Animal models of osteogenesis imperfecta: applications in clinical research

Extra-Skeletal Manifestations in Osteogenesis Imperfecta Mouse Models

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a rare heritable connective tissue disorder of skeletal fragility with an incidence of roughly 1:15,000. Approximately 85% of the pathogenic variants responsible for OI are in the type I collagen genes, COL1A1 and COL1A2, with the remaining pathogenic OI variants spanning at least 20 additional genetic loci that often involve type I collagen post-translational modification, folding, and intracellular transport as well as matrix incorporation and mineralization. In addition to being the most abundant collagen in the body, type I collagen is an important structural and extracellular matrix signaling molecule in multiple organ systems and tissues. Thus, OI disease-causing variants result not only in skeletal fragility, decreased bone mineral density (BMD), kyphoscoliosis, and short stature, but can also result in hearing loss, dentinogenesis imperfecta, blue gray sclera, cardiopulmonary abnormalities, and muscle weakness. The extensive genetic and clinical heterogeneity in OI has necessitated the generation of multiple mouse models, the growing awareness of non-skeletal organ and tissue involvement, and OI being more broadly recognized as a type I collagenopathy.This has driven the investigation of mutation-specific skeletal and extra-skeletal manifestations and broadened the search of potential mechanistic therapeutic strategies. The purpose of this review is to outline several of the extra-skeletal manifestations that have recently been characterized through the use of genetically and phenotypically heterogeneous mouse models of osteogenesis imperfecta, demonstrating the significant potential impact of OI disease-causing variants as a collagenopathy (affecting multiple organ systems and tissues), and its implications to overall health.

Exploration of the skeletal phenotype of the Col1a1 +/Mov13 mouse model for haploinsufficient osteogenesis imperfecta type 1

INTRODUCTION

Osteogenesis Imperfecta is a rare genetic connective tissue disorder, characterized by skeletal dysplasia and fragile bones. Currently only two mouse models have been reported for haploinsufficient (HI) mild Osteogenesis Imperfecta (OI); the Col1a1 ^+/Mov13 (Mov13) and the Col1a1 ^+/-365 mouse model. The Mov13 mice were created by random insertion of the Mouse Moloney leukemia virus in the first intron of the Col1a1 gene, preventing the initiation of transcription. Since the development of the Mov13 mice almost four decades ago and its basic phenotypic characterization in the 90s, there have not been many further studies. We aimed to extensively characterize the Mov13 mouse model in order to critically evaluate its possible use for preclinical studies of HI OI.

METHODS

Bone tissue from ten heterozygous Mov13 and ten wild-type littermates (WT) C57BL/6J mice (50% males per group) was analyzed at eight weeks of age with bone histomorphometry, micro computed tomography (microCT), 3-point bending, gene expression of different collagens, as well as serum markers of bone turnover.

RESULTS

The Mov13 mouse presented a lower bone strength and impaired material properties based on our results of 3-point bending and microCT analysis respectively. In contrast, no significant differences were found for all histomorphometric parameters. In addition, no significant differences in Col1a1 bone expression were present, but there was a significant lower P1NP concentration, a bone formation marker, measured in serum. Furthermore, bone tissue of Mov13 mice presented significantly higher expression of collagens (Col1a2, Col5a1 and Col5a2), and bone metabolism markers (Bglap, Fgf23, Smad7, Edn1 and Eln) compared to WT. Finally, we measured a significantly lower Col1a1 expression in heart and skin tissue and also determined a higher expression of other collagens in the heart tissue.

CONCLUSION

Although we did not detect a significant reduction in Col1a1 expression in the bone tissue, a change in bone structure and reduction in bone strength was noted. Regrettably, the variability of the bone phenotype and the appearance of severe lymphoma in adult Mov13 mice, does not favor their use for the testing of new long-term drug studies. As such, a new HI OI type 1 mouse model is urgently needed.

Tendon properties in a mouse model of severe osteogenesis imperfecta

PURPOSE/AIM OF THE STUDY

Osteogenesis imperfecta is a heritable bone disorder that is usually caused by mutations in collagen type I encoding genes. The impact of such mutations on tendons, a structure with high collagen type I content, remains largely unexplored. We hypothesized that tendon properties are abnormal in the context of a mutation affecting collagen type I. The main purpose of the study was to assess the anatomical, mechanical, and material tendon properties of Col1a1^Jrt/+ mice, a model of severe dominant OI.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The Flexor Digitorum Longus (FDL) tendon of Col1a1^Jrt/+ mice and wild-type littermates (WT) was assessed with in vitro mechanical testing.

RESULTS

The results showed that width and thickness of FDL tendons were about 40% larger in WT (p < 0.01) than in Col1a1^Jrt/+ mice, whereas the cross-sectional area was 138% larger (p < 0.001). The stiffness, peak- and yield-force were between 160% and 194% higher in WT vs. Col1a1^Jrt/+ mice. The material properties did not show significant differences between mouse strains with differences <15% between WT and Col1a1^Jrt/+ (p > 0.05). Analysis of the Achilles tendon collagen showed no difference between mice strains for the content but collagen solubility in acetic acid was 66% higher in WT than in Col1a1^Jrt/+ (p < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

This study shows that the FDL tendon of Col1a1^Jrt/+ mice has reduced mechanical properties but apparently normal material properties. It remains unclear whether the tendon phenotype of Col1a1^Jrt/+ mice is secondary to muscle weakness or a direct effect of the Col1a1 mutation or a combination of both.

An Update on Animal Models of Osteogenesis Imperfecta

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a heterogeneous disorder characterized by bone fragility, multiple fractures, bone deformity, and short stature. In recent years, the application of next generation sequencing has triggered the discovery of many new genetic causes for OI. Until now, more than 25 genetic causes of OI and closely related disorders have been identified. However, the mechanisms of many genes on skeletal fragility in OI are not entirely clear. Animal models of OI could help to understand the cellular, signaling, and metabolic mechanisms contributing to the disease, and how targeting these pathways can provide therapeutic targets. To date, a lot of animal models, mainly mice and zebrafish, have been described with defects in 19 OI-associated genes. In this review, we summarize the known genetic causes and animal models that recapitulate OI with a main focus on engineered mouse and zebrafish models. Additionally, we briefly discuss domestic animals with naturally occurring OI phenotypes. Knowledge of the specific molecular basis of OI will advance clinical diagnosis and potentially stimulate targeted therapeutic approaches.

ER, Mitochondria, and ISR Regulation by mt-HSP70 and ATF5 upon Procollagen Misfolding in Osteoblasts

Cellular response to protein misfolding underlies multiple diseases. Collagens are the most abundant vertebrate proteins, yet little is known about cellular response to misfolding of their procollagen precursors. Osteoblasts (OBs)-the cells that make bone-produce so much procollagen that it accounts for up to 40% of mRNAs in the cell, which is why bone bears the brunt of mutations causing procollagen misfolding in osteogenesis imperfecta (OI). The present study of a G610C mouse model of OI by multiple transcriptomic techniques provides first solid clues to how OBs respond to misfolded procollagen accumulation in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and how this response affects OB function. Surprisingly, misfolded procollagen escapes the quality control in the ER lumen and indirectly triggers the integrated stress response (ISR) through other cell compartments. In G610C OBs, the ISR is regulated by mitochondrial HSP70 (mt-HSP70) and ATF5 instead of their BIP and ATF4 paralogues, which normally activate and regulate ISR to secretory protein misfolding in the ER. The involvement of mt-HSP70 and ATF5 together with other transcriptomic findings suggest that mitochondria might initiate the ISR upon disruption of ER-mitochondria connections or might respond to the ISR activated by a yet unknown sensor.

Compression Fractures and Partial Phenotype Rescue With a Low Phosphorus Diet in the Chihuahua Zebrafish Osteogenesis Imperfecta Model

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a group of heritable disorders affecting bone and other connective tissues. Dominant OI forms are mainly caused by mutations in collagen type I. Patients suffer from skeletal deformities, fractures of long bones and vertebral compression fractures from early childhood onward. Altered collagen structure and excess mineralisation are the main causes for the bone phenotype. The Chihuahua (Chi/+) zebrafish has become an important model for OI. Given that reduced dietary phosphorus (P) intake reduces the bone mineral content and promotes bone matrix formation in teleosts, including zebrafish, we tested whether a low dietary P (LP) intake mitigates the OI phenotype in the Chi/+ model. To answer this question, we characterised the Chi/+ vertebral column phenotype at a morphological, cellular and subcellular level. We present the first description of vertebral compression fractures in Chi/+ and assess the effects of LP diet on the Chi/+ phenotype (Chi/+_LP). Compared to untreated Chi/+, two months of LP dietary treatment decreases vertebral deformities in the abdominal region and reduces shape variation of caudal vertebral bodies to a condition more similar to wild type (WT). At the histological level, the osteoid layer, covering the bone at the vertebral body endplates in WT zebrafish, is absent in Chi/+, but it is partially restored with the LP diet. Whole mount-stained specimens and histological sections show various stages of vertebral compression fractures in Chi/+ and Chi/+_LP animals. Both Chi/+ and Chi/+_LP show abundant osteoclast activity compared to WT. Finally, the ultrastructure analysis of WT, Chi/+ and Chi/+_LP shows Chi/+ and Chi/+_LP osteoblasts with enlarged endoplasmic reticulum cisternae and a high protein content, consistent with intracellular retention of mutated collagen. Nevertheless, the secreted collagen in Chi/+_LP appears better organised concerning fibre periodicity compared to Chi/+. Our findings suggest that a reduced mineral content of Chi/+ bone could explain the lower frequency of vertebral column deformities and the restored shape of the vertebral bodies in Chi/+_LP animals. This, together with the improved quality of the bone extracellular matrix, suggests that two months of reduced dietary P intake can alleviate the severe bone phenotype in Chi/+ zebrafish.

A systematic review and meta-analysis on the efficacy of stem cell therapy on bone brittleness in mouse models of osteogenesis imperfecta

There is no cure for osteogenesis imperfecta (OI), and current treatments can only partially correct the bone phenotype. Stem cell therapy holds potential to improve bone quality and quantity in OI. Here, we conduct a systematic review and meta-analysis of published studies to investigate the efficacy of stem cell therapy to rescue bone brittleness in mouse models of OI. Identified studies included bone marrow, mesenchymal stem cells, and human fetal stem cells. Effect size of fracture incidence, maximum load, stiffness, cortical thickness, bone volume fraction, and raw engraftment rates were pooled in a random-effects meta-analysis. Cell type, cell number, injection route, mouse age, irradiation, anatomical bone, and follow up time were considered as moderators. It was not possible to investigate further parameters due to the lack of standards of investigation between the studies. Despite the use of oim mice in the majority of the investigations considered and the lack of sham mice as control, this study demonstrates the promising potential of stem cell therapy to reduce fractures in OI. Although their low engraftment, cell therapy in mouse models of OI had a beneficial effect on maximum load, but not on stiffness, cortical thickness and bone volume. These parameters all depend on bone geometry and do not inform on its material properties. Being bone fractures the primary symptom of OI, there is a critical need to measure the fracture toughness of OI bone treated with stem cells to assess the actual efficacy of the treatment to rescue OI bone brittleness.

Zebrafish Models for Human Skeletal Disorders

In 2019, the Nosology Committee of the International Skeletal Dysplasia Society provided an updated version of the Nosology and Classification of Genetic Skeletal Disorders. This is a reference list of recognized diseases in humans and their causal genes published to help clinician diagnosis and scientific research advances. Complementary to mammalian models, zebrafish has emerged as an interesting species to evaluate chemical treatments against these human skeletal disorders. Due to its versatility and the low cost of experiments, more than 80 models are currently available. In this article, we review the state-of-art of this “aquarium to bedside” approach describing the models according to the list provided by the Nosology Committee. With this, we intend to stimulate research in the appropriate direction to efficiently meet the actual needs of clinicians under the scope of the Nosology Committee.

Increased cochlear otic capsule thickness and intracortical canal porosity in the oim mouse model of osteogenesis imperfecta

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI or brittle bone disease) is a group of genetic disorders of the connective tissues caused mainly by mutations in the genes encoding collagen type I. Clinical manifestations of OI include skeletal fragility, bone deformities, and severe functional disabilities, such as hearing loss. Progressive hearing loss, usually beginning in childhood, affects approximately 70% of people with OI with more than half of the cases involving the inner ear. There is no cure for OI nor a treatment to ameliorate its corresponding hearing loss, and very little is known about the properties of OI ears. In this study, we investigate the morphology of the otic capsule and the cochlea in the inner ear of the oim mouse model of OI. High-resolution 3D images of 8-week old oim and WT inner ears were acquired using synchrotron microtomography. Volumetric morphometric measurements were conducted for the otic capsule, its intracortical canal network and osteocyte lacunae, and for the cochlear spiral ducts. Our results show that the morphology of the cochlea is preserved in the oim ears at 8 weeks of age but the otic capsule has a greater cortical thickness and altered intracortical bone porosity, with a larger number and volume density of highly branched canals in the oim otic capsule. These results portray a state of compromised bone quality in the otic capsule of the oim mice that may contribute to their hearing loss.

Intrafibrillar mineralization deficiency and osteogenesis imperfecta mouse bone fragility

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI), a brittle bone disease, is known to result in severe bone fragility. However, its ultrastructural origins are still poorly understood. In this study, we hypothesized that deficient intrafibrillar mineralization is a key contributor to the OI induced bone brittleness. To test this hypothesis, we explored the mechanical and ultrastructural changes in OI bone using the osteogenesis imperfecta murine (oim) model. Synchrotron X-ray scattering experiments indicated that oim bone had much less intrafibrillar mineralization than wild type bone, thus verifying that the loss of mineral crystals indeed primarily occurred in the intrafibrillar space of oim bone. It was also found that the mineral crystals were organized from preferentially in longitudinal axis in wild type bone to more randomly in oim bone. Moreover, it revealed that the deformation of mineral crystals was more coordinated with collagen fibrils in wild type than in oim bone, suggesting that the load transfer deteriorated between the two phases in oim bone. The micropillar test revealed that the compression work to fracture of oim bone (8.2 ± 0.9 MJ/m³) was significantly smaller (p < 0.05) than that of wild type bone (13.9 ± 2.7 MJ/m³), while the bone strength was not statistically different (p > 0.05) between the two genotype groups. In contrast, the uniaxial tensile test showed that the ultimate strength of wild type bone (50 ± 4.5 MPa) was significantly greater (p < 0.05) than that of oim bone (38 ± 5.3 MPa). Furthermore, the nanoscratch test showed that the toughness of oim bone was much less than that of wild type bone (6.6 ± 2.2 GJ/m³ vs. 12.6 ± 1.4 GJ/m³). Finally, in silico simulations using a finite element model of sub-lamellar bone confirmed the links between the reduced intrafibrillar mineralization and the observed changes in the mechanical behavior of OI bone. Taken together, these results provide important mechanistic insights into the underlying cause of poor mechanical quality of OI bone, thus pave the way toward future treatments of this brittle bone disease.

Mouse mutant phenotyping at scale reveals novel genes controlling bone mineral density

The genetic landscape of diseases associated with changes in bone mineral density (BMD), such as osteoporosis, is only partially understood. Here, we explored data from 3,823 mutant mouse strains for BMD, a measure that is frequently altered in a range of bone pathologies, including osteoporosis. A total of 200 genes were found to significantly affect BMD. This pool of BMD genes comprised 141 genes with previously unknown functions in bone biology and was complementary to pools derived from recent human studies. Nineteen of the 141 genes also caused skeletal abnormalities. Examination of the BMD genes in osteoclasts and osteoblasts underscored BMD pathways, including vesicle transport, in these cells and together with in silico bone turnover studies resulted in the prioritization of candidate genes for further investigation. Overall, the results add novel pathophysiological and molecular insight into bone health and disease.

Patients affected by osteoporosis frequently present with decreased BMD and increased fracture risk. Genes are known to control the onset and progression of bone diseases such as osteoporosis. Therefore, we aimed to identify osteoporosis-related genes using BMD measures obtained from a large pool of mutant mice genetically modified for deletion of individual genes (knockout mice). In a collaborative endeavor involving several research sites world-wide, we generated and phenotyped 3,823 knockout mice and identified 200 genes which regulated BMD. Of the 200 BMD genes, 141 genes were previously not known to affect BMD. The discovery and study of novel BMD genes will help to better understand the causes and therapeutic options for patients with low BMD. In the long run, this will improve the clinical management of osteoporosis.

Clinical Application of Bone Marrow Mesenchymal Stem/Stromal Cells to Repair Skeletal Tissue

There has been an escalation in reports over the last decade examining the efficacy of bone marrow derived mesenchymal stem/stromal cells (BMSC) in bone tissue engineering and regenerative medicine-based applications. The multipotent differentiation potential, myelosupportive capacity, anti-inflammatory and immune-modulatory properties of BMSC underpins their versatile nature as therapeutic agents. This review addresses the current limitations and challenges of exogenous autologous and allogeneic BMSC based regenerative skeletal therapies in combination with bioactive molecules, cellular derivatives, genetic manipulation, biocompatible hydrogels, solid and composite scaffolds. The review highlights the current approaches and recent developments in utilizing endogenous BMSC activation or exogenous BMSC for the repair of long bone and vertebrae fractures due to osteoporosis or trauma. Current advances employing BMSC based therapies for bone regeneration of craniofacial defects is also discussed. Moreover, this review discusses the latest developments utilizing BMSC therapies in the preclinical and clinical settings, including the treatment of bone related diseases such as Osteogenesis Imperfecta.

Craniofacial allometry in the OIM-/- mouse model of osteogenesis imperfecta

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a skeletal disorder characterized by the impaired synthesis of type I collagen (Col1). This study tests the hypothesis that the craniofacial phenotype of severe OI is linked to an overall reduction in body size. 3D landmark data were collected from µCT scans of adult OIM^-/- and wild-type (WT) mice and used to calculate centroid sizes (CS) and interlandmark distances (ILDs). To remove the effect of body size, ILDs were scaled against craniomandibular lengths and CS. Mann-Whitney U tests were used to compare CS and absolute/scaled ILDs between genotypes. OIM^-/- mice are smaller than their WT littermates in body mass, craniomandibular CS, and absolute ILDs including skull, basicranial, palatal, mandibular, and toothrow lengths. When linear distances are scaled to CS, OIM^-/- mice have a relatively short midface, short nasal bones, tall mandibular corpora, and long mandibular toothrows. Results underscore the importance of size and scaling in morphometric analyses. The deleterious effect of Col1 mutations on global skeletal dimensions combined with localized morphometric changes may underlie the facial phenotype seen in human patients with severe OI. Attempts to identify these localized changes should first account for the restricted growth and small body sizes present in individuals with OI.

Finite element analysis of bone strength in osteogenesis imperfecta

As a dedicated experimentalist, John Currey praised the high potential of finite element (FE) analysis but also recognized its critical limitations. The application of the FE methodology to bone tissue is reviewed in the light of his enthusiastic and colorful statements. In the past decades, FE analysis contributed substantially to the understanding of structure-function properties in the hierarchical organization of bone and to the simulation of bone adaptation. The systematic experimental validation of FE analysis of bone strength in anatomical locations at risk of fracture led to its application in clinical studies to evaluate efficacy of antiresorptive or anabolic treatment of bone fragility. Beyond the successful analyses of healthy or osteoporotic bone, FE analysis becomes increasingly involved in the investigation of other fragility-related bone diseases. The case of osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is exposed, the multiscale alterations of the bone tissue and the effect of treatment summarized. A few FE analyses attempting to answer open questions in OI are then reported. An original study is finally presented that explored the structural properties of the Brtl/+ murine model of OI type IV subjected to sclerostin neutralizing antibody treatment using microFE analysis. The use of identical material properties in the four-point bending FE simulations of the femora reproduced not only the experimental values but also the statistical comparisons examining the effect of disease and treatment. Further efforts are needed to build upon the extraordinary legacy of John Currey and clarify the impact of different bone diseases on the hierarchical mechanical properties of bone.

Early Fracture Healing is Delayed in the Col1a2+/G610C Osteogenesis Imperfecta Murine Model

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a rare heritable skeletal dysplasia mainly caused by type I collagen abnormalities and characterized by bone fragility and susceptibility to fracture. Over 85% of the patients carry dominant mutations in the genes encoding for the collagen type I α1 and α2 chains. Failure of bone union and/or presence of hyperplastic callus formation after fracture were described in OI patients. Here we used the Col1a2^+/G610C mouse, carrying in heterozygosis the α2(I)-G610C substitution, to investigate the healing process of an OI bone. Tibiae of 2-month-old Col1a2^+/G610C and wild-type littermates were fractured and the healing process was followed at 2, 3, and 5 weeks after injury from fibrous cartilaginous tissue formation to its bone replacement by radiography, micro-computed tomography (µCT), histological and biochemical approaches. In presence of similar fracture types, in Col1a2^+/G610C mice an impairment in the early phase of bone repair was detected compared to wild-type littermates. Smaller callus area, callus bone surface, and bone volume associated to higher percentage of cartilage and lower percentage of bone were evident in Col1a2^+/G610C at 2 weeks post fracture (wpf) and no change by 3 wpf. Furthermore, the biochemical analysis of collagen extracted from callus 2 wpf revealed in mutants an increased amount of type II collagen, typical of cartilage, with respect to type I, characteristic of bone. This is the first report of a delay in OI bone fracture repair at the modeling phase.