Yield of retinal examination in suspected physical abuse with normal neuroimaging

Retinal hemorrhages in abusive head trauma with atraumatic neuroimaging

We report 3 cases of suspected abusive head trauma with retinal hemorrhages on fundus examination and neuroimaging findings not necessarily suggestive of shaking injury. Previous studies have suggested that retinal hemorrhages are rare in patients without neuroimaging abnormalities. These cases demonstrate some common features (rib fractures, developmental delay, and history of abuse) that may increase suspicion for abusive head trauma. Our findings suggest a potential role for ophthalmic consultation in scenarios with high clinical suspicion for abusive head trauma without definitive neuroimaging evidence of head injury. The nonspecific neuroimaging features of these 3 cases highlight the importance of interpreting cases with global clinical context.

Evidence-Based Screening to Optimize the Yield of Positive Ophthalmologic Examinations in Children Evaluated for Suspected Child Abuse

PURPOSE

To determine nonocular findings associated with significant retinal hemorrhage on dilated fundus examination in cases of suspected child abuse.

METHODS

This was a retrospective chart review from May 2014 to August 2021 at a level-1 trauma center. Two hundred seventy-four patients met the following inclusion criteria: (1) children 36 months and younger; (2) concern for child abuse; and (3) had an ophthalmology consultation. Through univariate and multivariate logistic regression, the study produced a screening algorithm for ophthalmic work-up in child abuse.

RESULTS

One or more abnormal neuroimaging findings had a statistically significant association with retinal hemorrhages and produced the strongest association with a univariate odds ratio of 170 (confidence interval: 10.245 to > 999.999). The multivariate model (P < .0001 with a c-statistic of 0.980) proposes using the following variables for predicting retinal hemorrhage on examination: abnormal neuroimaging, Glasgow Coma Scale score less than 15, altered mental status on examination, seizure activity, vomiting, bruising, scalp hematoma/swelling, and skull fractures.

CONCLUSIONS

This study elucidates clinical and imaging factors that correlate to retinal findings, validating previously studied variables and introducing new variables to be considered. The authors propose an evidence-based screening algorithm to increase the yield of positive dilated examinations and decrease the burden of potentially unnecessary child abuse ophthalmologic examinations. [J Pediatr Ophthalmol Strabismus. 2022;59(5):310-319.].

Predictive value of non-ocular findings for retinal haemorrhage in children evaluated for non-accidental trauma

PURPOSE

To determine non-ocular examination findings in non-accidental trauma (NAT) patients that are associated with retinal haemorrhage and warrant urgent examination by an ophthalmologist.

METHODS

A hospital- and clinic-based retrospective cross-sectional and cohort study of children age 0-12 years who underwent workup for NAT over a span of nine years in a level I trauma and tertiary referral centre. Details of ocular and non-ocular examination and imaging findings at the time of NAT evaluation were collected by chart review. Univariate and logistic regression analysis for association between retinal haemorrhage and non-ocular examination findings was performed.

RESULTS

A total of 557 patients with ophthalmology evaluation and 425 without were included in this study. All ages combined, none of the cutaneous signs of trauma or non-skull fractures were associated with retinal haemorrhage on univariate analysis (p > 0.05). By logistic regression, subdural or extra-axial haemorrhage (OR = 16.2; 95% CI [5.11-51.3]), occipital lobe insult (OR = 6.2; 95% CI [1.77-21.6]) and Glasgow coma score (GCS) <15 (OR = 5.8; 95% CI [1.96-17.4]) were significant predictors of retinal haemorrhage.

CONCLUSION

Subdural or undistinguished extra-axial haemorrhage, GCS <15, and occipital lobe insult are risk factors for the presence of retinal haemorrhage in patients with suspected NAT and their presence warrant urgent dilated fundus examination by an ophthalmologist. The presence of cutaneous trauma or non-skull bone fractures without the aforementioned risk factors does not warrant ophthalmology evaluation.

Diagnosis of Abusive Head Trauma : Neurosurgical Perspective

Abusive head trauma (AHT) is the most severe form of physical abuse in children. Such injury involves traumatic damage to the head and/or spine of infants and young children. The term AHT was introduced to include a wider range of injury mechanisms, such as intentional direct blow, throw, and even penetrating trauma by perpetuator(s). Currently, it is recommended to replace the former term, shaken baby syndrome, which implicates shaking as the only mechanism, with AHT to include diverse clinical and radiological manifestations. The consequences of AHT cause devastating medical, social and financial burdens on families, communities, and victims. The potential harm of AHT to the developing brain and spinal cord of the victims is tremendous. Many studies have reported that the adverse effects of AHT are various and serious, such as blindness, mental retardation, physical limitation of daily activities and even psychological problems. Therefore, appropriate vigilance for the early recognition and diagnosis of AHT is highly recommended to stop and prevent further injuries. The aim of this review is to summarize the relevant evidence concerning the early recognition and diagnosis of AHT. To recognize this severe type of child abuse early, all health care providers maintain a high index of suspicion and vigilance. Such suspicion can be initiated with careful and thorough history taking and physical examinations. Previously developed clinical prediction rules can be helpful for decision-making regarding starting an investigation when considering meaningful findings. Even the combination of biochemical markers may be useful to predict AHT. For a more confirmative evaluation, neuroradiological imaging is required to find AHT-specific findings. Moreover, timely consultation with ophthalmologists is needed to find a very specific finding, retinal hemorrhage.

Clinical evaluation and management of children with suspected physical abuse

Evaluating and managing children with suspected physical abuse is challenging. Few single injuries are pathognomonic for abuse and, as a result, child abuse is easily missed. As such, a healthy bit of skepticism is needed to recognize and protect abused children. The medical history and clinical presentation should guide evaluation. Medical providers must consider the differential diagnosis, epidemiology of injuries, and child development to inform the assessment. In this review, we address evidence-based recommendations to inform child physical abuse evaluations. We also discuss the role of medical providers in communicating with families, mandated reporting and interpreting medical information for investigative agencies and other non-medical colleagues entrusted with protecting children.

Nonaccidental trauma in pediatric patients: evidence-based screening criteria for ophthalmologic examination

BACKGROUND

Ophthalmologic examination is included in the work-up for pediatric nonaccidental trauma (NAT) when there is concern for retinal hemorrhage. However, dilated fundus examination entails patient discomfort and prohibition of assessment of pupillary response. Previous studies have suggested that patients without neuroimaging abnormalities are unlikely to have retinal hemorrhage. The purpose of the current study was to analyze the findings in patients who received NAT evaluation with eye examination at our institution, and to propose screening criteria for inclusion of ophthalmologic examination in NAT evaluation.

METHODS

The medical records of patients who received NAT evaluation with ophthalmologic examination at The Johns Hopkins Children's Center Pediatric Emergency Department from August 2014 to July 2018 were reviewed retrospectively. Data collected included demographics, presenting symptoms, imaging findings, and ophthalmologic examination findings. The main outcome measure was presence of retinal hemorrhage.

RESULTS

A total of 192 evaluations with ophthalmologic examination were included, representing 190 unique individuals of mean age 8.4 ± 9.5 months at presentation. In approximately half (54%) of the evaluations, there were abnormal findings on neuroimaging. Fifteen children (8%) had retinal hemorrhage, all of whom also had abnormal neuroimaging. Abnormal neuroimaging was associated with presence of retinal hemorrhage, with an odds ratio of 21.0 (95% CI, 3.47-∞; P < 0.001). Of the 15 children with retinal hemorrhage, 14 had subdural hemorrhage.

CONCLUSIONS

When neuroimaging abnormalities are present, ophthalmologic examination should be performed as part of the pediatric NAT evaluation. When there is no evidence of head injury on neuroimaging, ophthalmologic examination should not be routine.

Ophthalmology referral as part of a multidisciplinary approach to suspected abusive head trauma

OBJECTIVE

To determine the use of ophthalmology consultation as part of investigation of children with suspected abusive head trauma (AHT).

METHODS

Retrospective chart review of children under age 3 years evaluated at McMaster Children's Hospital for suspected AHT from January 2011 to December 2017.

RESULTS

Fifty-seven children were investigated, and 29 (50.9%) of these were determined to have likely AHT. Eleven (19.3%) had other nonaccidental injuries. A mean of 3.6 consulting services were involved. Neuroimaging was performed for 52 patients (91.2%), including all patients in the AHT group. Intracranial hemorrhage (ICH) was present in 21 of the 29 AHT children (72.4%). All 57 patients had a dilated fundus examination, and retinal hemorrhages (RH) were seen in 23 patients (40.4%), including 16 (55.2%) in the AHT group. All patients with RH in AHT also had ICH. In the AHT group, there were more cases of hemorrhages too numerous to count (68.8% vs 28.6%), multilayered hemorrhages (75.0% vs 57.1%), and hemorrhages in the posterior pole and periphery (87.5% vs 42.9%) when compared with patients with RH from other etiologies. Retinoschisis was seen in the AHT group only in 3 patients (18.8%).

CONCLUSIONS

A multidisciplinary approach is important when investigating suspected AHT. Not every child with RH had suffered AHT; however, children with AHT showed more widespread and more multilayered RH. The only finding specific to AHT was retinoschisis.

Comparison of the characteristics of retinal hemorrhages in abusive head trauma versus normal vaginal delivery

BACKGROUND

Retinal hemorrhage (RH) is one of the hallmarks of abusive head trauma (AHT); however, RH is also encountered with normal vaginal deliveries (NVD) and thus presents the clinician with a diagnostic dilemma. The purpose of this study was to compare RHs in AHT with those of NVD.

METHODS

Records of with AHT and NVD infants with RH evaluated from 2013 to 2015 were reviewed retrospectively. Pattern, size, extent, and severity were compared using RetCam images. Severities were calculated using the RH grading scale.

RESULTS

A total of 20 patients with AHT and 200 NVD infants were included. RH size was significantly larger in AHT patients compared to the NVD group (3.1 ± 0.512 vs 0.96 ± 0.046 disk diameters, resp.). The AHT group also demonstrated a higher RH incidence involving all three retinal layers compared to the NVD group (60% vs 0.6%, resp. [P < 0.001]). Vitreous hemorrhages were more common in the AHT group compared to the NVD group (54.3% vs 1.5% [P < 0.001]). Also, the grading scale demonstrated higher scores in the AHT group than the NVD group (7.15 ± 0.948 vs 3.59 ± 0.274, resp.).

CONCLUSIONS

AHT and NVD share similar retinal findings, but they also have unique differentiators. In our subjects, AHT presented with more severe retinal findings than NVD, including larger RH size, a higher percentage involving all three retinal layers, a higher percentage of vitreous hemorrhages, and higher RH grading scale scores. Also, NVD retinal hemorrhages resolved quickly, within 4 weeks of birth in 95% of the patients.

Abusive head trauma: a review of the evidence base

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this article is to review the constellation of findings of abusive head trauma, which may be accompanied by injuries to the appendicular and axial skeleton, brain and spinal cord, and retina. Additional common features include skin and soft-tissue injury, visceral findings, and evidence of oral trauma.

CONCLUSION

The evidence base for abusive head trauma encompasses diverse disciplines, including diagnostic imaging, pathology, pediatrics, biomechanics, ophthalmology, epidemiology, and orthopedics. When the varied sources of evidence are pieced together and taken in toto, abusive head trauma is often readily differentiated from alternative explanations of an infant's injuries.

Risk factors associated with retinal hemorrhage in suspected abusive head trauma

PURPOSE

To determine risk factors associated with retinal hemorrhage (RH) in pediatric abusive head trauma (AHT) suspects.

METHODS

Records of children aged 0-3 years hospitalized for suspected AHT from January 2007 to November 2011 were retrospectively reviewed in this case-control study. Children were classified into case and control groups based on RH presence. Medical history, presenting symptoms, reasons, and characteristics of injury were recorded. Logistic regression analysis was performed to identify risk factors.

RESULTS

A total of 168 children (104 males) were included. Of these, 103 were classified as cases and 65 as controls. The mean age (with standard deviation) was 9.3 ± 8.3 months (range, 1 day-36 months). Of the 103 cases, 22 (21%) had subretinal hemorrhage, 9 (9%) had retinoschisis, and 1 (1%) had vitreous hemorrhage. Children presenting with lethargy or altered mental status (P < 0.0001), subdural hemorrhage (P < 0.0001), and other radiologic findings (eg, cerebral ischemia, diffuse axonal injury, hydrocephalus, or solid organ injury; P = 0.01546) were likely to have RH. All 23 children with skull or nonskull fracture without intracranial hemorrhage did not have RH (P < 0.0001 both categories).

CONCLUSIONS

Retinal hemorrhages were almost never found in the absence of intracranial hemorrhage and not found in the setting of fracture without intracranial hemorrhage.

Utility of a child abuse screening guideline in an urban pediatric emergency department

BACKGROUND

Previous studies have found racial and socioeconomic status bias in the way clinicians screen for and detect child abuse in patients presenting to the emergency department. We hypothesized that implementing a guideline for screening would attenuate this bias.

METHODS

An algorithm for child abuse screening in patients younger than 1 year presenting with fractures was developed for a pediatric trauma center emergency department. Data were collected 1.5 years before and after implementation of the algorithm to investigate implementation success. Data were compared before and after the implementation of the algorithm using χ and univariate logistic regression analysis.

RESULTS

The characteristics of patients with fractures were similar before and after the algorithm implementation. Implementation of the algorithm was related to a significant increase in algorithm required screenings: skeletal survey (p < 0.001), urinalysis (p < 0.001), and transaminase levels (p < 0.001). The racial composition of those screened did not change after the implementation of the protocol. Children with government-subsidized or no insurance were more likely to be screened for child abuse via skeletal survey before the algorithm implementation compared with those with private insurance (odds ratio, 2.7; 95% confidence interval, 1.2-6.0; p = 0.017). This relationship did not exist after the algorithm implementation (odds ratio, 1.2; 95% confidence interval, 0.56-2.46; p = 0.66). Final determination of child abuse was related to insurance status both before and after the algorithm implementation.

CONCLUSION

A child abuse screening algorithm was successfully implemented in an urban trauma center. After implementation, screening was no longer associated with socioeconomic status of the patient's family, although final determination of child abuse still was. Additional research is needed to determine utility of unbiased screening on patient outcomes.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic study, level IV.

Dedicated retinal examination in children evaluated for physical abuse without radiographically identified traumatic brain injury

OBJECTIVE

To determine the rate of retinal hemorrhages in children evaluated for physical abuse without traumatic brain injury (TBI) by diagnostic imaging.

STUDY DESIGN

This study was a prospectively planned, secondary analysis of the Examining Siblings to Recognize Abuse (ExSTRA) research network, and included only index children who presented with concerns for abuse. Subjects were eligible for the parent study if they were less than 10 years old and evaluated by a Child Abuse Physician for concerns of physical abuse. Child Abuse Physicians recorded results of all screening testing and determination of the likelihood of abuse in each case. For this analysis, we examined the results of dedicated retinal examinations for children with neuroimaging that showed no TBI. Isolated skull fractures were not considered to be TBI.

RESULTS

The original ExSTRA sample included 2890 index children evaluated for physical abuse. Of this group, 1692 underwent neuroimaging and 1122 had no TBI. Of these 1122 children, 352 had a dedicated retinal examination. Retinal hemorrhages were identified in 2 (0.6%) children. In both cases, there were few (defined as 3-10) hemorrhages isolated to the posterior poles; neither was diagnosed with physical abuse. The presence of facial bruising, altered mental status, or complex skull fractures was neither sensitive nor specific for retinal hemorrhage identification.

CONCLUSIONS

Forensically significant retinal hemorrhages are unlikely to be found in children evaluated for physical abuse without TBI on neuroimaging, and such children may not require routine dedicated retinal examination.

Abusive head trauma in young children: a population-based study

OBJECTIVE

The objectives of this study were to provide population-based incidence estimate of abusive head trauma (AHT) in children aged 0 to 5 years from inpatient and emergency department (ED) and identify risk characteristics for recognizing high-risk children to improve public health surveillance.

METHODS

This was a retrospective cohort study based on children's first encounter in ED or hospital admission with a diagnosis of head trauma (HT), 2000-2010. The relationship between clinical markers and AHT was examined controlling for covariables in the model using Cox hazards regression. Kaplan-Meier incidence probability was plotted, and the number of weeks elapsing from date of birth to the first encounter with HT established the survival time (T).

RESULTS

Twenty-six thousand six hundred eighty-one children had HT, 502 (1.8%) resulted from abuse; 42.4% was captured from ED. Incidence varied from 28.9 (95% confidence interval [CI], 27.9-37.4) in infants to 4.1 (95% CI, 2.4-5.7) in 5-year-olds per 100,000 per year. Adjusted hazard ratio was 20.3 (95% CI, 10.9-38.0) for intracranial bleeding and 11.4 (95% CI, 8.57-15.21) for retinal hemorrhage.

CONCLUSIONS

Incidence estimates of AHT are incomplete without including ED. Intracranial bleeding is a cardinal feature of AHT to be considered in case ascertainment to improve public health surveillance.

Prevalence of retinal hemorrhages in critically ill children

BACKGROUND

Retinal hemorrhages (RHs) with encephalopathy and subdural bleeding are considered suggestive of abusive head trauma (AHT). Existing studies describing RH focus on AHT and have potential selection bias. We undertook a prospective observational study to define the prevalence, distribution, and extent of RH in critically ill children.

METHODS

From February 2008 to December 2009, emergency intensive care admissions ≥ 6 weeks of age underwent dilated retinal examination by either a pediatric ophthalmologist or RetCam (retinal photograph) imaging after written informed consent. Patients with suspected or proven AHT, penetrating eye trauma, and elective admissions were excluded.

RESULTS

The prevalence of RH was 15.1% (24/159; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 9.5%-21%); 16/24 (66%) mild, and 2/24 (8%) moderate. Severe multilayered RH were seen in only 6 patients (3.7%), 3 with myeloid leukemia and sepsis, 2 with severe accidental head injury, and 1 with severe coagulopathy secondary to late onset hemorrhagic disease of newborn. There was no detectable impact of age, gender, seizures, coagulopathy or cardiopulmonary resuscitation on prevalence of severe multilayered RH; however, sepsis (odds ratio: 3.2; 95% CI: 1.3-8.0, P = .018) and coagulopathy (odds ratio: 2.8; 95% CI: 1.2-7.0, P = .025) were significantly associated with any RH. Only admission diagnosis was independently associated with severe multilayered RH on logistic regression.

CONCLUSIONS

RHs were seen in critically ill children with a prevalence of 15.1% (24/159); however, most were mild. Severe multilayered RH resembling those described in AHT were rare (6/24) and were only seen in patients with fatal accidental trauma, severe coagulopathy, sepsis with myeloid leukemia, or a combination of these factors.