Factors associated with occurrence and reversibility of connective tissue attachment loss

Non-human primates used in studies of periodontal disease pathogenesis: a review of the literature

The inability to examine initiation and progression of periodontal disease and to assess certain therapies in humans has led to a great interest in the use of animal models in periodontal research. Some of the most prominent animals used are non-human primates. This article reviews the characteristics of non-human primate models in periodontal health, in the transition from health to gingivitis to periodontitis, and in experimental gingivitis and periodontitis. Where possible, the results of these studies are compared with results from human studies. Only a few studies have compared in detail the anatomy, physiology, immunology, and tissue interactions in monkeys with those of humans. With the exceptions of differences and variations in size of the dentition, the number of each tooth type as well as larger canines, presence of diastemata between anterior teeth, and an edge-to-edge relationship of the incisors, the dental and periodontal anatomy of non-human primates seem quite similar to that of humans. Clinically healthy gingiva can be established and maintained in non-human primates, and gingivitis as well as periodontitis occur in these animals. It is possible to induce experimental periodontitis by placement of peri-dental silk ligatures or orthodontic elastics as well as by surgical removal of alveolar bone. Although the most appropriate model for studies of periodontal disease pathogenesis in non-human primates appears to involve the application of silk ligatures, some difficulties may occur in establishing periodontal break-down by using this model. Many clinical, histological, microbiological, and immunological characteristics of spontaneous and experimental marginal inflammation in most non-human primates are similar to those in humans. The most significant differences between small non-human primates and humans are the very limited number of lymphocytes and plasma cells in the inflammatory infiltrate of squirrel monkeys (Saimiri sciureus) and marmosets. Therefore, the use of squirrel monkeys and marmosets may not be appropriate in many studies of periodontal disease pathogenesis. The most significant microbial differences between macaque species and humans are a lower proportion of Actinomyces species, the presence of a catalase-producing Prevotella melaninogenica strain, and the high carrier rate for Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans in subgingival plaque of macaque species. The significance of these differences is presently unknown. It is concluded that the use of many non-human primate species due to the apparent close anatomic and biologic similarities to humans is appropriate in experimental studies of periodontal disease, provided the use of laboratory animals is requisite and lower species are not applicable.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Disturbances of gingival fibroblast population homeostasis due to experimentally induced inflammation in the cynomolgus monkey (Macaca fascicularis): potential mechanism of disease progression

We have studied the relationship between perturbations of fibroblast turnover in inflamed gingiva of different severities. To perform detailed spatial analyses of gingival fibroblast progenitor cells, inflammatory cell infiltrates and blood vessels, 3 Cynomolgus monkeys with healthy periodontium and 2 with naturally occurring gingivitis and ligature-induced periodontitis were pulse-labeled with 3H-thymidine. Morphometric analyses of radioautographs from mid-sagittal supra-alveolar gingival connective tissues of incisors were performed in sites subjacent to junctional sulcular and oral epithelium, in the body of the lamina propria and just superior to the alveolar crest. The percentage of fibroblasts incorporating 3H-thymidine label, expressed as the labeling index (LI), was higher subjacent to the sulcular epithelium in periodontitis (1.73 +/- 0.37) than in healthy sites (1.06 +/- 0.22). This was not statistically significant (0.05 < p < 0.1) due to the small number of animals used. The sites subjacent to the sulcular epithelium also exhibited the largest increase in lymphocyte density from health to gingivitis (p < 0.01). In contrast, the LI of fibroblasts subjacent to the oral epithelium was 5-fold higher in healthy (0.82 +/- 0.17) compared to periodontitis sites (0.13 +/- 0.09; p < 0.05). Labeled fibroblasts were found close to blood vessels in all compartments and in all disease states; distance to blood vessels was reduced in inflamed sites (p < 0.10). There were increased numbers of blood vessels per unit area in the lamina propria of gingivitis compared to healthy sites. However, there were no regional differences with respect to blood vessel numbers or area in sites subjacent to junctional epithelium with different disease states. The results indicate that: 1) experimentally-induced inflammation in the gingiva of Cynomolgus monkeys is associated with site-specific perturbations of cell turnover; 2) fibroblast progenitors are preferentially situated adjacent to blood vessels as in the periodontal ligament; 3) the vascular response to inflammation is a generalized increase in blood vessel numbers, but not their size; 4) reactive proliferation of fibroblasts may compensate for cell death in the lamina propria but is not detectable at the site of connective tissue attachment loss subjacent to the junctional epithelium. Failure to maintain the fibroblast progenitor population may be an important component of attachment loss in progressive periodontitis lesions.

Cell populations and episodic periodontal attachment loss in humans

The purpose of the present study was to assess possible associations between episodic probing attachment loss and cell populations in the supracrestal connective tissue in humans. 10 systemically healthy adult patients with untreated advanced periodontitis were monitored during a period of 10 months. At baseline and every month thereafter, probing attachment levels were measured at 6 sites of every tooth using an electronic pressure sensitive probe and flexible stents. Corresponding contralateral sites were identified where 1 site had lost 2 mm or more attachment within the previous month (P), and the other site had not (C). Supracrestal soft tissue biopsies were taken from these sites, processed and cut into 1 micron sections. Cell populations were identified in superficial and deep connective tissue areas by counting fibroblasts, macrophages, plasma cells, mast cells, granulocytes, lymphocytes, endothelial cells and the total number of inflammatory cells. Analysis of variance assessed differences in cell populations between P- and C-sites. There were statistically significantly higher numbers of fibroblasts in the standard areas of C-sites (p less than 0.0001). In P-sites, the numbers of macrophages, plasma cells, mast cells, lymphocytes and total inflammatory cells were significantly higher as compared to C-sites (p = 0.05-0.0001). There were no differences in cell populations between superficial and deep connective tissue areas within P- and C-sites (p greater than 0.2). Clinically assessed episodes of periodontal disease progression may be associated with site-specific shifts in inflammatory cell populations.