Different outcomes of phonemic verbal fluency in Parkinson's disease patients with subthalamic nucleus deep brain stimulation

Speech, voice, and language outcomes following deep brain stimulation: A systematic review

BACKGROUND

Deep brain stimulation (DBS) reliably ameliorates cardinal motor symptoms in Parkinson's disease (PD) and essential tremor (ET). However, the effects of DBS on speech, voice and language have been inconsistent and have not been examined comprehensively in a single study.

OBJECTIVE

We conducted a systematic analysis of literature by reviewing studies that examined the effects of DBS on speech, voice and language in PD and ET.

METHODS

A total of 675 publications were retrieved from PubMed, Embase, CINHAL, Web of Science, Cochrane Library and Scopus databases. Based on our selection criteria, 90 papers were included in our analysis. The selected publications were categorized into four subcategories: Fluency, Word production, Articulation and phonology and Voice quality.

RESULTS

The results suggested a long-term decline in verbal fluency, with more studies reporting deficits in phonemic fluency than semantic fluency following DBS. Additionally, high frequency stimulation, left-sided and bilateral DBS were associated with worse verbal fluency outcomes. Naming improved in the short-term following DBS-ON compared to DBS-OFF, with no long-term differences between the two conditions. Bilateral and low-frequency DBS demonstrated a relative improvement for phonation and articulation. Nonetheless, long-term DBS exacerbated phonation and articulation deficits. The effect of DBS on voice was highly variable, with both improvements and deterioration in different measures of voice.

CONCLUSION

This was the first study that aimed to combine the outcome of speech, voice, and language following DBS in a single systematic review. The findings revealed a heterogeneous pattern of results for speech, voice, and language across DBS studies, and provided directions for future studies.

Deep Brain Stimulation Impact on Voice and Speech Quality in Parkinson's Disease: A Systematic Review

OBJECTIVE

Deep brain stimulation (DBS) has considerable efficacy for the motor dysfunction of idiopathic Parkinson's disease (PD) on patient quality of life. However, the benefit of DBS on voice and speech quality remains controversial. We carried out a systematic review to understand the influence of DBS on parkinsonian dysphonia and dysarthria.

DATA SOURCES

A PubMed/MEDLINE and Cochrane systematic review was carried out following Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) and Population, Intervention, Comparison, Outcome, Timing, and Setting (PICOTS) statements.

REVIEW METHODS

Three investigators screened studies published in the literature from inception to May 2022. The following data were retrieved: age, demographic, sex, disease duration, DBS duration, DBS location, speech, and voice quality measurements.

RESULTS

From the 180 studies identified, 44 publications met the inclusion criteria, accounting for 866 patients. Twenty-nine studies focused on voice/speech quality in subthalamic DBS patients, and 6 included patients with stimulation of pallidal, thalamic, and zona incerta regions. Most studies (4/6) reported a deterioration of the vocal parameters on subjective voice quality evaluation. For speech, the findings were more contrasted. There was an important heterogeneity between studies regarding the voice and speech quality outcomes used to evaluate the impact of DBS on voice/speech quality.

CONCLUSION

The impact of DBS on voice and speech quality significantly varies between studies. The stimulated anatomical region may have a significant role since the stimulation of the pallidal area was mainly associated with voice quality improvement, in contrast with other regions. Future controlled studies comparing all region stimulation are needed to get reliable findings.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III: evidence from evidence summaries developed from systematic reviews.

Subthalamic oscillatory activity during normal and impaired speech

OBJECTIVE

We studied the relationship between oscillatory activity in the subthalamic nucleus (STN) and speech production in order to better understand the functional role of the STN.

METHODS

We simultaneously recorded subthalamic local field potentials and audio recordings from 5 patients with Parkinson's disease while they performed verbal fluency tasks. We then analyzed the oscillatory signals present in the subthalamic nucleus during these tasks.

RESULTS

We report that normal speech leads to a suppression of subthalamic alpha and beta power. Contrarily, a patient with motor blocks during speech initiation showed a low beta power increase. We also report an increase in error rates in the phonemic non-alternating verbal fluency task during deep brain stimulation (DBS).

CONCLUSIONS

We confirm previous findings that intact speech leads to desynchronization in the beta range in the STN. The speech related narrowband beta power increase in a patient with speech problems suggests that exaggerated synchronization in this frequency band is associated with motor blocks during speech initiation. The increased number of errors in verbal fluency tasks during DBS might be caused by an impairment of the response inhibition network caused by stimulation of the STN.

SIGNIFICANCE

We suggest that the inability to attenuate beta activity during motor processes is associated with motor freezing across motor behaviours such as speech and gait, as previously shown for freezing of gait.

Subthalamic Nucleus Stimulation Does Not Have Any Acute Effects on Verbal Fluency or on Speed of Word Generation in Parkinson's Disease

BACKGROUND

Deep brain stimulation of the subthalamic nucleus (STN-DBS) has been shown to be generally safe from a cognitive perspective, with consistent evidence that the major impact of STN-DBS in Parkinson's disease (PD) is on verbal fluency.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was first to identify the influence of acute manipulation of STN-DBS in PD on the number and time pattern of word generation on different verbal fluency (VF) tasks, phonemic, switching, and cued switching, and second to determine whether cueing improved VF and if cueing effects interacted with STN-DBS effects.

METHODS

Parallel versions of these three verbal fluency tasks were completed by 31 patients with Parkinson's disease who had had bilateral DBS of the STN, twice, with DBS On and Off, with the order counterbalanced across patients.

RESULTS

There was no effect of acute STN-DBS on the total number of words generated during verbal fluency. As expected, the number of words generated significantly declined over the six 10-second intervals of the verbal fluency tasks, but this time pattern of word generation was not altered by STN-DBS. External cueing significantly increased the number of words generated relative to an uncued switching verbal fluency task, but the cueing effect on VF was not altered by STN-DBS.

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, (i) acute STN-DBS manipulation did not alter either verbal fluency performance or the time pattern of word generation and (ii) external cueing significantly improved verbal fluency performance both with STN-DBS On and Off.