Age-dependent losses in the penetrability of mouse eggs

Genome Transfer Prevents Fragmentation and Restores Developmental Potential of Developmentally Compromised Postovulatory Aged Mouse Oocytes

Changes in oocyte quality can have great impact on the developmental potential of early embryos. Here we test whether nuclear genome transfer from a developmentally incompetent to a developmentally competent oocyte can restore developmental potential. Using in vitro oocyte aging as a model system we performed nuclear transfer in mouse oocytes at metaphase II or at the first interphase, and observed that development to the blastocyst stage and to term was as efficient as in control embryos. The increased developmental potential is explained primarily by correction of abnormal cytokinesis at anaphase of meiosis and mitosis, by a reduction in chromosome segregation errors, and by normalization of the localization of chromosome passenger complex components survivin and cyclin B1. These observations demonstrate that developmental decline is primarily due to abnormal function of cytoplasmic factors involved in cytokinesis, while the genome remains developmentally fully competent.

•

In vitro aging as a model of oocyte fragmentation and poor developmental potential

•

Nuclear transfer restores normal cytokinesis of in vitro aged mouse oocytes

•

Nuclear transfer restores development to term of in vitro aged oocytes

•

Developmental potential is primarily limited by the cytoplasm, not the nucleus

Cortical mechanics and myosin-II abnormalities associated with post-ovulatory aging: implications for functional defects in aged eggs

STUDY HYPOTHESIS

Cellular aging of the egg following ovulation, also known as post-ovulatory aging, is associated with aberrant cortical mechanics and actomyosin cytoskeleton functions.

STUDY FINDING

Post-ovulatory aging is associated with dysfunction of non-muscle myosin-II, and pharmacologically induced myosin-II dysfunction produces some of the same deficiencies observed in aged eggs.

WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY

Reproductive success is reduced with delayed fertilization and when copulation or insemination occurs at increased times after ovulation. Post-ovulatory aged eggs have several abnormalities in the plasma membrane and cortex, including reduced egg membrane receptivity to sperm, aberrant sperm-induced cortical remodeling and formation of fertilization cones at the site of sperm entry, and reduced ability to establish a membrane block to prevent polyspermic fertilization.

STUDY DESIGN, SAMPLES/MATERIALS, METHODS

Ovulated mouse eggs were collected at 21-22 h post-human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) (aged eggs) or at 13-14 h post-hCG (young eggs), or young eggs were treated with the myosin light chain kinase (MLCK) inhibitor ML-7, to test the hypothesis that disruption of myosin-II function could mimic some of the effects of post-ovulatory aging. Eggs were subjected to various analyses. Cytoskeletal proteins in eggs and parthenogenesis were assessed using fluorescence microscopy, with further analysis of cytoskeletal proteins in immunoblotting experiments. Cortical tension was measured through micropipette aspiration assays. Egg membrane receptivity to sperm was assessed in in vitro fertilization (IVF) assays. Membrane topography was examined by low-vacuum scanning electron microscopy (SEM).

MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE

Aged eggs have decreased levels and abnormal localizations of phosphorylated myosin-II regulatory light chain (pMRLC; P = 0.0062). Cortical tension, which is mediated in part by myosin-II, is reduced in aged mouse eggs when compared with young eggs, by ∼40% in the cortical region where the metaphase II spindle is sequestered and by ∼50% in the domain to which sperm bind and fuse (P < 0.0001). Aging-associated parthenogenesis is partly rescued by treating eggs with a zinc ionophore (P = 0.003), as is parthenogenesis induced by inhibition of mitogen-activated kinase (MAPK) 3/1 [also known as extracellular signal-regulated kinase (ERK)1/2] or MLCK. Inhibition of MLCK with ML-7 also results in effects that mimic those of post-ovulatory aging: fertilized ML-7-treated eggs show both impaired fertilization and increased extents of polyspermy, and ML-7-treated young eggs have several membrane abnormalities that are shared by post-ovulatory aged eggs.

LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION

These studies were done with mouse oocytes, and it remains to be fully determined how these findings from mouse oocytes would compare with other species. For studies using methods not amenable to analysis of large sample sizes and data are limited to what images one can capture (e.g. SEM), data should be interpreted conservatively.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS

These data provide insights into causes of reproductive failures at later post-copulatory times.

LARGE SCALE DATA

Not applicable.

STUDY FUNDING AND COMPETING INTERESTS

This project was supported by R01 HD037696 and R01 HD045671 from the NIH to J.P.E. Cortical tension studies were supported by R01 GM66817 to D.N.R. The authors declare there are no financial conflicts of interest.

Conserving, distributing and managing genetically modified mouse lines by sperm cryopreservation

BACKGROUND

Sperm from C57BL/6 mice are difficult to cryopreserve and recover. Yet, the majority of genetically modified (GM) lines are maintained on this genetic background.

METHODOLOGY/PRINCIPAL FINDINGS

Reported here is the development of an easily implemented method that consistently yields fertilization rates of 70+/-5% with this strain. This six-fold increase is achieved by collecting sperm from the vas deferens and epididymis into a cryoprotective medium of 18% raffinose (w/v), 3% skim milk (w/v) and 477 microM monothioglycerol. The sperm suspension is loaded into 0.25 mL French straws and cooled at 37+/-1 degrees C/min before being plunged and then stored in LN(2). Subsequent to storage, the sperm are warmed at 2,232+/-162 degrees C/min and incubated in in vitro fertilization media for an hour prior to the addition of oocyte cumulus masses from superovulated females. Sperm from 735 GM mouse lines on 12 common genetic backgrounds including C57BL/6J, BALB/cJ, 129S1/SvImJ, FVB/NJ and NOD/ShiLtJ were cryopreserved and recovered. C57BL/6J and BALB/cByJ fertilization rates, using frozen sperm, were slightly reduced compared to rates involving fresh sperm; fertilization rates using fresh or frozen sperm were equivalent in all other lines. Developmental capacity of embryos produced using cryopreserved sperm was equivalent, or superior to, cryopreserved IVF-derived embryos.

CONCLUSIONS/SIGNIFICANCE

Combined, these results demonstrate the broad applicability of our approach as an economical and efficient option for archiving and distributing mice.

Developmental potential of aged oocyte rescued by nuclear transfer following parthenogenetic activation and in vitro fertilization

Mouse oocyte aged in vitro cannot develop normally following activation. To investigate the roles of nucleus or cytoplasm elements in oocyte aged in vitro process and their subsequent development capability following activation, we reconstructed oocytes with MII chromosome spindle and cytoplasm from aged and fresh oocytes by nuclear transfer. The subsequent developmental potential after parthenogenetic activation (PA) or in vitro fertilization (IVF) was evaluated. After nuclear transfer, more than 75.6% of karyoplast and cytoplast pairs can be fused and reconstructed oocytes have a normal haploid karyotype. Following PA, aged oocytes cannot develop beyond four-cell stage, reconstructed oocytes from fresh nucleus and aged cytoplasm developed to blastocyst with a low percentage (9.1%). Instead, blastocyst formation rate of reconstructed oocyte from aged nucleus and fresh cytoplasm was higher (60.0%). Following IVF, zygote with diploid karyotype can be formed from zona pellucida (ZP)-free oocyte. After cultured in vitro, aged oocytes cannot develop beyond two-cell; reconstructed oocytes from fresh nucleus and aged cytoplasm developed to blastocyst with low percentage (15.0%). However, high blastocyst formation rate (86.2%) can be obtained from reconstructed oocytes from aged nucleus and fresh cytoplasm. Furthermore, after embryo transfer, three viable pups have been obtained, although the efficiency is very low. These observation demonstrated that cytoplasm is more crucial than nucleus to aging process. Fresh cytoplasm could partly rescue nucleus susceptibility to apoptosis from aging in vitro.

Membrane and cortical abnormalities in post-ovulatory aged eggs: analysis of fertilizability and establishment of the membrane block to polyspermy

Fertilization at increased times after ovulation is associated with poor reproductive outcomes. This study examines the effects of post-ovulatory ageing on egg membrane function through analyses of mouse eggs collected at 13 and 22 h post-HCG ('young' and 'aged' eggs, respectively). Experiments in which fertilized zona pellucida-free young and aged eggs are challenged with additional sperm reveal that aged eggs are less able to establish a membrane block to prevent polyspermy, since sperm penetrate 24% of fertilized aged eggs but are unable to penetrate fertilized young eggs. This is not due to a failure of aged eggs to respond to fertilization, as the extent of sperm-induced cortical granule exocytosis is similar in aged and young eggs. Post-ovulatory ageing also affects egg membrane receptivity to sperm as a subset of zona pellucida-free aged eggs are slow to fertilize or resistant to fertilization. Sperm binding to young and aged eggs is similar, but aged eggs develop cytoskeletal abnormalities that may affect membrane/cortical function, such as the ability of the egg membrane to support sperm-egg fusion. These data demonstrate that the poor reproductive outcomes associated with post-ovulatory ageing could be a result of reduced fertilization, due to reduced egg membrane receptivity to sperm, or a result of increased incidence of polyspermy, due to the reduced ability to establish a membrane block to polyspermy. This analysis of egg membrane function deficiencies provides insights into post-ovulatory ageing and has implications for assisted reproductive technologies.

Production of Offspring from One-Day-Old Oocytes Stored at Room Temperature

To determine the feasibility of preserving oocytes without freezing, we stored mouse oocytes in several media at different temperatures for one day. Confocal microscopy of the metaphase-II spindle in these stored oocytes revealed gross abnormalities in both the spindle and the arrangement of chromosomes. The abnormal spindles could not be rescued by transplanting the aged spindle-chromosome complex into a fresh enucleated oocyte. A diploid parthenogenetic development showed that some of the oocytes stored at room temperature could still develop into blastocysts (10-57%). However, oocytes stored in a refrigerator (5%) or incubator (0%) lost the potential almost entirely. Fertilization of room-temperature-preserved oocytes with fresh spermatozoa by ICSI or IVF resulted in, respectively, 4 and 10%, full-term births. These results suggest that when oocytes are stored at room temperature for one day, most have irreversible damage not only to their cytoplasm but also to the spindle. However, since at least a few percent of stored oocytes retained the potential for full-term development, it may be possible to overcome these problems and develop a simple method for preserving mammalian oocytes without freezing.

Effects of aging on inositol 1,4,5-triphosphate-induced Ca(2+) release in unfertilized mouse oocytes

We previously demonstrated in the mouse oocyte that in vivo postovulatory aging significantly suppresses activity of the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) Ca(2+)-ATPase (Igarashi et al. 1997. Mol Reprod Dev 48:383-390). We undertook the present study to further examine the effects of oocyte aging on Ca(2+) release from the inositol 1,4,5-triphosphate (InsP(3))-sensitive Ca(2+) channels of the ER membrane, because not only Ca(2+) reuptake, but also Ca(2+) release from the ER, substantially affect Ca(2+) oscillations in fertilized oocytes. A transient increase in cytosolic free Ca(2+) concentration ([Ca(2+)](i)) was induced by photolysis of caged InsP(3) microinjected into the cytoplasm in both fresh (14 hr post hCG) and aged (20 hr or 24 hr post hCG) oocytes, where the maximum rate of increase in [Ca(2+)](i) significantly decreased in the aged oocytes. Reduced ER Ca(2+) release in the aged oocyte may not be attributable to aging-related desensitization of the InsP(3)-sensitive Ca(2+) channels in the ER because concentrations of caged InsP(3) for half maximal [Ca(2+)](i) increase were identical for fresh and aged oocytes. The peak [Ca(2+)](i) response following administration of 5 microM thapsigargin, a specific ER Ca(2+)-ATPase inhibitor, was significantly reduced in the aged oocyte, suggesting reduction of the ER Ca(2+) stores. We conclude from these results that reduction of Ca(2+) release from the InsP(3)-sensitive Ca(2+) stores in the aged oocyte arises from depletion of the ER Ca(2+) stores with aging. These aging-related changes in Ca(2+) release and reuptake may account for alterations in Ca(2+) oscillations in aged fertilized oocytes.

Decreased teratogen susceptibility in mouse fetuses obtained from delayed mating

We examined whether the susceptibility of fetuses to a teratogen differs between fetuses from delayed mating and those from normal mating. Mitomycin-C (MMC; 2.5 mg/kg or 5.0 mg/kg) was administered to pregnant mice intraperitoneally on day 10 of gestation after either normal or delayed mating (6 h). The incidence of MMC-induced malformations in fetuses from delayed mating was significantly lower than in those from the normal mating group when the treatment time was adjusted to be at the same critical period according to the "catch-up" phenomenon of developmental progression in the delayed mating group.

Influences of in vitro oocyte aging on microfertilization in the mouse with reference to zona hardening

PURPOSE

Our purpose was to investigate the influence of in vitro oocyte aging on fertilization and subsequent embryonic development following subzonal sperm injection with reference to spontaneous zona hardening in the mouse.

RESULTS

First cleavage rate was significantly higher in long vs short (69 vs 41%, P < 0.001). However, significantly higher blastocyst formation and hatching were observed in short than long (50 vs 7%, P < 0.001, and 86 vs 50%, P < 0.001, respectively). No significant differences were found for two pronuclei formation between short and long (30 vs 27%). Sham injection revealed a significantly higher parthenogenetic activation in long than short (19 vs 2%, P < 0.001). Zona digestion required a significantly longer time for long compared to short (trypsin--37 vs 29 min, P < 0.01; pronase--17 vs 14 min, P < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Prolonged culture of mature mouse oocytes in vitro alters the zona pellucida, increases the rate of parthenogenetic activation by subzonal sperm injection, and impairs subsequent embryonic development. Zona hardening appears to be an indicator of oocyte aging.

The effect on fertilization of exposure of mouse oocytes to dimethyl sulfoxide: an optimal protocol

Mouse oocytes, with or without an intact cumulus mass, were exposed to various concentrations of dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) at different temperatures for different periods of time and using different protocols of DMSO addition and removal. The effect of these procedures on the chymotrypsin sensitivity of the zona pellucida and the fertilizability of the oocytes was then assessed. Some procedures were found to affect adversely both the zona pellucida and the cumulus mass, resulting in reductions in the fertilization rate. As a result of both these and previously reported experiments (1-3), an optimal schedule is proposed for the handling of mouse oocytes during cryopreservation, namely, to equilibrate cumulus-intact oocytes in 1.5 M DMSO precooled to 4 degrees C prior to freezing, to remove DMSO at 4 degrees C after thawing prior to restoring the oocytes to 37 degrees C, to loosen or remove the cumulus cells, and then to hold oocytes at 37 degrees C for at least 1 hr to allow recovery of the spindle prior to insemination.

Spontaneous zona reaction in the mouse as a limiting factor for the time in which an oocyte may be fertilized

This study evaluated the effect of ovum aging on the in vitro fertilizability of mouse ova. Over 1347 ova were evaluated. Serial trypsin digestion of in vitro and in vivo aged ova revealed an increase in zona digestion time (0.25% trypsin) beginning at 40 hr, which increased over a 40-hr period and resulted in the unfertilized zona becoming as "hard" as the fertilized embryo zona. In vitro fertilizability showed a rapid decrease as zona hardening occurred with loss of cortical granules as assessed by electron microscopy. These data suggest that the window of fertilizability is "closed" by a spontaneous zona reaction occurring at about 55 hr post-human chorionic gonadotropin with loss of cortical granules and zona hardening as manifested by increasing zona digestion time with 0.25% trypsin.

Effects of delayed mating on preimplantation embryos in spontaneously ovulated mice

The effects of delayed mating on mouse preimplantation embryos (78 +/- 1 hours) were studied by setting up different mating periods in relation to the estimated time of spontaneous ovulation. Copulation occurred even in the late morning and early afternoon after the night of spontaneous ovulation. However, females mated in the early afternoon had no viable embryos at the time of laparotomy. Although embryonic development was not affected in the groups mated 6 or 10 hours after estimated ovulation, the percentage of degenerated embryos was increased in these groups. These results suggest that prolonged intervals between the estimated time of ovulation and mating have some deleterious effects on preimplantation embryos.

Interactions of aged gametes: in vitro fertilization using in vitro-aged sperm and in vivo-aged ova in the mouse

A study of varying combinations of in vitro-aged sperm and in vivo-aged ova at 3 hr intervals from 0-24 hr resulted in failures at different steps of the fertilization process during in vitro fertilization of mouse ova. Significant decreases caused by sperm aging, ova aging, and sperm X ova aging interaction were found in sperm penetration. Pronuclear formation was not affected by sperm aging and was enhanced by ova aging, and there was a significant effect of sperm X ova aging interaction. Sperm aging significantly influenced the prometaphase stage of the fertilization process. Therefore, it is suggested that the detrimental fertilization effects resulting from aging gametes are due to different mechanisms in sperm and ova, that these mechanisms are affected at different times, and that they affect different steps in the fertilization process.

Effect of aging and cold temperature storage of hamster ova as assessed in the sperm penetration assay

The penetration of zona pellucida-free hamster ova by human spermatozoa has been used to quantitate sperm penetration potential. However, since mammalian eggs in vitro have limited viability, the effect of in vitro aging on the ability of hamster ova to be penetrated by human spermatozoa was examined. Zona-free ova maintained at room temperature (25 degrees C) lost their ability to be subsequently penetrated with a half-life of 50.1 +/- 8.8 minutes. This was partly the result of removing the zona pellucida by trypsin digestion, since zona-free oocytes in the presence of trypsin inhibitor or zona pellucida-intact oocytes had half-lives of 99.1 +/- 15.2 and 120.5 +/- 17.4 minutes, respectively. Reduction in penetration rates associated with ovum aging did not appear to be due to loss of viability and could be completely prevented by maintaining the ova on ice (4 degrees C). In the presence of TEST-yolk buffer at 4 degrees C, ova retained (100%) their ability to be penetrated for up to 24 hours and were morphologically indistinguishable from fresh ova. These observations show that ovum aging in vitro at 25 degrees C is much greater than previously anticipated. This may result in artifactually low and variable scores in the penetration bioassay.

Sperm interaction with the zona-free hamster egg

The interaction of sperm with the zona-free hamster egg was studied. Hamster sperm were capacitated in Tyrodes media, containing 50% heat-inactivated serum and used to inseminate zona-free eggs in BWW containing 10% serum. Capacitated sperm began fusing with eggs within the first hour of insemination and by 3 h penetration had ceased as indicated by the absence of further changes in the mean number of sperm incorporated per egg. Penetration by capacitated hamster sperm was linearly related to the log of the motile sperm concentration at concentrations above 10(4) cells/ml. The viability of sperm and eggs in culture was limited in these studies to approximately 3-5 h. The existence of a block to unlimited sperm penetration of the zona-free egg was sought in reinsemination experiments. A relatively low sperm concentration was used to initiate egg responses, followed, at timed intervals, by reinsemination with a high challenge concentration of sperm. Subsequent polyspermy levels reflected the presence or absence of the egg's block to polyspermy response. In order to circumvent the problems arising from the rapid aging of hamster sperm in culture, mouse sperm were employed, a convenience afforded by the lack of species specificity in this egg. Reinseminated eggs incorporated additional sperm during the challenge; therefore, the hamster egg is not capable of preventing unlimited sperm penetration. The implications of these findings to the use of the zona-free hamster egg test in fertility evaluation is discussed.

Penetration of zona-free hamster ova as a test to assess fertilizing ability of bull sperm after frozen storage

Frozen stored sperm samples of two Holstein bulls (A and B) were compared for their abilities to interact with zona-free hamster ova. The percentage of hamster vitelli interacting with sperm from Bull A was significantly higher than that interacting with sperm from Bull B (94.5% vs. 68.2%, P<0.01), and these results were in good agreement with 60 day non-return data for the same months (68.2% for Bull A vs. 64.3% for Bull B). Sperm from Bull A also excelled in average numbers attached to vitelli, and in average numbers of sperm penetrated into the zona-free hamster ova. However, of the penetrated vitelli, sperm of Bull B resulted in more pronuclei. In these experiments the percentage of progressively motile sperm at insemination was highly correlated with the percentage of vitelli interacting with sperm. The percentages and numbers of sperm cells with intact acrosomes were significantly correlated with the average number of sperm attached per vitellus. These observations encourage further development of this test for assessing sperm fertilizing ability.

Failure of human spermatozoa to penetrate zona free mouse and rat ova in vitro

When incubated for 8 to 26 hours with zona-free mouse or rat ova, human spermatozoa failed to attach to or penetrate any of the ova. The ova were capable of being fertilized since both intra- and inter-species penetration of spermatozoa and formation of pronuclei occurred between rat and mouse gametes. When mouse spermatozoa were incubated for three to eight hours with rat ova, a high proportion of the ova were penetrated, formation of pronuclei occurred and in 9 out of 36 ova incubated for 40 hours after insemination, regular cleavage and formation of morphologically normal 2-cell embryos occurred. Human spermatozoa retained their morphological integrity and motility only when the culture medium contained purified bovine serum albumin (3 mg/ml) or human serum (5% v/v) and not when unpurified BSA from several different commercial sources was used as a protein source. In this latter medium, the ova of both rats and mice degenerated after 8-hour incubation in the presence of human spermatozoa but not when human spermatozoa were absent or in the presence of either rat or mouse spermatozoa. Electron microscopy indicated that the human spermatozoa incubated for eight hours in medium containing purified BSA had undergone an acrosome reaction. These spermatozoa also attached to and penetrated human oocytes which had been matured in vitro.