of the infrared evanescent wave as the polymer film became thinner between the internal reflection element and the film substrate overlayer. The increase in p-polarization resulted in an increase in characteristic peak absorbances of dipoles aligned normal to the substrate due to the overlayer enhancement of the electric field with NAFION films on Si or Au film substrates. These results show that the specific thin film sampling geometry, especially in internal reflection experiments, must be considered to rationally quantify changes in NAFION thin film infrared spectra.

Interfacial Structure and Proton Conductivity of Nafion at the Pt-Deposited Surface

Understanding the Nafion-Pt interface structure is important because fuel cell reactions occur at the three-phase boundary. Infrared (IR) p-polarized multiple-angle incidence resolution spectrometry (p-MAIRS) technique was used to investigate the in-plane (IP) and out-of-plane (OP) spectra in the identical substrate. Our previous study revealed that the proton conductivity of the Nafion thin films decreased at the MgO and SiO2 surfaces. We proposed that the origin for the lower proton conductivity can be derived from the highly oriented structure at the interface. However, the interface structure of the Nafion-Pt interface remains unclear. In this study, Nafion thin films were prepared by spin-coating on a Pt-deposited MgO substrates. The IP spectrum exhibited a well-known spectrum, but the OP spectrum was quite differed considerably from the IP spectrum. Furthermore, thickness dependence of the degree of orientation for this OP band was observed at the Nafion-Pt interface. This OP band can be assigned as the vibration mode of the mixture of the CF2 and sulfonic acid groups. At the low-RH region, proton conductivity of the Nafion thin film on the Pt-deposited surface was 1 order of magnitude higher than that on the SiO2 surface. Furthermore, the activation energy was 0.4-0.5 eV, which is lower than that of the SiO2 surface. These results, which suggest that the Pt surface influenced the proton transport property of Nafion thin film, can contribute to understand the relationship between the proton transport property and thin film structure on the Pt-deposited surface at the three-phase boundary for fuel cells.

Theoretical voltammetric response of electrodes coated by solid polymer electrolyte membranes

A model for the differential capacitance of metal electrodes coated by solid polymer electrolyte membranes, with acid/base groups attached to the membrane backbone, and in contact with an electrolyte solution is developed. With proper model parameters, the model is able to predict a limit response, given by Mott-Schottky or Gouy-Chapman-Stern theories depending on the dissociation degree and the density of ionizable acid/base groups. The model is also valid for other ionic membranes with proton donor/acceptor molecules as membrane counterions. Results are discussed in light of the electron transfer rate at membrane-coated electrodes for electrochemical reactions that strongly depend on the double layer structure. In this sense, the model provides a tool towards the understanding of the electro-catalytic activity on modified electrodes. It is shown that local maxima and minima in the differential capacitance as a function of the electrode potential may occur as consequence of the dissociation of acid/base molecular species, in absence of specific adsorption of immobile polymer anions on the electrode surface. Although the model extends the conceptual framework for the interpretation of cyclic voltammograms for these systems and the general theory about electrified interfaces, structural features of real systems are more complex and so, presented results only are qualitatively compared with experiments.

Ion effects at electrode/solid polymer electrolyte membrane interfaces

The differential capacity and the potential distribution at electrode/solid polymer electrolyte membrane/solution interfaces are calculated through an analytical approach. The model considers coions' and counterions' permeation through the membrane from the solvent phase and the ions' partitioning equilibrium at the SPEM/solution interface. The latter effects are included by incorporating the Donnan equilibrium, the steric hindrance, the solvation energy change when ions move from water to membrane pores and ion electrostatic interactions. It is shown that capacitance maxima in capacitance-potential curves may appear because of the acid-base dissociation process inside the membrane and the change in the ions' total interaction energy with the applied potential. For low dielectric constants inside membrane pores, εp, sharp peaks can be obtained. These peaks broaden, decrease in magnitude and shift to positive potentials once εp is increased. Finally, model predictions are discussed in light of recent experimental data obtained on Nafion® covered Pt(111) electrodes, providing a theoretical framework for the qualitative electroanalysis of these systems.

In situ surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopic studies of nafion adsorption on Au and Pt electrodes

Understanding interactions between Nafion (perfluorosulfonic acid) and Pt catalysts is important for the development and deployment of proton exchange membrane fuel cells. However, study of such interactions is challenging and Nafion/Pt interfacial structure remains elusive. In this study, adsorption of Nafion ionomer on Au and Pt surfaces was investigated for the first time by in situ surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy. The study is made possible by the use of uniform SiO(2)@Au core-shell particle arrays which provides very strong enhancement of Raman scattering. The high surface sensitivity offered by this approach yields insightful information on interfacial Nafion structure. Through spectral comparison of several model compounds, vibration assignments of SERS bands were made. The SER spectra suggest the direct interaction of sulfonate group with the metal surfaces, in accord with cyclic voltammetric results. Comparison of present SERS results with previous IR spectra was briefly made.

Responses of hydrophobic and hydrophilic groups in Nafion differentiated by least squares modeling of infrared spectra recorded during thin film hydration

Least squares modeling was applied to gain insights into changes that occur in the structure of Nafion polymer membrane during hydration. Transmission infrared spectra followed changes in the strong polymer bands in the range of 1400-950 cm(-1) during water uptake by initially dry membrane upon exposure to 100% relative humidity atmosphere. Spectra recorded during hydration were fit to a rate equation that modeled the loss of a dry state accompanied by the development of a hydrated state. The evolution of the two states was described by an equation for diffusion in a cylindrical pore in the long time limit. Comparison of the experimental spectra in a data set to spectra calculated from the pure components derived by least squares modeling gave an excellent match for bands of the -CF2 and C-O-C group modes, but agreement was not as close for bands arising from modes of the hydrophilic -SO3(-) group and (modeled separately) water. The differences are discussed in terms of the likelihood that the -SO3(-) groups have stronger interactions with bulk-like water condensed in the membrane and therefore undergo more complex changes than do more hydrophobic polymer regions during hydration. A different model is necessary to describe the evolution of spectral features for water and -SO3(-) end groups during water uptake into Nafion thin films.

Transmission infrared spectroscopy as a probe of Nafion film structure: analysis of spectral regions fundamental to understanding hydration effects

Transmission infrared spectroscopy was applied to investigate properties of the perfluorosulfonated polymer Nafion. Measurements were made on thin films formed by casting the polymer from solution onto ZnSe windows. Effects of water vapor permeation were studied. A complex band structure between 1350 and 1100 cm(-1) was analyzed qualitatively by fitting the region to Gaussian functions. Features associated with vibrational modes of -CF(2) and -SO(3)(-) groups were identified and observed to be sensitive to film hydration. The intensities of bands for the -SO(3)(-) modes increased with film hydration, while bands assignable to -CF(2) modes decreased. The results were applied to interpret infrared difference spectra of Nafion and shed light on the complicated features that appear. Vibrational bands for water were also examined. In partially hydrated films, the stretching mode of the free -OH group for interfacial water present in pores and channels of the polymer and bands for hydrated proton clusters were detected.