Syme amputation for the treatment of fibular deficiency. An evaluation of long-term physical and psychological functional status

Fibular hemimelia: reconstruction of difficult cases with tibial lengthening and ankle arthrodesis

PURPOSE

Management of fibular hemimelia includes either prosthetic care with or without a suitable amputation or tibial lengthening. Many studies have documented the success of both procedures. Most parents of these children refuse an amputation or have no access to good prosthetic care. The author presents a limb-salvage procedure with tibial lengthening and ankle stabilization.

METHODS

Twelve children of fibular hemimelia with 14 extremities had been subjected to limb lengthening after lateral leg release. To correct the valgus procurvatum, double oblique diaphyseal osteotomy (DODO) of the tibia was performed in 11 extremities. The age of the patients ranged from two to 15 years with the median of five years. All were male. The proposed procedure included three stages of loosening, lengthening, and stabilization with ankle arthrodesis at a later stage.

RESULTS

All patients returned for follow-up for the first four years and had been walking on their sensate feet. With DODO followed by fixator/traction could straighten and lengthen the tibia simultaneously and correct the valgus procurvatum. Ankle stabilization provided stability and a plantigrade foot. A follow-up of six to 30 years with a median of ten years has been reported.

CONCLUSION

A new procedure of loosening, lengthening, and stabilization of the leg with ankle arthrodesis has been proposed. A follow-up of 30 years with a median of ten years of the said procedure has been reported. The procedure provides a long-lasting plantigrade and painless foot that has sensation and proprioception. An amputation at any level has not been recommended.

Participation in sports of Dutch children with lower limb deficiencies

PURPOSE

The primary aim was to describe sports participation of Dutch children and adolescents with lower limb deficiencies (LLD). The secondary aim was to explore perceived limitations concerning sports participation.

METHODS

A total of 103 children and adolescents with LLD, aged 8-18 years (mean 11.7 years), were asked about their sports participation using a study-specific self-report questionnaire.

RESULTS

Children and adolescents with LLD frequently (78%) participated in sports activities, and most of them (68%) participated in the sport of their preference. Just over half of all children (52%) perceived an inability to participate in specific sports. Physical performance (running) and endurance were mentioned as the most limiting factors in participating in certain sports.

CONCLUSION

Children and adolescents with LLD in the Netherlands participate in a variety of sports. Despite dependency on lower limb prostheses in most cases, children and adolescents with LLD have a high potentiality of participating in sports.

Principles of Amputation Surgery, Prosthetics, and Rehabilitation in Children

Pediatric patients may benefit from extremity amputations with potential prosthetic fitting when addressing limb deficiencies, trauma, infection, limb ischemia, or other pathologies. The performance of a quality amputation is a fundamental skill to an orthopaedic surgeon, yet avoidance of pitfalls can be elusive in children. The need for surgical precision and sound decision-making is amplified in pediatric amputations, where the skeleton is dynamic and growing, anatomy can be miniscule and (in the case of congenital anomalies) variable. The principles that guide amputation level and technical approach are unique in children. Despite this, descriptions of these procedures as they should be applied to a growing or congenitally deficient skeleton are lacking. Furthermore, surgeons must also understand the unique prosthetic and psychosocial considerations for children. A collaborative approach between the surgeons, rehabilitation physicians, prosthetists, therapists, and families is essential to ensuring optimal results.

Lengthening Reconstruction Surgery for Fibular Hemimelia: A Review

Fibular hemimelia (FH) presents with foot and ankle deformity and leg length discrepancy. Many historic reconstructions have resulted in poor outcomes. This report reviews modern classification and reconstruction methods. The Paley SHORDT procedure (SHortening Osteotomy Realignment Distal Tibia) is designed to correct dynamic valgus deformity. The Paley SUPERankle procedure (Systematic Utilitarian Procedure for Extremity Reconstruction) is designed to correct fixed equino-valgus foot deformity. The leg length discrepancy in FH is successfully treated with serial lengthening and epiphysiodesis. Implantable intramedullary lengthening devices have led to all internal lengthenings. Recent advancements in techniques and implants in extramedullary implantable limb lengthening (EMILL) have allowed internal lengthenings in younger and smaller patients, who would traditionally require external fixation. These new internal techniques with lengthenings of up to 5 cm can be repeated more easily and frequently than external fixation, reducing the need to achieve larger single-stage lengthenings (e.g., 8 cm). Modern reconstruction methods with lengthening are able to achieve limb length equalization with a plantigrade-stable foot, resulting in excellent functional result comparable or better than a Syme’s amputation with prosthetic fitting.

What matters to children with lower limb deformities: an international qualitative study guiding the development of a new patient-reported outcome measure

BACKGROUND

Lower limb deformities include conditions such as leg length discrepancy, lower limb deficiency and associated angular and rotational deformities of the hips, knees, ankles and feet. Children with lower limb deformities often have physical limitations due to gait irregularities and pain. The differences in the appearance and function of their lower limbs can discourage participation in social, recreational and leisure activities, which may result in behavioural, emotional, psychological and social adjustment problems. The health-related quality of life (HRQL) of these children is often impacted due to the factors discussed above, as well as by the complex surgical procedures. Surgical treatment options for limb deformities in children vary from limb lengthening and reconstruction to amputation. The lack of evidence demonstrating superiority of either treatment options and their effect on HRQL limits the ability of healthcare providers to counsel families on the best evidence-based treatment option for them. This manuscript describes the international qualitative study which guided the development of a new patient-reported outcome measure (PROM). Individual semi-structured face-to-face interviews with children with lower limb deformities and their parents were conducted at five sites: Canada (2 sites), Ethiopia, India and the USA.

RESULTS

Seventy-nine interviews were conducted at five international sites. Five main themes emerged from the qualitative interviews and formed the basis of the conceptual framework. These themes were: 1) appearance, 2) physical health, 3) psychological health 4) school and 5) social health.

CONCLUSIONS

Lower limb deformities have a substantial impact on the HRQL of children. The concepts of interest identified in our study were similar across children from all countries. The conceptual framework guided the development of outcome scales specific to these patients. The information about the impact of various treatment options on the HRQL of children with lower limb deformities, collected using this new PROM, could be used to inform parents and children about outcomes (physical, social, psychological) associated with specific treatment options. This information could supplement other objective outcome information (e.g., complication rates, how the leg will look, etc.) to help families to come to a more informed decision on a child's course of treatment.

Physical performance of children with longitudinal fibular deficiency (fibular hemimelia)

PURPOSE

Longitudinal fibular deficiency (LFD) is the most common congenital long bone deficiency. This study aimed to objectively assess the physical performance of children and adolescents with LFD compared with unaffected peers, and to examine trends over age for subgroups of the LFD population.

METHODS

Differences between children with LFD and unaffected peers were examined with hand-held dynamometry for lower-limb muscle strength, Six-Minute Walk Test, Timed up and down stairs test, Star Excursion Balance Test, and Standing long jump.

RESULTS

Thirty-nine children with LFD and 284 unaffected peers participated. Children with LFD performed at a lower level than their unaffected peers, on all measures of physical performance (mean 2.1 z-scores lower, all p < 0.01), except in long jump (p = 0.27). When comparing the performance of children with LFD to their unaffected peers across four age groups, there was a significant between-groups difference on all strength measures, and on the Six-Minute Walk distance, between children with and without LFD. These differences were smallest in young children (3-6 years) and largest in the older children (15-18 years) (all p < 0.01). Children with no lengthening surgery performed better on the Six-Minute Walk Test, covering a greater distance during the test, than those who had surgery (mean difference 83 metres, p < 0.01). There were no significant differences between children who had or had not undergone an amputation.

CONCLUSIONS

Children with LFD performed at a significantly lower level than unaffected peers on all measures of physical performance other than jumping. The largest differences were in older children. This paper provides baseline functional data for future interventions in LFD.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Cross-sectional study.Implications for RehabilitationThis paper provides the first baseline functional data using validated objective measures on a consecutive cohort of children and adolescents with longitudinal fibular deficiency.Children with LFD performed significantly worse than their unaffected peers on all measures of physical performance other than jumping, with children falling further behind their peers as they age.Children who undergo an amputation typically have the most severe anatomical presentation and yet perform at an equivalent functional level.This paper identifies multiple modifiable impairments that represent potential opportunities for rehabilitation professionals to target with conservative treatment options to improve functional performance.

Amputation Versus Limb Reconstruction for Fibula Hemimelia: A Meta-analysis

PURPOSE

Fibula hemimelia is the most common congenital deficiency of long bones. Primary treatment options include amputation with prosthetic fitting or limb reconstruction. The aim of our study was to conduct a systematic review comparing amputation with limb reconstruction for fibula hemimelia.

METHODS

MEDLINE, EMBASE, Web of Science, Elsevier Scopus, and the Cochrane Registry of Clinical Trials were searched from 1951 to 2019 for studies that evaluated amputation versus limb reconstruction for fibula hemimelia. Random effect models were utilized for the meta-analytic comparisons of amputation versus limb reconstruction for patient satisfaction and surgical complications. Descriptive, quantitative, and qualitative data were extracted.

RESULTS

Seven retrospective cohort studies were eligible for the meta-analysis, with a total of 169 fibula hemimelia cases. Amputation resulted in an odds ratio of 6.8 (95% confidence interval: 2.4, 19.2) when compared with limb reconstruction in terms of patient satisfaction. Furthermore, limb reconstruction was found to have an odds ratio of 28 (95% confidence interval: 7.8, 100.3) for complications. The total surgical complication rates in the amputation and limb reconstruction groups were 0.2 and 1.2 complications per limb. The rate of surgical procedures per patient was 1.5 and 4.2 for amputation and limb reconstruction, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

The cumulative evidence at present indicates better patient satisfaction with less surgical complications and less number of procedures with amputation for fibula hemimelia when compared with limb reconstruction. Absence of uniform protocols make it difficult to compare results accurately.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III-therapeutic.

Use of Paley Classification and SUPERankle Procedure in the Management of Fibular Hemimelia

BACKGROUND

Fibular hemimelia is the most common deficiency involving the long bones. Paley classification is based on the ankle joint morphology, identifies the basic pathology, and helps in planning the surgical management. Reconstruction surgery encompasses foot deformity correction and limb length equalization. The SUPERankle procedure is a combination of bone and soft tissue procedures that stabilizes the foot and addresses all deformities.

METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed 29 consecutive patients (29 limb segments), surgically treated between December 2000 and December 2014. Among the 29 patients, 27 were treated with reconstructive procedures. Type 1 (8 patients) cases were treated with only limb lengthening, and correction of tibial deformities. Type 2 (7 patients) cases were treated by distal tibial medial hemiepiphysiodesis or supramalleolar varus osteotomy. In type 3 (10 patients) cases, the foot deformity was corrected using the SUPERankle procedure. Type 4 (2 patients) cases were treated with supramalleolar osteotomy along with posteromedial release and lateral column shortening. In a second stage, limb lengthening was performed, using the Ilizarov technique. In the remaining 2 patients (type 3A and type 3C), amputation was performed using Syme technique as a first choice of treatment.

RESULTS

The results were evaluated using Association for the Study and Application of Methods of Ilizarov scoring. Excellent results were obtained in 15 of 27 (55%) patients. Six (22%) patients had good results, 4 (14.8%) had fair results, and 2 (7%) had poor results. Mean limb length discrepancy at initial presentation was 3.55 cm (range: 2 to 5.5 cm) which significantly improved to 1.01 cm (range: 0 to 3 cm) after treatment (P=0.015).

CONCLUSIONS

Our results and a review of the literature clearly suggest that limb reconstruction according to Paley classification, is an excellent option in the management of fibular hemimelia. Our 2-staged procedure (SUPERankle procedure followed by limb lengthening) helps in reducing the complications of limb lengthening and incidence of ankle stiffness. Performing the first surgery at an earlier age (below 5 y) plays a significant role in preventing recurrent foot deformities.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV.

Amputation Versus Staged Reconstruction for Severe Fibular Hemimelia: Assessment of Psychosocial and Quality-of-Life Status and Physical Functioning in Childhood

Background

Fibular hemimelia, a congenital disorder characterized by the partial or complete absence of the fibula, tibial growth inhibition, and foot and ankle deformity and deficiency, is the most common deficiency of long bones. The purpose of the present study of children with congenital fibular hemimelia was to examine the functional and psychosocial outcomes at a minimum of 2 years after treatment either with amputation and a prosthesis or with reconstruction and lengthening.

Methods

Twenty children who were managed with primary amputation were compared with 22 children who were managed with staged limb reconstruction. The average age of the patients at the time of evaluation was 9 years (range, 5 to 15 years). Patients and parents completed psychosocial, quality-of-life, and satisfaction surveys. Patients underwent instrumented gait analysis and a timed 25 or 50-yard dash. The number and nature of surgical procedures were recorded from a retrospective chart review.

Results

Families of children managed with amputation had lower economic and educational levels and were more ethnically diverse compared with the families of children managed with limb reconstruction. Scores on psychosocial and quality-of-life surveys were comparable with those from healthy patient populations. Parents of males treated with amputation perceived a lower school-related quality of life for their child; socioeconomic and ethnic differences between groups might account for this finding. Statistically but not clinically significant differences were measured during instrumented gait analysis at a self-selected walking speed and during a timed 25 or 50-yard dash. The majority of patients and parents reported satisfaction with the treatment method selected and would select the same treatment method again.

Conclusions

At this interim stage of growth, there were no significant functional or psychological differences between groups. Both groups were satisfied with the outcome in mid-childhood, irrespective of the selection of amputation or limb reconstruction.

Level of Evidence

Therapeutic Level III. See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

Longitudinal Fibular Deficiency: A Cross-Sectional Study Comparing Lower Limb Function of Children and Young People with That of Unaffected Peers

Longitudinal fibular deficiency (LFD), or fibular hemimelia, is congenital partial or complete absence of the fibula. We aimed to compare the lower limb function of children and young people with LFD to that of unaffected peers. A cross-sectional study of Australian children and young people with LFD, and of unaffected peers, was undertaken. Twenty-three (12 males) children and young people with LFD (74% of those eligible) and 213 unaffected peers, all aged 7–21 years were subject to the Knee Osteoarthritis Outcome Score (KOOS/KOOS-Child) and the Cumberland Ankle Instability Tool (CAIT/CAIT-Youth). Linear regression models compared affected children and young people to unaffected peers. Participants with LFD scored lower in both outcomes (adjusted p < 0.05). The difference between participants with LFD and unaffected peers was significantly greater among younger participants than older participants for KOOS activities and sports domain scores (adjusted p ≤ 0.01). Differences in the other KOOS domains (pain/symptoms/quality of life) and ankle function (CAIT scores) were not affected by age (adjusted p ≥ 0.08). Children and young people with LFD on average report reduced lower limb function compared to unaffected peers. Knee-related activities and sports domains appear to be worse in younger children with LFD, and scores in these domains become closer to those of unaffected peers as they become older.

Syme Amputation: A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

In the decision-making process toward an amputation of the lower extremity, knowledge about patient-related outcomes after amputation and rehabilitation is important. We have not found a systematic review that provides this knowledge for Syme amputation. The aim of this study was to present an overview of outcomes after a Syme amputation grouped according to the International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF) model, focusing on body structures and functions, activities, and participation.

METHODS

A systematic literature search was performed. Included studies went through 2 selection procedures by 2 independent assessors. Included were all studies concerning Syme amputation with patient-related outcomes.

RESULTS

Thirty-six studies were included for data extraction, concerning 1056 patients (238 children and 818 adults). Heel pad migration was reported in 49 of 176 (28%), skin problems in 23 of 128 (18%), and bone problems in 42 of 145 (29%) children. No reamputations were reported. All children were fitted with a prosthesis, and 62 of 90 (69%) children participated in sports. Skin problems were reported in 35 of 195 (18%), ulceration or infection in 120 of 512 (23%), residual limb pain in 46 of 181 (25%), and reamputations in 180 of 919 (20%) adults. In total, 247 of 363 (68%) adults were fitted with a prosthesis. Walking aids were used by 45 of 135 (33%) adults. Employment status was unchanged in 147 of 209 (72%) adults.

CONCLUSION

In children, no reamputations were necessary and few complications were reported, with good participation in daily life in the majority of children. In adults, more complications and reamputations were reported; nevertheless, most adult amputees became successful prosthesis users.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic Level III, systematic review containing retrospective cohort studies.

Physical function and health-related quality of life in young adults with unilateral congenital lower-limb deficiencies

PURPOSE

The primary aim was to examine if there were differences in physical function and health-related quality of life (HRQoL) between young adults (18 to 35 years) with unilateral congenital lower-limb deficiency (CLLD) who had been surgically lengthened (Surg) and those using lengthening prostheses (Pros). Second, we wanted to compare their health status with an age- and gender-matched reference group (Ref) without CLLD.

METHODS

Cross-sectional study including a study-specific questionnaire, clinical examination, two field tests evaluating physical function (the six-minute walk test and the Stair test) and HRQoL questionnaires (Short Form (SF)-36 and EuroQol (EQ)-5D-3L).

RESULTS

Physical function and HRQoL did not differ between the two treatment groups. The odds for having painful or disfiguring scars were 18 times higher in the Surg group (n = 16) compared with the Pros group (n = 14). The CLLD group showed significantly reduced physical function compared with the Ref group. HRQoL, measured by the EQ-5D-3L visual rating scale, was significantly reduced in the CLLD group compared with the Ref group, as was the SF-36 physical function domain in both genders. Men with CLLD also showed increased bodily pain and reduced general health (SF-36), while we found a reduction in the emotional role domain in women compared with Ref.

CONCLUSION

There were no significant differences in physical function and quality of life in young adults with CLLD treated with surgical lengthening compared with those using lengthening prostheses. Compared with the general Norwegian population, young adults with CLLD had significantly lower physical function and reduced HRQoL in some domains.

State of the Art: Amputation and Prosthetics

Amputation is not a defeat or failure of treatment, but an effective management strategy for certain conditions in the pediatric population. The principles of management, especially in the pediatric population, have not changed. Current surgical strategies focus on providing an optimal residual limb for prosthetic fitting. New technology provides improvement in the design and fabrication of prosthetic devices.

A comparison of functional outcome between amputation and extension prosthesis in the treatment of congenital absence of the fibula with severe limb deformity

PURPOSE

Complete fibula absence often presents with significant lower-limb deformity. Parental counselling regarding management is paramount in achieving the optimum functional outcome. Amputation offers a single surgical event with minimal complications. This study compares outcomes with an amputation protocol to those using an extension prosthesis.

METHOD

Thirty-two patients were identified. Nine patients (2 males, 7 females; median age at assessment of 23.5 years) used an extension prosthesis. Twenty-three patients (16  males, 7 females; median age at assessment of eight years) underwent 25 amputations during childhood. Mobility was assessed using SIGAM and K scores. Quality of life was assessed using the PedsQL inventory questionnaire; pain by a verbal severity score.

RESULTS

The 19 Syme and one Boyd amputation in 19 patients were performed early (mean age 15 months). Four Syme and one trans-tibial amputation in four patients took place in older children (mean age 6.6 years). Only two underwent tibial kyphus correction to aid prosthetic fitting. K scores were significantly higher (mean 4 vs 2) and pain scores lower in the amputation group allowing high impact activity compared with community ambulation with an extension prosthesis. The SIGAM and PedsQL scores were all better in the amputation group, but not significantly so.

CONCLUSION

Childhood amputation for severe limb length inequality and foot deformity in congenital fibula absence offers excellent short-term functional outcome with prosthetic support. The tibial kyphus does not need routine correction and facilitates prosthetic suspension. Accommodative extension prostheses offer reasonable long-term function but outcome scores are lower.

Amputation and rotationplasty in children with limb deficiencies: current concepts

PURPOSE

Amputations and fitting surgery have a long history in children with limb deficiencies. With the current developments in limb reconstruction and new techniques in prosthetics, the indications for amputation and fitting surgery might have shifted, but still have a very important role in creating high functional performance, optimal participation and quality of life. The purpose of this current concepts article is to give an overview of the indications, dilemmas and technical considerations in the decision-making for amputation and fitting surgery. A special part of this overview is dedicated to the indications, variations and outcomes in rotationplasties.

METHODS

The article is based on the experience of a multidisciplinary reconstruction team for children with complex limb deficiencies, as well as research of the literature on the various aspects that cover this multidisciplinary topic.

RESULTS

For those children with a more severe limb deficiency, reconstruction is not always feasible for every patient. In those cases, amputation with prosthetic fitting can lead to a good result. Outcomes in quality of life and function do not significantly differ from the children that had reconstruction. For children with a postaxial deficiency with a femur that is too short for lengthening, and with a stable ankle and foot with good function, rotationplasty offers the best functional outcome. However, the decision-making between the different options will depend on different individual factors.

CONCLUSIONS

Amputations and rotationplasties combined with optimal prosthesis fitting in children with more severe limb deficiencies may lead to excellent short- and long-term results. An experienced multidisciplinary team for children with complex limb deficiencies should guide the patient and parents in the decision-making between the different options without or with prosthesis.

Surgical reconstruction for fibular hemimelia

Fibular hemimelia presents with foot deformity and leg length discrepancy. Previous classifications have focused on the degree of fibular deficiency rather than the type of foot deformity. Published methods of surgical reconstruction have often failed due to residual or recurrent foot deformity. The purpose of this report is to introduce new classification and reconstruction methods. The Paley SHORDT procedure is used to stabilize the ankle when there is a hypoplastic distal fibula with a dynamic valgus deformity. It involves shortening and realignment of the distal tibia relative to the fibula. In contrast, the Paley SUPERankle procedure is used when there is a fixed equinovalgus foot deformity. The SUPERankle uses a supramalleolar shortening-realignment osteotomy and/or subtalar osteotomies with anlage resection. Due to the bony instead of soft tissue correction of deformity, residual or recurrent deformity is prevented. Weakening of gastro-soleus and peroneal muscles is avoided by shortening of the tibia instead of tendon lengthening. The limitation of ankle motion is related to ankle dysplasia rather than surgery or lengthening. A plantigrade-stable foot and ankle leads to an excellent functional result comparable or better than a Syme's amputation with prosthetic fitting. Serial lengthening procedures combined with the SHORDT or SUPERankle reconstruction lead to limb length equalization with a plantigrade, painless, functional foot.

Internal lengthening device for congenital femoral deficiency and fibular hemimelia

BACKGROUND

Patients with congenital limb shortening can present with joint instability, soft tissue contractures, and significant leg length discrepancy. Classically, lengthening is done with external fixation, which can result in scarring, pin site infection, loss of motion, and pain. We therefore developed an alternative to this approach, a new, controllable, internal lengthening device for patients with congenital limb shortening.

QUESTIONS/PURPOSES

We evaluated this device in terms of (1) healing index, (2) complications, (3) accuracy of the device's external controller, and (4) adjacent-joint ROM.

METHODS

Between January 2012 and May 2013, we treated 66 patients for congenital limb shortening, of whom 21 were treated using this device. During this period, general indications for using the device were patients with leg length discrepancies of 2 cm or more, with intramedullary canals able to withstand rods of at least 12.5-mm diameter and 230-mm length, without active infection in the affected bone, able to comply with the need for frequent lengthening, and without metal allergies or an implanted pacemaker. We included only those patients who had completed their course of treatment and were currently fully weightbearing, leaving 18 patients (21 bone segments) available for followup at a minimum of 6 months after limb lengthening (mean, 14 months; range, 6-22 months). Mean age was 19 years (range, 9-49 years). Sixteen femurs and five tibias were lengthened a mean of 4.4 cm (range, 2.1-6.5 cm). Mean distraction index was 1.0 mm/day (range, 0.5-1.8 mm/day). Healing index, complications, device accuracy, and ROM were recorded. To date, 10 of the 21 devices have been removed. This was typically done 12-24 months after insertion when the bone was solidly healed on all four cortices.

RESULTS

Mean healing index was 0.91 months/cm (range, 0.2-2.0 months/cm). There were seven complications requiring an additional unplanned surgery, including one hip flexion contracture, three femurs with delayed healing, one tibia with delayed healing, one hip subluxation/dislocation, and one knee subluxation. The external controller was accurate as programmed and actual lengthening amounts were consistent. ROMs of the hip, knee, and ankle were essentially maintained.

CONCLUSIONS

This device is completely internal, allowing for satisfactory joint motion during treatment in most patients. Lengthening was achieved in an accurate, controlled manner, and all patients reached their goal length. Complications remain a concern, as is the case with all approaches to this complex patient population. Both future comparative studies and longer-term followup are needed.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV, therapeutic study. See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

Prenatal diagnosis of congenital femoral deficiency and fibular hemimelia

OBJECTIVES

Routine ultrasonography can detect congenital femoral deficiency (CFD) and fibular hemimelia (FH), but prenatal detection rate and its relation to deformity severity have never been reported. Whether mothers prefer prenatal diagnosis is also unknown. We aimed to determine whether mothers prefer prenatal diagnosis, to report detection rates for CFD and/or FH, and to correlate detection rates to severity of limb shortening.

METHODS

Surveys were mailed to 171 mothers who gave birth to children with CFD/FH between 2000 and 2008. Bilateral femoral and tibial lengths were measured on postnatal radiographs. We calculated corresponding femoral/tibial lengths at gestational weeks 20 and 30.

RESULTS

Sixty-five surveys were returned, and 56 radiographs were reviewed. Most mothers (63%) preferred prenatal diagnosis as it enables prenatal counseling. Congenital limb shortening was detected in 24 cases (37%) and was not detected in 41 cases (63%). Detection rate was 52% (12 of 23) in CFD cases, 23% (three of 13) in FH cases, and 30% (six of 20) in combined cases. CFD cases with severe shortening had a higher detection rate.

CONCLUSIONS

Ultrasonographers should measure both femoral and tibial lengths. Unilateral shortening should result in pediatric orthopedic consultation to estimate limb-length discrepancy at maturity and discuss treatment.

Fibular hemimelia - diagnostic management, principles, and results of treatment

The objective of this study is to present treatment of fibular hemimelia along with the complications, results, and an algorithm for treatment indications on the basis of authors' experience. A group of 31 patients was studied. In patients fulfilling the criteria for amputation, Syme's amputation should be performed. Elongation should be performed in case of type IA or IB fibular hemimelia, with a functional foot with more than three rays, leg shortening less than 5 cm at birth, and less than 10 cm at 9 years of life. The combination of epiphysiodesis with elongation produces the best outcome and is best accepted by the patients.

Lower-limb amputations in patients with diabetes mellitus

It is estimated that approximately 23.6 million people in the United States have diabetes mellitus. With adequate control of this disease and appropriate foot care and basic surveillance, many patients can lead active and healthy lifestyles. However, some patients experience complications associated with poorly controlled glucose levels, including lower-extremity ulcerations and infections. When conservative measures have failed in treating these conditions, a lower-extremity amputation is an option for patients seeking to gain maximal functional recovery. A complete preoperative workup includes assessment of healing potential and preoperative ambulatory status, control or optimization of comorbidities when possible, and determination of amputation level using modern diagnostic modalities. Once the decision to proceed with an amputation has been made, it is important to choose an appropriate level of amputation and practice sound surgical technique. This article describes the preoperative evaluation and operative techniques involved in performing amputations on diabetic patients and reviews the current literature on the most common lower-extremity amputations performed in the care of infections in the feet of patients with diabetes mellitus.

Recurrence of axial malalignment after surgical correction in congenital femoral deficiency and fibular hemimelia

PURPOSE

Recurrent genu valgum deformity complicates treatment of congenital femoral deficiencies (CFD) and fibular hemimelia (FH). We analysed factors influencing recurrence.

METHODS

Patients who underwent limb lengthening or deformity correction for CFD and/or FH were reviewed. Radiographs after surgery and after a minimum of a further six months were analysed. Change in parameters of mechanical axis deviation per month (∆ MAD/month) and of angle per month were calculated. These parameters were tested against cofactors patient age, baseline MAD, type of CFD and FH, severity of ball-and-socket joints, ankle-joint stiffness, absence of cruciate ligaments and resection of the fibular anlage.

RESULTS

Recurrent valgus deformity was found in 23 of the 42 limbs included with a mean change of MAD of 23.4 mm (5-60 mm). There was no significant difference between patients with ∆ MAD/month <0.5 mm versus >1 mm regarding MAD in the first radiograph and patient age. CFD cases Pappas types VII and VIII showed a ∆ MAD/month of 1.6 mm, whereas milder cases of Pappas IX showed a ∆ MAD/month of 0.8. Mild FH (type Ia) showed a mean ∆ MAD/month of 0.39 mm, whereas mean ∆ MAD/month for FH type Ib/II was 0.72 mm. In FH type II cases, mean ∆ MAD/month was 0.79 mm after resection of the fibular anlage compared with 1.98 mm in those without resection.

CONCLUSIONS

Recurrence in FH and CFD was not dependent on patient age but partly on FH and CFD type. Limbs with more severe ball-and-socket knee joints showed more recurrence. Overcorrection depending deformity type should be performed.

Limb lengthening and deformity correction by the Ilizarov technique in type III fibular hemimelia: an alternative to amputation

BACKGROUND

Fibular hemimelia is partial or total aplasia of the fibula; it represents the most frequent congenital defect of the long bones. It usually is associated with other anomalies of the tibia, femur, and foot.

QUESTIONS/PURPOSES

We reviewed 32 patients with Type III fibular hemimelia treated by successive lower limb lengthening and deformity correction using the Ilizarov method. We had three aims; first, to analyze complications, including the need for reoperation. The second was to assess knee and ankle function, specifically addressing knee ROM and stability and function of the foot and ankle. The third was assessment of overall patient satisfaction.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Thirty-two patients underwent 56 tibia lengthenings and 14 ipsilateral femoral lengthenings. Their mean age and mean functional leg-length discrepancy at initial treatment were 6.7 years and 6.2 cm, respectively. Activity level, pain, patient satisfaction with function, pain, and cosmesis, complications, and residual length discrepancy were assessed at the end of treatment.

RESULTS

The mean number of surgeries was six per case. The healing index was 44.9 days/cm. Although complications were observed during 60 lengthenings (82%), the highly versatile system overcame most of them. Nearly equal limb length and a plantigrade foot were achieved by 16 patients. For two patients, a Syme's amputation was performed. The outcome was considered satisfactory in 17 patients (53%) and relatively good in eight patients (25%).

CONCLUSIONS

The Ilizarov technique has satisfactory results for treatment of Type III congenital fibular hemimelia and can be considered a good alternative to amputation.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV, therapeutic study. See the Guidelines for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

Participation and quality of life in children and adolescents with congenital limb deficiencies: A narrative review

Children and adolescents with congenital limb deficiencies are visibly and physically different from their peers. They present limitations in activities, depending on the severity of deficiency. Therefore they are at risk for lower participation in social and leisure activities. This might negatively influence the perception on their quality of life. The aim of this narrative review is to describe participation and quality of life in children with congenital limb deficiencies. Participation and quality of life are relatively new concepts. Psychosocial functioning, being closely related to the concept of quality of life, is described as well. A comprehensive review of the literature was conducted on participation, quality of life and psychosocial functioning in children and adolescents with congenital limb deficiencies. The review involved a systematic search using multiple data sources. Fifteen cross-sectional studies were included in this review. The literature to date provides limited knowledge on how children and adolescents with congenital limb deficiencies participate and how they perceive their quality of life. The psychosocial functioning, although described as at risk, appears to be comparable to healthy peers. In conclusion, more research is needed on how children and adolescents with congenital limb deficiencies participate and how they perceive their quality of life. A broader perspective will not only help parents in making the right choices for their children, but can also have implications for health care providers, teachers and agencies funding rehabilitation services.

Limb length discrepancy and congenital limb anomalies in fibular hemimelia

The aim of this study was to determine the prevalence of ipsilateral congenital musculoskeletal anomalies associated with fibular hemimelia. We also attempted to determine the corelation between the eventual limb length discrepancy at maturity and these associated anomalies, as well as the Achterman-Kalamchi class of these patients. The records and roentgenograms of 45 patients with fibular hemimelia were reviewed retrospectively. All patients were classified into three groups (types I-A, I-B, and II) according to the Achterman-Kalamchi system. The prevalence of congenital limb anomalies, lower extremity discrepancy percentage, and ultimate limb length discrepancy at skeletal maturity were evaluated. There was no significant statistical association between the number of congenital limb anomalies and severity of the limb length discrepancy, but patients included in the mildly affected group (type I-A) had a higher average prevalence of congenital limb anomalies than those classified as types I-B and II. There was a substantial correlation between congenital short femur as well as the Achterman-Kalamchi classification system and the predicted limb length discrepancy. A similar percentage of limb length discrepancy in types I-B and II was seen. In conclusion, the numbers of associated congenital limb anomalies are not predictive of the eventual limb length discrepancy. Presence of a congenital short femur and ball and socket ankle are predictive of a higher limb length discrepancy. Achterman-Kalamchi types I-B and II show a similar percentage of limb length discrepancy and this is significantly higher than that seen in type I-A.

Limb sparing reconstructive surgery and Ilizarov lengthening in fibular hemimelia of Achterman-Kalamchi type II patients

The aim of this study is to evaluate the long-term results of management of fibular hemimelia (Achterman-Kalamchi type-II) using the Ilizarov method. We reviewed 157 consecutive patients (180 limb segments) with a mean follow-up period of 10.7 years (1.2-21 years). The results were favorable. Although, this type of management is technically demanding and entails a lengthy procedure with many complications anticipated, the Ilizarov lengthening after limb reconstruction is still an option for management of this type of limb deficiency.

Adult outcomes following amputation or lengthening for fibular deficiency

BACKGROUND

Fibular deficiency results in a small, unstable foot and ankle as well as a limb-length discrepancy. The purpose of this study was to assess outcomes in adults who, as children, had had amputation or limb-lengthening, commonly used treatments for fibular deficiency.

METHODS

Retrospective review of existing data collected since 1950 at six pediatric orthopaedic centers identified 248 patients with fibular deficiency who were twenty-one years of age or older at the time of the review. Excluding patients with other anomalies and other treatments (with the excluded group including six who had had lengthening and then amputation), we identified ninety-eight patients who had had amputation or limb-lengthening for the treatment of isolated unilateral fibular deficiency. Sixty-two patients (with thirty-six amputations and twenty-six lengthening procedures) completed several questionnaires, including one asking general demographic questions, the Beck Depression Inventory-II, the Quality of Life Questionnaire, and the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons Lower Limb Questionnaire including the Short Form-36. A group of twenty-eight control subjects completed the Beck Depression Inventory-II and the Quality of Life Questionnaire.

RESULTS

There were forty men and twenty-two women. The average age at the time of the interview was thirty-three years. There were more amputations in those with fewer rays and less fibular preservation. Lengthening resulted in more surgical procedures (6.3 compared with 2.4 in patients treated with amputation) and more days in the hospital (184 compared with sixty-three) (both p<0.0001). However, when we compared treatment outcomes we did not find differences between groups with regard to education, employment, income, public assistance or disability payments, pain or use of pain medicine, sports participation, activity restriction, comfort wearing shorts, dislike of limb appearance, or satisfaction with treatment. No patient who had been treated for fibular deficiency reported signs of depression. The only significant difference between treatment groups shown by the Quality of Life Questionnaire was in the scores on the Job Satisfiers content scale, with the amputees scoring better than the patients treated with lengthening (p=0.015). The American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons Lower Limb Module did not demonstrate differences in health-related quality of life or physical function.

CONCLUSIONS

The patients who were treated with lengthening had started out with more residual foot rays and more fibular preservation than the amputees. They also required more surgical intervention than did those with an amputation. While patients with an amputation spent less of their childhood undergoing treatment, they were found to have a better outcome in terms of only one of seventeen quality-of-life parameters. Both groups of patients who had had treatment of fibular deficiency were functioning at high levels, with an average to above-average quality of life compared with that of the normal adult population.

Bilateral fibular hemimelia with recto-vestibular fistula associated with amniotic bands

Fibular Hemimelia is a rare congenital disorder of deficiency to complete absence of fibula. It has been associated with post axial skeletal anomalies like shortening of femur, absence of lateral rays of foot and syndactyle, polydactyle etc. We report this case because of associated amniotic constriction bands over both the forearm, suggesting amniotic bands may be one of the causal factors of Fibular Hemimelia due to insult to the growing limb bud.

Limb lengthening in fibular hemimelia type II: can it be an alternative to amputation?

The purpose of our study was to analyze limb lengthening in fibular hemimelia type II. Ten patients underwent 16 tibia lengthenings. The mean tibia shortening was 5.8 cm. We used the Ilizarov technique in all cases. The mean follow-up time was 7.2 years. The mean lengthening was 23% of the former length. The healing index was 50.8 days/cm. In the final examination six patients were skeletally mature, equal limb length and functional foot positioning were achieved in four of them. Complications were observed during 14 lengthenings (87.5%). Although lengthening in fibular hemimelia is difficult, elongation with axis and foot correction may offer an alternative to amputation.

Treatment of tibial hemimelia without amputation: preliminary report

Treatment of tibial hemimelia, traditionally, is by amputation. This is not acceptable in our community. Hence we treated our cases without amputation. We treated two cases of type Ia and four cases of type II tibial hemimelia. The age at operation ranged from 3.5 to 13 years For type Ia cases, we applied the Ilizarov external fixator to the femur, fibula and foot to centralize the fibula between the femoral condyles and talus using gradual distraction. The second step was the Brown procedure. Then the fixator was reapplied to correct the deformities. For type II, synostosis of the tibia and fibula was performed followed by differential lengthening. Then we overlengthened the femur. After follow-up for 2-5.5 years, all patients showed improved function and were satisfied. The tibial lengthening ranged from 6 to 8.5 cm, and femoral lengthening ranged from 5 to 7 cm.

Malleolus externus plasty for joint reconstruction in fibular aplasia: preliminary report of a new technique

The instability of the upper and the lower ankle joint represents a serious problem in patients with fibular aplasia. None of the previous techniques demonstrated at least sufficient results. In this report we present a new technique of malleolus externus plasty applied in a 5 1/2-year-old boy with fibular aplasia (type II according to Coventry and Johnson or type Ib according to Achtermann and Kalamchi) with a 6 cm length deficiency of the lower leg and 1 cm of the upper leg. Furthermore, he showed a tibial antecurvation deformity of 20 degrees, a fourth ray foot with adduction deformity of the hindfoot, cutane syndactyly D 2-4, and a hallux varus. This new technique works on the following principle. A triangular iliac crest transplant is implanted with an apophysis and the annexing fascia glutealis, including the osseous part of the transplant, in the lateral distal tibia in a way that the growing apophyseal part lays distally covering the lateral talus. Gluteal fascia annexed to the apophysis was used for the reconstruction of a lateral tendon. Using a ring fixator the transplant is fixed and coincidentally the lower leg lengthened and the axis corrected. The axis deformity and the leg-length deficiency of 7 cm were equalized. The fixator could be removed after 6 months. Radiologically, an entire integration of the iliac crest transplant was found. Magnetic resonance imaging showed it had sufficient circulation. The reexamination 2.5 years later demonstrated a simultaneous growth of the malleolus externus and the distal tibia and stable ankle joints with sufficient mobility and full weight-bearing capability. For support of the foot the boy uses ready-made shoes with curved arch supports. In conclusion, using this new technique an individually adapted lateral malleolus with growth-potential can be constructed that stabilizes the foot and the ankle joints. Thus, reluxations of the foot specifically in relation to lengthening of lower legs can be avoided with concurrent preservation of the range of movement of the ankle joint.

Fibular hemimelia: comparison of outcome measurments after amputation and lengthening

BACKGROUND

Treatment of fibular hemimelia includes either Syme or Boyd amputation with early prosthetic fitting or tibial lengthening. Numerous studies have documented the success of both procedures. The purpose of our study was to compare the outcome after amputation with that after tibial lengthening, specifically with regard to activity restrictions, pain, satisfaction, complications, number of procedures, and cost, in children with fibular hemimelia.

METHODS

Thirty limbs in twenty-five patients treated with either an amputation or a lengthening procedure and followed for at least two years were studied. Fifteen patients underwent amputation, and ten patients underwent lengthening of the tibia. The mean age was 1.2 years at the time of amputation and 9.7 years at the time of initial lengthening. The mean duration of follow-up was 6.9 years after the amputations and 7.1 years after the lengthening procedures.

RESULTS

The patients who underwent amputation were able to perform more activities than those who had a lengthening (mean activity score, 0 compared with 1.2 points; p<0.05), and they had less pain (mean pain score, 0.2 compared with 1.2 points; p = 0.091), were more satisfied and had a lower complication rate (0.37 compared with 1.91; p<0.05). The patients who underwent amputation also had fewer procedures (1.9 compared with 7.0; p<0.05), at a lower cost ($7016 compared with $26,900; p<0.05), than those who had a lengthening. Lengthening was successful in equalizing limb lengths; the mean limb-length discrepancy, assessed in nine of eleven limbs, was 0.7 centimeter.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrated that children who undergo early amputation are more active, have less pain, are more satisfied, have fewer complications, undergo fewer procedures, and incur less cost than those who undergo lengthening. This was true even though good results were obtained with the lengthening procedures and most patients achieved limb-length equality, were able to walk, had minimal pain, and were quite active.