Shifted focus of bronchoalveolar lavage in patients with suspected thoracic malignancy: an analysis of 224 patients

Diagnostic value of exfoliated tumor cells combined with DNA methylation in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid for lung cancer

BACKGROUND

To evaluate the diagnostic value of exfoliated tumor cells (ETCs) numbers combined with DNA methylation levels in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid (BALF) in lung cancer.

METHODS

BALF samples were collected from 43 patients with lung cancer and 23 with benign lung disease. ETCs were detected by the nano-enrichment method, and the methylation status of the short stature homeobox gene 2 (SHOX2) and the RAS association domain family 1, isoform A (RASSF1A) gene were detected by RT-PCR. The diagnostic value of each metric was evaluated by receiver operating characteristic curve analysis, specificity and sensitivity.

RESULTS

The sensitivity/specificity of RASSF1A and SHOX2 methylation detection were 44.12%/76.47% and 93.75%/87.50%, respectively. When "RASSF1A/SHOX2 methylation" was used as a positive result, the sensitivity increased to 88.24%, and the specificity decreased to 81.25%. When "RASSF1A + SHOX methylation" was used as positive, the sensitivity was reduced to 32.35%, but the specificity was increased to 100.00%. The sensitivity and specificity of ETCs detection in BALF were 89.47% and 16.67%, respectively. When "SHOX2/RASSF1A methylation + ETCs was used as a positive result, the sensitivity and specificity of the detection were 79.31% and 81.82%, respectively. When "SHOX2 + RASSF1A + ETCs" was used as positive, the sensitivity was 34.48% and the specificity was 90.91%. Receiver operating characteristic curve analysis showed that when SHOX2, RASSF1A methylation and ETCs were combined, the diagnostic sensitivity increased to 0.778.

CONCLUSION

ETCs counting in combination with SHOX2 and RASSF1A methylation assays in BALF samples has demonstrated excellent sensitivity for lung cancer diagnosis and is an effective complementary tool for clinical diagnosis of lung cancer.

Diagnosis of pulmonary nodules by DNA methylation analysis in bronchoalveolar lavage fluids

BACKGROUND

Lung cancer is the leading cause of cancer-related mortality. The alteration of DNA methylation plays a major role in the development of lung cancer. Methylation biomarkers become a possible method for lung cancer diagnosis.

RESULTS

We identified eleven lung cancer-specific methylation markers (CDO1, GSHR, HOXA11, HOXB4-1, HOXB4-2, HOXB4-3, HOXB4-4, LHX9, MIR196A1, PTGER4-1, and PTGER4-2), which could differentiate benign and malignant pulmonary nodules. The methylation levels of these markers are significantly higher in malignant tissues. In bronchoalveolar lavage fluid (BALF) samples, the methylation signals maintain the same differential trend as in tissues. An optimal 5-marker model for pulmonary nodule diagnosis (malignant vs. benign) was developed from all possible combinations of the eleven markers. In the test set (57 tissue and 71 BALF samples), the area under curve (AUC) value achieves 0.93, and the overall sensitivity is 82% at the specificity of 91%. In an independent validation set (111 BALF samples), the AUC is 0.82 with a specificity of 82% and a sensitivity of 70%.

CONCLUSIONS

This model can differentiate pulmonary adenocarcinoma and squamous carcinoma from benign diseases, especially for infection, inflammation, and tuberculosis. The model's performance is not affected by gender, age, smoking history, or the solid components of nodules.

Microtechnology-enabled filtration-based liquid biopsy: challenges and practical considerations

Liquid biopsy, an important enabling technology for early diagnosis and dynamic monitoring of cancer, has drawn extensive attention in the past decade. With the rapid developments of microtechnology, it has been possible to manipulate cells at the single-cell level, which dramatically improves the liquid biopsy capability. As the microtechnology-enabled liquid biopsy matures from proof-of-concept demonstrations towards practical applications, a main challenge it is facing now is to process clinical samples which are usually of a large volume while containing very rare targeted cells in complex backgrounds. Therefore, a high-throughput liquid biopsy which is capable of processing liquid samples with a large volume in a reasonable time along with a high recovery rate of rare targeted cells from complex clinical liquids is in high demand. Moreover, the purity, viability and release feasibility of recovered targeted cells are the other three key impact factors requiring careful considerations. To date, among the developed techniques, micropore-type filtration has been acknowledged as the most promising solution to address the aforementioned challenges in practical applications. However, the presently reported studies about micropore-type filtration are mostly based on trial and error for device designs aiming at different cancer types, which requires lots of efforts. Therefore, there is an urgent need to investigate and elaborate the fundamental theories of micropore-type filtration and key features that influence the working performances in the liquid biopsy of real clinical samples to promote the application efficacy in practical applications. In this review, the state of the art of microtechnology-enabled filtration is systematically and comprehensively summarized. Four key features of the filtration, including throughput, purity, viability and release feasibility of the captured targeted cells, are elaborated to provide the guidelines for filter designs. The recent progress in the filtration mode modulation and sample standardization to improve the filtration performance of real clinical samples is also discussed. Finally, this review concludes with prospective views for future developments of filtration-based liquid biopsy to promote its application efficacy in clinical practice.

Bronchoalveolar lavage as a diagnostic procedure: a review of known cellular and molecular findings in various lung diseases

Bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) is a commonly used procedure in the evaluation of lung disease as it allows for sampling of the lower respiratory tract. In many circumstances, BAL differential cell counts have been reported to be typical of specific lung disorders. In addition, more specific diagnostic tests including molecular assays such as polymerase chain reaction (PCR) or enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, special cytopathologic stains, or particular microscopic findings have been described as part of BAL fluid analysis. This review focuses on common cellular and molecular findings of BAL in a wide range of lung diseases. Since the performance of the first lung irrigation in 1927, BAL has become a common and important diagnostic tool. While some pulmonary disorders have a highly characteristic signature of BAL findings, BAL results alone often lack specificity and require interpretation along with other clinical and radiographic details. Development of new diagnostic assays is certain to reinforce the utility of BAL in the future. Our review of the BAL literature is intended to serve as a resource to assist clinicians in the care of patients with lung disorders.

A rapid liquid biopsy of lung cancer by separation and detection of exfoliated tumor cells from bronchoalveolar lavage fluid with a dual-layer "PERFECT" filter system

Separation and detection of exfoliated tumor cells (ETCs) from bronchoalveolar lavage fluid (BALF), namely the liquid biopsy of BALF, has been proved to be a valuable tool for the diagnosis of lung cancer. Herein, we established a rapid liquid biopsy of BALF based on a dual-layer PERFECT (precise, efficient, rapid, flexible, easy-to-operate, controllable and thin) filter system for the first time. Methods: The dual-layer PERFECT filter system consists of an upper-layer filter with large micropores (feature size of 49.4 ± 0.5 μm) and a lower-layer filter with small micropores (9.1 ± 0.1 μm). The upper-layer filter contributes to the isolation of cell clusters and removal of mucus from BALF samples, meanwhile the lower-layer one targets for the separation of single ETCs. First, separation of 10000 spiked A549s (cultured lung cancer cells) from 10 mL clinical BALF samples (n=3) were performed to investigate the performance of the proposed system in rare cell separation. Furthermore, separation and detection of ETCs and ETC clusters from clinical BALF samples were performed with this system to test its efficacy and compared with the routine cytocentrifuge. The clinical BALF samples were collected from 33 lung cancer-suspected patients with visible lesions under bronchoscope. The final histopathological results showed that 20 samples were from lung cancer positive patients while the other 13 cases were from lung cancer negative patients. Results: The recovery rate of spiked A549 cells from clinical BALF samples with the developed system (89.8 ± 5.2%) is significantly higher than that with the cytocentrifuge (13.6 ± 7.8%). In the preliminary clinical trial, although 33 clinical BALF samples with volume ranging from 6 mL to 18 mL showed greatly varied turbidity, filtrations could be finished within 3 min for 54.6% of samples (18/33), and 10 min at most for the rest. The dual-layer PERFECT filter system is proved to have a much higher sensitivity (80.0%, 95% CI: 55.7%-93.4%) than the routine cytocentrifuge (45.0%, 95% CI: 23.8%-68.0%), p=0.016 (McNemar test, two-tail). Moreover, the sensitivity of this platform is neither interfered by the variations of turbidity of the BALF samples, nor associated with the types of lung cancer. Conclusions: The easy and rapid processing of BALF samples with varying volume and turbidity, competitive sensitivity and good versatility for different lung cancer types will make the established dual-layer PERFECT filter system a promising approach for the liquid biopsy of BALF. The high-performance BALF-based liquid biopsy will improve the cytopathological identification and diagnosis of lung cancer.

Rapid liquid biopsy for Mohs surgery: rare target cell separation from surgical margin lavage fluid with a high recovery rate and selectivity

In melanoma surgery, it is difficult to identify residual scattered tumor cells at the surgical margin because of invasive growth. Mohs surgery, widely applied to increase the cure rate and decrease the recurrence rate of melanoma, involves examination of the tissue for tumor cells after tissue removal. Here, we established a liquid biopsy platform for rapid (<5 h), sensitive examination of residual tumor cells at the margin after Mohs surgery using clinical samples from patients with pigment nevus for a demonstration. The design involved highly sensitive, selective rare target cell separation from surgical margin lavage fluid (SMLF) through micropore-arrayed filtration. High recovery rates (86.7% ± 16.3% and 72.7% ± 46.7%, respectively) for separation of spiked 5 A375s (cultured human melanoma cells) and 1 A375 from 1 mL PBS were achieved for this platform. Detection of SMLF samples from patients with pigment nevus was performed, and many (66-7420) Melan-A-positive target cells were successfully recovered and identified, demonstrating the application performance of this rapid liquid biopsy for Mohs surgery in clinical practice. Moreover, a high-selectivity separation of larger target A375 cells from smaller background Jurkat cells was achieved with a high enrichment factor (4.2 ± 1.1). In clinical practice, high selectivity contributes to effective depletion of red blood cells (RBCs), thus ensuring verification of target cells from samples with severe RBC contamination. Furthermore, target cells were obtained with high purity (2.7-35.2%). The capability of this method for rare-cell separation with a high recovery rate and good selectivity may facilitate improvement of performance of Mohs surgery for real clinical practice, including shortening examination time and increasing detection sensitivity.

The utility and safety of flexible bronchoscopy in critically ill acute leukemia patients: a retrospective cohort study

PURPOSE

Flexible bronchoscopy with bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) is commonly performed in immunocompromised patients. Nevertheless, it remains unclear whether bronchoscopy with BAL leads to changes in medical management or is associated with procedural complications among critically ill acute leukemia (AL) patients.

METHODS

We evaluated 71 AL patients who underwent diagnostic bronchoscopy with BAL in the intensive care unit (ICU) between 1 January 2007 and 31 December 2012. We recorded baseline characteristics, vital signs (before, during, and after the procedure), changes in medical management following the procedure, and procedural complications. Using a multivariable logistic regression model, we explored the relationship between patient characteristics and whether bronchoscopy changed management or caused complications. Patient characteristics included as predictors in the regression model were age, sex, immunosuppression status (those undergoing active chemotherapy), and the Acute Physiology And Chronic Health Evaluation II score.

RESULTS

The most common indication for ICU admission was respiratory failure (51 patients, 72%), followed by sepsis (14 patients, 20%). Overall, the results obtained from bronchoscopy with BAL were associated with a change in management in 32 patients (45%), most commonly a change in antimicrobial therapy as a result of an infectious pathogen being identified (17 patients, 24%). Complications were documented in nine patients (13%) and included post-procedural hypoxia (six patients, 8%), the need for intubation (one patient, 9% of non-intubated patients), and tracheal perforation (one patient, 1%). No clinically significant changes in patient vital signs were observed during or immediately following the procedure. Patient characteristics did not predict whether bronchoscopy was associated with changes in medical management or procedural complications in multivariable analyses.

CONCLUSIONS

Flexible bronchoscopy with BAL is relatively safe and helps to guide medical management among patients with AL admitted to the ICU.