Detection of residual or recurrent meningioma after surgery: value of enhanced vs unenhanced MR imaging

Is non-contrast MRI sufficient to detect meningioma residue after surgery?

BACKGROUND

Contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is the imaging modality routinely used to follow up patients who have undergone surgical resection of brain meningiomas. There are growing concerns about the massive use of gadolinium-based contrast agents (GBCA). Our aim was to evaluate the performance of a new imaging protocol, performed without GBCA injection, in the detection of tumoral residue or local recurrence after surgery of parafalcine and convexity meningiomas.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Only adult patients with a documented resected parafalcine or convexity meningioma were included. We performed a dedicated MRI protocol that included non-contrast and post-contrast sequences. The presence or absence of residue on the unenhanced sequences was independently recorded by three observers: first blindly, then in comparison with a baseline enhanced MRI examination.

RESULTS

A total of 51 patients were included. 37 of them featured a tumor residue on the reference enhanced sequence. Overall, an average of 32 of 37 (87%) residues were identified on the unenhanced sequences that were blindly reviewed; and more than 34 of 37 (93%) were identified with the help of the comparative baseline enhanced examination, with a high sensitivity. The missed cases were related to small residues.

CONCLUSION

Unenhanced MRI sequences are highly sensitive and specific in identifying a tumor residue or a local recurrence in the post operative follow up of brain meningiomas. Sensitivity is even higher with the help of a comparative baseline enhanced MRI examination, whatever the strength of magnetic field.

Potential impact of (68)Ga-DOTATOC PET/CT on stereotactic radiotherapy planning of meningiomas

PURPOSE

Since meningiomas show a high expression of somatostatin receptor subtype 2, PET with (68)Ga-DOTATOC was proposed as an additional imaging modality beside CT and MRI for planning radiotherapy. We investigated the input of (68)Ga-DOTATOC-PET/CT on the definition of the "gross tumour volume" (GTV) in meningiomas, in order to assess the potential value of this method.

METHODS

Prior to radiotherapy, 42 patients with meningiomas (26 f, 16 m, mean age 55) underwent MRI and (68)Ga-DOTATOC-PET/CT examinations.

HISTORY

operated n = 24, radiotherapy n = 1, operation and radiotherapy n = 8, no treatment n = 9. PET/CT and MRI data were co-registered using a BrainLAB workstation. For comparison, the GTV was defined first under consideration of CT and MRI data, then using PET data.

RESULTS

3/42 patients were excluded from the analysis (two with negative PET results, one with an extensive tumour, not precisely delineable by MRI or PET/CT). The average GTV(CT/MRI) was 22(+/-19)cm(3); GTV(PET) was 23(+/-20)cm(3). Additional GTV, obtained as a result of PET was 9(+/-10)cm(3) and was observed in patients with osseous infiltration. In some pre-treated patients there were intratumoural areas (as identified in CT/MRI) without SR-expression (7(+/-11)cm(3)). Common GTV as obtained by both CT/MRI and PET was 15(+/-14)cm(3). The mean bi-directional difference between the GTV(CT/MRI) and GTV(PET) accounted to 16(+/-15)cm(3) (93%, p < 0.001). In a subgroup of seven patients with multiple meningiomas, PET showed a total of 19 lesions; nine of them were not recognizable by CT or MRI.

CONCLUSION

(68)Ga-DOTATOC-PET enables delineation of SR-positive meningiomas and delivers additional information to both CT and MRI regarding the planning of stereotactic radiotherapy. The acquisition on a PET/CT scanner helps to estimate the relation of PET findings to anatomical structures and is especially useful for detection of osseous infiltration. (68)Ga-DOTATOC-PET also allows detection of additional lesions in patients with multiple meningiomas.

Recurrent extracranial sinonasal meningioma presenting 27 years after complete surgical eradication of right frontal meningioma

A 79-year-old man presented to our department with nasal obstruction and postnasal drip. On examination he had unusual bilateral nasal polyps, which were histologically diagnosed as meningioma. Twenty-seven years earlier he had undergone successful removal of a right frontal meningioma. A CT scan performed 7 years after his primary surgery had shown complete excision with no evidence of recurrence. Extracranial meningiomas are rare tumours and are usually extensions from an intracranial mass lesion. We document what we believe to be the first case of an extracranial meningioma, presenting as nasal polyps, 27 years after successful surgical eradication of the primary lesion.

Juxtaorbital en plaque meningiomas. Report of four cases and review of literature

Juxtaorbital spheroid wing or ridge meningiomas are the most common of the basal meningiomas. These are at times meningiomas en plaque, which in most patients do not have significant intracranial component. This article reviews the literature on en-plaque meningiomas and discusses the role of MR imaging and CT in the diagnosis of en-plaque meningiomas of the paraorbital region. The role of fat-suppression, gadolinium-enhanced, T1-weighted MR imaging is emphasized.

Clinical significance of diffuse dural enhancement detected by magnetic resonance imaging

This study was performed to determine the clinical significance of diffuse dural enhancement (DDE) detected by magnetic resonance (MR) imaging and to typify enhancing patterns related to inflammatory or metastatic causes. The authors retrospectively evaluated the clinical, imaging, and laboratory characteristics of 20 consecutive patients with DDE. Those with DDE and an underlying neoplastic disease (13 patients) were compared to 11 consecutive patients with cytological evidence of neoplastic leptomeningeal metastasis evaluated by MR imaging. The DDE was often associated with an underlying malignancy (13 (65%) of 20 patients) but it coexisted with leptomeningeal metastasis in only one patient. Skull metastases were evident in 10 (77%) of 13 patients and cranial nerve palsies in six (46%) of 13. Other causes of DDE were related to cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leak or shunting (five (25%) of 20), with or without symptoms of intracranial hypotension, and to dural sinus thrombosis and pachymeningitis. Dural biopsies obtained in two patients with DDE showed a narrow rim of granulation-like tissue adherent to the dural surface facing the inner skull table. Magnetic resonance subtraction, diffusion, and perfusion studies revealed unique characteristics in patients with metastatic causes as compared to those with DDE secondary to CSF leak. None of the patients with proven leptomeningeal metastasis had DDE, but four of them presented with focal dural enhancement and two displayed apparent leptomeningeal enhancement. The findings indicate that DDE is not a radiographic hallmark of leptomeningeal metastasis in spite of the similarities in clinical manifestations (for example, headache and cranial polyneuropathy). Nonetheless, DDE is most frequently associated with metastatic malignancies and particularly with skull metastases and CSF leak. Special MR techniques can discern the underlying cause and elucidate the disparity in the pathophysiological mechanisms leading to DDE.

Recurrent spheno-orbital meningioma

A series of 15 patients who underwent neurosurgical procedures for recurrent spheno-orbital meningioma is reported. There were 11 women and four men, with a mean age of 46 years. The mean duration between the first and second operations was 46 months. Progressive proptosis without neurological deficit was the most common symptom. All tumors were large at the time of reoperation and involved the greater and lesser wings of the sphenoid bone and the orbit. Aggressive resection in all patients resulted in no deaths and only slight morbidity, with the exception of one patient who developed blindness 24 hours after surgery due to central retinal artery occlusion. Fourteen patients were improved cosmetically and one patient, treated early in the series, had persistent proptosis due to inadequate bone removal. No attempt was made to remove tumor within the cavernous sinus in patients who were neurologically normal. Although postoperative imaging demonstrated complete gross excision of tumor in nine patients, 10 underwent conventional radiation therapy for residual tumor visualized at the time of surgery in the dura of the superior orbital fissure, the cavernous sinus, or the basal optic canal. Although this study is inconclusive and requires further long-term documentation, no recurrences have been seen to date in the follow-up period, ranging from 16 to 95 months. The following important points are discussed: 1) the failure by experienced surgeons to radically excise bone, tumor, and involved dura at the first operation; 2) the importance of early aggressive therapy, depending upon the patient's age and medical condition; 3) the almost invariable intracranial dural involvement, which at times was seen only by gadolinium-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging and not visualized on computerized tomography; 4) an illustrated stepwise surgical technique for complete resection through a small craniotomy without the need for complicated reconstruction of the orbit or temporal fossa; 5) the role of radiation therapy when removal is incomplete or deemed hazardous because of cavernous sinus involvement; and 6) the excellent cosmetic results possible with minimal morbidity and no mortality.