Tracking unfolding and refolding of single GFPmut2 molecules

Insight into GFPmut2 pH Dependence by Single Crystal Microspectrophotometry and X-ray Crystallography

The fluorescence of Green Fluorescent Protein (wtGFP) and variants has been exploited in distinct applications in cellular and analytical biology. GFPs emission depends on the population of the protonated (A-state) and deprotonated (B-state) forms of the chromophore. Whereas wtGFP is pH-independent, mutants in which Ser65 is replaced by either threonine or alanine (as in GFPmut2) are pH-dependent, with a p K_a around 6. Given the wtGFP pH-independence, only the structure of the protonated form was determined. The deprotonated form was deduced on the basis of the crystal structure of the Ser65Thr mutant at basic pH, assuming that it corresponds to the conformation populated in solution. Here, we present an investigation where structures of the protonated and deprotonated forms of GFPmut2 were determined from crystals grown in either MPD at pH 6 or PEG at pH 8.5, and moved to either higher or lower pH. Both crystal forms of GFPmut2 were titrated monitoring the process via polarized absorption microspectrophotometry in order to precisely correlate the protonation process with the structures. We found that (i) in solution, chromophore titration is not thermodynamically coupled with any residue and Glu222 is always protonated independent of the protonation state of the chromophore; (ii) the lack of coupling is reflected in the structural behavior of the chromophore and Glu222 environments, with only the former showing variations with pH; (iii) titrations of low-pH and high-pH grown crystals exhibit a Hill coefficient of about 0.75, indicating an anticooperative behavior not observed in solution; (iv) structures where pH was changed in the crystal point to Glu222 as the ionizable group responsible for the outset of the anticooperative behavior; and (v) in GFPmut2 the canonical GFP proton wire involving the chromophore is not interrupted at the level of Ser205 and Glu222 at basic pH as in the Ser65Thr mutant. This allows proposing the structure of the deprotonated state of GFPmut2 as an alternative model for the analogous state of wtGFP.

Random single amino acid deletion sampling unveils structural tolerance and the benefits of helical registry shift on GFP folding and structure

Altering a protein’s backbone through amino acid deletion is a common evolutionary mutational mechanism, but is generally ignored during protein engineering primarily because its effect on the folding-structure-function relationship is difficult to predict. Using directed evolution, enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) was observed to tolerate residue deletion across the breadth of the protein, particularly within short and long loops, helical elements, and at the termini of strands. A variant with G4 removed from a helix (EGFP^G4Δ) conferred significantly higher cellular fluorescence. Folding analysis revealed that EGFP^G4Δ retained more structure upon unfolding and refolded with almost 100% efficiency but at the expense of thermodynamic stability. The EGFP^G4Δ structure revealed that G4 deletion caused a beneficial helical registry shift resulting in a new polar interaction network, which potentially stabilizes a cis proline peptide bond and links secondary structure elements. Thus, deletion mutations and registry shifts can enhance proteins through structural rearrangements not possible by substitution mutations alone.

•

Using directed evolution, the impact of amino acid deletion on EGFP is explored

•

Loops, helices, and strand termini are especially tolerant to amino acid deletion

•

A deletion mutant that enhances cellular production and fluorescence is identified

•

Structure reveals that a helical registry shift creates a new polar network

Understanding the folding of GFP using biophysical techniques

Green fluorescent protein (GFP) and its many variants are probably the most widely used proteins in medical and biological research, having been extensively engineered to act as markers of gene expression and protein localization, indicators of protein-protein interactions and biosensors. GFP first folds, before it can undergo an autocatalytic cyclization and oxidation reaction to form the chromophore, and in many applications the folding efficiency of GFP is known to limit its use. Here, we review the recent literature on protein engineering studies that have improved the folding properties of GFP. In addition, we discuss in detail the biophysical work on the folding of GFP that is beginning to reveal how this large and complex structure forms.

Role of histidine 148 in stability and dynamics of a highly fluorescent GFP variant

The armory of GFP mutants available to biochemists and molecular biologists is huge. Design and selection of mutants are usually driven by tailored spectroscopic properties, but some key aspects of stability, folding and dynamics of selected GFP variants still need to be elucidated. We have prepared, expressed and characterized three H148 mutants of the highly fluorescent variant GFPmut2. H148 is known to be involved in the H-bonding network surrounding the chromophore, and all the three mutants, H148G, H148R and H148K, show increased pKa values of the chromophore. Only H148G GFPmut2 (Mut2G) gave good expression and purification yields, indicating that position 148 is critical for efficient folding in vivo. The chemical denaturation of Mut2G was monitored by fluorescence emission, absorbance and far-UV circular dichroism spectroscopy. The mutation has little effect on the spectroscopic properties of the protein and on its stability in solution. However, the unfolding kinetics of the protein encapsulated in wet nanoporous silica gels, a system that allows to stabilize conformations that are poorly or only transiently populated in solution, indicate that the unfolding pathway of Mut2G is markedly different from the parent molecule. In particular, encapsulation allowed to identify an unfolding intermediate that retains a native-like secondary structure despite a destructured chromophore environment. Thus, H148 is a critical residue not only for the chromophoric and photodynamic properties, but also for the correct folding of GFP, and its substitution has great impact on expression yields and stability of the mature protein.

Structural basis of fluorescence quenching in caspase activatable-GFP

Apoptosis is critical for organismal homeostasis and a wide variety of diseases. Caspases are the ultimate executors of the apoptotic programmed cell death pathway. As caspases play such a central role in apoptosis, there is significant demand for technologies to monitor caspase function. We recently developed a caspase activatable-GFP (CA-GFP) reporter. CA-GFP is unique due to its "dark" state, where chromophore maturation of the GFP is inhibited by the presence of a C-terminal peptide. Here we show that chromophore maturation is prevented because CA-GFP does not fold into the robust β-barrel of GFP until the peptide has been cleaved by active caspase. Both CA-GFP and GFP₁₋₁₀ , a split form of GFP lacking the 11th strand, have similar secondary structure, different from mature GFP. A similar susceptibility to proteolytic digestion indicates that this shared structure is not the robust, fully formed GFP β-barrel. We have developed a model that suggests that as CA-GFP is translated in vivo it follows the same folding path as wild-type GFP; however, the presence of the appended peptide does not allow CA-GFP to form the barrel of the fully matured GFP. CA-GFP is therefore held in a "pro-folding" intermediate state until the peptide is released, allowing it to continue folding into the mature barrel geometry. This new understanding of the structural basis of the dark state of the CA-GFP reporter will enable manipulation of this mechanism in the development of reporter systems for any number of cellular processes involving proteases and potentially other enzymes.

The shape-shifting quasispecies of RNA: one sequence, many functional folds

E Unus pluribum, or "Of One, Many", may be at the root of decoding the RNA sequence-structure-function relationship. RNAs embody the large majority of genes in higher eukaryotes and fold in a sequence-directed fashion into three-dimensional structures that perform functions conserved across all cellular life forms, ranging from regulating to executing gene expression. While it is the most important determinant of the RNA structure, the nucleotide sequence is generally not sufficient to specify a unique set of secondary and tertiary interactions due to the highly frustrated nature of RNA folding. This frustration results in folding heterogeneity, a common phenomenon wherein a chemically homogeneous population of RNA molecules folds into multiple stable structures. Often, these alternative conformations constitute misfolds, lacking the biological activity of the natively folded RNA. Intriguingly, a number of RNAs have recently been described as capable of adopting multiple distinct conformations that all perform, or contribute to, the same function. Characteristically, these conformations interconvert slowly on the experimental timescale, suggesting that they should be regarded as distinct native states. We discuss how rugged folding free energy landscapes give rise to multiple native states in the Tetrahymena Group I intron ribozyme, hairpin ribozyme, sarcin-ricin loop, ribosome, and an in vitro selected aptamer. We further describe the varying degrees to which folding heterogeneity impacts function in these RNAs, and compare and contrast this impact with that of heterogeneities found in protein folding. Embracing that one sequence can give rise to multiple native folds, we hypothesize that this phenomenon imparts adaptive advantages on any functionally evolving RNA quasispecies.

Characterization of sol-gel-encapsulated proteins using small-angle neutron scattering

Entrapment of biomolecules in silica-derived sol-gels has grown into a vibrant area of research since it was originally demonstrated. However, accessing the consequences of entrapment on biomolecules and the gel structure remains a major challenge in characterizing these biohybrid materials. We present the first demonstration that it is possible with small-angle neutron scattering (SANS) to study the conformation of dilute proteins that are entrapped in transparent and dense sol-gels. Using deuterium-labeled green fluorescent protein (GFP) and SANS with contrast variation, we demonstrate that the scattering signatures of the sol-gel and the protein can be separated. Analysis of the scattering curves of the sol-gels using a mass-fractal model shows that the size of the colloidal silica particles and the fractal dimensions of the gels were similar in the absence and presence of protein, demonstrating that GFP did not influence the reaction pathway for the formation of the gel. The major structural difference in the gels was that the pore size was increased 2-fold in the presence of the protein. At the contrast match point for silica, the scattering signal from GFP inside the gel became distinguishable over a wide q range. Simulated scattering curves representing a monomer, end-to-end dimer, and parallel dimer of the protein were calculated and compared to the experimental data. Our results show that the most likely structure of GFP is that of an end-to-end dimer. This approach can be readily applied and holds great potential for the structural characterization of complex biohybrid and other materials.

Fast biosynthesis of GFP molecules: a single-molecule fluorescence study

It's not easy being green: Real-time visualization of labeled ribosomes and de novo synthesized green fluorescent protein molecules using single-molecule-sensitive fluorescence microscopy demonstrates that the mutant GFPem is produced with a characteristic time of five minutes. Fluorescence of the fastest GFP molecules appears within one minute (see picture).

Development of free-energy-based models for chaperonin containing TCP-1 mediated folding of actin

A free-energy-based approach is used to describe the mechanism through which chaperonin-containing TCP-1 (CCT) folds the filament-forming cytoskeletal protein actin, which is one of its primary substrates. The experimental observations on the actin folding and unfolding pathways are collated and then re-examined from this perspective, allowing us to determine the position of the CCT intervention on the actin free-energy folding landscape. The essential role for CCT in actin folding is to provide a free-energy contribution from its ATP cycle, which drives actin to fold from a stable, trapped intermediate I3, to a less stable but now productive folding intermediate I2. We develop two hypothetical mechanisms for actin folding founded upon concepts established for the bacterial type I chaperonin GroEL and extend them to the much more complex CCT system of eukaryotes. A new model is presented in which CCT facilitates free-energy transfer through direct coupling of the nucleotide hydrolysis cycle to the phases of actin substrate maturation.

Structural stability of green fluorescent proteins entrapped in polyelectrolyte nanocapsules

Molecules of a green fluorescent protein mutant, GFPmut2, have been immobilized in nanocapsules, assemblies of charged polyelectrolyte multilayers, with the aim to study the effect of protein-polyelectrolyte interactions on the protein stability against chemical denaturation. GFPmut2 proteins turn out to be stabilized and protected against the denaturating action of small chemical compounds. The nanocapsule protective effect on GFPmut2 is likely due to protein interactions with the negatively charged polymers, that induce an increase in the local rigidity of the protein nano-environment. This suggestion is supported by Fluorescence Polarization measurements on GFPmut2 proteins bound to the NC layers.

The rough energy landscape of superfolder GFP is linked to the chromophore

Many green fluorescent protein (GFP) variants have been developed for use as fluorescent tags, and recently a superfolder GFP (sfGFP) has been developed as a robust folding reporter. This new variant shows increased stability and improved folding kinetics, as well as 100% recovery of native protein after denaturation. Here, we characterize sfGFP, and find that this variant exhibits hysteresis as unfolding and refolding equilibrium titration curves are non-coincident even after equilibration for more than eight half-lives as estimated from kinetic unfolding and refolding studies. This hysteresis is attributed to trapping in a native-like intermediate state. Mutational studies directed towards inhibiting chromophore formation indicate that the novel backbone cyclization is responsible for the hysteresis observed in equilibrium titrations of sfGFP. Slow equilibration and the presence of intermediates imply a rough landscape. However, de novo folding in the absence of the chromophore is dominated by a smoother energy landscape than that sampled during unfolding and refolding of the post-translationally modified polypeptide.

Environment effects on the oscillatory unfolding kinetics of GFP

The chromophore of a green fluorescent protein (GFP) mutant engineered to enhance emission and stability is known to display erratic switchings among a few of its chemical substates and, in particular, between the anionic A and the neutral N substates, whose difference is associated with a proton exchange and a consequent conformation rearrangement. However, when close to unfolding, the A-N switchings suddenly become very regular as shown by fluorescence oscillations that have been recently observed for molecules embedded in wet silica gel. In order to establish whether the matrix hosting the protein is responsible for these oscillations, we investigated the effect of another medium (silanized surfaces), of a different denaturant (urea) and of cosolvents (D(2)O and glycerol). The occurrence of periodic A-N switchings, in the last milliseconds before GFP unfolding, is observed under all investigated conditions, together with three specific frequency values that characterize the pre-unfolding fluorescence. Urea and guanidinium, the denaturants employed in order to unfold GFP, do not lead to appreciable differences in the observed switching parameters, whereas the different media embedding the protein give rise only to frequency shifts that scale with the viscosity of the host. The periodicity of the GFP A-N switchings and their dependence on cosolvents suggest that they could be associated with oscillatory motions between meta-stable conformations of the beta-barrel surrounding the chromophore near protein unfolding.

GFP-mut2 proteins in trehalose-water matrixes: spatially heterogeneous protein-water-sugar structures

We report investigations on the properties of nanoenvironments around single-GFP-mut2 proteins in trehalose-water matrixes. Single-GFPmut2 molecules embedded in thin trehalose-water films were characterized in terms of their fluorescence brightness, bleaching dynamics, excited state lifetime, and fluorescence polarization. For each property, sets of approximately 100-150 single molecules have been investigated as a function of trehalose content and hydration. Three distinct and interconverting families of proteins have been found which differ widely in terms of bleaching dynamics, brightness, and fluorescence polarization, whose relative populations sizably depend on sample hydration. The reported results evidence the simultaneous presence of different protein-trehalose-water nanostructures whose rigidity increases by lowering the sample hydration. Such spatial inhomogeneity is in line with the well-known heterogeneous dynamics in supercooled fluids and in nonsolid carbohydrate glasses and gives a pictorial representation of the sharp, sudden reorganization of the above structures after uptake <==>release of water molecules.

Voltage regulation of single green fluorescent protein mutants

We report the analysis of the fluorescence intensity fluctuations of single proteins of a GFP mutant, GFPmut2, embedded in a polyelectrolyte nanocapsule adsorbed on thin conductive layers. Our results, based on single molecule fluorescence spectroscopy, indicate that the fluorescence blinking dynamics of GFP is strongly dependent on the bulk conductivity of the metal layer substrate, on the distance from the conductive surfaces and on the amplitude of the voltage applied to the poly-electrolyte layers. These findings suggest that fluorescence blinking itself might be employed as a reporter signal in nano-bio-technology applications.

Evidence of discrete substates and unfolding pathways in green fluorescent protein

We present evidence of conformational substates of a green fluorescent protein mutant, GFPmut2, and of their relationship with the protein behavior during chemical unfolding. The fluorescence of single molecules, excited by two infrared photons from a pulsed laser, was detected in two separate channels that simultaneously collected the blue or the green emission from the protein chromophore chemical states (anionic or neutral, respectively). Time recording of the fluorescence signals from molecules in the native state shows that the chromophore, an intrinsic probe sensitive to conformational changes, switches between the two states with average rates that are found to assume distinct values, thereby suggesting a multiplicity of protein substates. Furthermore, under denaturing conditions, the chromophore switching rate displays different and reproducible time evolutions that are characterized by discrete unfolding times. The correlation that is found between native molecules' switching rate values and unfolding times appears as direct evidence that GFPmut2 can unfold only along distinct paths that are determined by the initial folded substate of the protein.

Unfolding time distribution of GFP by single molecule fluorescence spectroscopy

We have studied the unfolding of single molecules of GFP-mut2 mutant trapped in wet silica gels in a wide range of GuHCl concentration. After the addition of denaturant, the number of fluorescent molecules decreases with unfolding rates (of the order of 0.01 min(-1)) that are in very good agreement with bulk fluorescence and circular dichroism data. Unexpectedly, single molecule experiments show rare fluctuations in the number of fluorescent proteins at equilibrium. On the other hand, although a first approximate description of the number decays can be reasonably performed by single exponential functions, the distributions of the single molecule unfolding times show a maximum at times congruent with 50-100 min up to the denaturation midpoint concentration of [GuHCl] congruent with 2.5 M. A theoretical analysis of the distributions indicates that this feature is a fingerprint of the competition between unfolding and refolding processes when the protein is very far from the midpoint denaturant concentration.