Pattern of cervical biopsy results in cases with cervical cytology interpreted as higher than low grade in the background with atrophic cellular changes

Performance of P16INK4a immunocytochemical stain in facilitating cytology interpretation of HSIL for HPV-positive women aged 50 and above

Background

Few articles have focused on the cytological misinterpretation of high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion (HSIL). Due to estrogen deficiency, cervical epithelial cells in postmenopausal women tend to show atrophic change that looks like HSIL on Papanicolaou-stained cytology slides, resulting in a higher rate of cytological misinterpretation. P16INK4a immunocytochemical staining (P16 cytology) can effectively differentiate diseased cells from normal atrophic ones with less dependence on cell morphology.

Objective

To evaluate the role of P16 cytology in differentiating cytology HSIL from benign atrophy in women aged 50 years and above.

Methods

Included in this analysis were women in a cervical cancer screening project conducted in central China who tested positive for high-risk human papillomavirus (hr-HPV) and returned back for triage with complete data of primary HPV testing, liquid-based cytology (LBC) analysis, P16 immuno-stained cytology interpretation, and pathology diagnosis. The included patients were grouped by age: ≥50 (1,127 cases) and <50 years (1,430 cases). The accuracy of LBC and P16 cytology in the detection of pathology ≥HSIL was compared between the two groups, and the role of P16 immuno-stain in differentiating benign cervical lesions from cytology ≥HSIL was further analyzed.

Results

One hundred sixty-seven women (14.8%; 167/1,127) in the ≥50 group and 255 (17.8%, 255/1,430) in the <50 group were pathologically diagnosed as HSIL (Path-HSIL). LBC [≥Atypical Squamous Cell Of Undetermined Significance (ASCUS)] and P16 cytology (positive) respectively detected 63.9% (163/255) and 90.2% (230/255) of the Path-≥HSIL cases in the <50 group and 74.3% (124/167) and 93.4% (124/167) of the Path-≥HSIL cases in the ≥50 group. LBC matched with pathology in 105 (41.2%) of the 255 Path-≥HSIL cases in the <50 group and 93 (55.7%) of the 167 Path-≥HSIL cases in the ≥50 group. There were five in the <50 group and 14 in the ≥50 group that were Path-≤LSIL cases, which were interpreted by LBC as HSIL, but negative in P16 cytology.

Conclusion

P16 cytology facilitates differentiation of Path-≤LSIL from LBC-≥HSIL for women 50 years of age and above. It can be used in the lower-resource areas, where qualified cytologists are insufficient, as the secondary screening test for women aged ≥50 to avoid unnecessary biopsies and misinterpretation of LBC primary or secondary screening.

Challenging lesions in cervical cytology: The elusive HSIL

Cervical cytology has been an integral part of cervical cancer screening since the mid-20th century with the implementation of screening protocols utilising Pap testing. During that time, cervical cancer has gone from the leading cause of cancer deaths in women to not even appearing in the top 10 causes of US cancer deaths. However, despite its long and widespread use, cervical cytology remains a diagnostically challenging area in the practice of cytopathology. Of particular importance for diagnosticians is the accurate diagnosis of high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions (HSILs), given the significant risk of progression to invasive cervical cancer and the importance to patient management. Therefore, this review is presented in order to highlight the diagnostic features of HSIL, its various appearances, and important benign and neoplastic differential considerations with an emphasis on morphological clues that can aid in distinguishing between these different processes.

Prevalence of Positive Cervical Cancer Screening Tests Past the Age of 65 Years With Prior Adequate Negative Screening

OBJECTIVES

Cervical cancer screening recommendations suggest that cessation can be offered above the age of 65 years if specific prior negative screening criteria are met. We investigated the prevalence of abnormal results in individuals who continue screening despite satisfying the American Society for Colposcopy and Cervical Pathology guidelines for cessation.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In this retrospective study, medical records 2008-2019 from a single urban hospital-based clinic were queried. Charts were manually reviewed to determine which patients met the American Society for Colposcopy and Cervical Pathology exit criteria but continued screening. Findings detected during the extended surveillance period beyond the age of 65 years were analyzed.

RESULTS

Two hundred ninety-six patients met the criteria of additional screening despite meeting guidelines for cessation. Length of the continued additional surveillance period ranged from 1 to 15 years with a mean of 3.98 years and median of 3 years. Thirty-nine individuals had abnormalities during additional surveillance: 25 high-risk human papillomavirus (HR-HPV) positive only with negative cytology, 8 atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance, 3 low-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions, 2 atypical glandular cells of undetermined significance, and 1 high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion. No cases of cervical cancer were detected. Total rate of abnormalities including HR-HPV positive only was 332.20 per 10,000 person-years, and cytologic abnormalities alone at 119.25 per 10,000 person-years.

CONCLUSIONS

Most findings were HR-HPV positive with negative cytology, which studies suggest may confer low risk of progression in older individuals. In addition, no patient was found to develop cervical malignancy. Despite controversy regarding this recommendation, our data suggest screening cessation may be appropriate with adequate negative screening history.