Usability and Effectiveness of Immersive Virtual Grocery Shopping for Assessing Cognitive Fatigue in Healthy Controls: Protocol for a Randomized Controlled Trial

Assessing the usability of an immersive virtual reality grocery store in healthy controls

BACKGROUND

Immersive virtual reality (IVR) as a research platform to study human behaviors is an emerging field and may be useful for studying self-care management, especially in the gap between formal healthcare recommendations and day-to-day living. Self-care activities, such as grocery shopping, can be challenging for people with chronic illness. We developed an IVR environment that simulates a real-life grocery store and conducted a usability study to demonstrate the safety and acceptability of IVR as an experimental environment.

METHODS

This study was a three-arm randomized control trial involving 24 participants, conducted as a usability study to evaluate aspects of the experimental condition including the effectiveness of a training exposure, the occurrence of undesirable effects associated with IVR, and participants' experiences of realism, immersion, and spatial presence. The experiment, using a head mounted device and handheld controllers, included a 10-minute training exposure, followed by one of three unique 30-minute experimental conditions which exposed participants to different combinations of tasks and stimuli, and a post-experience interview. We measured controller errors, undesirable symptoms associated with IVR, and the perception of realism, immersion, and spatial presence.

RESULTS

Participants used controllers effectively to interact within the IVR environment. Hand controller use errors were fewer during the experimental conditions compared to the training exposure. Minimal undesirable IVR symptoms were reported. Presence was rated in the middle range with no significant differences based on experimental condition. Overall, user experience feedback was positive.

CONCLUSIONS

We demonstrated that participants could engage in our IVR environment without excessive error or experiencing undesirable effects and confirmed that the virtual experience attained a level of presence necessary to effectively engage in the study. These findings give us confidence that this IVR intervention designed to explore instrumental activities of daily living is safe, effective and provides a credible, controlled simulated community-like setting.

Visualization of health information within immersive virtual reality environments

The Advanced Visualization Branch of the National Institute of Nursing Research uses computer technologies to study information visualization in support of self-care management. Advanced technologies, such as immersive virtual reality (IVR), afford researchers the opportunity to study health information visualization where user-initiated information search in visually dense settings precedes acquisition, interpretation, and use. While IVR has broad applicability in healthcare, we chose to target lay people managing chronic disease because of the growing unmet need to translate clinical recommendations into everyday behaviors. To explore how lay people seek, acquire, and interpret health information in everyday settings, we developed an IVR grocery store. In this environment, a person can locate food products, read and compare nutrition labels, and use information to make food selections. The goal of this perspective is to introduce the opportunities afforded by IVR to both present and study health information visualization and to highlight critical design considerations.