Quantification of Protein-Lipid Selectivity using FRET: Application to the M13 Major Coat Protein

Lipid–Protein Interactions in Plasma Membrane Organization and Function

Lipid–protein interactions in cells are involved in various biological processes, including metabolism, trafficking, signaling, host–pathogen interactions, and transmembrane transport. At the plasma membrane, lipid–protein interactions play major roles in membrane organization and function. Several membrane proteins have motifs for specific lipid binding, which modulate protein conformation and consequent function. In addition to such specific lipid–protein interactions, protein function can be regulated by the dynamic, collective behavior of lipids in membranes. Emerging analytical, biochemical, and computational technologies allow us to study the influence of specific lipid–protein interactions, as well as the collective behavior of membranes on protein function. In this article, we review the recent literature on lipid–protein interactions with a specific focus on the current state-of-the-art technologies that enable novel insights into these interactions.

Expected final online publication date for the Annual Review of Biophysics, Volume 51 is May 2022. Please see http://www.annualreviews.org/page/journal/pubdates for revised estimates.

FRET detects lateral interaction between transmembrane domain of EGF receptor and ganglioside GM3 in lipid bilayers

Ganglioside GM3 in the plasma membranes suppresses cell growth by preventing the autophosphorylation of the epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR). Biological studies have suggested that GM3 interacts with the transmembrane segment of EGFR. Further biophysical experiments are particularly important for quantitative evaluation of the peptide-glycolipid interplay in bilayer membranes using a simple reconstituted system. To examine these interactions in this way, we synthesized the transmembrane segment of EGFR bearing a nitrobenzoxadiazole fluorophore (NBD-TM) at the N-terminus. The affinity between EGFR and GM3 was evaluated based on Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) between NBD-TM and ATTO594-labeled GM3 in bilayers where their non-specific interaction due to lateral proximity was subtracted by using NBD-labeled phospholipid. This method for selectively detecting the specific lipid-peptide interactions in model lipid bilayers disclosed that the lateral interaction between GM3 and the transmembrane segment of EGFR plays a certain role in disturbing the formation of active EGFR dimers.

Förster Resonance Energy Transfer as a Tool for Quantification of Protein-Lipid Selectivity

This chapter addresses the determination of protein-lipid selectivity, here described as the preference of a protein for having a specific type of lipid in its vicinity, from Förster resonance energy transfer methodologies. These allow a quantification of the effect, that is, the determination of the biasing in distribution of the lipid under study around the protein, as compared to its bulk membrane distribution, with advantages over established approaches that have been used for the same purpose, such as electron spin resonance spectroscopy. The experiment can be carried out with steady-state instrumentation, the formalisms are described in detail, and the model can be applied to a membrane protein of any size.

Probing protein-lipid interactions by FRET between membrane fluorophores

Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) is a powerful fluorescence technique that has found numerous applications in medicine and biology. One area where FRET proved to be especially informative involves the intermolecular interactions in biological membranes. The present study was focused on developing and verifying a Monte-Carlo approach to analyzing the results of FRET between the membrane-bound fluorophores. This approach was employed to quantify FRET from benzanthrone dye ABM to squaraine dye SQ-1 in the model protein-lipid system containing a polycationic globular protein lysozyme and negatively charged lipid vesicles composed of phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylglycerol. It was found that acceptor redistribution between the lipid bilayer and protein binding sites resulted in the decrease of FRET efficiency. Quantification of this effect in terms of the proposed methodology yielded both structural and binding parameters of lysozyme-lipid complexes.

The influence of fluorescent silica nanoparticle surface chemistry on the energy transfer processes with lipid bilayers

A study of 3D and 2D intracellular FRET processes at the interface between surface tailored silica nanoparticles and lipid bilayers.

Developments and recent advancements in the field of endogenous amino acid selective bond forming reactions for bioconjugation

Bioconjugation methodologies have proven to play a central enabling role in the recent development of biotherapeutics and chemical biology approaches. Recent endeavours in these fields shed light on unprecedented chemical challenges to attain bioselectivity, biocompatibility, and biostability required by modern applications. In this review the current developments in various techniques of selective bond forming reactions of proteins and peptides were highlighted. The utility of each endogenous amino acid-selective conjugation methodology in the fields of biology and protein science has been surveyed with emphasis on the most relevant among reported transformations; selectivity and practical use have been discussed.

Electrostatically driven lipid-protein interaction: Answers from FRET

Electrostatics govern the association of a large number of proteins with cellular membranes. In some cases, these proteins present specialized lipid-binding modules or membrane targeting domains while in other cases association is achieved through nonspecific interaction of unstructured clusters of basic residues with negatively charged lipids. Given its spatial resolution in the nanometer range, Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) is a powerful tool to give insight into protein-lipid interactions and provide molecular level information which is difficult to retrieve with other spectroscopic techniques. In this review we present and discuss the basic formalisms of both hetero- and homo-FRET pertinent to the most commonly encountered problems in lipid-protein interaction studies and highlight some examples of implementations of different FRET methodologies to characterize lipid/protein systems in which electrostatic interactions play a crucial role. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Lipid-protein interactions.

Förster resonance energy transfer as a tool for quantification of protein-lipid selectivity

This chapter addresses the determination of protein-lipid selectivity, here described as the preference of a protein for having a specific type of lipid in its vicinity (annular lipids), from Förster resonance energy transfer methodologies. These allow a quantification of the effect, i.e., the determination of the biasing in distribution of the lipid under study around the protein, as compared to its bulk membrane distribution, with advantages over established approaches that have been used for the same purpose, such as electron spin resonance spectroscopy. The experiment can be carried out with steady-state instrumentation, the formalisms are described in detail, and the model can be applied to a membrane protein of any size.

Using hydrogen/deuterium exchange mass spectrometry to define the specific interactions of the phospholipase A2 superfamily with lipid substrates, inhibitors, and membranes

The phospholipase A(2) (PLA(2)) superfamily consists of 16 groups and many subgroups and constitutes a diverse set of enzymes that have a common catalytic activity due to convergent evolution. However, different PLA(2) types have unique three-dimensional structures and catalytic residues as well as specific tissue localization and distinct biological functions. Understanding how the different PLA(2) enzymes associate with phospholipid membranes, specific phospholipid substrate molecules, and inhibitors on a molecular basis has advanced in recent years due to the introduction of hydrogen/deuterium exchange mass spectrometry. Its theory, practical considerations, and application to understanding PLA(2)/membrane interactions are addressed.

Phosphatidylethanolamine-lactose permease interaction: a comparative study based on FRET

In this work we have investigated the selectivity of lactose permease (LacY) of Escherichia coli (E. coli) for its surrounding phospholipids when reconstituted in binary mixtures of 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine (POPE), 1,2-Palmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine (DPPE), or 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine (DOPE) with 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-(phospho-rac-(1-glycerol)) (POPG). Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) measurements have been performed to investigate the selectivity between a single tryptophan mutant of LacY used as donor (D), and two analogues of POPE and POPG labeled with pyrene in the acyl chains (Pyr-PE and Pyr-PG) used as acceptors. As a difference from previous works, now the donor has been single-W151/C154G/D68C LacY. It has been reported that the replacement of the aspartic acid in position 68 by cysteine inhibits active transport in LacY. The objectives of this work were to elucidate the phospholipid composition of the annular region of this mutant and to determine whether the mutation performed, D68C, induced changes in the protein-lipid selectivity. FRET efficiencies for Pyr-PE were always higher than for Pyr-PG. The values of the probability of each site in the annular ring being occupied by a label (μ) were similar at the studied temperatures (24 °C and 37 °C), suggesting that the lipid environment is not significantly affected when increasing the temperature. By comparing the results with those obtained for single-W151/C154G LacY, we observe that the mutation in the 68 residue indeed changes the selectivity of the protein for the phospholipids. This might be probably due to a change in the conformational dynamics of LacY.

FRET in Membrane Biophysics: An Overview

Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET), in most applications used as a “spectroscopic ruler,” allows an easy determination of the donor-acceptor intermolecular distance. However, the situation becomes complex in membranes, since around each donor there is an ensemble of acceptors at non-correlated distances. In this review, state-of-the-art methodologies for this situation are presented, usually involving time-resolved data and model fitting. This powerful approach can be used to study the occurrence of phase separation (“rafts” or other type of domains), allowing their detection as well as size evaluation. Formalisms for studying lipid–protein and protein–protein interactions according to specific topologies are also addressed. The advantages and added complexity of a specific type of FRET (energy homotransfer or energy migration) are described, as well as applications of FRET under the microscope.

Transmembrane peptides influence the affinity of sterols for phospholipid bilayers

Cholesterol is distributed unevenly between different cellular membrane compartments, and the cholesterol content increases from the inner bilayers toward the plasma membrane. It has been suggested that this cholesterol gradient is important in the sorting of transmembrane proteins. Cholesterol has also been to shown play an important role in lateral organization of eukaryotic cell membranes. In this study the aim was to determine how transmembrane proteins influence the lateral distribution of cholesterol in phospholipid bilayers. Insight into this can be obtained by studying how cholesterol interacts with bilayer membranes of different composition in the presence of designed peptides that mimic the transmembrane helices of proteins. For this purpose we developed an assay in which the partitioning of the fluorescent cholesterol analog CTL between LUVs and mbetaCD can be measured. Comparison of how cholesterol and CTL partitioning between mbetaCD and phospholipid bilayers with different composition suggests that CTL sensed changes in bilayer composition similarly as cholesterol. Therefore, the results obtained with CTL can be used to understand cholesterol distribution in lipid bilayers. The effect of WALP23 on CTL partitioning between DMPC bilayers and mbetaCD was measured. From the results it was clear that WALP23 increased both the order in the bilayers (as seen from CTL and DPH anisotropy) and the affinity of the sterol for the bilayer in a concentration dependent way. Although WALP23 also increased the order in DLPC and POPC bilayers the effects on CTL partitioning was much smaller with these lipids. This indicates that proteins have the largest effect on sterol interactions with phospholipids that have longer and saturated acyl chains. KALP23 did not significantly affect the acyl chain order in the phospholipid bilayers, and inclusion of KALP23 into DMPC bilayers slightly decreased CTL partitioning into the bilayer. This shows that transmembrane proteins can both decrease and increase the affinity of sterols for the lipid bilayers surrounding proteins. This is likely to affect the sterol distribution within the bilayer and thereby the lateral organization in biomembranes.

Quantification of protein-lipid selectivity using FRET

Membrane proteins exhibit different affinities for different lipid species, and protein-lipid selectivity regulates the membrane composition in close proximity to the protein, playing an important role in the formation of nanoscale membrane heterogeneities. The sensitivity of Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) for distances of 10 A up to 100 A is particularly useful to retrieve information on the relative distribution of proteins and lipids in the range over which protein-lipid selectivity is expected to influence membrane composition. Several FRET-based methods applied to the quantification of protein-lipid selectivity are described herein, and different formalisms applied to the analysis of FRET data for particular geometries of donor-acceptor distribution are critically assessed.

Membrane protein frustration: protein incorporation into hydrophobic mismatched binary lipid mixtures

Bacteriophage M13 major coat protein was reconstituted in different nonmatching binary lipid mixtures composed of 14:1PC and 22:1PC lipid bilayers. Challenged by this lose-lose situation of hydrophobic mismatch, the protein-lipid interactions are monitored by CD and site-directed spin-label electron spin resonance spectroscopy of spin-labeled site-specific single cysteine mutants located in the C-terminal protein domain embedded in the hydrophobic core of the membrane (I39C) and at the lipid-water interface (T46C). The CD spectra indicate an overall alpha-helical conformation irrespective of the composition of the binary lipid mixture. Spin-labeled protein mutant I39C senses the phase transition in 22:1PC, in contrast to spin-labeled protein mutant T46C, which is not affected by the transition. The results of both CD and electron spin resonance spectroscopy clearly indicate that the protein preferentially partitions into the shorter 14:1PC both above and below the gel-to-liquid crystalline phase transition temperature of 22:1PC. This preference is related to the protein tilt angle and energy penalty the protein has to pay in the thicker 22:1PC. Given the fact that in Escherichia coli, which is the host for M13 bacteriophage, it is easier to find shorter 14 carbon acyl chains than longer 22 carbon acyl chains, the choice the M13 coat protein makes seems to be evolutionary justified.

Role of helix 0 of the N-BAR domain in membrane curvature generation

A group of proteins with cell membrane remodeling properties is also able to change dramatically the morphology of liposomes in vitro, frequently inducing tubulation. For a number of these proteins, the mechanism by which this effect is exerted has been proposed to be the embedding of amphipathic helices into the lipid bilayer. For proteins presenting BAR domains, removal of an N-terminal amphipathic alpha-helix (H0-NBAR) results in much lower membrane tubulation efficiency, pointing to a fundamental role of this protein segment. Here, we studied the interaction of a peptide corresponding to H0-NBAR with model lipid membranes. H0-NBAR bound avidly to anionic liposomes but partitioned weakly to zwitterionic bilayers, suggesting an essentially electrostatic interaction with the lipid bilayer. Interestingly, it is shown that after membrane incorporation, the peptide oligomerizes as an antiparallel dimer, suggesting a potential role of H0-NBAR in the mediation of BAR domain oligomerization. Through monitoring the effect of H0-NBAR on liposome shape by cryoelectron microscopy, it is clear that membrane morphology is not radically changed. We conclude that H0-NBAR alone is not able to induce vesicle curvature, and its function must be related to the promotion of the scaffold effect provided by the concave surface of the BAR domain.

Monitoring the looping up of acyl chain labeled NBD lipids in membranes as a function of membrane phase state

Lipids that are labeled with the NBD (7-nitrobenz-2-oxa-1,3-diazol-4-yl) group are widely used as fluorescent analogues of native lipids in biological and model membranes to monitor a variety of processes. The NBD group of acyl chain labeled NBD lipids is known to loop up to the membrane interface in fluid phase membranes. However, the organization of these lipids in gel phase membranes is not resolved. In this paper, we monitored the influence of the membrane phase state on the looping up behavior of acyl chain labeled NBD lipids utilizing red edge excitation shift (REES) and other sensitive fluorescence approaches. Interestingly, our REES results indicate that NBD group of lipids, which are labeled at the fatty acyl region, resides in the more hydrophobic region in gel phase membranes, and complete looping of the NBD group occurs only in the fluid phase. This is supported by other fluorescence parameters such as polarization and lifetime. Taken together, our results demonstrate that membrane packing, which depends on temperature and the phase state of the membrane, significantly affects the localization of acyl chain labeled NBD lipids. In view of the wide ranging use of NBD-labeled lipids in cell and membrane biology, these results could have potentially important implications in future studies involving these lipids as tracers.

FRET study of membrane proteins: determination of the tilt and orientation of the N-terminal domain of M13 major coat protein

A formalism for membrane protein structure determination was developed. This method is based on steady-state FRET data and information about the position of the fluorescence maxima on site-directed fluorescent labeled proteins in combination with global data analysis utilizing simulation-based fitting. The methodology was applied to determine the structural properties of the N-terminal domain of the major coat protein from bacteriophage M13 reconstituted into unilamellar DOPC/DOPG (4:1 mol/mol) vesicles. For our purpose, the cysteine mutants A7C, A9C, N12C, S13C, Q15C, A16C, S17C, and A18C in the N-terminal domain of this protein were produced and specifically labeled with the fluorescence probe AEDANS. The energy transfer data from the natural Trp-26 to AEDANS were analyzed assuming a two-helix protein model. Furthermore, the polarity Stokes shift of the AEDANS fluorescence maxima is taken into account. As a result the orientation and tilt of the N-terminal protein domain with respect to the bilayer interface were obtained, showing for the first time, to our knowledge, an overall alpha-helical protein conformation from amino acid residues 12-46, close to the protein conformation in the intact phage.

Motional restrictions of membrane proteins: a site-directed spin labeling study

Site-directed mutagenesis was used to produce 27 single cysteine mutants of bacteriophage M13 major coat protein spanning the whole primary sequence of the protein. Single-cysteine mutants were labeled with nitroxide spin labels and incorporated into phospholipid bilayers with increasing acyl chain length. The SDSL is combined with ESR and CD spectroscopy. CD spectroscopy provided information about the overall protein conformation in different mismatching lipids. The spin label ESR spectra were analyzed in terms of a new spectral simulation approach based on hybrid evolutionary optimization and solution condensation. This method gives the residue-level free rotational space (i.e., the effective space within which the spin label can wobble) and the diffusion constant of the spin label attached to the protein. The results suggest that the coat protein has a large structural flexibility, which facilitates a stable protein-to-membrane association in lipid bilayers with various degrees of hydrophobic mismatch.

FRET study of membrane proteins: simulation-based fitting for analysis of membrane protein embedment and association

A new formalism for the simultaneous determination of the membrane embedment and aggregation of membrane proteins is developed. This method is based on steady-state Förster (or fluorescence) resonance energy transfer (FRET) experiments on site-directed fluorescence labeled proteins in combination with global data analysis utilizing simulation-based fitting. The simulation of FRET was validated by a comparison with a known analytical solution for energy transfer in idealized membrane systems. The applicability of the simulation-based fitting approach was verified on simulated FRET data and then applied to determine the structural properties of the well-known major coat protein from bacteriophage M13 reconstituted into unilamellar DOPC/DOPG (4:1 mol/mol) vesicles. For our purpose, the cysteine mutants Y24C, G38C, and T46C of this protein were produced and specifically labeled with the fluorescence label AEDANS. The energy transfer data from the natural tryptophan at position 26, which is used as a donor, to AEDANS were analyzed assuming a helix model for the transmembrane domain of the protein. As a result of the FRET data analysis, the topology and bilayer embedment of this domain were quantitatively characterized. The resulting tilt of the transmembrane helix of the protein is 18 +/- 2 degrees. The tryptophan is located at a distance of 8.5 +/- 0.5 A from the membrane center. No specific aggregation of the protein was found. The methodology developed here is not limited to M13 major coat protein and can be used in principle to study the bilayer embedment of any small protein with a single transmembrane domain.

Non-Uniform Membrane Probe Distribution in Resonance Energy Transfer: Application to Protein–Lipid Selectivity

Biological membranes are, at the molecular level, quasi-two dimensional systems. Membrane components are often distributed non-uniformly in the bilayer plane, as a consequence of lipid phase separation/domain formation or local enrichment/depletion of particular lipid species arising form favorable/unfavorable lipid-membrane protein interactions. Due to its explicit dependence on donor-acceptor distance or local acceptor concentration, resonance energy transfer (RET) has large potential in the characterization of membrane heterogeneity. RET formalisms for the basic geometric arrangements relevant for membranes have now been known for several decades. However, these formalisms usually assume uniform distributions, and more general models are required for the study of membrane lateral heterogeneity. We present a model that addresses the possibility of non-uniform acceptor (e.g., lipid probe) distribution around each donor (e.g., protein) in a membrane. It considers three regions with distinct local acceptor concentration, namely, an exclusion zone, the membrane bulk, and, lying in between, a region of enhanced probability of finding acceptors (annular region). Numerical solutions are presented, and convenient empirical fitting functions are given for RET efficiency as a function of bulk acceptor surface concentration, for several values of the model parameters. The usefulness of the formalism is illustrated in the analysis of experimental data.

Lipid bilayer topology of the transmembrane alpha-helix of M13 Major coat protein and bilayer polarity profile by site-directed fluorescence spectroscopy

This article presents a new formalism to perform a quantitative fluorescence analysis using the Stokes shift of AEDANS-labeled cysteine mutants of M13 major coat protein incorporated in lipid bilayers. This site-directed fluorescence spectroscopy approach enables us to obtain the topology of the bilayer-embedded transmembrane alpha-helix from the orientation and tilt angles, and relative bilayer location. Both in pure dioleoylphosphatidylcholine and dioleoylphosphatidylcholine/dioleoylphosphatidylglycerol (4:1 mol/mol) bilayers, which have a similar bilayer thickness, the tilt angle of the transmembrane helix of the coat protein turns out to be 23 degrees +/- 4. Upon decreasing the hydrophobic thickness on going from dieicosenoylphosphatidylcholine to dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine, the tilt angle and orientation angle of the transmembrane alpha-helix change. The protein responds to an increase of hydrophobic stress by increasing the tilt angle so as to keep much of its hydrophobic part inside the bilayer. At the same time, the transmembrane helix rotates at its long axis so as to optimize the hydrophobic and electrostatic interactions of the C-terminal phenylalanines and lysines, respectively. The increase of tilt angle cannot completely keep the hydrophobic protein section within the bilayer, but the C-terminal part remains anchored at the acyl-chain/glycerol backbone interface at the cost of the N-terminal section. In addition, our analysis results in the profile of the dielectric constant of the hydrophobic domain of the bilayer. For all phospholipid bilayers studied the profile has a concave shape, with a value of the dielectric constant of 4.0 in the center of the bilayer. The dielectric constant increases on approaching the headgroup region with a value of 12.4 at the acyl-chain/glycerol backbone interface for the various phosphatidylcholines with different chain lengths. For dioleoylphosphatidylcholine/dioleoylphosphatidylglycerol (4:1 mol/mol) bilayers the value of the dielectric constant at the acyl-chain/glycerol backbone interface is 18.6. In conclusion, the consistency of our analysis shows that the applied cysteine-scanning mutagenesis method with AEDANS labeling of a helical transmembrane protein in combination with a quantitative formalism offers a reliable description of the lipid bilayer topology of the protein and bilayer properties. This also indicates that the spacer link between the protein and AEDANS label is long enough to monitor the local polarity of the lipid environment and not that of the amino-acid residues of the protein, and short enough to have the topology of the protein imposing on the fluorescence properties of the AEDANS label.

Imaging protein molecules using FRET and FLIM microscopy

Förster (or fluorescence) resonance energy transfer (FRET) and fluorescence lifetime imaging (FLIM) have moved center stage and are increasingly forming part of multifaceted imaging approaches. They are complementary methodologies that can be applied to advanced quantitative analyses. The widening application of FRET and FLIM has been driven by the availability of suitable fluorophores, increasingly sophisticated microscopy systems, methodologies to correct spectral bleed-through, and the ease with which FRET can be combined with other techniques. FRET and FLIM have recently found use in several applications: in the analysis of protein-protein interactions with high spatial and temporal specificity (e.g. clustering), in the study of conformational changes, in the analysis of binding sequences, and in applications such as high-throughput screening.