Challenges in diagnosis and management of a spiradenocarcinoma: a comprehensive literature review

BACKGROUND

Spiradenocarcinoma is a rare skin adnexal neoplasm that may behave aggressively. It is often associated with a benign slow-growing spiradenoma that has undergone malignant transformation. Given the paucity of cases in the literature, there is a lack of consensus on treatment.

METHODS

The terms 'malignant spiradenoma' or 'spiradenocarcinoma' were systematically used to search the PubMed, MEDLINE and Google Scholar databases. A total of 182 cases of spiradenocarcinoma were identified as eligible for this comprehensive literature review.

RESULTS

Spiradenocarcinoma was commoner in older age and Caucasian race. In most cases, surgical excision for local disease is the mainstay of treatment. Lymph node dissection is usually reserved for those with suspected or confirmed lymph node metastases. High rates of local recurrence (20.8%), metastasis (37.4%) and mortality (19.1%) were identified, prompting some authors to suggest regular follow up including chest X-rays and liver function tests.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with spiradenocarcinoma may benefit from a magnetic resonance imaging and fluorodeoxyglucose-positron emission tomography/computed tomography to establish the extent of disease. We recommend wide local excision as the treatment of choice to achieve surgical margins of ≥1 cm, with node resection to be determined on a case-to-case basis. Regular follow up is important given the high rate of local recurrence, metastasis and mortality. This should include an examination of the regional lymph nodes. Further research is required to refine an evidence-based approach to spiradenocarcinoma.

Spiradenocarcinoma: A Comprehensive Data Review

INTRODUCTION

Spiradenocarcinomas (SCs) are rare and potentially aggressive skin adnexal tumors. Optimal treatment has not yet been established. Experiences with this carcinoma are mostly presented in case reports and few case series.

OBJECTIVE

To generate to a synopsis of published data on SC with regard to diagnostic procedures, treatment, and outcome.

RESULTS

Median patient age was 60 years and sex distribution was balanced. Tumor manifestations were evenly distributed within the sweat gland carrying skin. The most commonly reported symptom was accelerated growth of a longstanding indolent lesion, typically present for more than 2 years. Metastatic spread to the lung, bone, lymph nodes, liver, kidney, and breast has been documented. For staging computed tomography (CT) and positron emission tomography-CT are recommended, especially for detection of hematogenic metastases and lymph node involvement. Clear resection margins and tumor free regional lymph nodes reduce recurrence and carcinoma related death. Although low-grade SCs were reported over 3 times more often, high-grade carcinomas show a greater likelihood for recurrence and lethal outcome.

CONCLUSION

Suspicion of an SC should lead to performance of a magnetic resonance imaging for defining tumor extent, and a fludeoxyglucose positron emission tomography-CT for detection of metastases. Radical tumor excision and resection of tumor involved regional lymph nodes are essential for a curative approach. Histopathological evaluation should involve determination of tumor differentiation grade, because high-grade carcinomas seem to have a much more aggressive behavior. Excision of distant metastases has no therapeutic value. Follow-up needs to be carried out in short intervals with frequent imaging.

Low-grade cylindromatous adnexal carcinoma with unusual histopathological features: report of a case with comparative immunohistochemical study and meta-analysis of the literature

We present an extremely rare case of low-grade cylindromatous adnexal carcinoma (CAC) on the right chest wall of a 77-year-old man. Histopathologically, the neoplasm was initially diagnosed as a cylindroma that developed over the course of 13 years. A diagnosis of low-grade CAC was rendered after the documentation of a local recurrence and histopathology of the recurrent tumor. To further assess the evolution of low-grade CAC over time, we compared the morphology, mitotic account, proliferative markers and adhesion molecule immunoreactivity among paired primary and recurrent tumors. Unlike those earlier reported, our case showed the maintenance of tumor morphology after a recurrence without areas of obvious malignant transformation or metaplastic change. We showed here for the first time the expression of adhesion molecules of CAC/spiradenoma and a comparison of proliferation indices between a primary tumor and its local recurrence. This peculiar tumor differs from previously reported cases and harbors a malignant potential although the histopathological features of malignancy are subtle. Our meta-analysis of the literature provided background information regarding this rare entity. Alterations of E-cadherin and GCDFP-15 expression may provide additional helpful clues in differential diagnosis and determining the clinical behavior of this unusual neoplasm. Further studies are warranted to confirm the potential discriminative role of these markers.

Morphologically low-grade spiradenocarcinoma: a clinicopathologic study of 19 cases with emphasis on outcome and MYB expression

Spiradenocarcinoma is a rare skin adnexal neoplasm with potential for aggressive behavior, classified histologically into low- and high-grade tumors. Morphologically, low-grade tumors are thought to behave more favorably. Limited information is available, however, with only 18 published cases. To study their clinical behavior, histological features, and the diagnostic value of immunohistochemistry, 19 morphologically low-grade spiradenocarcinomas were retrieved and compared with 21 spiradenomas and cylindromas. H&E-stained sections were reviewed, follow-up was obtained, and immunohistochemistry for Ki-67, p53 and, MYB was performed. The tumors were solitary, measuring 0.8-7 cm (median: 2.7 cm), with a predilection for the head and neck of elderly patients (median age: 72 years; range 53-92) without gender bias. Histologically, the tumors were multinodular and located in deep dermis and subcutis. A pre-existing spiradenoma was present in all cases. The malignant component was characterized by expansile growth with loss of the dual cell population, up to moderate cytological atypia and increased mitotic activity (median: 10/10 HPF; range 1-28). Additional findings included squamoid differentiation (n=9), necrosis (n=7), and ulceration (n=5). P53 expression was variable and no significant differences were noted in the benign compared with the malignant parts of the tumors. In contrast, in the malignant components the Ki-67 proliferative index was slightly increased, and MYB expression was lost. Follow-up (median: 67 months; range: 13-132) available for 16 patients (84%) revealed a local recurrence rate of 19% but no metastases or disease-related mortality. In this large study with long-term follow-up, we demonstrate that spiradenocarcinomas with low-grade morphology pursue an indolent course, characterized by local recurrence only. Metastases and disease-related mortality appear to be exceptional. Lack of MYB expression may be useful as an additional aid in the diagnosis of these challenging tumors.