Three-Dimensional Compared with Two-Dimensional Preoperative Planning of Corrective Osteotomy for Extra-Articular Distal Radial Malunion: A Multicenter Randomized Controlled Trial

Clinical added value of 3D printed patient-specific guides in orthopedic surgery (excluding knee arthroplasty): a systematic review

INTRODUCTION

Patient-specific guides (PSGs) provide customized solutions and enhanced precision. However, the question remains: does clinical evidence support the added value of PSGs? This study critically appraises, summarizes, and compares the literature to assess the clinical value of PSGs in orthopedic surgery.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

PubMed and Embase were used to search for studies reporting on randomized controlled trials (RCTs) that compared the use of PSGs with a control group for an orthopedic intervention, excluding knee arthroplasty. The risk of bias was assessed using the Cochrane risk-of-bias tool (RoB 2). The clinical value was expressed as patient reported outcome measures (PROMs), complications, accuracy, surgery duration, blood loss, and radiation exposure. Relative and absolute differences were determined, and whether these were negative or positive for using PSGs.

RESULTS

From 6310 studies, 27 RCTs were included, covering various interventions. The studies' heterogeneity prevented meta-analysis. Six (22.2%) of the included articles scored low risk of bias. Significant differences in the benefit of PSGs were reported across all included metrics: 32.2% in PROMs, 22.7% in complications, 69.8% in accuracy, 42.1% in surgery duration, 46.7% in blood loss, and 93.3% in radiation exposure. No significant negative differences were found in any of the studies.

CONCLUSION

PSGs generally show superior outcomes for accuracy and radiation exposure across multiple intervention types, while the reduction in complications was primarily significant in spinal fusion surgery. For PROMs, complications in other treatments, surgery duration, and blood loss, there may be clinical added value but future well-designed RCTs are needed to provide stronger evidence.

Comparison of patient-specific implants with standard plates after 3-D-planned corrective osteotomy for distal radial malunions

We compared 3-D-printed patient-specific implants (PSIs) with standard palmar locking plates for radiological accuracy after extra-articular corrective osteotomy for malunited distal radial fractures. Eleven patients were operated on with a PSI. Additionally, a plastic printed model of each patient was operated on with a standard plate in vitro. Three months postoperatively, radial alignment in patients and models was compared with the preoperative ideal planning using CT scans. Patients with PSIs showed smaller rotational deviations (median 7°) compared with standard plate models (9°). Deviations in the direction of translation, radial inclination, palmar tilt, radial height and ulnar variance were also smaller or similar with the PSI compared with the standard plates. The preoperative grip strength with a median of 8 kg and a Patient-Rated Wrist Evaluation score of 44 improved to 23 kg and 3 points, respectively, at a median follow-up of 13.5 months. Our results indicate superior radial alignment after PSI compared with standard plates, but the clinical relevance of these findings needs to be investigated.Level of evidence: IV.

A review of novel methods to assist digital planning and execution of osteotomy for upper limb deformities

Corrective osteotomy for upper limb deformities caused by fractures, trauma, or degeneration necessitates detailed preoperative planning to ensure accurate anatomical alignment, restore limb length, and correct angular deformities. This review evaluates the effectiveness of a three-dimensional (3D) preoperative planning program and an image fusion system designed for intraoperative guidance during corrective osteotomy procedures. The application processes and clinical outcomes observed with these technologies in various surgical scenarios involving the upper extremities were summarized. The systems proved beneficial in allowing surgeons to visualize surgical steps and optimize implant placement. However, despite these technological advancements, we found no significant impact on clinical outcomes compared to conventional methods. This indicates a need for further enhancements in system efficiency and user-friendliness to significantly improve patient results. Future developments should focus on addressing these limitations to enhance the practical utility of such advanced systems.

Validation of the Lift-Off Screw Technique in Patients Undergoing Corrective Osteotomy for Malunited Distal Radius Fractures

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to validate the clinical accuracy of the lift-off screw (LOS) technique for volar tilt correction (VTC) in patients undergoing corrective osteotomy for dorsally angulated distal radius fracture malunions.

METHODS

We conducted a retrospective review of 23 patients with dorsally angulated distal radius fracture malunions treated with corrective osteotomy using the LOS technique. The LOS equation Ls = [tan(Tc) ∗ Lp + C]/[cos(⍬s)] and standardized intraoperative fluoroscopic images were used to determine and compare the calculated and clinical VTC and final volar tilt. Correlations between the LOS length and the clinical VTC were calculated, as well as between the desired VTC and the correction accuracy.

RESULTS

Preoperative volar tilt ranged from -6° to -50° (mean = -22.9° ± 10.6°). The calculated VTC was 32.7° ± 9.4°, and the clinical VTC achieved was 25.8° ± 9.3°. The difference between the clinical and calculated correction was -6.9°, with an average postoperative clinical volar tilt of 2.8° ± 5.7°, compared with a calculated volar tilt of 9.7° ± 4.4°. There was a moderately strong positive correlation between LOS screw length and clinical VTC achieved, and a moderately weak negative correlation between the desired amount of correction and the accuracy of the correction.

CONCLUSIONS

The LOS technique is a reproducible method to plan the amount of sagittal plane correction during corrective osteotomy surgery for dorsally angulated distal radius fracture malunions. We demonstrate that this technique underestimates the clinical correction achieved by an average of 7°, with larger deformities experiencing greater undercorrection. Undercorrection of volar tilt during corrective osteotomy should be anticipated by surgeons and considered in future implant and cutting guide designs.

TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic IV.

Management of Extra-Articular and Intra-Articular Distal Radius Malunion

This article presents a comprehensive overview of managing extra-articular and intra-articular distal radius malunions (DRM), discussing the pathoanatomy, clinical, and radiologic evaluation, conservative treatment, and surgical strategies. Corrective osteotomy remains the primary surgical intervention for symptomatic DRM. Surgical planning should consider factors such as timing, approach, correction technique, implant, graft, and associated injuries. The correction of extra-articular malunion necessitates brachioradialis tenotomy, circumferential periosteum release, and intrafocal elevation with grafting to facilitate distal radius realignment following osteotomy. Computer-assisted planning with 3D-printed patient-specific instrumentation (PSI) could help execute extra-articular osteotomy with high precision. As for the management of intra-articular malunion, it may require wrist arthrotomy, arthroscopy, or PSI assistance for precise articular osteotomy and reduction of the joint surface. This review highlights the importance of early intervention, thorough preoperative planning, and appropriate surgical techniques to optimize outcomes and minimize complications. Future research should focus on large-scale randomized controlled trials to compare different surgical methods, particularly for intra-articular DRM.

Functional outcome of 2-D- and 3-D-guided corrective forearm osteotomies: a systematic review

We performed a systematic review to compare conventional (2-D) versus 3-D-guided corrective osteotomies regarding intraoperative results, patient-reported outcome measures, range of motion, incidence of complications and pain score. PubMed (MEDLINE), Embase and Cochrane CENTRAL were searched, and 53 articles were included, reporting 1257 patients undergoing forearm corrective osteotomies between 2010 and 2022. 3-D-guided surgery resulted in a greater improvement in median Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand (DASH) score (28, SD 7 vs. 35, SD 5) and fewer complications (12% vs. 6%). Pain scores and range of motion were similar between 3-D-guided and conventional surgery. 3-D-guided corrective osteotomy surgery appears to improve patient-reported outcomes and reduce complications compared to conventional methods. However, due to the limited number of comparative studies and the heterogeneity of the studies, a large randomized controlled trial is needed to draw definitive conclusions.Level of evidence: III.

Forearm rotation improves after corrective osteotomy in patients with symptomatic distal radius malunion

Objectives

Distal radius malunion can result in pain and functional complaints. One of the functional problems that can affect daily life is impaired forearm rotation. The primary aim of this study was to investigate the effect of corrective osteotomy for distal radius malunion on forearm rotation at 12 months after surgery. We secondarily studied the effect on grip strength, radiological measurements, and patient-reported outcome measurements (PROMs).

Patients and methods

This cohort study analysed prospectively collected data of adult patients with symptomatic distal radius malunion. All patients underwent corrective osteotomy for malunion and were followed for 1 year. We measured forearm rotation (pronation and supination) and grip strength and analysed radiographs. PROMs consisted of the Patient-Rated Hand/Wrist Evaluation (PRWHE) questionnaire, Visual Analogue Scale for pain, and satisfaction with hand function.

Results

Preoperative total forearm rotation was 112° (SD: 34°), of which supination of 49° (SD: 25°) was more impaired than pronation of 63° (SD: 17°). Twelve months after surgery, an unpaired Student's t-test showed a significant improvement of total forearm rotation to 142° (SD: 17°) (p < 0.05). Pronation improved to 72° (SD: 10°), and supination to 69° (SD: 13°) (p < 0.05). Grip strength, PROMs, as well as inclination and volar tilt on radiographs improved significantly during the first year after surgery (p < 0.05).

Conclusion

In patients with reduced forearm rotation due to distal radius malunion, corrective osteotomy is an effective treatment that significantly improves forearm rotation. In addition, this intervention improves grip strength, the PRWHE-score, pain, and satisfaction with hand function.

Are Orthopaedic Clinical Trials Linguistically and Culturally Diverse? A Systematic Review

Purpose

Underrepresentation and misrepresentation of historically underrepresented populations in randomized controlled trials (RCTs) may have implications for the validity of research results and their application for diverse populations. To evaluate the representation of historically linguistically, racially, and ethnically underrepresented participants in orthopaedic randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and to assess the use of translated and culturally adapted patient reported outcome measures (PROMs).

Methods

Separate and comprehensive literature searches of PubMed, Web of Science, and Embase databases were performed to identify RCTs utilizing PROMs between the years 2012 - 2022 among the top five highest 5-year impact factor orthopaedic journals according to the 2021 Journal Citation Reports database. The primary outcomes of interest included reporting of linguistic, racial and ethnic demographic characteristics of trial participants and the utilization of translated PROMs. The methodological quality of each clinical trial was assessed using the Jadad Criteria.

Results

230 RCTs met inclusion criteria. The language of participants was reported in 14% of trials and in 17% of trials when searching both the published text and clinical trial registration information. In addition, race and/or ethnicity was reported in 11% of trials, and the use of translated PROMs was reported in 7% of trials. Among the six multinational studies, none reported the language of the study population nor the use of translated PROMs. Notably, four studies (2%) reported utilizing culturally adapted PROMs. The average Jadad score was 3.07.

Conclusion

Participant language, race, and ethnicity are infrequently reported in orthopaedic clinical trials, potentially limiting the application and interpretation of study results. Similarly, the linguistic and cultural adaptation of PROMs utilized are often not reported, which also limits interpretations of the validity and generalizability of orthopedic study results. Researchers and journals should promote standard reporting of demographic data and methods of PROM adaptation to ensure results are generalizable to diverse patient populations.

Level of Evidence

III.

A comparison of 3-D CT and 2-D plain radiograph measurements of the wrist in extra-articular malunited fractures of the distal radius

Two-dimensional (2-D) plain radiographs may be insufficient for the evaluation of distal radial malunion, as it is a three-dimensional (3-D) deformity. This study introduced a 3-D measuring method that outputs radial inclination, ulnar variance, palmar tilt and axial rotation. To this end, a standardized and clearly defined coordinate system was constructed that allowed 3-D measurements closely resembling the conventional 2-D method in 35 patients. Mean differences between 3-D and 2-D measurements in affected wrists were 1.8° for radial inclination, 0.8 mm for ulnar variance and 3.7° for palmar tilt. In addition, inter- and intra-observer reproducibility of all 3-D and 2-D measurements were good or excellent (intraclass correlation coefficient >0.75), with 3-D reproducibility always better than 2-D. Axial rotation was present in all patients with a mean of 7.9° (SD 6.9). Although the differences between 2-D and 3-D measurements were small, 3-D evaluation enables the assessment of axial rotation and brings us closer to a routine 3-D evaluation of malunion.Level of evidence: III.

Three-Dimensionally Planned and Printed Patient-Tailored Plates for Corrective Osteotomies of the Distal Radius and Forearm

PURPOSE

We evaluated the 1-year postoperative clinical and patient-reported outcomes in patients who had a 3-dimensional planned corrective osteotomy of their distal radius, radial shaft, or ulnar shaft using a printed, anatomical, patient-tailored plate to determine the feasibility and effectiveness of this methodology.

METHODS

Simulations in computer-assisted preoperative planning of corrective osteotomies resulted in 3-dimensionally printed surgical guides, surgical models, and anatomically customized plates for application at the distal radius and forearm. Patients with malunions of the distal radius or forearm who underwent fixation with the custom-made plates were documented in our registry. Grip strength and range of motion assessments were made before surgery (baseline), as well as at 6 weeks and 3 and 12 months. Additionally, patients rated their wrist-related pain and disability using the Patient-Rated Wrist Evaluation.

RESULTS

Fifteen patients underwent corrective surgery, and the 1-year follow-up data of 14 patients with a median age of 56 years (interquartile range, 24-64 years) were available for analysis. The median baseline Patient-Rated Wrist Evaluation score improved from 47 to 7 after 1 year. The flexion-extension arc of motion of the wrist increased from 90° at baseline to 130° at 1 year and the pronation-supination arc of motion of the wrist increased from 135° to 160° in the same time period. Differences in radiological measurements for palmar and radial inclinations, as well as for ulnar variance between the affected and contralateral wrists, were reduced with the osteotomy. In 1 case, the plate was removed 11 months after the osteotomy. No severe adverse events were reported.

CONCLUSIONS

Three-dimensionally planned and printed patient-tailored plates offer a reliable method for correcting even complex malunions of the distal radius and forearm.

TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic IV.

Three cases of posttraumatic wrist problems solved with 3D-printed patient-specific guides

Symptomatic malunion of the wrist is one of the most common posttraumatic wrist problems. This study demonstrates three patients with complex malunions of the wrist who benefited from a corrective osteotomy using preplanned 3D-printed patient-specific guides, by experiencing improvement in their wrist function, grip strength and a reduction in pain.

Managing the Extra-Articular Distal Radius Malunion

Distal radius fractures are common injuries. Satisfactory outcomes are typically achieved with appropriate nonoperative or operative treatment. A proportion of these injuries develop symptomatic malunions, which may be treated surgically with distal radius corrective osteotomy. A thorough understanding of the anatomy, biomechanics, radiographic parameters, and indications is needed to provide appropriate treatment. Factors, including surgical approach, osteotomy type, use of bone graft, fixation construct, management of associated tendon and/or nerve conditions, soft tissue contracture releases, and need for ulnar-sided procedures, should be considered. A comprehensive evaluation is necessary to guide understanding for when salvage procedures may be preferred.

Role of Three-Dimensional Guides in Management of Forearm and Wrist Malunions

Although its precise added value and cost-effectiveness need to be determined, three-dimensional (3D) planning and intraoperative guidance facilitate restoration of normal anatomy. The use of 3D computer planning and patient-specific intraoperative guides leads to more accurate and reproducible correction of forearm and wrist malunion. Its value augments with increasing complexity of deformities. Combined deformities and complex intra-articular malunions of the forearm and wrist benefit the most from the use of 3D techniques. New technical developments, including lower-dose scanning technology, software improvement, artificial intelligence, and in-hospital printing, may lower the associated costs and make its application more accessible.

Managing the Intra-articular Distal Radius Malunion

Intra-articular malunion of the distal radius represents a difficult clinical problem. While not all patients require treatment, corrective osteotomy may significantly improve motion, grip strength, and patient-reported outcome measures. Meticulous planning and technical precision are required with the possible need for multiple surgical approaches and both volar and dorsal implants. Arthroscopic assistance may be used to visualize the joint and articular reduction. Custom 3-dimensional planning guides are helpful in addressing complex multiplanar deformities. Regardless, intervention may not change the natural history of these injuries and post-traumatic arthritis is to be expected.

3D-assisted corrective osteotomies of the distal radius: a comparison of pre-contoured conventional implants versus patient-specific implants

PURPOSE

There is a debate whether corrective osteotomies of the distal radius should be performed using a 3D work-up with pre-contoured conventional implants (i.e., of-the-shelf) or patient-specific implants (i.e., custom-made). This study aims to assess the postoperative accuracy of 3D-assisted correction osteotomy of the distal radius using either implant.

METHODS

Twenty corrective osteotomies of the distal radius were planned using 3D technologies and performed on Thiel embalmed human cadavers. Our workflow consisted of virtual surgical planning and 3D printed guides for osteotomy and repositioning. Subsequently, left radii were fixated with patient-specific implants, and right radii were fixated with pre-contoured conventional implants. The accuracy of the corrections was assessed through measurement of rotation, dorsal and radial angulation and translations with postoperative CT scans in comparison to their preoperative virtual plan.

RESULTS

Twenty corrective osteotomies were executed according to their plan. The median differences between the preoperative plan and postoperative results were 2.6° (IQR: 1.6-3.9°) for rotation, 1.4° (IQR: 0.6-2.9°) for dorsal angulation, 4.7° (IQR: 2.9-5.7°) for radial angulation, and 2.4 mm (IQR: 1.3-2.9 mm) for translation of the distal radius, thus sufficient for application in clinical practice. There was no significant difference in accuracy of correction when comparing pre-contoured conventional implants with patient-specific implants.

CONCLUSION

3D-assisted corrective osteotomy of the distal radius with either pre-contoured conventional implants or patient-specific implants results in accurate corrections. The choice of implant type should not solely depend on accuracy of the correction, but also be based on other considerations like the availability of resources and the preoperative assessment of implant fitting.

Preoperative simulated surgery on 3D model assists osteotomy feasibility verification and surgical guidance for patients with cubitus valgus/varus deformity: a retrospective observational study

BACKGROUND

As the common delayed complication of supracondylar fractures in children, cubitus valgus/varus deformity might lead to pain and loss of motion of the elbow. The current corrective treatment might not be accurate enough and even contribute to postoperative deformity. This study retrospectively analyzed the clinical value of preoperative simulated surgery on 3D model-assisted osteotomy feasibility verification and surgical guidance for cubitus valgus/varus deformity.

METHODS

Seventeen patients were selected from October 2016 to November 2019. Deformities were analyzed from imaging data and 3D models and corrected after the simulated operations. The radiographic evaluation comprised osseous union, carrying angle, and anteversion angle of the distal humerus. The clinical evaluation was performed according to the Hospital for Special Surgery (HSS) scoring system.

RESULTS

All patients underwent the operation successfully and had no postoperative deformity. The carrying angle was significantly improved postoperatively (P < 0.001). The anteversion angle of the distal humerus did not change significantly (P > 0.05). The HSS score rose after surgery (P < 0.001). The function of the elbow joint was excellent in seven cases and good in ten cases.

CONCLUSION

Simulated surgery on 3D model plays an important role in osteotomy plan and surgical guidance, contributing to good surgical efficacy.

Insights and trends review: the role of three-dimensional technology in upper extremity surgery

The use of three-dimensional (3-D) technology in upper extremity surgery has the potential to revolutionize the way that hand and upper limb procedures are planned and performed. 3-D technology can assist in the diagnosis and treatment of conditions, allowing virtual preoperative planning and surgical templating. 3-D printing can allow the production of patient-specific jigs, instruments and implants, allowing surgeons to plan and perform complex procedures with greater precision and accuracy. Previously, cost has been a barrier to the use of 3-D technology, which is now falling rapidly. This review article will discuss the current status of 3-D technology and printing, including its applications, ethics and challenges in hand and upper limb surgery. We have provided case examples to outline how clinicians can incorporate 3-D technology in their clinical practice for congenital deformities, management of acute fracture and malunion and arthroplasty.

Virtual surgical planning and mirrored, 3-dimensionally printed guides for corrective clavicle osteotomies in clavicle malunions and nonunions

BACKGROUND

The objective of this study was to retrospectively review clinical and radiographic outcomes of patients who underwent corrective osteotomies for clavicle malunion and internal fixation for nonunion using a combination of virtual surgical planning, patient-specific 3-dimensional (3D)-printed clavicles, and 3D-printed cutting guides manufactured at the point of care.

METHODS

Between 2015 and 2021, 18 patients underwent corrective osteotomy for a clavicle malunion (7 shoulders) or internal fixation for a clavicle nonunion (11 shoulders). There were 11 male and 7 female individuals with an average patient age of 43.9 (range 19-76) years. All patients underwent computed tomography evaluation of both clavicles. The DICOM files were manually segmented, virtual surgical planning was performed selectively using commercially available software, and a mirrored version of the normal clavicle was 3D printed along with a 3D-printed replica of the affected clavicle. Three-dimensionally printed mirrored clavicles were used in all cases to ensure adequate restoration of the shape and length of the clavicle and to precontour fixation plates. Virtual surgical planning and 3D-printed cutting guides for osteotomy were used in 4 of 18 (22%) patients. Either cancellous or structural intercalary bone grafting was used in 15 of 18 (83%) cases. Patients were contacted postoperatively to determine clinical outcome scores. Preoperative, early postoperative, and late postoperative radiographs were reviewed to assess for union and complications. The average follow-up time was 24.9 months.

RESULTS

Radiographic evaluation at the most recent follow-up demonstrated adequate restoration of length and successful union for all shoulders. There were no complications or reoperations. Postoperative patient-reported outcomes could be obtained in 16 of 18 (88.9%) patients. At the most recent follow-up, the mean visual analog scale for pain was 2.38 points (range, 1-7), the mean shoulder American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons score was 73.2 points (range, 25-100), and the mean Patient-Reported Outcome Measurement Information System Upper Extremity score was 26 points (range, 7-35). All (100%) the patients were satisfied with their outcome (9 very satisfied, 7 satisfied), and their mean subjective shoulder value was 73% (range, 10%-100%). However, 2 patients complained of hardware-related symptoms, and 1 patient had return of preoperative symptoms after an interim 2 years of pain relief.

CONCLUSION

The use of mirrored 3D-printed clavicles combined with virtual surgical planning and patient-specific 3D guides provides a reliable technique for restoring native anatomy when performing corrective osteotomies for clavicle malunion or internal fixation for clavicle nonunion, with a high rate of satisfactory clinical and radiographic outcomes.

3D-printed patient specific instruments for corrective osteotomies of the lower extremity

3D-printing has become a promising adjunct in orthopedic surgery over the past years. A significant drop in costs and increased availability of the required hardware and software needed for using the technique, have resulted in a relatively fast adaptation of 3D-printing techniques for various indications. In this review, the role of 3D-printing for deformity corrections of the lower extremity is described.

Preoperative templating in orthopaedic fracture surgery: The past, present and future

Preoperative planning in orthopaedic fracture surgery corroborates with the goal of establishing the best possible surgical result and ensuring a functioning limb for the patient. From placing sketches on overhead projector paper and measuring lengths from anatomical landmarks, ways of preoperative planning have evolved rapidly over the last 100 years. Today, preoperative planning includes methods such as advanced 3-Dimensional (3D) printed models and software programs incorporating entire libraries of osteosynthesis materials that can be shaped and rotated to fit a patient's specific anatomy. Relevant literature was evaluated to review the development of preoperative templating from the past and present, in order to assess its impact on the future of osteosynthesis.We identified studies on 3D-imaging, computer-assisted systems, and 3D-printed fractured bones and drill guides. The use of some of these systems resulted in a reduction in operation time, blood loss, perioperative fluoroscopy and hospital stay, as well as better placement of osteosynthesis material. Only few studies have identified differences in patient morbidity and mortality. Future techniques of preoperative templating are on the rise and the potential is vast. The cost-effectiveness and usefulness of certain methods need to be evaluated further, but the benefit of preoperative templating has the potential of being revolutionary, with the possibility of radical advances within orthopaedic surgery.

A Two-Step Approach for 3D-Guided Patient-Specific Corrective Limb Osteotomies

Background: Corrective osteotomy surgery for long bone anomalies can be very challenging since deformation of the bone is often present in three dimensions. We developed a two-step approach for 3D-planned corrective osteotomies which consists of a cutting and reposition guide in combination with a conventional osteosynthesis plate. This study aimed to assess accuracy of the achieved corrections using this two-step technique. Methods: All patients (≥12 years) treated for post-traumatic malunion with a two-step 3D-planned corrective osteotomy within our center in 2021 were prospectively included. Three-dimensional virtual models of the planned outcome and the clinically achieved outcome were obtained and aligned. Postoperative evaluation of the accuracy of performed corrections was assessed by measuring the preoperative and postoperative alignment error in terms of angulation, rotation and translation. Results: A total of 10 patients were included. All corrective osteotomies were performed according to the predetermined surgical plan without any complications. The preoperative deformities ranged from 7.1 to 27.5° in terms of angulation and 5.3 to 26.1° in terms of rotation. The achieved alignment deviated on average 2.1 ± 1.0 and 3.4 ± 1.6 degrees from the planning for the angulation and rotation, respectively. Conclusions: A two-step approach for 3D-guided patient-specific corrective limb osteotomies is reliable, feasible and accurate.

Arthroscopic Foveal Repair of the Triangular Fibrocartilage Complex Improved the Clinical Outcomes in Patients With Persistent Symptomatic Distal Radio-Ulnar Joint Instability After Plate Fixation of Distal Radius Fractures: Minimum 2-Year Follow-Up

PURPOSE

To investigate the longitudinal trend of symptomatic distal radioulnar joint (DRUJ) instability after plate fixation for distal radius fractures (DRFs), determine which factors are associated with persistent symptomatic DRUJ instability, and evaluate the postoperative outcomes of arthroscopic foveal repair of the triangular fibrocartilage complex (TFCC) in patients with persistent symptomatic DRUJ instability after plate fixation for DRF.

METHODS

All consecutive patients who underwent plate fixation for DRF between January 2014 and December 2017 and were followed up for a minimum of 1 year were included in this retrospective study. DRUJ instability was evaluated by subjective ulnar wrist pain and physical examination that included foveal sign and ballottement testing every 2 months after surgery. In patients with persistent symptomatic DRUJ instability lasting >6 months, arthroscopic transosseous foveal repair was performed with consent. Clinical outcomes were evaluated at a minimum of 2 years after surgery. The Generalized Estimating Equation model was used to analyze the incidence rate trend of symptomatic DRUJ instability.

RESULTS

Overall, 204 patients were included. The incidence of symptomatic DRUJ instability decreased gradually with time after fixation for DRF until 6 months and was maintained thereafter. Thirty-four of 204 patients (16.6%) had persistent symptomatic DRUJ instability. In multivariable analysis, only high-energy injury was an independent risk factor for persistent symptomatic DRUJ instability (P = .003; odds ratio = 3.599). Seventeen patients underwent arthroscopic foveal repair. The mean follow-up period thereafter was 28.6 months. All clinical outcomes improved significantly compared with preoperative values, and no patient had residual DRUJ instability.

CONCLUSION

In patients who had persistent symptomatic DRUJ instability for >6 months after plate fixation for DRFs, arthroscopic foveal repair of the TFCC is considered as a treatment option. Arthroscopic foveal repair of the TFCC to stabilize the DRUJ provided satisfactory clinical and functional outcomes and decreased ulnar-side pain.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV, retrospective case series.

Distal radius fractures

The management of distal radius fractures has evolved considerably in the last two decades. Techniques and hardware have improved so much that the surgeon can usually assure good results in these debilitating fractures. Yet no one method can be used for all injuries, as the personality of each fracture demands a customized approach. Furthermore, what works in one age group may not work in another. For this reason, every available treatment has its own space in our options. The need for surgeons to be well versed in all techniques is critical. We offer a concise update of important evolutionary and current treatment guidelines for this common fracture.

Fracture planning is easy: Development of a basic method of digital planning based on the traditional pencil and paper technique

INTRODUCTION

Preoperative planning constitutes a fundamental tool in the management of fractures; however, its practical application is far from the desired, perhaps due to the absence of a basic and simple method, adapted to the current times. We describe a digital planning method, halfway between the traditional and the technological, which preserves its educational essence, allows the understanding of the fracture and the individualization of the osteosynthesis.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

After the initial analysis of the fracture and the patient's characteristics, different measurements are made on X-ray and CT images with a digital medical imaging software. These images are then copied into a presentation program (Microsoft® PowerPoint or Keynote ©Apple Inc.), in which the main fragments and fracture lines are traced with the computer pointer. These are subsequently moved into a reduced position and the implants for internal fixation are graphically represented together with a guide of the surgical strategy.

RESULTS

We show 4 cases of different types of fractures operated through reduction and osteosynthesis after preoperative planning according to the described method. The basic points for the surgical planning, logistics, tactics and postoperative radiological results of each case are detailed.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite rise of advanced planning software, traditional paper and pencil methods are still fundamental, even more so for the trauma surgeon in training. The digital planning method described is very appropriate for this purpose, as it combines the advantages of both methods: simplicity, accessibility, quickness, low-cost, reproducibility, educational character, efficiency and possibility of simulation, corrections and reuse of cases.

The malunion of distal radius fracture: Corrective osteotomy through planning with prototyping in 3D printing

INTRODUCTION

Distal radius fractures (DRF) are among the most frequent in the body. About one third of these fractures can result in malunion with restriction of movement and pain in the wrist, the treatment in these cases consists of corrective osteotomy of the deformity. Due to its three-dimensional (3D) complexity, careful preoperative planning is a fundamental step in correction. The prototyping from the 3D reconstruction of the computed tomography of the affected wrist, allows the real understanding of the deformity.

METHODS

Patients with malunion of the distal radius with indication for surgical treatment, from December 2019, were included in the group of corrective osteotomies through planning with prototyping in 3D printing. The postoperative functional outcome was assessed by the Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand Score (DASH) and visual analogue scale (VAS). Radiographic data including radial inclination, volar tilt and joint step were recorded from standard posteroanterior and lateral radiographic views.

RESULTS

A total of 9 patients were included. The mean age was 47 years. The average postoperative DASH value of the patients was 24.9 and VAS was 3.6. Radiographically, the palmar tilt had an average improvement of 25.22°, and the radial inclination had an average improvement of 2°.

CONCLUSION

Corrective osteotomy through planning with prototyping in 3D printing is an effective method of treating symptomatic distal radius malunions. The possibility of performing the osteotomy in a 3D model, simulating the surgery, making the procedure more predictable.

The Application of Three-Dimensional Technology Combined With Image Navigation in Nasal Skull Base Surgery

Three-dimensional (3D) technology including 3D reconstruction and 3D printing technology, has been widely used in clinical treatment, especially in surgical planning, and image navigation technology, which can make surgical procedures more accurate, now is also increasingly favored by surgeons. But the combination of those 2 technologies was rarely reported. Thus, this study will preliminarily investigate the feasibility and the effect of the combination of 2 technologies in endonasal skull base surgery. Eight patients were involved in this study (from October 2016 to July 2017 at The Affiliated Hospital of Qingdao University), 5 cases of nasal skull base tumors and 3 cases of foreign body perforation. All operations were done under the assistance of 3D technology and image guidance system. Surgical discussion with patient, preoperative planning and clinical teaching were investigated between 2D images and 3D models by voting. For all cases, 3D reconstruction model and 3D printed model were deemed to be more helpful than CT/MRI images in surgical discussion with the patient; surgical simulation on 3D model in preoperative planning was largely deemed to be helpful and very helpful; and in clinical teaching, 3D models combined with image guidance system were deemed to be more helpful in understanding the disease than using 2D images. Besides, all patients recovered well after surgery, no recurrence and complications were found in the follow-up. The combination of 3D technology and electromagnetic image guidance system could improve surgical efficiency and the quality of clinical teaching.

Corrective Osteotomy of Upper Extremity Malunions Using Three-Dimensional Planning and Patient-Specific Surgical Guides: Recent Advances and Perspectives

Malunions of the upper extremity can result in severe functional problems and increase the risk of osteoarthritis. The surgical reconstruction of complex malunions can be technically challenging. Recent advances in computer-assisted orthopedic surgery provide an innovative solution for complex three-dimensional (3-D) reconstructions. This study aims to evaluate the clinical applicability of 3-D computer-assisted planning and surgery for upper extremity malunions. Hence, we provide a summary of evidence on this topic and highlight recent advances in this field. Further, we provide a practical implementation of this therapeutic approach based on three cases of malunited forearm fractures treated with corrective osteotomy using preoperative three-dimensional simulation and patient-specific surgical guides. All three cases, one female (56 years old) and two males (18 and 26 years old), had painful restrictions in range of motion (ROM) due to forearm malunions and took part in clinical and radiologic assessments. Postoperative evaluation of patient outcomes showed a substantial increase in range of motion, reduction of preoperatively reported pain, and an overall improvement of patients' satisfaction. The therapeutic approach used in these cases resulted in an excellent anatomical and functional reconstruction and was assessed as precise, safe, and reliable. Based on current evidence and our results, the 3-D preoperative planning technique could be the new gold standard in the treatment of complex upper extremity malunions in the future.

Distal radius malunion in adults

Distal radius malunion (DRMU) consists in a non-anatomical consolidation of a distal radius fracture. The resulting alteration of the articular or extra-articular radial anatomy impairs wrist function to a greater or lesser degree: Restricted ranges of motion, loss of strength, pain. There may also be nerve or tendon involvement. Adaptive carpal malalignment and ulnar-carpal impingement are also possible. Imaging assessment should at least include X-ray and CT; CT-arthrography is essential in intra-articular DRMU, which regularly progresses toward radiocarpal osteoarthritis. Surgical indications are guided by clinical assessment. Restoring distal radial anatomy requires osteotomy, according to type of DRMU: anterior or posterior opening or closing wedge. Bone or bone-substitute graft may need to be associated. Computerisation has improved planning and should be implemented, whenever possible. Ulnar osteotomy may be performed, isolated or associated to distal radial osteotomy. Palliative partial fusion or bone resection is possible in case of joint involvement or in patients with low functional demand.

Computer-assisted open reduction internal fixation of intraarticular radius fractures navigated with patient-specific instrumentation, a prospective case series

BACKGROUND

Intra-articular fractures are associated with posttraumatic arthritis if inappropriately treated. Exact reduction of the joint congruency is the main factor to avoid the development of arthrosis. Aim of this study was to evaluate feasibility of computer-assisted surgical planning and 3D-printed patient-specific instrumentation (PSI) for treatment of distal intraarticular radius fractures.

METHOD

7 Patients who suffered a distal intraarticular radius fracture were enrolled in this prospective case series. Preoperative CT-scan was recorded, whereupon a 3D model was computed for surgical planning and design of PSI for surgical navigation. Postoperative accuracy and joint congruency were assessed. Patients were followed-up 3, 6 and 12 months postoperatively.

RESULTS

Mean follow-up was 16 months. Over all range of motion was restored and flexion, extension and pronation showed significant recovery, p < 0.05. Biggest intraarticular joint step-off and gap reduced from average 2.49 (± 1.04) to 0.8 mm (± 0.44), p < 0.05 and 6.12 mm (± 1.04) to 2.21 mm (± 1.16), p < 0.05. Average grip strength restored (3-16 months) from 20.33 kg (± 7.12) to 39.3 kg (± 19.55) p < 0.05, 100% of the healthy contralateral side. 3D-accuracy for guided fragments was 2.07 mm (± 0.64) and 8.59° (± 2.9) and 2.33 mm (± 0.69) and 12.86° (± 7.13), p > 0.05 for fragments reduced with ligamentotaxis.

CONCLUSION

Computer-assisted and PSI navigated intraarticular radius fracture treatment is feasible, safe and accurate. The benefits of this method, however, do not outstand the additional effort.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV.

Instability in the Setting of Distal Radius Fractures: Diagnosis, Evaluation, and Treatment

Distal radius fractures with severe displacement or concomitant triangular fibrocartilage complex tears may be accompanied by distal radioulnar joint instability. Clinicians should examine the distal radioulnar joint closely when managing wrist fractures and treat coexisting instability appropriately. Chronic instability from distal radius malunion may require osteotomy or radioulnar ligament reconstruction. With proper management, most patients recover forearm stability and rotational motion after distal radius fracture.

Three-Dimensional Versus Radiographic Measurements for Analyzing Extra-Articular Distal Radius Malunion

PURPOSE

To compare the accuracy of evaluating deformity in distal radius malunions using plain radiographic measurements compared with a 3-dimensional method involving 3-dimensional computer bone models.

METHODS

Consecutive patients who had an extra-articular distal radius malunion were included. Standard radiographs and computed tomography scans of both wrists were performed. Palmar tilt, radial tilt, and ulnar variance were measured on radiographs. The computed tomography scan data were sent to a workstation and 3-dimensional bone surface models of the radius were created. The 3-dimensional palmar tilt, 3-dimensional radial tilt, 3-dimensional ulnar variance, and axial rotational deformity were calculated.

RESULTS

Thirteen patients, mean age 40 years (range, 22-57 years) were included. The 3 3-dimensional values were positively correlated with their corresponding radiographic values. Nevertheless, the 3-dimesional palmar tilt and 3-dimensional radial tilt values were slightly smaller than the radiographic palmar tilt and radial tilt. The quantitative difference between the 3-dimensional method and plain radiographs was on average 2° for the dorsal deformity group and 3° for the palmar deformity group. The 3-dimensional ulnar variance was significantly higher than the radiographic ulnar variance by an average of +1.3 mm for malunions with dorsal tilt and +0.6 mm for malunions with palmar tilt. The 3-dimensional method allowed us to measure the extent of the axial rotational deformity, which was 9° on average (range, 2° to 21°).

CONCLUSIONS

Despite small differences, measurements made on both plain radiographs and 3-dimensional computer bone models are accurate for evaluating the deformity in extra-articular distal radius malunions. Our 3-dimensional method seems to provide a more accurate measurement of ulnar variance, particularly for dorsally angulated cases, and is helpful for measuring rotational malalignment.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

In this study, we found that either a 3-dimensional computer bone model or plain radiographs can be used as a benchmark to evaluate the deformity of extra-articular distal radius malunion. The 3-dimensional method can also be used to define axial rotational deformity.

Evaluation of CT-MR image registration methodologies for 3D preoperative planning of forearm surgeries

Computerized surgical planning for forearm procedures that considers both soft and bony tissue, requires alignment of preoperatively acquired computed tomography (CT) and magnetic resonance (MR) images by image registration. Normalized mutual information (NMI) registration techniques have been researched to improve efficiency and to eliminate the user dependency associated with manual alignment. While successfully applied in various medical fields, the application of NMI registration to images of the forearm, for which the relative pose of the radius and ulna likely differs between CT and MR acquisitions, is yet to be described. To enable the alignment of CT and MR forearm data, we propose an NMI-based registration pipeline, which allows manual steering of the registration algorithm to the desired image subregion and is, thus, applicable to the forearm. Successive automated registration is proposed to enable planning incorporating multiple target anatomical structures such as the radius and ulna. With respect to gold-standard manual registration, the proposed registration methodology achieved mean accuracies of 0.08 ± 0.09 mm (0.01-0.41 mm range) in comparison with 0.28 ± 0.23 mm (0.03-0.99 mm range) associated with a landmark-based registration when tested on 40 patient data sets. Application of the proposed registration pipeline required less than 10 minutes on average compared with 20 minutes required by the landmark-based registration. The clinical feasibility and relevance of the method were tested on two different clinical applications, a forearm tumor resection and radioulnar joint instability analysis, obtaining accurate and robust CT-MR image alignment for both cases.

Intra-articular corrective osteotomy for intra-articular malunion of distal radius fracture using three-dimensional surgical computer simulation and patient-matched instrument

BACKGROUND

Corrective osteotomy of malunited intra-articular distal radius fracture is challenging. In this study, we investigated the results in patients with malunited intra-articular distal radius fracture who underwent intra-articular corrective osteotomy through an extra-articular approach using three-dimensional (3-D) computer simulation and a patient-matched instrument (PMI).

METHODS

We retrospectively studied five consecutive patients with symptomatic malunited intra-articular distal radius fracture who underwent corrective osteotomy using a PMI. The maximal step-off on computed tomography and the deformity angle on plain radiographs were evaluated. The clinical examination parameters included range of motion (ROM), grip strength, pain according to visual analog scale (VAS), and Patient-Rated Wrist Evaluation (PRWE) score.

RESULTS

The maximal step-off was significantly reduced from 4.9 ± 1.8 to 1.0 ± 0.2 mm (p = 0.008). The absolute differences between the affected side and the normal contralateral side in radial inclination were significantly reduced from 5.4° ± 3.4°-1.2° ± 1.1° (p = 0.043). These differences were not significantly reduced postoperatively in the volar tilt and ulnar variance. VAS was significantly reduced from 4.1 ± 1.6 to 0.9 ± 0.7 cm (p = 0.006). The PRWE score significantly improved from 41.6 ± 22.0 to 15.7 ± 19.5 (p = 0.043). Grip strength was significantly increased from 54.0% ± 14.8%-85.8% ± 18.8% (p = 0.003). The preoperative and postoperative total arc of the wrist and forearm ROM were not significantly different.

CONCLUSIONS

Intra-articular corrective osteotomy using PMI could be one of the reliable treatment options for intra-articular malunion. PMI has exceptionally high precision performance, and it is also anticipated to yield superior surgical results.

Sterility of 3D-Printed Orthopedic Implants Using Fused Deposition Modeling

The use of 3-dimensional (3D) printing in orthopedics is developing rapidly and impacting the areas of preoperative planning, surgical guides, and simulation. As this technology continues to improve, the greatest impact of 3D printing may be in low- and middle-income countries where surgical items are in short supply. This study investigated sterility of 3D-printed ankle fracture fixation plates and cortical screws. The hypothesis was that the process of heated extrusion in fused deposition modeling printing would create sterile prints in a timely fashion that would not require postproduction sterilization. A free computer-assisted design program was used to design the implant models. One control group and 8 study groups were printed. Print construct, orientation, size, and postproduction sterilization differed among the groups. Sterility was assessed using thioglycollate broth cultures at 24 hours, 48 hours, and 7 days. Positive growth was speciated for aerobic and anaerobic bacteria. Print time and failed prints were recorded. Control samples were 100% positive for bacterial growth. All test samples remained sterile at all time points (100%). Speciation of control samples was obtained, and Staphylococcus was the most common species. Print times varied; however, no print time exceeded 6.75 minutes. Eighteen prints (17%) failed in the printing process. These findings demonstrate an intrinsic sterilization process associated with fused deposition modeling 3D printing and indicate the feasibility of 3D-printed surgical implants and equipment for orthopedic applications. With future research, 3D-printed implants may be a treatment modality to assist orthopedic surgeons in low- and middle-income countries. [Orthopedics. 2020; 43(1): 46-51.].

Image-Based Comparison Between the Bilateral Symmetry of the Distal Radii Through Established Measures

PURPOSE

Anthropometric assessment of bony structures in the body is important for preoperative computer-aided surgery, implant design, finite element modeling, and biomechanical studies investigating joint structure and function. The use of the contralateral limb in surgery and clinical practice relies on the assumption that the right and left limbs of an individual are symmetric. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to quantify the bilateral symmetry of the bony structures of the distal radius using 3-dimensional (3D) computed tomography.

METHODS

We collected computed tomography images of 37 paired, fresh-frozen, healthy cadaveric male upper limbs (aged 75.4 ± 8.3 years). Three-dimensional reconstructed models were created using semiautomatic segmentation. Using the 3D models, we measured 3D radial inclination, 3D volar tilt, 3D radial height, medial volar cortical angle, middle volar cortical angle, and lateral volar cortical angle and compared them between sides.

RESULTS

There were no statistically significant differences measured between right and left distal radius in 37 paired wrists. Mean radial height was 12.81 mm (SD, 1.74 mm) on the left and 12.88 mm (SD, 1.72 mm) on the right. Mean volar tilt was 10.74° (SD, 3.74°) and 10.77° (SD, 3.19°) and radial inclination was 24.05° (SD, 2.63°) and 24.18° (SD, 3.41°) on the left and right, respectively. Mean volar cortical angle across the radius was 140.9° (SD, 7.9°) on the left and 140.1° (SD, 7.9°) on the right.

CONCLUSIONS

Direct bilateral comparison of the distal radius and wrist joints is useful to predict normal anatomy of the injured radius, because bilateral similarities exist.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

This article provides a comprehensive list of measurements of the distal radius compared bilaterally using a 3D model. From this study, we found that the contralateral radius can be used as a benchmark with which to compare fracture reduction and to manage malunions during the preoperative planning of corrective osteotomies. It can also be used to define normal anatomy.

Use of three-dimensional technology for complications of upper limb fracture treatment

In malunion cases, restoration of anatomy is a key factor in obtaining a good functional outcome, but this can be technically very challenging.

Three-dimensional printed bone models can further improve understanding of the malunion pattern.

The use of three-dimensional (3D) computer planning, and the assembly of patient-specific instruments and implants, especially in complex deformities of the upper limb, allow accurate correction while reducing operation time, blood loss volume and radiation exposure during surgery.

One of the major disadvantages of the 3D technique is the additional cost because it requires specific computer software, a dedicated clinical engineer, and a 3D printer.

Further technical developments and clinical investigations are necessary to better define the added value and cost/benefit relationship of 3D in the treatment of complex fractures, non-unions, and malunions.

Cite this article: EFORT Open Rev 2019;4 DOI: 10.1302/2058-5241.4.180074

Best Approaches in Distal Radius Fracture Malunions

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Malunion remains a common complication in the treatment of distal radius fractures. The purpose of this review was to discuss the various approaches in planning and surgical management for extra- and intra-articular distal radius malunions.

RECENT FINDINGS

Several recent studies have reported good results with surgical correction of distal radius malunions utilizing a number of preoperative planning methods and surgical approaches. Three-dimensional models and custom cutting guides have recently become more popular, but their benefit in comparison to other methods remains unclear. Regardless of preoperative planning method or surgical approach, good results can be achieved with correction of distal radius malunion with careful attention to patient selection, indications, and surgical technique.