CHEMOSENSORY RESPONSES TO AMINO ACIDS AND CERTAIN AMINES BY THE CILIATE TETRAHYMENA: A FLAT CAPILLARY ASSAY

Distinctive chemotactic responses of three marine herbivore protists to DMSP and related compounds

Marine planktonic predator-prey interactions occur in microscale seascapes, where diffusing chemicals may act either as chemotactic cues that enhance or arrest predation, or as elemental resources that are complementary to prey ingestion. The phytoplankton osmolyte dimethylsulfoniopropionate (DMSP) and its degradation products dimethylsulfide (DMS) and acrylate are pervasive compounds with high chemotactic potential, but there is a longstanding controversy over whether they act as grazing enhancers or deterrents. Here, we investigated the chemotactic responses of three herbivorous dinoflagellates to point-sourced, microscale gradients of dissolved DMSP, DMS, and acrylate. We found no evidence for acrylate being a chemotactic repellent and observed a weak attractor role of DMS. DMSP behaved as a strong chemoattractor whose potential for grazing facilitation through effects on swimming patterns and aggregation depends on the grazer's feeding mode and ability to incorporate DMSP. Our study reveals that predation models will fail to predict grazing impacts unless they incorporate chemotaxis-driven searching and finding of prey.

Integrative Neuroscience of Paramecium, a "Swimming Neuron"

Paramecium is a unicellular organism that swims in fresh water by beating thousands of cilia. When it is stimulated (mechanically, chemically, optically, thermally…), it often swims backward then turns and swims forward again. This "avoiding reaction" is triggered by a calcium-based action potential. For this reason, some authors have called Paramecium a "swimming neuron." This review summarizes current knowledge about the physiological basis of behavior of Paramecium.

Learning in single cell organisms

The survival of all species requires appropriate behavioral responses to environmental challenges. Learning is one of the key processes to acquire information about the environment and adapt to changing and uncertain conditions. Learning has long been acknowledged in animals from invertebrates to vertebrates but remains a subject of debate in non-animal systems such a plants and single cell organisms. In this review I will attempt to answer the following question: are single cell organisms capable of learning? I will first briefly discuss the concept of learning and argue that the ability to acquire and store information through learning is pervasive and may be found in single cell organisms. Second, by focusing on habituation, the simplest form of learning, I will review a series of experiments showing that single cell organisms such as slime molds and ciliates display habituation and follow most of the criteria adopted by neuroscientists to define habituation. Then I will discuss disputed evidence suggesting that single cell organisms might also undergo more sophisticated forms of learning such as associative learning. Finally, I will stress out that the challenge for the future is less about whether or not to single cell organisms fulfill the definition of learning established from extensive studies in animal systems and more about acknowledging and understanding the range of behavioral plasticity exhibited by such fascinating organisms.

A computational model for how cells choose temporal or spatial sensing during chemotaxis

Cell size is thought to play an important role in choosing between temporal and spatial sensing in chemotaxis. Large cells are thought to use spatial sensing due to large chemical difference at its ends whereas small cells are incapable of spatial sensing due to rapid homogenization of proteins within the cell. However, small cells have been found to polarize and large cells like sperm cells undergo temporal sensing. Thus, it remains an open question what exactly governs spatial versus temporal sensing. Here, we identify the factors that determines sensing choices through mathematical modeling of chemotactic circuits. Comprehensive computational search of three-node signaling circuits has identified the negative integral feedback (NFB) and incoherent feedforward (IFF) circuits as capable of adaptation, an important property for chemotaxis. Cells are modeled as one-dimensional circular system consisting of diffusible activator, inactivator and output proteins, traveling across a chemical gradient. From our simulations, we find that sensing outcomes are similar for NFB or IFF circuits. Rather than cell size, the relevant parameters are the 1) ratio of cell speed to the product of cell diameter and rate of signaling, 2) diffusivity of the output protein and 3) ratio of the diffusivities of the activator to inactivator protein. Spatial sensing is favored when all three parameters are low. This corresponds to a cell moving slower than the time it takes for signaling to propagate across the cell diameter, has an output protein that is polarizable and has a local-excitation global-inhibition system to amplify the chemical gradient. Temporal sensing is favored otherwise. We also find that temporal sensing is more robust to noise. By performing extensive literature search, we find that our prediction agrees with observation in a wide range of species and cell types ranging from E. coli to human Fibroblast cells and propose that our result is universally applicable.

Unicellular organisms and other single cells often have to migrate towards food sources or away from predators by sensing chemicals present in the environment. There are two ways for a cell to sense these external chemicals: temporal sensing, where the cell senses the external chemical at two different time points after it has moved through a certain distance, or spatial sensing, where the cell senses the external chemical at two different locations on its cellular surface (e.g., the front and rear of the cell) simultaneously. It has been thought that small unicellular organisms employ temporal sensing as their small size prohibits sensing at two different locations on the cellular surface. Using computational modeling, we find that the choice between temporal and spatial sensing is determined by the ratio of cell velocity to the product of cell diameter and rate of signaling, as well as the diffusivities of the signaling proteins. Predictions from our model agree with experimental observations over a wide range of cells, where a fast-moving, small cell performs better comparing the chemoattractant at different times in its trajectory; whereas, a slow-moving, big cell performs better by comparing the chemoattractant concentration at its two ends.

Effect of vasoactive peptides in Tetrahymena: chemotactic activities of adrenomedullin, proadrenomedullin N-terminal 20 peptide (PAMP) and calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP)

Adrenomedullin (AMD), proadrenomedullin N-terminal 20 peptide (PAMP) and calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP) were studied for chemotaxis, chemotactic selection and G-actin/F-actin transition in Tetrahymena. The aim of the experiments was to study the effects of two different peptides encoded by the same gene compared to a peptide related to one of the two, but encoded by a different gene, at a low level of phylogeny. The positive, chemotactic effect of ADM and the strong negative, chemorepellent effect of PAMP suggest that in Tetrahymena, the two peptides elicit their chemotactic effects via different signalling mechanisms. The complexity of swimming behaviour modulated by the three peptides underlines that chemotaxis, chemokinesis and some characteristics of migratory behaviour (velocity, tortuosity) are working as a sub-population level complex functional unit. Chemotactic responsiveness to ADM and CGRP is short-term, in contrast to PAMP, which as a chemorepellent ligand, has the ability to select sub-populations with negative chemotactic responsiveness. The different effects of ADM and PAMP on the polymerization of actin networks show that the microtubular structure of cilia is more essential to chemotactic response than are transitions of the actin network. The results draw attention to the characteristic effects of vasoactive peptides at this low level of phylogeny.

Chloroplast symbiosis in a marine ciliate: ecophysiology and the risks and rewards of hosting foreign organelles

Simultaneous use of both heterotrophic and autotrophic metabolism (“mixotrophy”) is common among protists. Strombidium rassoulzadegani is a planktonic mixotrophic marine ciliate that saves chloroplasts from its algal food and obtains a nutritional subsidy via photosynthesis. Cultures from the northeast, northwest, and southwest Atlantic Ocean show similar numerical response parameters (maximum growth rate, food concentration at which growth is half its maximum, and threshold food concentration for growth), and some isolates have been maintained in vitro for over 3 years. This ciliate grows equally well when fed on the green alga Tetraselmis chui (strain PLY429) or the cryptophyte Rhodomonas lens (strain RHODO). It appears to be an obligate mixotroph, requiring both food and light to achieve positive growth, when feeding on either of these algae. However, it has also been grown for several weeks (>10 generations) heterotrophically on the dinoflagellate Prorocentrum minimum (strain EXUV) during which it grows better in dark than in light. In this paper, we review the ecology of S. rassoulzadegani, discuss some aspects of its photo- and feeding physiology, and speculate on benefits and costs to the ciliate of chloroplast symbiosis.

Chemo-accumulation without changes in membrane potential in the microstome form of the ciliate Tetrahymena vorax

The swimming behaviour of ciliates is mainly determined by membrane potential and transmembrane fluxes. In a chemical gradient, swimming ciliates may approach or move away from the source. Based on experiments on Paramecium, it is generally assumed that chemical attractants and repellents affect the swimming behaviour of ciliates by specific changes in the membrane potential. We have examined whether there is a causal relationship between membrane potential and chemo-accumulation in the microstome form of the polymorphic ciliate Tetrahymena vorax. Effects of chemo-attractants on the membrane potential of Tetrahymena have not been previously reported. Microstome T. vorax cells aggregated close to a point source of l-cysteine and the complex meat hydrolysate proteose peptone. Chemo-accumulated cells displayed a significantly higher turning frequency than control cells at a similar cell density. A concentration of 20 mmol l(-1) l-cysteine did not evoke any detectable change in the membrane potential whereas 1% proteose peptone depolarised the cells by ∼12 mV. This is contrary to the current model, which predicts agents that induce a moderate depolarisation to be repellents. A solution of 1% proteose peptone contains 21 mmol(-1) Na(+). A solution of 21 mmol(-1) NaCl without organic compounds also caused ∼12 mV depolarisation but had no aggregating effect on the cells. Collectively, the electrophysiological and behavioural data indicate that chemo-accumulation in the microstome form of T. vorax is not governed obligatorily by the membrane potential. We thus suggest that the simple membrane potential model for chemokinesis in Paramecium may not be valid for T. vorax.

Chemotactic activity of oligopeptides containing an EWS motif on Tetrahymena pyriformis: the effect of amidation of the C-terminal residue

Chemotactic properties of 3-7-mer peptides containing an EWS motive and their peptide amides synthesized and characterized by us were investigated in Tetrahymena pyriformis GL model. Analysis of the peptide acids shows that SEWS possesses exceptionally strong (660%+/-21; 430%+/-18) chemoattractant ability at 10(-12) and 10(-11) m respectively. The shorter peptide (EWS) possesses chemorepellent activity, while longer peptides display neutral (WSEWS) or moderate chemoattractant (EWSEWS and GEWSEWS) chemotactic ability. Amidation of the C-terminus can significantly modify the character of peptides: it points to the conclusion that a free alpha-COOH group at this position is required for the high efficiency of SEWS, while in the shorter (EWS) and longer peptides (WSEWS and EWSEWS) amidation can result in chemoattractant ligands. Evaluation of the structure-function relationship of these compounds establishes the significance of Glu (E) with its high surface-exposed area and negatively-charged side chain. The high discriminative ability and good chemotactic responsiveness of Tetrahymena support the theory that a chemotactic signalling mechanism working in higher levels of phylogeny is a well conserved and inducible one even in protozoa.

Synthesis of oligopeptides with the sequence SXWS and their chemotactic effects on a ciliated protozoan Tetrahymena pyriformis

In this paper, the solid phase synthesis and chemical characterization of members of an SXWS sub-library (SAWS, SDWS and SKWS) as well as the comparison of their chemotactic properties with those of SEWS, which exhibits a prominent effect at 10(-12) M on a ciliated protozoan, Tetrahymena pyriformis, are described. We found that the chemotaxis of cells induced with the SXWS peptides varied according to the nature of the amino acid residue (Ala, Asp, Lys) in position X. The chemotactic activity of SEWS was not surpassed by any of three new tetrapeptides, although SAWS was also chemoattractant. Interestingly, SDWS, with an acidic side chain at position X, could not elicit any chemotactic response. SKWS, however, showed mild but significant chemorepellent activity over a wide concentration range. Chemotactic selection studies showed that the two chemoattractant peptides (SAWS and SEWS) had an expressed ability to select high-responder offspring cell populations. Peptides with neutral (SDWS) or chemorepellent (SKWS) properties were not able to select such subpopulations from the mixed cultures of Tetrahymena, indicating that the chemotactic response elicited by SXWS peptides is ligand-specific. For ligand-binding experiments N-terminally labelled fluorescent derivatives of SXWS peptides were prepared. applying [4-[7-hydroxycoumaryl]]acetic acid (Hca-OH) or 4-ethoxymethylene-2-[1]-naphthyl-5(4H)-oxazolone (naOx-OEt) as markers. Hca-OH was introduced using an active ester technique as the last step of SPPS, or after cleavage in solution. The oxazolone naOx-OEt reacted with the amino group of the peptide by liberation of EtOH. The binding characteristics of fixed Tetrahymena cells with the naOx-labelled peptides showed good correlation between binding profiles and chemotactic responsiveness (SEWS > SAWS > SDWS - SKWS). A similar binding pattern was observed in the case of Hca-peptides (SEWS > SAWS > SDWS). Hca-SKWS, however, bound remarkably to the cell surface. The binding activity of the Hca-peptides was less pronounced than that of the naOx-peptides, indicating the importance of the fluorophores applied.

Signaling in unicellular eukaryotes

Aspects of intercellular and intracellular signaling systems in cell survival, proliferation, differentiation, chemosensory behavior, and programmed cell death in free-living unicellular eukaryotes have been reviewed. Comparisons have been made with both bacteria and metazoa. The central organisms were flagellates (Trypanosoma, Leishmania, and Crithidia), slime molds (Dictyostelium), yeast cells (Saccharomyces cerevisiae), and ciliates (Paramecium, Euplotes, and Tetrahymena). There are two novel aspects in this review. First, cellular responses are viewed in an evolutionary perspective, rather than from the more prevailing one, in which the unicellular eukaryotes are seen by the mammalian organisms. Second, results obtained with cell cultures in minimal, chemically defined nutrient media at low cell densities where intercellular signaling is strongly reduced are discussed. These results shed light on control mechanisms and their cooperation inside the living cell. Intracellular systems have many common features in unicellular and multicellular organisms.

Effects of L-alanine and L-alanine peptides on the chemotaxis of tetrahymena: evolutionary conclusions

L-alanine and its peptides (L-Ala-2-6) do not attract or repulse Tetrahymena in a 10(-8) M concentration. In 10(-10) M concentration there is a consistent repellent effect. Twenty four hours after L-alanine or L-alanine-peptides' pretreatment (imprinting) the progeny generation of the cells react differently to the same materials. L-Alanine, L-alanine penta- and hexapeptide in both concentrations are chemoattractant, while L-alanine tetrapeptide is repellent. L-Alanine dipeptide is inert in 10(-10) M and repellent at 10(-8) M concentrations, while L-alanine tripeptide is strongly repellent at 10(-10) M and attractant at 10(-8) M concentrations. This means, that the first encounter (imprinting) with an exogenous amino acid or peptide is decisive to the later reaction of the protozoan cell. The chain length is important in the imprinting, however the reaction is not consistent. The experiments call the attention to the significance of imprinting in the receptor and hormone evolution.

Chemorepellents in Paramecium and Tetrahymena

Although Paramecium has been widely used as a model sensory cell to study the cellular responses to thermal, mechanical and chemoattractant stimuli, little is known about their responses to chemorepellents. We have used a convenient capillary tube repellent bioassay to describe 4 different compounds that are chemorepellents for Paramecium and compared their response with those of Tetrahymena. The classical Paramecium t-maze chemokinesis test was also used to verify that this is a reliable chemorepellent assay. The first two compounds, GTP and the oxidant NBT, are known to be depolarizing chemorepellents in Paramecium but this is the first report of them as repellents in Tetrahymena. The second two compounds, the secretagogue alcian blue and the dye cibacron blue, have not previously been described as chemorepellents in either of these ciliates. Two other compounds, the secretagogue AED and the oxidant cytochrome c, were found to be repellents to Paramecium but not to Tetrahymena. The repellent nature of each of these compounds is not related to toxicity because cells are completely viable in all of them. More importantly, all of these repellents are effective at micromolar to nanomolar concentrations, providing an opportunity to use them as excitatory ligands in future works concerning their membrane receptors and possible receptor operated ion channels.

Cilia-mediated oriented chemokinesis in Tetrahymena thermophila

The role of the cilia in the locomotion ("gliding") of Tetrahymena thermophila in a semi-solid medium has been studied when cells were migrating in gradients of attractant. Video recordings and computer-aided motion analysis of migrating cells and their ciliary activity show that Tetrahymena thermophila migrate by swimming forward in semi-solid methyl cellulose, using their cilia. Ciliary reversals occur at certain intervals and cause a termination ("stop") of cellular migration. Cells with reversed cilia resume forward migration when normal ciliary beating resumes. In gradients of attractants, cells migrating towards the attractant suppress ciliary reversals, which leads to longer runs between stops than in control cells. Cells migrating away from the attractant have a higher frequency of ciliary reversals than the control cells resulting in shorter runs. Stimulated cells adapt to a particular ambient concentration of attractant several times during migration in the gradient. Adaptation is followed by de-adaptation, which occurs during the "stop." In the presence of cycloheximide, a strong inhibitor of chemoattraction, the attractant-induced suppression of ciliary reversal is abolished (cells become desensitized to the attractant). It is concluded that Tetrahymena has a short-term memory during adaptation. This is important for the efficiency of migration towards an attractant.

Cortical ultrastructure and chemoreception in ciliated protists (Ciliophora)

The ciliated protists (ciliates) offer a unique opportunity to explore the relationship between chemoreception and cell structure. Ciliates resemble chemosensory neurons in their responses to stimuli and presence of cilia. Ciliates have highly patterned surfaces that should permit precise localization of chemoreceptors in relation to effector organelles. Furthermore, ciliates are easy to grow and to manipulate genetically; they can also be readily studied biochemically and by electrophysiological techniques. This review contains a comparative description of the ultrastructural features of the ciliate cell surface relevant to chemoreception, examines the structural features of putative chemoreceptive cilia, and provides a summary of the electron microscopic information available so far bearing on chemoreceptive aspects of swimming, feeding, excretion, endocytosis, and sexual responses of ciliates. The electron microscopic identification and localization of specific chemoreceptive macromolecules and organelles at the molecular level have not yet been achieved in ciliates. These await the development of specific probes for chemoreceptor and transduction macromolecules. Nevertheless, the electron microscope has provided a wealth of information about the surface features of ciliates where chemoreception is believed to take place. Such morphological information will prove essential to a complete understanding of reception and transduction at the molecular level. In the ciliates, major questions to be answered relate to the apportionment of chemoreceptive functions between the cilia and cell soma, the global distribution of receptors in relation to the anterior-posterior, dorsal-ventral, and left-right axes of the cell, and the relationship of receptors to ultrastructural components of the cell coat, cell membrane, and cytoskeleton.

Chemosensory behaviour of Tetrahymena

Free swimming cells of the ciliated protozoan Tetrahymena are attracted to certain chemicals by chemokinesis. However, a special type of chemotaxis in response to a chemical gradient is found in cells gliding very slowly in semisolid media. In contrast to classical chemotaxis by leukocytes, which is solely positive towards chemo-attractants, the oriented chemokinesis by gliding Tetrahymena involves both positive and negative elements. The major chemo-attractants are peptides and/or proteins, and they may be compounds which signal the presence of food in the natural environment of this freshwater phagotroph.

A paper membrane filter assay for ciliate chemoattraction

A quantitative bioassay for ciliate chemoattraction based on the Boyden assay is described with the ciliates Tetrahymena thermophila and Tetrahymena pyriformis as test organisms. A chamber is separated into two compartments by a Whatman 3MM filter, and a suspension of starved cells (approximately 10(5) cells/ml) is placed in one compartment and a solution containing attractant in the other. The gradient of chemoattractant across the filter causes the cells to swim through the filter into the attractant-containing compartment where their appearance is determined by electronic cell counting. The assay described is convenient with a signal-to-noise ratio of approximately 10. It is shown here to work with the attractants proteose peptone and platelet-derived growth factor.

Stimulation of growth and polyamine biosynthesis of the ciliated protozoan Tetrahymena thermophila. Regulation by L-arginine

Tetrahymena thermophila cells grown in a synthetic nutrient medium for 9 h removed 97% of the free L-arginine but less than 50% of any of the other essential amino acids. The major portion of the arginine was degraded rapidly (76-92%) whereas 5-15% was conserved as intact and only 2.5-10% were incorporated into protein. However, if bovine serum albumin (BSA) was present in the medium as a macromolecular arginine source the incorporation of free arginine into protein was reduced to less than 1% but the degraded fraction was increased. Apparently, the uptake mode of arginine determines its fate: arginine taken up by phagocytosis is bound for protein biosynthesis, arginine taken up by membrane receptors is chanelled to degradation. Media without arginine did not support growth of Tetrahymena. Citrulline and ornithine, the precursors of arginine biosynthesis in yeast and vertebrates, were not able to substitute for arginine. Pronounced morphological changes, e.g. greatly reduced ribosome content, were observed in Tetrahymena cells after 24 h of arginine starvation in otherwise complete medium, but not in cells starved in water, salt solution, or buffer. Thus, arginine is an essential nutrient component for Tetrahymena and the rapid degradation of this compound involving the enzymes arginine deiminase (ADI) and citrulline hydrolase (CH) might be of regulatory importance for the unicellular, as it is the case with acetylcholine and catecholamines in mammalian organisms. Since the product of these enzymes, L-ornithine, is the substrate for the regulatory key enzyme of polyamine biosynthesis, ornithine decarboxylase (ODC), the effects of the presence of absence of arginine on the activities of each particular enzyme of the pathway were studied, including ODC and the enzyme ornithine-oxo-acid aminotransferase (O delta T), which is a competitor of ODC for the common substrate. The arginine-degradative pathway was stimulated by extracellular free but not by peptide-bound arginine and was modulated by extracellular protein which induced phagocytosis; O delta T was stimulated with a time lag. The stimulation of ODC was in a reciprocal relation to the arginine concentration and enhanced by phagocytosis and previous arginine starvation.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

L-glutamate-induced membrane hyperpolarization and behavioural responses in Paramecium tetraurelia

Paramecium tetraurelia is attracted to L-glutamic acid concentrations of 10(-9) M to 10(-4) M in a behavioural assay. Electrophysiological studies show that P. tetaurelia responds to L-glutamate application with hyperpolarization. This response is transient, even in the continued presence of the stimulus. The concentration dependence of the membrane potential response is similar to that of the behavioural responses, although the threshold concentration of L-glutamate required for hyperpolarization is three orders of magnitude lower than for attraction. The membrane potential response to L-glutamate persists following artificial deciliation of P. tetraurelia. While application of L-glutamate to P. tetraurelia invariably elicits a hyperpolarization, withdrawal of the stimulus frequently results in a second transient membrane response, in the form of either a hyperpolarization or a depolarization. It is suggested that these 'off-responses' may have a significant role in maintaining a behavioural response to L-glutamate.

Eukaryotic unicells: how useful in studying chemoreception?

The description of the chemoreception pathway in Paramecium is incomplete, but the technical means are available to study these pathways at the molecular level. The hallmark of ciliates is their versatility and their most important attribute is the availability of useful mutants. It is just this versatility and amenability to genetic manipulation that will move the study of Paramecium chemoreception forward and provide useful information for chemoreceptor cell function in general.

Hormone evolution studies: multiplication promoting and imprinting ("memory") effects of various amino acids on Tetrahymena

Aromatic, heterocyclic, polar and non-polar amino acids were examined for imprinting potential in a unicellular (Tetrahymena) model system. Serine gave rise to positive, glycine to negative imprinting, whereas valine, tryptophan, tyrosine and phenylalanine had no imprinting effect whatever. However, tyrosine and phenylalanine stimulated the division of Tetrahymena already at primary interaction, the former even for a relatively long time. It follows that amino acids, too, can give rise to imprinting, although their imprinting potentials are dissimilar. These phenomena have attracted attention to possible interrelationships between the supposed amino acid receptors of Tetrahymena and the evolution of amino acids to hormones.