The mechanical complications and behavior of angulated dental implant abutment systems versus conventional abutments, a narrative review

Background

Angulated screw channel (ASC) abutment allows off-axis dental implants to be used in dental restorations without the need for cementation. As this is a relatively new system, research on its clinical performance is limited.

Objectives

To summarize the available in-vitro and in-vivo studies on the mechanical and technical issues associated with the ASC system and compare its clinical performance with that of conventional implant-supported abutments.

Methods

A comprehensive literature search in PubMed, Web of Science, and ScienceDirect databases was performed, focusing on articles about angulated (angled) screw channel (ASC) systems published in English between January 2015 and November 2023. Only in-vitro and in-vivo studies were included.

Results

After analyzing the recorded articles, 26 studies (11 in vivo and 15 in vitro) were included in the final discussion and review.

Conclusion

Although the ASC system is still relatively new, and is presently outperformed by conventional abutment systems in terms of technical and mechanical properties, in short- and medium-term in-vivo studies, it was shown reliable for retaining single or multiple-unit implant restorations in both posterior and anterior zones. Still, further long-term clinical research is needed to fully elucidate the risk factors associated with ASC failures.

Effects of cyclic loading on loss of abutment screw torque of angled screw channel single implant crowns on narrow diameter implants

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

Screw access channels that emerge on the facial aspect of anterior screw-retained implant crowns can compromise esthetics. Recently, angled screw channels (ASCs) have been developed that can alter screw access channel angulations to improve esthetics. While ASCs can be used on narrow-diameter implants, information is limited on the loss of abutment screw torque on narrow-diameter implants with ASCs.

PURPOSE

The purpose of this in vitro study was to compare the loss of abutment screw torque after thermocycling and the cyclic loading of ASCs from 3 different companies connected to narrow-diameter implants.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A total of 40 narrow-diameter implants (NobelReplace Conical Connection 3.5×11.5 mm) were mounted individually in acrylic resin blocks and divided equally into 4 groups. The first group, NB-0 (Control), consisted of screw-retained zirconia crowns fabricated on ASCs at 0-degree angulation (n=10). The other 3 groups consisted of a total of 30 screw-retained zirconia crowns fabricated on ASCs at 20-degree angulation: NB-20 (Angulated Screw Channel Solutions), ATL-20 (Atlantis Custom Base Solution with angulated screw access), and DA-20 (Dynamic TiBase). Each crown was secured on the mounted implant with its corresponding titanium base insert and screw and then tightened to the manufacturer's recommended torque with a digital torque gauge. The initial reverse torque value (RTVI) was obtained and recorded at baseline. Subsequently, a new set of screws were tightened to recommended values, and each specimen underwent thermocycling and then cyclic loading at 0 to 100 N at 10 Hz for 1 million cycles to simulate 1year of functional loading. After cyclic loading, the final reverse torque values (RTVF) were recorded and compared with the RTVI to evaluate the percentage torque loss (PTLF). Statistical analysis was performed using the Kruskal-Wallis analysis, Rank base analysis of covariance (ANCOVA), and the Tukey HSD post hoc comparisons (α=.05).

RESULTS

Significant differences were found for the PTLF among all groups after cyclic loading (P<.001). The PTLF in ATL-20 (51.4%) was significantly higher than in NB-0 (22.2%) (P<.001) and NB-20 (29.2%) (P=.010). No significant difference was found in the PTLF among other groups (P>.05).

CONCLUSIONS

The abutment screw torque loss after cyclic loading of the ASCs on narrow diameter implants among the 4 groups did not perform comparably. The largest percentage torque loss was recorded for the ATL-20 group. The NB-20 group demonstrated the lowest percentage torque loss. DA-20 showed percentage torque loss less than ATL-20; however, its RTVF was the lowest.

Optimal design and biomechanical analysis of sandwich composite metal locking screws for far cortical locking constructs

In the interests of more flexible and less stiff bridge constructs to stimulate bone healing, the technique of far cortical locking has been designed to improve locked plating constructs in terms of stress concentration, stress shielding, and inhibition of issues around fracture healing. However, far cortical locking screws currently lack objective designs and anti-fatigue designs. This study investigates an optimization algorithm to form a special locking screw composed of various metals, which can theoretically achieve the maintenance of the excellent mechanical properties of far cortical locking constructs in terms of fracture internal fixation, while maintaining the biomechanical safety and fatigue resistance of the structure. The numerical results of our study indicate that the maximum von Mises stress of the optimized construct is less than the allowable stress of the material under each working condition while still achieving sufficient parallel interfragmentary motion. Numerical analysis of high cycle fatigue indicates that the optimized construct increases the safety factor to five. A high cycle fatigue test and defect analysis indicates that the sandwich locking constructs have better fatigue resistance. We conclude that the sandwich locking construct theoretically maintains its biomechanical safety and fatigue resistance while also maintaining excellent mechanical properties for fracture internal fixation.

Short Narrow Dental Implants versus Long Narrow Dental Implants in Fixed Prostheses: A Prospective Clinical Study

There is a paucity of studies that assess short and narrow dental implants. This prospective study aimed to evaluate the performance of both short (≤8 mm) and narrow (≤3.5 mm width) dental implants supporting fixed prostheses in the atrophic maxilla or mandible. Towards that aim, patients with short implants were included in the study. The control group was those with long and narrow dental implants (length > 8 mm and diameter ≤ 3.5 mm). Clinical and demographic variables were extracted from clinical records. During the follow-up, implant survival and marginal bone loss were evaluated and statistically analysed. Forty-one implants were included (18 and 23 implants in the test and control groups, respectively). The median follow-up time was 26 months since insertion in both groups. The results revealed that there was no implant failure and no statistically significant differences in terms of marginal bone loss. Only one screw-loosening effect occurred in the short implants group. Short, narrow dental implants could be an alternative for the restoration of severely resorbed jaws.

Clinical and Laboratory Outcomes of Angled Screw Channel Implant Prostheses: A Systematic Review

The purpose of this systematic review was to evaluate the clinical and laboratory outcomes of angled screw channel (ASC) restorations and to summarize the influencing factors. An electronic search of the English language literature was performed in four databases and enriched by manual searches. Retrieved studies were screened against the predefined exclusion and inclusion criteria. Eight clinical and seven laboratory studies were eligible for the analysis. The risk of bias for included observational studies was performed using the Newcastle–Ottawa quality assessment scale. Laboratory studies quality assessment method was adapted from previous published systematic reviews. Two clinical studies focused on technical outcomes and the rest reported the biological outcomes of the ASC restorations. Out of the seven laboratory studies, two studies investigated the fracture resistance of ASC restorations, four studies evaluated the reverse torque value of the nonaxially tightened screws, and one study evaluated both variables. The present review revealed that while the performance of ASC restorations is promising in short-term clinical studies, the evidence of their long-term reliability is still lacking. The laboratory studies indicated comparable fracture resistance results of the ASC restorations with the straight screw channel restorations. In addition, factors, such as initial torque value, configuration of the screw driver, screw design, abutment system, and the angulation of screw channel, were shown to influence the screw resistance to loosening.

Clinical performance of posterior monolithic zirconia implant-supported fixed dental prostheses with angulated screw channels: A 3-year prospective cohort study

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

The choice of retention type of an implant-supported fixed dental prosthesis (FDP) becomes critical when the dental implant is not placed in a prosthetically ideal location. In recent years, computer-aided design and computer-aided manufacturing (CAD-CAM) technology has enabled the correction of the location of screw access hole depending on the clinical needs of the patient. However, how FPDs with angulated screw channels (ASCs) perform clinically is unclear.

PURPOSE

The purpose of this prospective clinical study was to evaluate the mechanical complications and crestal bone loss (CBL) when posterior monolithic zirconia implant-supported FDPs with an ASC are used.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Participants (N=37) with a missing single posterior tooth or multiple teeth, sufficient bone height, and an implant site without infection were included. Each participant received parallel-walled implants (Nobel Parallel CC) of 7-, 8.5-, or 10-mm length by using a 1-stage approach. After 4 months of healing, a conventional impression was made, and a digital workflow was followed. Monolithic zirconia restorations (Katana ML) were milled, stained, and mechanically attached to a titanium base (NobelProcera ASC abutment). CBL was measured from radiographs at 6, 12, 24, and 36 months after the placement of the prosthesis. Implant and prosthetic characteristics including implant diameter, implant length, screw channel angle (angle≤15 degrees versus angle>16 degrees), prosthetic type (single crown versus multiple-unit FDP), and antagonist dentition (natural versus prosthesis) were also recorded. A generalized linear mixed model with a log link was estimated to assess the independent predictors of CBL among the angles of ASC-retained definitive restorations and the clinically relevant variables (α=.05).

RESULTS

Thirty-seven participants received 51 implants, and the median follow-up period was 30 months (interquartile range: 22-36). Two single-crown implants failed within the first 12 months of delivery. The implant and restoration survival rate was 96% at 36 months. Screw loosening was recorded in 2 study participants. After a follow-up of 36 months, the mean ±standard deviation CBL value was 0.15 ±0.14 mm with an increase over time (P<.001). The effect of the angle of ASC, implant diameter, implant length, prosthetic type, and antagonist on the CBL was not statistically significant (P>.05).

CONCLUSIONS

CBL was not associated with the angle of ASC, implant diameter, implant length, prosthetic type, or antagonist when posterior monolithic zirconia implant-supported FDPs with ASCs were used. Screw loosening in 2 situations was the only mechanical complication during the first 3 years of service.

Implant-prosthetic treatment in patients with oral lichen planus: A systematic review

AIMS

This review is aiming on identifying the ideal implant-prosthetic treatment design in patients with OLP.

METHODS AND RESULTS

A systematic review was conducted using four electronic databases; Medline (PubMed), Cochrane library, DOAJ and SCOPUS, following the PRISMA statement recommendations to answer the PICO question: "which implant-prosthetic treatment design is most useful to ensure implant survival in OLP patients?". The study was pre-registered in PROSPERO (CRD 42020220102). Included articles quality was assessed using the "Newcastle-Ottawa scale" and the JBI critical appraisal tool for case series. No article was found specifically designed to analyze the prosthetic influence on implant survival in OLP patients. Despite, information about implant-prostheses in studies designed with other goals was compiled. Eight articles that involved 141 patients and 341 implants were finally selected. The weighted mean follow-up was 38 months and the weighted mean survival of the implants 98.9%. No statistical differences were observed between cemented or screw retained prostheses and the materials employed or the technology to manufacture the prostheses.

CONCLUSION

The influence of prosthetic design on implant survival in OLP patients is still poorly understood, but important clinical recommendations can be drawn. The strength of evidence was grade 3b (CEBM) or low (GRADE).

Effect of cyclic loading on reverse torque values of angled screw channel systems

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

The angled screw channel concept has become popular. However, research is lacking as to how reverse torque values of nonaxially tightened implant crowns compare with axially tightened cement-retained crowns restored on angle-correcting abutments when subjected to long-term cyclic loading.

PURPOSE

The purpose of this in vitro study was to evaluate the ability of different 25-degree angled screw channel hexalobular systems to apply the target torque value on their screws, the effect of cyclic loading on their reverse torque values, and their survival compared with crowns cemented on conventional 0-degree screw channel abutments.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A total of 28 implants were divided into 4 groups. Twenty-one angled screw channel crowns were fabricated at a 25-degree angle correction by using angled titanium (Ti) bases by 3 manufacturers DY (Dynamic Tibase), DE (AngleBase), and ASC (Angulated Screw Channel) (n=7). The fourth group, UB (Universal Base, Control), had cement-retained crowns with 25-degree custom-milled, angled zirconia abutments that were cemented onto their respective Ti bases (n=7). All implants were embedded in epoxy resin blocks and tightened to manufacturer recommended values: 35 Ncm for ASC, UB, and DE and 25 Ncm for DY. Initial torque values (ITV1) were recorded. After 24 hours, the reverse torque values (24hr-RTV1) were recorded. A new set of screws was then used for each group, and the initial torque values (ITV2) were recorded. Specimens were loaded at 2 Hz for 5 million cycles under a 200-N load, and reverse torque values (RTV2) were recorded. ANOVA (α=.05) was used to compare differences in the means of deviation of initial torque values and means of reverse torque values followed by a Tukey-Kramer post hoc analysis (α=.05). Preload efficiency was calculated for each system (RTV2/ITV2), and a survival analysis was performed by using the Lifetest procedure.

RESULTS

A significant difference in the means of deviation of initial torque values of the groups with 25-degree torque application (DY, DE, and ASC) was found when compared with UB at 0 degrees. ASC and DE had lower initial torque values than UB (P<.001 and P=.003 for ASC ITV1 and ITV2, P<.001 and P=.006 for DE ITV1 and ITV2). A significant difference was found in mean reverse torque values both for after 24 hours and after cyclic loading among all groups (P<.001). A significant difference was found between mean reverse torque values before and after cyclic loading for each group (P<.001). Preload efficiency was 43.8% for DY, 46.8% for DE, 54.2% for ASC, and 48.5% for UB. No significant difference was found in the time-to-failure survival among groups (P>.05).

CONCLUSIONS

The hexalobular system of DY delivered comparable initial torque values to its target value at 25 degrees, similar to how UB (control group) delivered at 0 degrees. ASC and DE scored lower initial torque values than their target value compared with UB. The DY abutment, which had a lower manufacturer recommended torque value, had lower reverse torque values compared with those of other groups. Time-to-failure survival of all groups was similar. Fractures at the zirconia to titanium base connection were seen with ASC crowns.

Torsion Resistance of the Ball Head System Screw and Screwdriver for Angled Screw Channels on Implant Prosthetics

The primary objective of this study was to determine the torsion resistance of the Ball Head System (BHS) screw and screwdriver set at 0°, 20°, and 30° angulations. The secondary objective was to compare the BHS set with the 1.3-mm hexagonal screwdriver system (HexS) at 20° and analyze the condition of the BHS after 10 and 30 iterations with 30 N·cm torque at 30° angulation. A workbench made from type 4 plaster with 6 steel implant replicas (external hexagon, 4.1 mm) inserted at 0°, 20°, and 30° angulation was designed. An analogical torque meter was used. The deformations produced on the whole set were examined by field emission scanning electron microscopy. A descriptive analysis was performed. The maximum torque performance for BHS at 30° angulation was 54 ± 12 N·cm. Most screws could be removed despite the deformations produced. At 20° angulation, the BHS set achieved an average torque resistance of 67 ± 12 N·cm, whereas the HexS failed at 45 ± 2 N·cm. Although the iterations performed at 30 N·cm torque and 20° angulation produced some deformations on BHS sets; these could be tightened and unscrewed. The BHS allows tightening at a torque of up to 54 N·cm. Under the same conditions, BHS showed more torque resistance than HexS. Deformation of BHS sets was directly related to the number of iterations.

Survival and Marginal Bone Loss of Dental Implants Supporting Cad-Cam Angled Channel Restorations: A Split-Mouth Retrospective Study

Objective  The aim of this study was to determine whether the screw emergence angulation correction by computer-aided design (CAD)-computer-aided manufacturing (CAM) can influence implant survival and marginal bone stability.

Materials and Methods  This was a controlled split-mouth retrospective study of angled channel restorations. The dental implants supporting the prosthesis were divided into the following two groups: the first group (Group 1) included the implants that required screw channel angulation, while the second group (Group 2) included the implants that did not require this correction to screw the prosthesis to the implant. The main outcome variables were implant survival and marginal bone loss (MBL).

Results  A total of 68 dental implants placed in 22 patients were included in the final cohort. The mean follow-up time was 39.65 ± 15.20 months. None of the studied implants failed during the follow-up period and the mean MBL was − 0.29 ± 0.51 mm at the end of the follow-up. No statistical differences in the MBL were observed between the two groups of the study (-0.18 ± 0.51 and − 0.23 ± 0.58 mm, respectively).

Conclusion  The angulation of the screw channel with CAD-CAM technology resulted in good clinical outcomes and did not affect MBL. Thus, the angulated screw channel might be considered an alternative to face undesired screw emergencies. Future prospective clinical studies should confirm these results.

Fabricating a screw-retained, complete arch, fixed implant prosthesis using selective metal laser sintering: A clinical report

In contemporary prosthodontic practice, implant-supported therapy has consistently resulted in high success rates, with satisfactory and predictable outcomes for completely edentulous patients. Of the several options, complete-arch, fixed screw-retained solutions are generally considered to be the preferred treatment solution. Screw retention offers advantages such as predictable retrievability and potentially easy prosthodontic maintenance, as well as excess cement not being a concern. However, implant mispositioning and malalignment may often necessitate the use of cement-retained prostheses. This clinical report describes a method of fabricating a complete-arch, implant screw-retained, double framework metal-ceramic prosthesis, despite the unfavorable implant positioning, by using selective direct metal laser sintering technology.