Campylobacter pylori in peptic ulcer disease. II. Endoscopic findings and cultivation of C. pylori

Review article: Helicobacter pylori-negative duodenal ulcer disease

BACKGROUND

Helicobacter pylori infection rates in duodenal ulcer (DU) patients may be lower than previously estimated.

AIM

To review the real prevalence of H. pylori-negative DUs and its possible causes.

METHODS

Bibliographical searches in MEDLINE looking for the terms 'H. pylori' and 'duodenal ulcer'.

RESULTS

Mean prevalence of H. pylori infection in DU disease, calculated from studies published during the last 10 years including a total of 16 080 patients, was 81%, and this figure was lower (77%) when only the last 5 years were considered. Associations with H. pylori-negative DU were: (1) False negative results of diagnostic methods, (2) NSAID use (21% in studies with <90% infection rate), (3) Complicated DU (bleeding, obstruction, perforation), (4) Smoking, (5) Isolated H. pylori duodenal colonization, (6) Older age, (7) Gastric hypersecretion, (8) Diseases of the duodenal mucosa, (9) Helicobacter'heilmanii' infection and (10) Concomitant diseases.

CONCLUSION

In patients with H. pylori-negative DU disease, one should carefully confirm that the assessment of H. pylori status is reliable. In truly H. pylori-negative patients, the most common single cause of DU is, by far, the use of NSAIDs. Ulcers not associated with H. pylori, NSAIDs or other obvious causes should, for the present, be viewed as 'idiopathic'. True idiopathic DU disease only exceptionally exists.

Helicobacter pylori-coccoid forms and biofilm formation

Electron microscopic studies have shown that Helicobacter pylori occurs in three stages: spiral forms, coccoid forms and degenerative forms. The spiral forms are viable, culturable, virulent and can colonize experimental animals and induce inflammation. The coccoid forms may also be viable but are nonculturable, less virulent and are less likely to colonize and induce inflammation in experimental animals than the spiral forms. The degenerative forms are pyknotic, nonculturable, coccoid forms of dead H. pylori. These forms cannot be cultured and the cell membrane has disintegrated but gene material can be detected by PCR in water supplies. There is no substantial evidence for viable H. pylori persisting in water supplies. Epidemiological studies suggest that environmental water is a risk factor for H. pylori infection when compared with tap water, and formation of H. pylori biofilm cannot be excluded. Helicobacter pylori does not seem to take part in biofilm formation in the oral cavity even though the bacterium may be detected.

The effect of omeprazole dosing on the isolation of Helicobacter pylori from gastric aspirates

BACKGROUND

Animal experiments suggest that omeprazole dosing increases shedding of Helicobacter into the gastric lumen, and hence into gastric juice.

AIM

To assess the effect of omeprazole dosing on the yield of H. pylori from gastric aspirates of infected volunteers.

METHODS

Six serial nasogastric aspirates, three before and three during dosing with omeprazole 40 mg b.d., were obtained for culture from 10 H. pylori infected volunteers and one uninfected volunteer. To reduce contamination, samples were diluted 1:10 with Maximum Recovery Diluent (MRD; pH 7.0) or HCl-KCl buffer (pH 2.2) prior to culture on Columbia and Dent's agar.

RESULTS

Undiluted gastric juice cultures were rapidly overgrown by upper respiratory tract flora. HCl-KCl dilution resulted in isolation of H. pylori from 77% of infected subject aspirates before, and 67% of aspirates during dosing with omeprazole. The yields were significantly lower with MRD dilution, 47% and 10%, respectively. Omeprazole dosing significantly decreased the yield after MRD dilution, but not after HCl-KCl dilution.

CONCLUSIONS

Decreasing intragastric acidity, by dosing with omeprazole, decreases the isolation of H. pylori from routinely processed gastric aspirates. In vitro acidification of gastric aspirates, by HCl-KCl dilution, increases the isolation of H. pylori both before and during omeprazole dosing.

Development of a PCR-based technique for detection of Helicobacter pylori

A primer-set was designed for specific detection of genes that encode for 16S rRNA of Helicobacter pylori, using direct polymerase chain reaction (PCR). The primers were selected in the hypervariable regions, derived from a complete small subunit 16S rRNA sequence of the reference strain H. pylori CCUG 17874. The primer-set amplified a 537 base pair (bp) sequence specifically from chromosomal H. pylori DNA. Amplification of purified chromosomal H. pylori DNA was achieved at concentrations as low as 1 femto gram (fg), equivalent to 5 bacteria. Furthermore, as few as 1 lysed H. pylori cell was detected by this PCR technique. The specificity of the primers was 100%, since purified chromosomal DNA was detected from all 32 various H. pylori isolates, whereas no other bacteria species were detected, whether related to Helicobacter or not. The 16S rDNA primers successfully detected H. pylori in antral biopsy specimens collected from infected patients.

Helicobacter pylori infection in north-eastern peninsular Malaysia. Evidence for an unusually low prevalence

The prevalence of Helicobacter pylori infection was determined in peptic ulcer patients, in non-ulcer dyspepsia (NUD) patients, and in the general adult population. The H. pylori infection rate ascertained by microbiologic examination of multiple gastric antral biopsy specimens was 50% (17 of 34) in duodenal ulcer (DU), 5% (1 of 22) in gastric ulcer, and 9% (15 of 159) in NUD patients. A seroepidemiologic survey showed a prevalence of only 4.2% among 496 blood donors and 4.8% among 921 subjects who attended health screening clinics. H. pylori infection is relatively uncommon and does not appear to be the predominant factor in the pathogenesis of peptic ulcer disease in the area. The incidence of peptic ulcer perforations in the area in 1991-92 was 1.5 per 100,000 person-years, reflecting a relatively low frequency of peptic ulcers, which might be due to the low prevalence of H. pylori infection in the population.

Evaluation of eight commercial kits for Helicobacter pylori IgG antibody detection

Eight commercial kits and an in-house ELISA for detection of IgG antibodies against Helicobacter pylori were evaluated for their use in diagnosis of H. pylori infection and in epidemiological research: Helico-GTM (Porton-Cambridge), G. A. P. test (Bio-Rad), H. pylori antibodies ELISA (Biometra), Anti-H. pylori IgG EIA (Roche), 2nd generation H. pylori EIA (Roche), Anti-H. pylori MTP-assay (Roche), Pylori stat test kit (Whittaker), Pyloriset latex agglutination kit (Orion), and the in-house ELISA based on heat-stable antigens. Fifty-four patients with dyspepsia (31 H. pylori positive by culture or microscopy) and 68 asymptomatic persons were tested. Sensitivities for the eight kits were 71%, 77%, 90%, 84%, 87%, 94%, 90%, 87%, and 87%, specificities were 74%, 65%, 74%, 74%, 83%, 83%, 70%, 65%, and 65%, respectively. For epidemiological use the estimated seroprevalence varied within approximately 15% in all age groups. Sensitivities and specificities obtained in different studies reveal as great differences in the results with the same kit as between results obtained with different kits in the same study. Kits with the highest sensitivities tend to be the same in all studies. It is therefore more important to test a kit in the population to which it is to be applied than to choose a specific kit.

Is Helicobacter pylori a cause of duodenal ulcer? A methodologic critique of current evidence

INTRODUCTION

Helicobacter pylori (HP) in the gastric antrum has been strongly associated with both duodenal ulcer (DU) and chronic active gastritis (CAG). The relationship between HP and DU has been interpreted as causal by many observers. An alternate hypothesis is that HP coincidently colonizes CAG, which is independently associated with DU by some yet-unknown mechanism.

PURPOSE

To assess the extent to which a causal relationship between HP and DU has been demonstrated, we performed a methodologic critique of published clinical studies. We carried out a literature search to identify clinical studies that included at least 25 subjects. Of the eight studies we identified, six used a cross-sectional design and two used a prospective cohort design. We applied methodologic criteria to assess causation: strength of association, biologic gradient, temporality, and experiment.

METHODS

A strong association between HP and DU was demonstrated in all eight studies. Biologic gradient and temporality were not assessed in any study. In the two experimental studies of therapy, loss of antral HP was associated with a decreased rate of DU relapse; however, we did not interpret this as sufficient to support causality because the effect may have been due to a direct mucosal action rather than eradication of HP.

CONCLUSION

We conclude that published evidence does not establish HP as a cause of DU. One approach to address causality would be an observational cohort study of ulcer relapse to assess the temporal relationships between HP, CAG, and DU.

The Helicobacter (Campylobacter) pylori-colonized duodenal mucosa and gastric metaplasia

Biopsies were obtained from non-ulcerated sites of the duodenum from 100 dyspeptic patients. Helicobacter (Campylobacter) pylori was cultivated from 19 of these biopsies. Active chronic duodenitis (ACD) was found in 17 biopsies and more than 5% gastric metaplasia in 20 biopsies. H. pylori as well as ACD occurred with a significantly increased frequency when more than 5% gastric metaplasia was found in the duodenal biopsies. H. pylori on metaplastic tissue without ACD was, however, seen in two cases. H. pylori was cultivated from 9% and ACD was found in 5% of the biopsies with less than 5% gastric metaplasia. Gastric metaplasia in the duodenum was found significantly more frequently in patients with endoscopic duodenitis or duodenal ulceration than in patients with normal endoscopy. No association between gastric metaplasia in the duodenum and gastric pH or serum antibodies against H. pylori was seen. This study indicates that there is an established, but not exclusive, connection between gastric metaplasia and the colonization of the duodenum by H. pylori, the most important role being played by the antral gastric mucosa rather than the duodenum.

Possible evidence of invasiveness of Helicobacter (Campylobacter) pylori

Gastric/duodenal biopsy material from 52 patients was examined immunohistochemically for Helicobacter (Campylobacter) pylori. Specimens from 34 of the patients harboured Helicobacter pylori along the mucosal surface and 13 of these featured, in addition, immunopositive material within the lamina propria. The remaining 18 biopsies were non-reactive. This observation suggests that Helicobacter pylori can penetrate the epithelium and its basement membrane, resulting in the production of specific systemic antibodies.

Campylobacter pylori and gastroduodenal ulcer disease. A prospective study in a Swedish population

In a consecutive prospective series of 208 Swedish primary peptic ulcer patients, 146 gastric, 55 duodenal and 7 in both sites, gastroduodenitis was found in 97.6% of the cases. The mucosal inflammation was associated with CP in 87% and 91% of the gastric and duodenal ulcer cases respectively. No significant correlation was found between CP colonisation and the type or severity of mucosal inflammation. Gastric metaplasia was present in only 8% of 48 bulbar ulcer cases. Ulcer healing and eradication of CP was achieved in 52% of patients treated with bismuth subnitrate in combination with erythromycin or according to the triple approach.