The Laxity of the Native Knee: A Meta-Analysis of in Vitro Studies

Development and validation of a biomechanically fidelic surgical training knee model

Knee arthroplasty technique is constantly evolving and the opportunity for surgeons to practice new techniques is currently highly dependent on the availability of cadaveric specimens requiring certified facilities. The high cost, limited supply, and heterogeneity of cadaveric specimens has increased the demand for synthetic training models, which are currently limited by a lack of biomechanical fidelity. Here, we aimed to design, manufacture, and experimentally validate a synthetic knee surgical training model which reproduces the flexion dependent varus-valgus (VV) and anterior-posterior (AP) mechanics of cadaveric knees, while maintaining anatomic accuracy. A probabilistic finite element modeling approach was employed to design physical models to exhibit passive cadaveric VV and AP mechanics. Seven synthetic models were manufactured and tested in a six-degree-of-freedom hexapod robot. Overall, the synthetic models exhibited cadaver-like VV and AP mechanics across a wide range of flexion angles with little variation between models. In the extended position, two models showed increased valgus rotation (<0.5°), and three models showed increased posterior tibial translation (<1.7 mm) when compared to the 95% confidence interval (CI) of cadaveric measurements. At full flexion, all models showed VV and AP mechanics within the 95% CI of cadaveric measurements. Given the repeatable mechanics exhibited, the knee models developed in this study can be used to reduce the current reliance on cadaveric specimens in surgical training.

Achieving Specified Laxity in a Noncruciate Total Knee: A Laboratory Design Study

BACKGROUND

Noncruciate total knee arthroplasty designs, including ultracongruent, medially congruent, and medial pivot, are gaining increasing attention in total knee arthroplasty surgery. However, there is no consensus for the bearing surface design, whether there should be different medial, lateral, anterior, and posterior laxities, or whether the medial side should be a medial pivot. This study proposes the criterion of reproducing the laxity of the anatomic knee, defined as the displacements and rotations of the femur on the tibia in the loaded knee when shear and torque are applied. The purpose of this study was to determine the ideal tibial radii to achieve that goal.

METHODS

The femoral component was based on the average knee from 100 mild arthritic knee scans. There were 8 tibial components that were designed with different sagittal radii: antero-medial, antero-lateral, postero-medial, and postero-lateral. Radii were defined as the percent height reduction from full conformity with the femoral profile. Components were 3-dimensional-printed. A test rig was constructed where the tibial component was fixed and shear and torque were applied to the femoral component. Displacements and rotations of the femoral component were measured at 0 and 45° of flexion, the latter representing any flexion angle due to the constant femoral sagittal radius.

RESULTS

Displacements ranged from 0 to 11 mm, and rotations ranged from 1 to 11°. Anterior femoral displacements were higher than posterior due to the shallow distal-anterior femoral profile. The final femoral and tibial components with the most closely matched anatomic laxity values were designed and tested.

CONCLUSIONS

A steeper distal-anterior femoral radius was an advantage. High medial-anterior tibial conformity was important. However, on the lateral side, the posterior sagittal tibial radius had to be shallower than ideal to allow femoral rollback in high flexion. This meant that the posterior laxity displacements on the lateral side were higher than anatomic, and there was no guidance for lateral femoral rollback.

Digital measurement of anterolateral knee laxity using strain sensors

PURPOSE

The ambition of the research group was to develop a sensor-based system that allowed the transfer of results with strain sensors applied to the knee joint. This system was to be validated in comparison to the current static mechanical measurement system. For this purpose, the internal rotation laxity of the knee joint was measured, as it is relevant for anterolateral knee laxity and anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury.

METHODS

This is a noninvasive measurement method using strain sensors which are applied to the skin in the course of the anterolateral ligament. The subjects were placed in supine position. First the left and then the right leg were clinically examined sequentially and documented by means of an examination form. 11 subjects aged 21 to 45 years, 5 women and 6 men were examined. Internal rotation of the lower leg was performed with a torque of 2 Nm at a knee flexion angle of 30°.

RESULTS

Comparison of correlation between length change and internal knee rotation angle showed a strong positive correlation (r = 1, p < 0.01). Whereas females showed a significant higher laxity vs. males (p = 0.003).

CONCLUSIONS

The present study showed that the capacitive strain sensors can be used for reproducible measurement of anterolateral knee laxity. In contrast to the previous static systems, a dynamic measurement will be possible by this method in the future.

The Effect of Minor Adjustments to Tibial and Femoral Component Position on Soft Tissue Balance in Robotic Total Knee Arthroplasty

BACKGROUND

Ideal goals for alignment and balance in total knee arthroplasty (TKA) remain controversial. We aimed to compare initial alignment and balance using mechanical alignment (MA) and kinematic alignment (KA) techniques, and to analyze the percentage of knees that could achieve balance using limited adjustments to component position.

METHODS

Prospective data on 331 primary robotic TKAs (115 MA and 216 KA) were analyzed. Medial and lateral virtual gaps were recorded in both flexion and extension. A computer algorithm was used to calculate potential (theoretical) implant alignment solutions to achieve balance within 1 millimeter (mm) without soft tissue release given an alignment philosophy (MA or KA), angular boundaries (±1, ±2, or ±3°), and gap targets (equal gaps or lateral laxity allowed). The percentage of knees that could theoretically achieve balance was compared.

RESULTS

Less than 5% of TKAs were initially balanced. Limited adjustments to component position increased the percentage of TKAs that could be balanced in a graduated manner, with no difference between MA and KA start points: adjustments of ±1 (10 vs 6% P=0.17), or ±2 (42 vs 39% P=0.61) or of ±3 (54 vs 51% P=0.66). A higher percentage of TKAs could be balanced when a greater range for lateral gap laxity was allowed. Balancing from KA resulted in increased joint line obliquity in the final implant alignment.

CONCLUSION

A high percentage of TKAs can be balanced without soft-tissue release using minor adjustments to component position. Surgeons should consider the relationship between alignment and balance goals when optimizing component positioning in TKA.

Endurance Behavior of Cemented Tibial Tray Fixation Under Anterior Shear and Internal-External Torsional Shear Testing: A New Methodological Approach

BACKGROUND

Early total knee arthroplasty failures continue to surface in the literature. Cementation technique and implant design are two of the most important scenarios that can affect implant survivorship. Our objectives were to develop a more suitable preclinical test to evaluate the endurance of the implant-cement-bone interface under anterior shear and internal-external (I/E) torsional shear testing condition in a biomechanical sawbones.

METHODS

Implants tested included the AS VEGA System PS and the AS Columbus CR/PS (Aesculap AG, Germany), with zirconium nitride (ZrN) coating. Tibial implants were evaluated under anterior shear and I/E torsional shear conditions with 6 samples in 4 test groups. For the evaluation of the I/E torsional shear endurance behavior, a test setup was created allowing for clinically relevant I/E rotation with simultaneous high axial/tibio-femoral load. The test was performed with an I/E displacement of ±17.2°, for 1 million cycles with an axial preload of 3,000 N.

RESULTS

After the anterior shear test an implant-cement-bone fixation strength for the AS VEGA System tibial tray of 2,674 ± 754 N and for the AS Columbus CR/PS tibial tray of 2,177 ± 429 N was determined (P = .191). After I/E rotational shear testing an implant-cement-bone fixation strength for the AS VEGA System PS tray of 2,561 ± 519 N and for the AS Columbus CR/PS tray of 2,824 ± 515 N was resulted (P = .39).

CONCLUSION

Both methods had varying degrees of failure modes from debonding to failure of the sawbones foam. These two intense biomechanical loading tests are more strenuous and more representative of clinical activity.

The interobserver reliability of clinical relevance in orthopaedic research

PURPOSE

A ratio of observed difference (OD) over the 95% confidence interval (CI) has been shown to be strongly associated with the perceived clinical relevance (CR) of medical research results. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the association between the OD/CI ratio and perceived CR in orthopaedic research.

METHODS

Sixty-seven orthopaedic surgeons completed a survey with 15 study outcomes (mean difference and CI) and were asked if they perceived the findings as clinically relevant. The interobserver reliability of perceived CR and the association between CR and the OD/CI ratio and p-value were assessed.

RESULTS

The interobserver reliability of CR between respondents was moderate (kappa = 0.46, CI 0.45 to 0.48). P-values did not differ between results with and without CR (median difference (MD) - 0.12, CI - 0.74 to 0.0009, p = 0.07). The OD/CI ratio, however, was greater for results with CR (MD 1.01, CI 0.3 to 3.9, p = 0.004). The area under the curve (AUC) for the p-value and OD/CI ratio receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves was 0.80 (p = 0.01) and 0.97 (p = 0.0003). The cutoff p -value and OD/CI ratio that maximized the sensitivity (SN) and specificity (SP) for CR were 0.001 (SN 80%, SP 80%) and 0.84 (SN 100%, SP 90%). The SN and SP of a p-value cutoff of 0.05 was 100% and 50%.

CONCLUSION

The interobserver reliability of the perceived CR of orthopaedic research findings was moderate. The OD/CI ratio, in contrast to the p-value, was strongly associated with perceived CR making it a potentially useful measure to evaluate research results.

A Morphometric Fixed-Bearing Unicompartmental Knee Arthroplasty Can Reproduce Normal Knee Kinematics. An In Vitro Robotic Evaluation

Background

Methods

Results

Conclusion

An anatomo-functional implant positioning technique with robotic assistance for primary TKA allows the restoration of the native knee alignment and a natural functional ligament pattern, with a faster recovery at 6 months compared to an adjusted mechanical technique

PURPOSE

An anatomo-functional implant positioning (AFIP) technique in total knee arthroplasty (TKA) could restore physiological ligament balance (symmetric gap in extension, asymmetric gap in flexion). The purposes were to compare (1) ligament balancing in extension and flexion after TKA in the AFIP group, (2) TKA alignment, implant positioning and patellar tracking between AFIP and adjusted mechanical alignment (aMA) techniques, (3) clinical outcomes between both groups at 12 months.

METHODS

All robotic-assisted TKA with an AFIP technique were included (n = 40). Exclusion criteria were genu valgum (HKA angle > 183°), extra-articular deformity more than 10°, and patellar maltracking (high-grade J-sign). One control patient with a TKA implanted by an aMA technique was matched for each case, based on age, body mass index, sex, and knee alignment. Ligament balancing (medial and lateral gaps in millimeters) in full extension and at 90° of flexion after TKA in the AFIP group was assessed with the robotic system. TKA alignment (HKA angle), implants positioning (femoral and tibial coronal axis, tibial slope, joint-line orientation), patellar tracking (patellar tilt and translation) and the Knee Society Score (KSS) at 6 and 12 months were compared between both groups. The ligament balancing was compared using a t test for paired samples in the AFIP group. The radiographic measurements and KSS scores were compared between groups using a t test for independent samples.

RESULTS

In the AFIP group, there was no significant difference between the medial and lateral gap laxity in extension (NS). A significant opening of the lateral gap was observed in flexion compared to extension (mean: + 2.9 mm; p < 0.0001). The mean postoperative HKA angle was comparable between both groups (177.3° ± 2.1 in the AFIP group vs 176.8° ± 3.2; NS). In the AFIP group, the femoral anatomy was restored (90.9° ± 1.6) and the tibial varus was partially corrected (87.4° ± 1.8). The improvement of Knee and Function KSS at 6 months was better in the AFIP group (59.3 ± 11.9 and 51.7 ± 20, respectively, versus 49.3 ± 9.7 and 20.8 ± 13; p < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

The AFIP concept allowed the restoration of the native knee alignment and a natural functional ligament pattern. With a more physiological target for ligament balancing, the AFIP technique had equivalent clinical outcomes at 12 months compared to aMA, with a faster recovery.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III retrospective therapeutic case control series.

Obtaining anatomic motion and laxity characteristics in a total knee design

BACKGROUND

Since the introduction of the first total knee designs, a frequent design goal has been to reproduce normal knee motion. However, studies of many currently used total knee designs, have shown that this goal has not been achieved. We proposed that Guided Motion total knee designs, could achieve more anatomic motion than present standard designs.

METHODS

Several Guided Motion knees for application without cruciate ligaments were designed using a computer method where the bearing surfaces were generated by the motion required. A knee testing machine was constructed where physiological forces including compressive, shear and torque were applied during knee flexion. The neutral path of motion and the laxity about the neutral path were measured. This evaluation method was a modification of the ASTM standard Constraint Test.

RESULTS

The motions of the Guided Motion knees and a standard PS knee were compared with the anatomic motion of knee specimens determined in an earlier study The Guided Motion knees showed motion patterns which were closer to anatomic than the PS knee.

CONCLUSIONS

The results provided justification for carrying out further evaluations of functional conditions, using either knee simulators or computer modelling. If anatomic motions could be reproduced in vivo, it is possible that clinical outcomes could be improved.

Rotational and varus-valgus laxity affects kinematics of the normal knee: A cadaveric study

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to evaluate the relationship between soft tissue laxity and kinematics of the normal knee using a navigation system.

METHODS

Fifteen cadaveric knees from 11 fresh frozen whole-body specimens were included in this study. The navigation system automatically recorded the rotation angle of the tibia as the internal-external (IE) kinematics and the coronal alignment of the lower limb as the varus-valgus (VV) kinematics. These measurements were made with the joint in maximal extension, at 10° intervals from 0° to 120° of flexion, and at maximal flexion during passive knee motion. For evaluation of laxity, the examiner gently applied maximum manual IE and VV stress to the knee at 0°, 30°, 60°, and 90° of flexion.

RESULTS

The measurements showed almost perfect reliability. The mean correlation coefficient between the intraoperative tibial rotation angle and the intermediate angle of IE laxity was 0.82, while that between the coronal alignment of the lower limb and the intermediate angle of the VV laxity was 0.96. There was a statistically significant correlation between kinematics and laxity at all degrees of knee flexion.

CONCLUSION

The present study revealed that the rotation angle of the tibia was correlated to the intermediate angle of IE laxity at 0°, 30°, 60°, and 90° of knee flexion and the coronal alignment of the lower limb also correlated to the intermediate angle of VV laxity. These findings provide important reference data on soft tissue laxity and kinematics of the normal knee.