The mechanism of glomerular dysmorphic red cell formation in the kidney

How to define and assess the clinically significant causes of hematuria in childhood

Given the wide diversity of causes of hematuria, ranging from simple urinary tract infections with rapid recovery to severe glomerulonephritis with fast decline in kidney function, it is essential to recognize the underlying disease. The first objective of the assessment is to determine whether the cause of the hematuria is medically significant. The combination of hematuria with proteinuria, the presence of hypertension, or worsening kidney function can represent signs of progressive kidney disease. Differentiating the various causes of hematuria is often simple and obvious based on the clinical signs and gross appearance of the urine. However, in some instances, additional non-invasive investigations, such as ultrasound imaging, urinary red cell morphology, measurement of calcium and other solutes in the urine, evaluation of kidney function, and protein excretion, are needed to elucidate the nature of the hematuria. Taking a detailed family history can help in establishing the underlying cause in cases of familial hematuria. On the other hand, the decision to perform a kidney biopsy in children with asymptomatic hematuria remains a challenging issue for clinicians. Ultimately, the frequency of diagnosis of glomerular involvement causing hematuria may depend on the threshold for performing a kidney biopsy. The following review will focus on the diagnostics of hematuria, starting with difficulties regarding its definition, followed by various means to differentiate between urinary, glomerular, and other causes, and finally reviewing the most common diseases that, due to their frequency or their effect on kidney function, present a diagnostic challenge in everyday practice.

Glomerular Hematuria and the Utility of Urine Microscopy: A Review

Evaluation of hematuria and microscopic examination of urine sediment are commonly used tools by nephrologists in their assessment of glomerular diseases. Certain morphological aspects of urine red blood cells (RBCs) seen by microscopy may help in identifying the source of hematuria as glomerular or not. Recognized signs of glomerular injury are RBC casts or dysmorphic RBCs, in particular acanthocytes (ring-shaped RBCs with protruding blebs). Despite being a highly operator-dependent test, urine sediment examination revealing these signs of glomerular hematuria has demonstrated specificities and positive predictive values ranging between 90%-100% for diagnosing glomerular disease, although sensitivity can be quite variable. Hematuria is a commonly used tool for diagnosing patients with proliferative glomerulonephritis such as IgA nephropathy, antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibody (ANCA)-associated vasculitis, and lupus nephritis, sometimes even as a surrogate for kidney involvement. Studies examining the role for hematuria in monitoring and predicting adverse outcomes in these diseases have shown inconsistent results, possibly due to inconsistent definitions that often fail to consider specific markers of glomerular hematuria such as dysmorphic RBCs, acanthocytes, or RBC casts. A consensus definition of what constitutes glomerular hematuria would help standardize use in future studies and likely improve the diagnostic and prognostic value of hematuria as a marker of glomerulonephritis.

Isomorphic red blood cells using automated urine flow cytometry is a reliable method in diagnosis of bladder cancer

BACKGROUND

We aimed to identify patients with a chief complaint of hematuria who could safely avoid unnecessary radiation and instrumentation in the diagnosis of bladder cancer (BC), using automated urine flow cytometry to detect isomorphic red blood cells (RBCs) in urine.

METHODS

We acquired urine samples from 134 patients over the age of 35 years with a chief complaint of hematuria and a positive urine occult blood test or microhematuria. The data were analyzed using the UF-1000i (®) (Sysmex Co., Ltd., Kobe, Japan) automated urine flow cytometer to determine RBC morphology, which was classified as isomorphic or dysmorphic. The patients were divided into two groups (BC versus non-BC) for statistical analysis. Multivariate logistic regression analysis was used to determine the predictive value of flow cytometry versus urine cytology, the bladder tumor antigen test, occult blood in urine test, and microhematuria test.

RESULTS

BC was confirmed in 26 of 134 patients (19.4 %). The area under the curve for RBC count using the automated urine flow cytometer was 0.94, representing the highest reference value obtained in this study. Isomorphic RBCs were detected in all patients in the BC group. On multivariate logistic regression analysis, only isomorphic RBC morphology was significantly predictive for BC (p < 0.001). Analytical parameters such as sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value of isomorphic RBCs in urine were 100.0, 91.7, 74.3, and 100.0 %, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Detection of urinary isomorphic RBCs using automated urine flow cytometry is a reliable method in the diagnosis of BC with hematuria.

A useful new classification of dysmorphic urinary erythrocytes

BACKGROUND

Among dysmorphic urinary erythrocytes (D cells), G1 cells or doughnut-shaped erythrocytes with one or more blebs are considered to be reliable markers for glomerular diseases. However, although there are many D cells with cytoplasmic color loss and without blebs in the urinary sediment, the significance of these cells is not clear. In this study, we devised a classification system for D cells and examined the relation between these cell types and urinalysis data.

METHODS

We classified D cells into three types (D1, D2, and D3 cells): D1 cells showed a ring-like shape and severe loss of cytoplasmic color with protrusions or blebs; D2 cells showed a doughnut-like shape and moderate cytoplasmic color loss with protrusions or blebs; and D3 cells showed a doughnut-like shape and mild cytoplasmic color loss without protrusions or blebs. We calculated the numbers of D cells of each type in 45 patients with glomerular diseases and in 303 general outpatients. This was done by bright-field microscopy modified for the analysis of urinary sediment, and we also examined the significance of these cell types.

RESULTS

In the 45 patients with glomerular diseases, the numbers of D1, D2, and D3 cells correlated with urine levels of proteinuria and hematuria and numbers of cellular and fatty casts. Numbers of D1 and D2 cells correlated with urine concentrations of albumin and N-acetyl-beta-D-glucosaminidase, and the proportions of D1 and D2 cells in D cells increased with the activity of glomerular diseases classified by urinalysis data. Only the number of D1 cells correlated with the urine concentration of potassium, which may increase in hemolysis. In the 303 outpatients, the sensitivity of D3 cells and D1 and/or D2 cells (G1 cells) was 73% and 46%, respectively, for the detection of glomerular diseases and the specificity was 93% and 99%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

These data indicate that the D3 cell is a sensitive marker for glomerular diseases, and that D1 and/or D2 cells are markers for severe glomerular diseases.

Urine cytology in renal glomerular disease and value of G1 cell in the diagnosis of glomerular bleeding

The objectives of the present study were to evaluate the cytology of urine sediments in patients with glomerular diseases, as well as the value of G1 dysmorphic erythrocytes (G1DE) or G1 cells in the detection of renal glomerular hematuria. Freshly voided urine samples from 174 patients with glomerular diseases were processed according to the method used for semiquantitative cytologic urinalysis. G1DEs (distorted erythrocytes with doughnut-like shape, target configuration with or without membranous protrusions or blebs), non-G1DEs (distorted erythrocytes without the above-mentioned morphologic changes), normal erythrocytes (NEs), and renal tubular cells (RTCs) were evaluated. Erythrocytic casts (ECs) were counted and graded as abundant (>1 per high-power field) or rare (1 per 5 high-power fields). G1DE/total erythrocyte ratios were calculated by counting 200 erythrocytes including G1DEs, non-G1DEs, and NEs. Only abundant NEs were found in 13 cases; abundant G1DEs, non-G1DEs, NEs, and no ECs in 95 cases; abundant NEs, non-G1DEs, and ECs and no G1DEs in 31 cases; and abundant NEs, G1DEs and non-G1DEs, and rare ECs in 35 cases. In 130 cases in which G1DEs were present, the G1DE/total erythrocyte ratios varied from 10% to 100%. This parameter was greater or equal to 80%, 50%, 20%, and 10% in 58 (44.6%), 29 (22.3%), 28 (21.5%), and 15 (11.5%) patients, respectively. In all cases, the number of RTCs was within normal limits or slightly increased, and a variable number of non-G1DEs were present in 161 cases. Thus, abundant ECs and/or G1DEs with a G1DE/total erythrocyte ratio of 10-100% proved to be specific urinary markers for renal glomerular diseases.

Diagnosis of glomerular haematuria: role of dysmorphic red cell, G1 cell and bright-field microscopy

Differentiation between glomerular and non-glomerular haematuria by observation of the changes in red cell morphology using phase-contrast microscopy is a well established technique. However, the method is not widely accepted in clinical practice because of controversy regarding the minimum percentage of dysmorphic red cells required to diagnose glomerular aetiology, as well as the need for specialized microscopes. Recently, a glomerular-specific morphological alteration of red cells has been described, which has the form of a doughnut shape with one or more blebs and which is termed the "G1" cell. In the present double-blind prospective study 250 urine samples were examined without any knowledge of diagnosis. Haematuria was detected in 122 cases. The type of haematuria was characterized by counting dysmorphic cells and G1 cells separately, in each case using a phase-contrast microscope as well as an ordinary bright-field microscope with and without staining of urinary sediments. The results were later correlated with the confirmed diagnosis. The study showed that the G1 cell is more specific than the dysmorphic cell for the diagnosis of glomerular haematuria. Evaluation of both dysmorphic red cells and G1 cells can be done using bright-field microscopy with 100% specificity and sensitivities of 82 and 100%, respectively. It has been concluded that the ordinary bright-field microscope can be used for the diagnosis of glomerular haematuria with an efficiency similar to that of a phase-contrast microscope.

Validity of G1-cells in the differentiation between glomerular and non-glomerular haematuria in children

Urine samples from 100 children and adolescents with micro- or macrohaematuria were investigated using phase contrast microscopy to establish the percentage of G1-cells that could differentiate glomerular from non-glomerular haematuria. The G1-cell is a special form of dysmorphic erythrocyte which seems to be specific for glomerular haematuria. Glomerular haematuria, defined by clinical criteria from biopsy, physical examination, standard laboratory evaluation and family history, was observed in 51 patients (group 1). Non-glomerular haematuria was found in 49 patients (group 2). The latter group had urinary tract infections, urolithiasis, hypercalciuria or haematuria caused by urological operation or diagnostic procedure. The percentage of dysmorphic erythrocytes differed significantly between the two groups studied (42 +/- 3% in group 1 vs. 6 +/- 1% in group 2, mean +/- SEM, P < 0.01); there was also a significant difference in G1-cells (19.4 +/- 1.7% in group 1 vs. 0.6 +/- 0.2% in group 2, mean +/- SEM, P < 0.01). When glomerular haematuria was defined on the basis of > or = 30% dysmorphic erythrocytes by phase contrast microscopy, sensitivity, specificity and efficiency were 71%, 100% and 85%, respectively. When glomerular haematuria was defined on the basis of > or = 5% G1-cells, sensitivity, specificity and efficiency were 100%, 100% and 100%, respectively. The differentiation of glomerular and non-glomerular haematuria in children by determination of G1-cells appears to be more sensitive and efficient than the determination of the percentage of dysmorphic erythrocytes by phase contrast microscopy.