Respiration Rate Estimation Based on Independent Component Analysis of Accelerometer Data: Pilot Single-Arm Intervention Study

Continuous Critical Respiratory Parameter Measurements Using a Single Low-Cost Relative Humidity Sensor: Evaluation Study

BACKGROUND

Accurate and portable respiratory parameter measurements are critical for properly managing chronic obstructive pulmonary diseases (COPDs) such as asthma or sleep apnea, as well as controlling ventilation for patients in intensive care units, during surgical procedures, or when using a positive airway pressure device for sleep apnea.

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this research is to develop a new nonprescription portable measurement device that utilizes relative humidity sensors (RHS) to accurately measure key respiratory parameters at a cost that is approximately 10 times less than the industry standard.

METHODS

We present the development, implementation, and assessment of a wearable respiratory measurement device using the commercial Bosch BME280 RHS. In the initial stage, the RHS was connected to the pneumotach (PNT) gold standard device via its external connector to gather breathing metrics. Data collection was facilitated using the Arduino platform with a Bluetooth Low Energy connection, and all measurements were taken in real time without any additional data processing. The device's efficacy was tested with 7 participants (5 men and 2 women), all in good health. In the subsequent phase, we specifically focused on comparing breathing cycle and respiratory rate measurements and determining the tidal volume by calculating the region between inhalation and exhalation peaks. Each participant's data were recorded over a span of 15 minutes. After the experiment, detailed statistical analysis was conducted using ANOVA and Bland-Altman to examine the accuracy and efficiency of our wearable device compared with the traditional methods.

RESULTS

The perfused air measured with the respiratory monitor enables clinicians to evaluate the absolute value of the tidal volume during ventilation of a patient. In contrast, directly connecting our RHS device to the surgical mask facilitates continuous lung volume monitoring. The results of the 1-way ANOVA showed high P values of .68 for respiratory volume and .89 for respiratory rate, which indicate that the group averages with the PNT standard are equivalent to those with our RHS platform, within the error margins of a typical instrument. Furthermore, analysis utilizing the Bland-Altman statistical method revealed a small bias of 0.03 with limits of agreement (LoAs) of -0.25 and 0.33. The RR bias was 0.018, and the LoAs were -1.89 and 1.89.

CONCLUSIONS

Based on the encouraging results, we conclude that our proposed design can be a viable, low-cost wearable medical device for pulmonary parametric measurement to prevent and predict the progression of pulmonary diseases. We believe that this will encourage the research community to investigate the application of RHS for monitoring the pulmonary health of individuals.

Breathing-Associated Facial Region Segmentation for Thermal Camera-Based Indirect Breathing Monitoring

Breathing can be measured in a non-contact method using a thermal camera. The objective of this study investigates non-contact breathing measurements using thermal cameras, which have previously been limited to measuring the nostril only from the front where it is clearly visible. The previous method is challenging to use for other angles and frontal views, where the nostril is not well-represented. In this paper, we defined a new region called the breathing-associated-facial-region (BAFR) that reflects the physiological characteristics of breathing, and extract breathing signals from views of 45 and 90 degrees, including the frontal view where the nostril is not clearly visible. Experiments were conducted on fifteen healthy subjects in different views, including frontal with and without nostril, 45-degree, and 90-degree views. A thermal camera (A655sc model, FLIR systems) was used for non-contact measurement, and biopac (MP150, Biopac-systems-Inc) was used as a chest breathing reference. The results showed that the proposed algorithm could extract stable breathing signals at various angles and views, achieving an average breathing cycle accuracy of 90.9% when applied compared to 65.6% without proposed algorithm. The average correlation value increases from 0.587 to 0.885. The proposed algorithm can be monitored in a variety of environments and extract the BAFR at diverse angles and views.

A Differential Inertial Wearable Device for Breathing Parameter Detection: Hardware and Firmware Development, Experimental Characterization

Breathing monitoring is crucial for evaluating a patient's health status. The technologies commonly used to monitor respiration are costly, bulky, obtrusive, and inaccurate, mainly when the user moves. Consequently, efforts have been devoted to providing new solutions and methodologies to overcome these limitations. These methods have several uses, including healthcare monitoring, measuring athletic performance, and aiding patients with respiratory diseases, such as COPD (chronic obtrusive pulmonary disease), sleep apnea, etc. Breathing-induced chest movements can be measured noninvasively and discreetly using inertial sensors. This research work presents the development and testing of an inertia-based chest band for breathing monitoring through a differential approach. The device comprises two IMUs (inertial measurement units) placed on the patient's chest and back to determine the differential inertial signal, carrying out information detection about the breathing activity. The chest band includes a low-power microcontroller section to acquire inertial data from the two IMUs and process them to extract the breathing parameters (i.e., RR-respiration rate; TI/TE-inhalation/exhalation time; IER-inhalation-to-exhalation time; V-flow rate), using the back IMU as a reference. A BLE transceiver wirelessly transmits the acquired breathing parameters to a mobile application. Finally, the test results demonstrate the effectiveness of the used dual-inertia solution; correlation and Bland-Altman analyses were performed on the RR measurements from the chest band and the reference, demonstrating a high correlation (r¯ = 0.92) and low mean difference (MD¯ = -0.27 BrPM (breaths per minute)), limits of agreement (LoA¯ = +1.16/-1.75 BrPM), and mean absolute error (MAE¯ = 1.15%). Additionally, the experimental results demonstrated that the developed device correctly measured the other breathing parameters (TI, TE, IER, and V), keeping an MAE of ≤5%. The obtained results indicated that the developed chest band is a viable solution for long-term breathing monitoring, both in stationary and moving users.

Novel Continuous Respiratory Rate Monitoring Using an Armband Wearable Sensor

Photoplethysmography (PPG) and accelerometer (ACC) are commonly integrated into wearable devices for continuous unobtrusive pulse rate and activity monitoring of individuals during daily life. However, obtaining continuous and clinically accurate respiratory rate measurements using such wearable sensors remains a challenge. This article presents a novel algorithm for estimation of respiration rate (RR) using an upper-arm worn wearable device by deriving multiple respiratory surrogate signals from PPG and ACC sensing. This RR algorithm is retrospectively evaluated on a controlled respiratory clinical testing dataset from 38 subjects with simultaneously recorded wearable sensor data and a standard capnography monitor as an RR reference. The proposed RR method shows great performance and robustness in determining RR measurements over a wide range of 4-59 brpm with an overall bias of -1.3 brpm, mean absolute error (MAE) of 2.7±1.6 brpm, and a meager outage of 0.3±1.2%, while a standard PPG Smart Fusion method produces a bias of -3.6 brpm, an MAE of 5.5±3.1 brpm, and an outage of 0.7±2.5% for direct comparison. In addition, the proposed algorithm showed no significant differences (p=0.63) in accurately determining RR values in subjects with darker skin tones, while the RR performance of the PPG Smart Fusion method is significantly (P<0.001) affected by the darker skin pigmentation. This study demonstrates a highly accurate RR algorithm for unobtrusive continuous RR monitoring using an armband wearable device.

An Overview of Wearable Piezoresistive and Inertial Sensors for Respiration Rate Monitoring

The demand for wearable devices to measure respiratory activity is constantly growing, finding applications in a wide range of scenarios (e.g., clinical environments and workplaces, outdoors for monitoring sports activities, etc.). Particularly, the respiration rate (RR) is a vital parameter since it indicates serious illness (e.g., pneumonia, emphysema, pulmonary embolism, etc.). Therefore, several solutions have been presented in the scientific literature and on the market to make RR monitoring simple, accurate, reliable and noninvasive. Among the different transduction methods, the piezoresistive and inertial ones satisfactorily meet the requirements for smart wearable devices since unobtrusive, lightweight and easy to integrate. Hence, this review paper focuses on innovative wearable devices, detection strategies and algorithms that exploit piezoresistive or inertial sensors to monitor the breathing parameters. At first, this paper presents a comprehensive overview of innovative piezoresistive wearable devices for measuring user’s respiratory variables. Later, a survey of novel piezoresistive textiles to develop wearable devices for detecting breathing movements is reported. Afterwards, the state-of-art about wearable devices to monitor the respiratory parameters, based on inertial sensors (i.e., accelerometers and gyroscopes), is presented for detecting dysfunctions or pathologies in a non-invasive and accurate way. In this field, several processing tools are employed to extract the respiratory parameters from inertial data; therefore, an overview of algorithms and methods to determine the respiratory rate from acceleration data is provided. Finally, comparative analysis for all the covered topics are reported, providing useful insights to develop the next generation of wearable sensors for monitoring respiratory parameters.