Influence of the crystalline state on photoinduced dynamics of photoactive yellow protein studied by ultraviolet-visible transient absorption spectroscopy

Blue and red in the protein world: Photoactive yellow protein and phytochromes as revealed by time-resolved crystallography

Time-resolved crystallography (TRX) is a method designed to investigate functional motions of biological macromolecules on all time scales. Originally a synchrotron-based method, TRX is enabled by the development of TR Laue crystallography (TRLX). TR serial crystallography (TR-SX) is an extension of TRLX. As the foundations of TRLX were evolving from the late 1980s to the turn of the millennium, TR-SX has been inspired by the development of Free Electron Lasers for hard X-rays. Extremely intense, ultrashort x-ray pulses could probe micro and nanocrystals, but at the same time, they inflicted radiation damage that necessitated the replacement by a new crystal. Consequently, a large number of microcrystals are exposed to X-rays one by one in a serial fashion. With TR-SX methods, one of the largest obstacles of previous approaches, namely, the unsurmountable challenges associated with the investigation of non-cyclic (irreversible) reactions, can be overcome. This article describes successes and transformative contributions to the TRX field by Keith Moffat and his collaborators, highlighting two major projects on protein photoreceptors initiated in the Moffat lab at the turn of the millennium.

Length and Charge of the N-terminus Regulate the Lifetime of the Signaling State of Photoactive Yellow Protein

Photoactive yellow protein (PYP) is one of the most extensively studied photoreceptors. Nevertheless, the role of the N-terminus in the photocycle and structural transitions is still elusive. Here, we attached additional amino acids to the N-terminus of PYP and investigated the effect of the length and charge of additional N-terminal residues using circular dichroism, two-dimensional nuclear magnetic resonance (2D-NMR), transient absorption (TA), and transient grating (TG) spectroscopic techniques. TA experiments showed that, except for negatively charged residues (5D-PYP), additional N-terminal residues of PYP generally enable faster dark recovery from the putative signaling state (pB2) to the ground state (pG). TG data showed that although the degree of structural changes can be controlled by adjusting specific amino acid residues in the extended N-terminus of N-terminal extended PYPs (NE-PYPs), the dark recovery times of wt-PYP and NE-PYPs, except for 5D-PYP, are independent of the structural differences between pG and pB2 states. These results demonstrate that the recovery time and the degree of structural change can be regulated by controlling the length and sequence of N-terminal residues of PYP. The findings in this study emphasize the need for careful attention to the remaining amino acid residues when designing recombinant proteins for genetic engineering purposes.

Protein Nucleation and Crystallization Process with Process Analytical Technologies in a Batch Crystallizer

Protein crystallization has drawn great attention to replacing the traditional downstream processing for protein-based pharmaceuticals due to its advantages in stability, storage, and delivery. Limited understanding of the protein crystallization processes requires essential information based on real-time tracking during the crystallization process. A batch crystallizer of 100 mL fitted with a focused beam reflectance measurement (FBRM) probe and a thermocouple was designed for in situ monitoring of the protein crystallization process, with simutaneously record of off-line concentrations and crystal images. Three stages in the protein batch crystallization process were identified: long-period slow nucleation, rapid crystallization, and slow growth and breakage. The induction time was estimated by FBRM, i.e., increasing numbers of particles in the solution, which could be half of the time required for detecting the decrease of the concentration, by offline measurement. The induction time decreased with an increase in supersaturation within the same salt concentration. The interfacial energy for nucleation was analyzed based on each experimental group with equal salt concentration and different concentrations of lysozyme. The interfacial energy reduced with an increase in salt concentration in the solution. The yield of the experiments was significantly affected by the protein and salt concentrations and could achieve up to 99% yield with a 26.5 μm median crystal size upon stabilized concentration readings.

In situ infrared spectroscopy depth profilometer for organic thin films

Organic films are widely used in organic optoelectronics due to their flexibility, low-cost fabrication, and ability to be processed over large areas. Typically, the composition of these thin films varies along the film depth direction. In this work, we present a home-developed in situ instrument comprised of a capacitive coupled plasma generator in combination with a Fourier transform infrared spectrometer, to measure the composition distribution along the film-normal direction. During the measurement, the film is sequentially etched by the soft plasma and the evolution of the infrared spectra of the film is in situ monitored by a spectrometer, from which the film-depth-dependent infrared spectra are extracted. The film-depth resolution of this analytical method has been improved to ∼1 nanometer. Thus, it is possible to calculate the composition that varies with depth by utilizing this analysis method. This equipment, which can be applied effectively to the characterization of thin films for both conjugated and unconjugated organic molecules by directly measuring their distinctive molecular vibration signatures, is simple and clear to set up in a large number of laboratories.

Femtosecond-to-millisecond mid-IR spectroscopy of Photoactive Yellow Protein uncovers structural micro-transitions of the chromophore's protonation mechanism

Protein structural dynamics can span many orders of magnitude in time. Photoactive Yellow Protein's (PYP) reversible photocycle encompasses picosecond isomerization of the light-absorbing chromophore as well as large scale protein backbone motions occurring on a millisecond timescale. Femtosecond-to-millisecond time-resolved mid-Infrared (IR) spectroscopy is employed here to uncover structural details of photocycle intermediates up to chromophore protonation and the first structural changes leading to formation of the partially-unfolded signalling state pB. The data show that a commonly thought stable transient photocycle intermediate is actually formed after a sequence of several smaller structural changes. We provide residue-specific spectroscopic evidence that protonation of the chromophore on a hundreds of microseconds timescale is delayed with respect to deprotonation of the nearby E46 residue. That implies that the direct proton donor is not E46 but most likely a water molecule. Such details may assist ongoing photocycle and protein folding simulation efforts on the complex and wide time-spanning photocycle of the model system PYP.

Reversible molecular motional switch based on circular photoactive protein oligomers exhibits unexpected photo-induced contraction

Molecular switches alterable between two stable states by environmental stimuli, such as light and temperature, offer the potential for controlling biological functions. Here, we report a circular photoswitchable protein complex made of multiple protein molecules that can rapidly and reversibly switch with significant conformational changes. The structural and photochromic properties of photoactive yellow protein (PYP) are harnessed to construct circular oligomer PYPs (coPYPs) of desired sizes. Considering the light-induced N-terminal protrusion of monomer PYP, we expected coPYPs would expand upon irradiation, but time-resolved X-ray scattering data reveal that the late intermediate has a pronounced light-induced contraction motion. This work not only provides an approach to engineering a novel protein-based molecular switch based on circular oligomers of well-known protein units but also demonstrates the importance of characterizing the structural dynamics of designed molecular switches.

Effect of Hydrated Ionic Liquid on Photocycle and Dynamics of Photoactive Yellow Protein

The mechanism by which proteins are solvated in hydrated ionic liquids remains an open question. Herein, the photoexcitation dynamics of photoactive yellow protein dissolved in hydrated choline dihydrogen phosphate (Hy[ch][dhp]) were studied by transient absorption and transient grating spectroscopy. The photocyclic reaction of the protein in Hy[ch][dhp] was similar to that observed in the buffer solution, as confirmed by transient absorption spectroscopy. However, the structural change of the protein during the photocycle in Hy[ch][dhp] was found to be different from that observed in the buffer solution. The known change in the diffusion coefficient of the protein was apparently suppressed in high concentrations of [ch][dhp], plausibly due to stabilization of the secondary structure.

Nonlinear Optical Investigation of Microbial Chromoproteins

Membrane-bound or cytosolic light-sensitive proteins, playing a crucial role in energy- and signal-transduction processes of various photosynthetic microorganisms, have been optimized for sensing or harvesting light by myriads of years of evolution. Upon absorption of a photon, they undergo a usually cyclic reaction series of conformations, and the accompanying spectro-kinetic events assign robust nonlinear optical (NLO) properties for these chromoproteins. During recent years, they have attracted a considerable interest among researchers of the applied optics community as well, where finding the appropriate NLO material for a particular application is a pivotal task. Potential applications have emerged in various branches of photonics, including optical information storage and processing, higher-harmonic and white-light continuum generation, or biosensorics. In our earlier work, we also raised the possibility of using chromoproteins, such as bacteriorhodopsin (bR), as building blocks for the active elements of integrated optical (IO) circuits, where several organic and inorganic photonic materials have been considered as active components, but so far none of them has been deemed ideal for the purpose. In the current study, we investigate the linear and NLO properties of biofilms made of photoactive yellow protein (PYP) and bR. The kinetics of the photoreactions are monitored by time-resolved absorption experiments, while the refractive index of the films and its light-induced changes are measured using the Optical Waveguide Lightmode Spectroscopy (OWLS) and Z-scan techniques, respectively. The nonlinear refractive index and the refractive index change of both protein films were determined in the green spectral range in a wide range of intensities and at various laser repetition rates. The nonlinear refractive index and refractive index change of PYP were compared to those of bR, with respect to photonics applications. Our results imply that the NLO properties of these proteins make them promising candidates for utilization in applied photonics, and they should be considered as valid alternatives for active components of IO circuits.

Confinement in crystal lattice alters entire photocycle pathway of the Photoactive Yellow Protein

Femtosecond time-resolved crystallography (TRC) on proteins enables resolving the spatial structure of short-lived photocycle intermediates. An open question is whether confinement and lower hydration of the proteins in the crystalline state affect the light-induced structural transformations. Here, we measured the full photocycle dynamics of a signal transduction protein often used as model system in TRC, Photoactive Yellow Protein (PYP), in the crystalline state and compared those to the dynamics in solution, utilizing electronic and vibrational transient absorption measurements from 100 fs over 12 decades in time. We find that the photocycle kinetics and structural dynamics of PYP in the crystalline form deviate from those in solution from the very first steps following photon absorption. This illustrates that ultrafast TRC results cannot be uncritically extrapolated to in vivo function, and that comparative spectroscopic experiments on proteins in crystalline and solution states can help identify structural intermediates under native conditions.

Protein structural dynamics can be studied by time-resolved crystallography (TRC) and ultrafast transient spectroscopic methods. Here, the authors perform electronic and vibrational transient absorption measurements to characterise the full photocycle of Photoactive Yellow Protein (PYP) both in the crystalline and solution state and find that the photocycle kinetics and structural intermediates of PYP deviate in the crystalline state, which must be taken into consideration when planning TRC experiments.

Local dynamics of the photo-switchable protein PYP in ground and signalling state probed by 2D-IR spectroscopy of –SCN labels

We employ 2D-IR spectroscopy of the protein label –SCN to describe the local dynamics in the photo-switchable protein PYP in its dark state (pG) and after photoactivation, concomitant with vast structural rearrangements, in its signalling state (pB).

Vibrational Lifetime of the SCN Protein Label in H2O and D2O Reports Site-Specific Solvation and Structure Changes During PYP's Photocycle

The application of vibrational labels such as thiocyanate  (-S-C≡N) for studying protein structure and dynamics is thriving. Absorption spectroscopy is usually employed to obtain wavenumber and line shape of the label. An observable of great significance might be the vibrational lifetime, which can be obtained by pump probe or 2D-IR spectroscopy. Due to the insulating effect of the heavy sulfur atom in the case of the SCN label, the lifetime of the C≡N oscillator is expected to be particularly sensitive to its surrounding as it is not dominated by through-bond relaxation. We therefore investigate the vibrational lifetime of the SCN label at various positions in the blue light sensor protein Photoactive Yellow Protein (PYP) in the ground state and signaling state of the photoreceptor. We find that the vibrational lifetime of the C≡N stretching mode is strongly affected both by its protein environment and by the degree of exposure to the solvent. Even for label positions where the line shape and wavenumber observed by FTIR are barely changing upon activation of the photoreceptor, we find that the lifetime can change considerably. To obtain an unambiguous measure for the solvent exposure of the labeled site, we show that it is imperative to compare the lifetimes in H₂O and D₂O. Importantly, the lifetimes shorten in H₂O as compared to D₂O for water exposed labels, while they stay largely the same for buried labels. We quantify this effect by defining a solvent exclusion coefficient (SEC). The response of the label's vibrational lifetime to its solvent exposure renders it a suitable universal probe for protein investigations. This applies even to systems that are otherwise hard to address, such as transient or short-lived states, which could be created during a protein's working cycle (as here in PYP) or during protein folding. It is also applicable to flexible systems (intrinsically disordered proteins), protein-protein and protein-membrane interactions.

Following local light-induced structure changes and dynamics of the photoreceptor PYP with the thiocyanate IR label

Photoactive Yellow Protein (PYP) is a bacterial blue light receptor that enters a photocycle after excitation. The intermediate states are formed on time scales ranging from femtoseconds up to hundreds of milliseconds, after which the signaling state with a lifetime of about 1 s is reached. To investigate structural changes and dynamics, we incorporated the SCN IR label at distinct positions of the photoreceptor via cysteine mutation and cyanylation. FT-IR measurements of the SCN label at different sites of the well-established dark state structure of PYP characterized the spectral response of the label to differences in the environment. Under constant blue light irradiation, we observed the formation of the signaling state with significant changes of wavenumber and lineshape of the SCN bands. Thereby we deduced light-induced structural changes in the local environment of the labels. These results were supported by molecular dynamics simulations on PYP providing the solvent accessible surface area (SASA) at the different positions. To follow protein dynamics via the SCN label during the photocycle, we performed step-scan FT-IR measurements with a time resolution of 10 μs. Global analysis yielded similar time constants of τ1 = 70 μs, τ2 = 640 μs, and τ3 > 20 ms for the wild type and τ1 = 36 μs, τ2 = 530 μs, and τ3 > 20 ms for the SCN-labeled mutant PYP-A44C*, a mutant which provided a sufficiently large SCN difference signal to measure step-scan FT-IR spectra. In comparison to the protein (amide, E46) and chromophore bands the dynamics of the SCN label show a different behavior. This result indicates that the local kinetics sensed by the label are different from the global protein kinetics.

Spectrokinetic characterization of photoactive yellow protein films for integrated optical applications

In this paper, the photocycle of the dried photoactive yellow protein film has been investigated in different humidity environments, in order to characterize its nonlinear optical properties for possible integrated optical applications. The light-induced spectral changes of the protein films were monitored by an optical multichannel analyser set-up, while the accompanying refractive index changes were measured with the optical waveguide lightmode spectroscopy method. To determine the number and kinetics of spectral intermediates in the photocycle, the absorption kinetic data were analysed by singular value decomposition and multiexponential fitting methods, whose results were used in a subsequent step of fitting a photocycle model to the data. The absorption signals of the films were found to be in strong correlation with the measured light-induced refractive index changes, whose size and kinetics imply that photoactive yellow protein may be a good alternative for utilization as an active nonlinear optical material in future integrated optical applications.

Regulation of Protein Structural Changes by Incorporation of a Small-Molecule Linker

Proteins have the potential to serve as nanomachines with well-controlled structural movements, and artificial control of their conformational changes is highly desirable for successful applications exploiting their dynamic structural characteristics. Here, we demonstrate an experimental approach for regulating the degree of conformational change in proteins by incorporating a small-molecule linker into a well-known photosensitive protein, photoactive yellow protein (PYP), which is sensitized by blue light and undergoes a photo-induced N-terminal protrusion coupled with chromophore-isomerization-triggered conformational changes. Specifically, we introduced thiol groups into specific sites of PYP through site-directed mutagenesis and then covalently conjugated a small-molecule linker into these sites, with the expectation that the linker is likely to constrain the structural changes associated with the attached positions. To investigate the structural dynamics of PYP incorporated with the small-molecule linker (SML-PYP), we employed the combination of small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS), transient absorption (TA) spectroscopy and experiment-restrained rigid-body molecular dynamics (MD) simulation. Our results show that SML-PYP exhibits much reduced structural changes during photo-induced signaling as compared to wild-type PYP. This demonstrates that incorporating an external molecular linker can limit photo-induced structural dynamics of the protein and may be used as a strategy for fine control of protein structural dynamics in nanomachines.

Molecular Dynamics Simulations of Macromolecular Crystals

The structures of biological macromolecules would not be known to their present extent without X-ray crystallography. Most simulations of globular proteins in solution begin by surrounding the crystal structure of the monomer in a bath of water molecules, but the standard simulation employing periodic boundary conditions is already close to a crystal lattice environment. With simple protocols, the same software and molecular models can perform simulations of the crystal lattice, including all asymmetric units and solvent to fill the box. Throughout the history of molecular dynamics, studies of crystal lattices have served to investigate the quality of the underlying force fields, correlate the simulated ensembles to experimental structure factors, and extrapolate the behavior in lattices to behavior in solution. Powerful new computers are enabling molecular simulations with greater realism and statistical convergence. Meanwhile, the advent of exciting new methods in crystallography, including femtosecond free-electron lasers and image reconstruction for time-resolved crystallography on slurries of small crystals, is expanding the range of structures accessible to X-ray diffraction. We review past fusions of simulations and crystallography, then look ahead to the ways that simulations of crystal structures will enhance structural biology in the future.

Enzyme intermediates captured "on the fly" by mix-and-inject serial crystallography

BACKGROUND

Ever since the first atomic structure of an enzyme was solved, the discovery of the mechanism and dynamics of reactions catalyzed by biomolecules has been the key goal for the understanding of the molecular processes that drive life on earth. Despite a large number of successful methods for trapping reaction intermediates, the direct observation of an ongoing reaction has been possible only in rare and exceptional cases.

RESULTS

Here, we demonstrate a general method for capturing enzyme catalysis "in action" by mix-and-inject serial crystallography (MISC). Specifically, we follow the catalytic reaction of the Mycobacterium tuberculosis β-lactamase with the third-generation antibiotic ceftriaxone by time-resolved serial femtosecond crystallography. The results reveal, in near atomic detail, antibiotic cleavage and inactivation from 30 ms to 2 s.

CONCLUSIONS

MISC is a versatile and generally applicable method to investigate reactions of biological macromolecules, some of which are of immense biological significance and might be, in addition, important targets for structure-based drug design. With megahertz X-ray pulse rates expected at the Linac Coherent Light Source II and the European X-ray free-electron laser, multiple, finely spaced time delays can be collected rapidly, allowing a comprehensive description of biomolecular reactions in terms of structure and kinetics from the same set of X-ray data.

Measurements of complex refractive index change of photoactive yellow protein over a wide wavelength range using hyperspectral quantitative phase imaging

A novel optical holographic technique is presented to simultaneously measure both the real and imaginary components of the complex refractive index (CRI) of a protein solution over a wide visible wavelength range. Quantitative phase imaging was employed to precisely measure the optical field transmitted from a protein solution, from which the CRIs of the protein solution were retrieved using the Fourier light scattering technique. Using this method, we characterized the CRIs of the two dominant structural states of a photoactive yellow protein solution over a broad wavelength range (461-582 nm). The significant CRI deviation between the two structural states was quantified and analysed. The results of both states show the similar overall shape of the expected rRI obtained from the Kramers-Kronig relations.

A short history of structure based research on the photocycle of photoactive yellow protein

The goals of time-resolved macromolecular crystallography are to extract the molecular structures of the reaction intermediates and the reaction dynamics from time-resolved X-ray data alone. To develop the techniques of time-resolved crystallography, biomolecules with special properties are required. The Photoactive Yellow Protein is the most sparkling of these.

Photocycle of Photoactive Yellow Protein in Cell-Mimetic Environments: Molecular Volume Changes and Kinetics

Using various spectroscopic techniques such as UV-visible spectroscopy, circular dichroism spectroscopy, NMR spectroscopy, small-angle X-ray scattering, transient grating, and transient absorption techniques, we investigated how cell-mimetic environments made by crowding influence the photocycle of photoactive yellow protein (PYP) in terms of the molecular volume change and kinetics. Upon addition of molecular crowding agents, the ratio of the diffusion coefficient of the blue-shifted intermediate (pB) to that of the ground species (pG) significantly changes from 0.92 and approaches 1.0. This result indicates that the molecular volume change accompanied by the photocycle of PYP in molecularly crowded environments is much smaller than that which occurs in vitro and that the pB intermediate under crowded environments favors a compact conformation due to the excluded volume effect. The kinetics of the photocycle of PYP in cell-mimetic environments is greatly decelerated by the dehydration, owing to the interaction between the protein and small crowding agents, but is barely affected by the excluded volume effect. The results lead to the inference that the signaling transducer of PYP may not necessarily utilize the conformational change of PYP to sense the signaling state.

Combined probes of X-ray scattering and optical spectroscopy reveal how global conformational change is temporally and spatially linked to local structural perturbation in photoactive yellow protein

Real-time probing of structural transitions of a photoactive protein is challenging owing to the lack of a universal time-resolved technique that can probe the changes in both global conformation and light-absorbing chromophores of the protein. In this work, we combine time-resolved X-ray solution scattering (TRXSS) and transient absorption (TA) spectroscopy to investigate how the global conformational changes involved in the photoinduced signal transduction of photoactive yellow protein (PYP) is temporally and spatially related to the local structural change around the light-absorbing chromophore. In particular, we examine the role of internal proton transfer in developing a signaling state of PYP by employing its E46Q mutant (E46Q-PYP), where the internal proton transfer is inhibited by the replacement of a proton donor. The comparison of TRXSS and TA spectroscopy data directly reveals that the global conformational change of the protein, which is probed by TRXSS, is temporally delayed by tens of microseconds from the local structural change of the chromophore, which is probed by TA spectroscopy. The molecular shape of the signaling state reconstructed from the TRXSS curves directly visualizes the three-dimensional conformations of protein intermediates and reveals that the smaller structural change in E46Q-PYP than in wild-type PYP suggested by previous studies is manifested in terms of much smaller protrusion, confirming that the signaling state of E46Q-PYP is only partially developed compared with that of wild-type PYP. This finding provides direct evidence of how the environmental change in the vicinity of the chromophore alters the conformational change of the entire protein matrix.

Protein structural dynamics revealed by time-resolved X-ray solution scattering

One of the most important questions in biological science is how a protein functions. When a protein performs its function, it undergoes regulated structural transitions. In this regard, to better understand the underlying principle of a protein function, it is desirable to monitor the dynamic evolution of the protein structure in real time. To probe fast and subtle motions of a protein in physiological conditions demands an experimental tool that is not only equipped with superb spatiotemporal resolution but also applicable to samples in solution phase. Time-resolved X-ray solution scattering (TRXSS), discussed in this Account, fits all of those requirements needed for probing the movements of proteins in aqueous solution. The technique utilizes a pump-probe scheme employing an optical pump pulse to initiate photoreactions of proteins and an X-ray probe pulse to monitor ensuing structural changes. The technical advances in ultrafast lasers and X-ray sources allow us to achieve superb temporal resolution down to femtoseconds. Because X-rays scatter off all atomic pairs in a protein, an X-ray scattering pattern provides information on the global structure of the protein with subangstrom spatial resolution. Importantly, TRXSS is readily applicable to aqueous solution samples of proteins with the aid of theoretical models and therefore is well suited for investigating structural dynamics of protein transitions in physiological conditions. In this Account, we demonstrate that TRXSS can be used to probe real-time structural dynamics of proteins in solution ranging from subtle helix movement to global conformational change. Specifically, we discuss the photoreactions of photoactive yellow protein (PYP) and homodimeric hemoglobin (HbI). For PYP, we revealed the kinetics of structural transitions among four transient intermediates comprising a photocycle and, by applying structural analysis based on ab initio shape reconstruction, showed that the signaling of PYP involves the protrusion of the N-terminus with significant increase of the overall protein size. For HbI, we elucidated the dynamics of complex allosteric transitions among transient intermediates. In particular, by applying structural refinement analysis based on rigid-body modeling, we found that the allosteric transition of HbI accompanies the rotation of quaternary structure and the contraction between two heme domains. By making use of the experimental and analysis methods presented in this Account, we envision that the TRXSS can be used to probe the structural dynamics of various proteins, allowing us to decipher the working mechanisms of their functions. Furthermore, when combined with femtosecond X-ray pulses generated from X-ray free electron lasers, TRXSS will gain access to ultrafast protein dynamics on sub-picosecond time scales.

Time-resolved crystallography and protein design: signalling photoreceptors and optogenetics

Time-resolved X-ray crystallography and solution scattering have been successfully conducted on proteins on time-scales down to around 100 ps, set by the duration of the hard X-ray pulses emitted by synchrotron sources. The advent of hard X-ray free-electron lasers (FELs), which emit extremely intense, very brief, coherent X-ray pulses, opens the exciting possibility of time-resolved experiments with femtosecond time resolution on macromolecular structure, in both single crystals and solution. The X-ray pulses emitted by an FEL differ greatly in many properties from those emitted by a synchrotron, in ways that at first glance make time-resolved measurements of X-ray scattering with the required accuracy extremely challenging. This opens up several questions which I consider in this brief overview. Are there likely to be chemically and biologically interesting structural changes to be revealed on the femtosecond time-scale? How shall time-resolved experiments best be designed and conducted to exploit the properties of FELs and overcome challenges that they pose? To date, fast time-resolved reactions have been initiated by a brief laser pulse, which obviously requires that the system under study be light-sensitive. Although this is true for proteins of the visual system and for signalling photoreceptors, it is not naturally the case for most interesting biological systems. To generate more biological targets for time-resolved study, can this limitation be overcome by optogenetic, chemical or other means?

Enzyme transient state kinetics in crystal and solution from the perspective of a time-resolved crystallographer

With recent technological advances at synchrotrons [Graber et al., J. Synchrotron Radiat. 18, 658-670 (2011)], it is feasible to rapidly collect time-resolved crystallographic data at multiple temperature settings [Schmidt et al., Acta Crystallogr. D 69, 2534-2542 (2013)], from which barriers of activation can be extracted. With the advent of fourth generation X-ray sources, new opportunities emerge to investigate structure and dynamics of biological macromolecules in real time [M. Schmidt, Adv. Condens. Matter Phys. 2013, 1-10] in crystals and potentially from single molecules in random orientation in solution [Poon et al., Adv. Condens. Matter Phys. 2013, 750371]. Kinetic data from time-resolved experiments on short time-scales must be interpreted in terms of chemical kinetics [Steinfeld et al., Chemical Kinetics and Dynamics, 2nd ed. (Prentience Hall, 1985)] and tied to existing time-resolved experiments on longer time-scales [Schmidt et al., Acta Crystallogr. D 69, 2534-2542 (2013); Jung et al., Nat. Chem. 5, 212-220 (2013)]. With this article, we will review and outline steps that are required to routinely determine the energetics of reactions in biomolecules in crystal and solution with newest X-ray sources. In eight sections, we aim to describe concepts and experimental details that may help to inspire new approaches to collect and interpret these data.

A comprehensive study of isomerization and protonation reactions in the photocycle of the photoactive yellow protein

A comprehensive picture of the overall photocycle was obtained to reveal a wide range of structural signals in the photoactive yellow protein.

Protein energy landscapes determined by five-dimensional crystallography

Free-energy landscapes decisively determine the progress of enzymatically catalyzed reactions [Cornish-Bowden (2012), Fundamentals of Enzyme Kinetics, 4th ed.]. Time-resolved macromolecular crystallography unifies transient-state kinetics with structure determination [Moffat (2001), Chem. Rev. 101, 1569-1581; Schmidt et al. (2005), Methods Mol. Biol. 305, 115-154; Schmidt (2008), Ultrashort Laser Pulses in Medicine and Biology] because both can be determined from the same set of X-ray data. Here, it is demonstrated how barriers of activation can be determined solely from five-dimensional crystallography, where in addition to space and time, temperature is a variable as well [Schmidt et al. (2010), Acta Cryst. A66, 198-206]. Directly linking molecular structures with barriers of activation between them allows insight into the structural nature of the barrier to be gained. Comprehensive time series of crystallographic data at 14 different temperature settings were analyzed and the entropy and enthalpy contributions to the barriers of activation were determined. One hundred years after the discovery of X-ray scattering, these results advance X-ray structure determination to a new frontier: the determination of energy landscapes.

Spectroscopic studies of model photo-receptors: validation of a nanosecond time-resolved micro-spectrophotometer design using photoactive yellow protein and α-phycoerythrocyanin

Time-resolved spectroscopic experiments have been performed with protein in solution and in crystalline form using a newly designed microspectrophotometer. The time-resolution of these experiments can be as good as two nanoseconds (ns), which is the minimal response time of the image intensifier used. With the current setup, the effective time-resolution is about seven ns, determined mainly by the pulse duration of the nanosecond laser. The amount of protein required is small, on the order of 100 nanograms. Bleaching, which is an undesirable effect common to photoreceptor proteins, is minimized by using a millisecond shutter to avoid extensive exposure to the probing light. We investigate two model photoreceptors, photoactive yellow protein (PYP), and α-phycoerythrocyanin (α-PEC), on different time scales and at different temperatures. Relaxation times obtained from kinetic time-series of difference absorption spectra collected from PYP are consistent with previous results. The comparison with these results validates the capability of this spectrophotometer to deliver high quality time-resolved absorption spectra.

High-throughput instant quantification of protein expression and purity based on photoactive yellow protein turn off/on label

Quantifying the concentration and purity of a target protein is essential for high-throughput protein expression test and rapid screening of highly soluble proteins. However, conventional methods such as PAGE and dot blot assay generally involve multiple time-consuming tasks requiring hours or do not allow instant quantification. Here, we demonstrate a new method based on the Photoactive yellow protein turn Off/On Label (POOL) system that can instantly quantify the concentration and purity of a target protein. The main idea of POOL is to use Photoactive Yellow Protein (PYP), or its miniaturized version, as a fusion partner of the target protein. The characteristic blue light absorption and the consequent yellow color of PYP is absent when initially expressed without its chromophore, but can be turned on by binding its chromophore, p-coumaric acid. The appearance of yellow color upon adding a precursor of chromophore to the co-expressed PYP can be used to check the expression amount of the target protein via visual inspection within a few seconds as well as to quantify its concentration and purity with the aid of a spectrometer within a few minutes. The concentrations measured by the POOL method, which usually takes a few minutes, show excellent agreement with those by the BCA Kit, which usually takes ∼1 h. We demonstrate the applicability of POOL in E. coli, insect, and mammalian cells, and for high-throughput protein expression screening.

Effect of Hofmeister cosolutes on the photocycle of photoactive yellow protein at moderately alkaline pH

The photocycle of photoactive yellow protein was studied by kinetic absorption spectroscopy from below 100ns to seconds, at moderately alkaline pH, in the presence of high concentrations of various salts. Chemometric analysis combined with multiexponential fit of the flash-induced difference spectra provided evidence for five intermediates, including a spectrally silent form before the final recovery of the parent state, but only three with significantly distinct spectra. The calculated intermediate spectra constituted the input for the following spectrotemporal model fit using a sufficiently complex photocycle scheme with reversible transitions. This yielded the rate coefficients of the molecular transitions, the final spectra and the kinetics of the intermediates. Except for the transition between the two red shifted (early) intermediates (pR1 and pR2) and the final photocycle step, all reactions appeared to be reversible. Kosmotropic and chaotropic cosolutes had a systematic effect on the molecular rate coefficients. The largest effect, associated presumably with the exposure of the hydrophobic interior of the protein, accompanies the transition between the second red-shifted and the first blue-shifted intermediate (pR2 and pB1, respectively), i.e. it coincides with the chromophore protonation. The dependence of the rate coefficients on the Hofmeister cosolutes suggests that the conformational change of photoactive yellow protein leading eventually to the most unfolded signaling state takes place in several steps, and starts already with the relaxation after the chromophore isomerization in the microsecond time domain.

Time-resolved structural studies at synchrotrons and X-ray free electron lasers: opportunities and challenges

X-ray free electron lasers (XFELs) are potentially revolutionary X-ray sources because of their very short pulse duration, extreme peak brilliance and high spatial coherence, features that distinguish them from today's synchrotron sources. We review recent time-resolved Laue diffraction and time-resolved wide angle X-ray scattering (WAXS) studies at synchrotron sources, and initial static studies at XFELs. XFELs have the potential to transform the field of time-resolved structural biology, yet many challenges arise in devising and adapting hardware, experimental design and data analysis strategies to exploit their unusual properties. Despite these challenges, we are confident that XFEL sources are poised to shed new light on ultrafast protein reaction dynamics.

pH dependence of the photoactive yellow protein photocycle investigated by time-resolved crystallography

Visualizing the three-dimensional structures of a protein during its biological activity is key to understanding its mechanism. In general, protein structure and function are pH-dependent. Changing the pH provides new insights into the mechanisms that are involved in protein activity. Photoactive yellow protein (PYP) is a signaling protein that serves as an ideal model for time-dependent studies on light-activated proteins. Its photocycle is studied extensively under different pH conditions. However, the structures of the intermediates remain unknown until time-resolved crystallography is employed. With the newest beamline developments, a comprehensive time series of Laue data can now be collected from a single protein crystal. This allows us to vary the pH. Here we present the first structure, to our knowledge, of a short-lived protein-inhibitor complex formed in the pB state of the PYP photocycle at pH 4. A water molecule that is transiently stabilized in the chromophore active site prevents the relaxation of the chromophore back to the trans configuration. As a result, the dark-state recovery is slowed down dramatically. At pH 9, PYP stops cycling through the pB state altogether. The electrostatic environment in the chromophore-binding site is the likely reason for this altered kinetics at different pH values.

Protein structural dynamics of photoactive yellow protein in solution revealed by pump-probe X-ray solution scattering

Photoreceptor proteins play crucial roles in receiving light stimuli that give rise to the responses required for biological function. However, structural characterization of conformational transition of the photoreceptors has been elusive in their native aqueous environment, even for a prototype photoreceptor, photoactive yellow protein (PYP). We employ pump-probe X-ray solution scattering to probe the structural changes that occur during the photocycle of PYP in a wide time range from 3.16 μs to 300 ms. By the analysis of both kinetics and structures of the intermediates, the structural progression of the protein in the solution phase is vividly visualized. We identify four structurally distinct intermediates and their associated five time constants and reconstructed the molecular shapes of the four intermediates from time-independent, species-associated difference scattering curves. The reconstructed structures of the intermediates show the large conformational changes such as the protrusion of N-terminus, which is restricted in the crystalline phase due to the crystal contact and thus could not be clearly observed by X-ray crystallography. The protrusion of the N-terminus and the protein volume gradually increase with the progress of the photocycle and becomes maximal in the final intermediate, which is proposed to be the signaling state. The data not only reveal that a common kinetic mechanism is applicable to both the crystalline and the solution phases, but also provide direct evidence for how the sample environment influences structural dynamics and the reaction rates of the PYP photocycle.

On the involvement of single-bond rotation in the primary photochemistry of photoactive yellow protein

Prior experimental observations, as well as theoretical considerations, have led to the proposal that C(4)-C(7) single-bond rotation may play an important role in the primary photochemistry of photoactive yellow protein (PYP). We therefore synthesized an analog of this protein's 4-hydroxy-cinnamic acid chromophore, (5-hydroxy indan-(1E)-ylidene)acetic acid, in which rotation across the C(4)-C(7) single bond has been locked with an ethane bridge, and we reconstituted the apo form of the wild-type protein and its R52A derivative with this chromophore analog. In PYP reconstituted with the rotation-locked chromophore, 1), absorption spectra of ground and intermediate states are slightly blue-shifted; 2), the quantum yield of photochemistry is ∼60% reduced; 3), the excited-state dynamics of the chromophore are accelerated; and 4), dynamics of the thermal recovery reaction of the protein are accelerated. A significant finding was that the yield of the transient ground-state intermediate in the early phase of the photocycle was considerably higher in the rotation-locked samples than in the corresponding samples reconstituted with p-coumaric acid. In contrast to theoretical predictions, the initial photocycle dynamics of PYP were observed to be not affected by the charge of the amino acid residue at position 52, which was varied by 1), varying the pH of the sample between 5 and 10; and 2), site-directed mutagenesis to construct R52A. These results imply that C(4)-C(7) single-bond rotation in PYP is not an alternative to C(7)=C(8) double-bond rotation, in case the nearby positive charge of R52 is absent, but rather facilitates, presumably with a compensatory movement, the physiological Z/E isomerization of the blue-light-absorbing chromophore.

Protein crystal microspectrophotometry

Single crystal microspectrophotometry has emerged as a valuable technique for monitoring molecular events that take place within protein crystals, thus tightly coupling structure to function. Absorption and fluorescence spectra, ligand binding affinities and kinetic constants can be determined, allowing i) the definition of the experimental conditions for X-ray crystallography experiments and their interpretation, ii) the assessment of whether crystal lattice forces have altered conformational equilibria, iii) the comparison with data obtained in solution. Microspectrophotometric measurements using oriented crystals and linearly polarized light are carried out usually off-line with respect to X-ray data collection and are aimed at an in- depth characterization of protein function in the crystal, leading to robust structure-function relationships. The power of this approach is highlighted by reporting a few case studies, including hemoglobins, pyridoxal 5'-phosphate-dependent enzymes and acetylcholinesterases. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Protein Structure and Function in the Crystalline State.

X-ray scattering combined with coordinate-based analyses for applications in natural and artificial photosynthesis

Advances in X-ray light sources and detectors have created opportunities for advancing our understanding of structure and structural dynamics for supramolecular assemblies in solution by combining X-ray scattering measurement with coordinate-based modeling methods. In this review the foundations for X-ray scattering are discussed and illustrated with selected examples demonstrating the ability to correlate solution X-ray scattering measurements to molecular structure, conformation, and dynamics. These approaches are anticipated to have a broad range of applications in natural and artificial photosynthesis by offering possibilities for structure resolution for dynamic supramolecular assemblies in solution that can not be fully addressed with crystallographic techniques, and for resolving fundamental mechanisms for solar energy conversion by mapping out structure in light-excited reaction states.

Helix formation is a dynamical bottleneck in the recovery reaction of Photoactive Yellow Protein

The bacterial sensor Photoactive Yellow Protein (PYP) signals the presence of blue light by undergoing a series of conformational changes. We present atomistic Parallel Tempering (Replica Exchange Molecular Dynamics) simulations of conformational changes occurring during the photo-cycle of PYP. First, we study the signaling state formation of PYP in detail. Our previous simulations have shown that the formation of the signaling state is characterized by the solvent exposure of both the chromophore and Glu46 (Vreede J, Crielaard W, Hellingwerf KJ, Bolhuis PG. Biophys J, 2005;8:3525-3535). Subsequent NMR results agreed with this prediction, but as these experiments were performed on an N-terminally truncated mutant, a simulation of this mutant would further substantiate our previous results. Here, we compare simulations of the truncated PYP to the NMR structures, as well as to the wild type predictions. This comparison also gives some insight into the role of the N-terminal domain of PYP, which restricts the movement of the chromophore binding pocket (CBP) in the wild type. Second, we report simulations of the recovery of the receptor state from the signaling state. While we did not observe complete refolding of the protein, we did observe transient interactions between residues of the CBP occurring when the chromophore is in a trans configuration. Using simulations that sample anomalous exposure of the chromophore in the receptor state, we were able to sample chromophore re-entry into its binding pocket. While the involved time scales prohibit drawing definitive conclusions even when using parallel tempering, we nevertheless propose that the formation of a helix in the CBP is essential for a successful recovery of the receptor state, and forms a kinetic barrier in this process.

Synergy within structural biology of single crystal optical spectroscopy and X-ray crystallography

Advances in the adaptation of optical spectroscopy to monitor photo-induced or enzyme-catalyzed reactions in the crystalline state have enabled X-ray crystal structures to be accurately linked with spectroscopically defined intermediates. This, in turn, has led to a deeper understanding of the role protein structural changes play in function. The integration of optical spectroscopy with X-ray crystallography is growing and now extends beyond linking crystal structure to reaction intermediate. Recent examples of this synergy include applications in protein crystallization, X-ray data acquisition, radiation damage, and acquisition of phase information important for structure determination.

Time-resolved methods in biophysics. 6. Time-resolved Laue crystallography as a tool to investigate photo-activated protein dynamics

When polychromatic X-rays are shined onto crystalline material, they generate a Laue diffraction pattern. At third generation synchrotron radiation sources, a single X-ray pulse of approximately 100 ps duration is enough to produce interpretable Laue data from biomolecular crystals. Thus, by initiating biological turnover in a crystalline protein, structural changes along the reaction pathway may be filmed by ultra-fast Laue diffraction. Using laser-light as a trigger, transient species in photosensitive macromolecules can be captured at near atomic resolution with sub-nanosecond time-resolution. Such pump-probe Laue experiments have now reached an outstanding level of sophistication and have found a domain of excellence in the investigation of light-sensitive proteins undergoing cyclic photo-reactions and producing stiff crystals. The main theoretical concepts of Laue diffraction and the challenges associated with time-resolved experiments on biological crystals are recalled. The recent advances in the design of experiments are presented in terms of instrumental choices, data collection strategy and data processing, and some of the inherent difficulties of the method are highlighted. The discussion is based on the example of myoglobin, a protein that has traversed the whole history of pump-probe Laue diffraction, and for which a massive amount of data have provided considerable insight into the understanding of protein dynamics.

Ultrafast infrared spectroscopy reveals a key step for successful entry into the photocycle for photoactive yellow protein

Photoactive proteins such as PYP (photoactive yellow protein) are generally accepted as model systems for studying protein signal state formation. PYP is a blue-light sensor from the bacterium Halorhodospira halophila. The formation of PYP's signaling state is initiated by trans-cis isomerization of the p-coumaric acid chromophore upon the absorption of light. The quantum yield of signaling state formation is approximately 0.3. Using femtosecond visible pump/mid-IR probe spectroscopy, we investigated the structure of the very short-lived ground state intermediate (GSI) that results from an unsuccessful attempt to enter the photocycle. This intermediate and the first stable GSI on pathway into the photocycle, I0, both have a mid-IR difference spectrum that is characteristic of a cis isomer, but only the I0 intermediate has a chromophore with a broken hydrogen bond with the backbone N atom of Cys-69. We suggest, therefore, that breaking this hydrogen bond is decisive for a successful entry into the photocycle. The chromophore also engages in a hydrogen-bonding network by means of its phenolate group with residues Tyr-42 and Glu-46. We have investigated the role of this hydrogen bond by exchanging the H bond-donating residue Glu-46 with the weaker H bond-donating glutamine (i.e., Gln-46). We have observed that this mutant exhibits virtually identical kinetics and product yields as WT PYP, even though during the I0-to-I1 transition, on the 800-ps time scale, the hydrogen bond of the chromophore with Gln-46 is broken, whereas this hydrogen bond remains intact with Glu-46.