Long-term sustained mixed chimerism after allogeneic stem cell transplantation in a patient with severe aplastic anemia

Long-Term Stable Mixed Chimerism after Hematopoietic Stem Cell Transplantation in Patients with Non-Malignant Disease, Shall We Be Tolerant?

Long-term stable mixed chimerism is a rare and poorly understood phenomenon post hematopoietic stem cell transplantation. This study aims to shed light on whether the two hematopoietic systems in patients with mixed chimerism remain functional. Additionally, we investigate possible immunologic differences in these individuals compared to patients with only donor derived immune cells. Patients with donor and mixed chimerism, at median 10 (5–16) years post-HSCT for non-malignant diseases, were assessed regarding clinical situation and immune system (phenotypical and functional). No difference in long-term outcome was seen in terms of general wellbeing, central phenotypic immune system features (e.g., differentiation status, CD4/CD8 ratio, B and NK-cell frequency) and antibody responses to immunizations. At a median of 10 years post transplantation, patients with mixed chimerism had significantly higher IgG3 and platelet levels. Additionally, these patients had higher NKT-cell levels (CD94+CD8+ and CD56+CD8+) than patients with donor chimerism. In depth phenotypic analysis of patients with mixed chimerism demonstrated recipient-derived fractions in most immune cell lineages (e.g., T-cell, B-cell and NK-cell subsets). Recipient cells were also capable of responding to mitogenic stimulation with production of several cytokines. In conclusion, long-term mixed chimerism did not negatively affect patient wellbeing and long-term outcome. Moreover, recipient-derived immunity may still be functional in these patients, suggesting an active state of tolerance and immunologic dependence on both hematopoietic systems.

Mixed chimerism in SCT: conflict or peaceful coexistence?

Stem cell transplants that follow both myeloablative and non-myeloablative conditioning regimens can result in states of mixed chimerism, which can be stable over time. With widespread availability of Y chromosome FISH in sex-mismatched transplantation and DNA-based methodologies for analysis of chimerism in other donor-recipient pairs, further insights have been gained regarding the implications of the mixed chimeric state. In transplants performed for inherited and acquired marrow failure disorders, disease status can be improved with only 10-20% donor cells, and it appears that stable mixed chimerism at that level is an acceptable outcome often leading to a state of tolerance, but an increasing level of recipient cells often precedes graft rejection. In transplants performed for malignant conditions, increasing levels of mixed chimerism may indicate disease relapse, but some cases with stable levels of mixed chimerism have been compatible with prolonged remission states. Understanding when mixed chimerism is an indication of secondary graft failure or impending graft rejection vs a state of tolerance and ongoing propensity for the establishment of a graft-vs-tumor effect is often difficult with currently available technologies and immunologic assays. The ability to understand the implication of mixed chimerism of multiple cell lineages and of varied lymphocyte subsets will remain important areas for future research to best harness the immunologic and other therapeutic benefits of allogeneic transplantation.