A comparison of sucralfate and prednisolone enemas in the treatment of active distal ulcerative colitis

Evaluation of the anti-inflammatory and antioxidant effects of the sucralfate in diversion colitis

Sucralfate enemas present good results in the treatment of colitis, however the mechanism of action of the drug is not yet fully clarified.

Objective To evaluate the anti-inflammatory and antioxidant effects of sucralfate enemas in diversion colitis model.

Method Thirty-six Wistar rats underwent intestinal bypass by end colostomy in the descending colon and distal mucous fistula. The animals were divided into 3 experimental groups according to the daily dose of enemas received containing 0.9% SF, sucralfate enemas or sucralfate enemas 1 g/kg/day or 2 g/kg/day. Each group was divided into two subgroups according to euthanasia to be performed 2–4 weeks after derivation. The tissue grade of inflammation was assessed histologically, and neutrophil infiltration by the tissue expression of myeloperoxidase (MPO) identified by immunohistochemistry and quantified by computerized morphometry. Oxidative stress was measured by tissue levels of malondialdehyde (MDA). To compare the results the Student's t test variance was used, and also the variance by ANOVA test, establishing a level of significance of 5% (p < 0.05) for both.

Results The intervention with sucralfate enemas showed improvement in the intensity of tissue inflammation related to the concentration used and the duration of the intervention. Intervention with sucralfate enemas reduced the tissue levels of MPO, independent of concentration or time of intervention (p < 0.01). There was a reduction of MDA levels in animals irrigated with sucralfate enemas, independent of concentration or duration of the intervention (p < 0.01).

Conclusion Enemas with sucralfate enemas reduce inflammation, neutrophil infiltration and oxidative stress in the excluded colon suggesting topical application of the substance to be a valid therapeutic option for the treatment of diversion colitis.

ENEMA DE SULCRALFATO PODE PREVENIR COLITE EM SEGMENTOS COLÔNICOS SEM TRÂNSITO FECAL?

RESUMO - RACIONAL: O estresse oxidativo é um dos principais mecanismos associados à ruptura dos mecanismos de defesa que formam a barreira epitelial cólica e reduz o conteúdo tecidual das proteínas claudina-3 e ocludina principais constituintes das junções de oclusão intercelulares. O sucralfato, possui atividade antioxidante e tem sido usado para tratar diferentes formas de colite. OBJETIVO: Mensurar o conteúdo tecidual de claudina-3 e ocludina da mucosa do cólon sem trânsito fecal, submetido à intervenção com sucralfato. MÉTODO: Trinta e seis ratos foram submetidos à colostomia do cólon esquerdo e fístula mucosa distal. Os animais foram divididos em dois grupos de acordo com a eutanásia ser realizada duas ou quatro semanas após a intervenção. Cada grupo foi dividido em três subgrupos de acordo com o tipo de intervenção realizada diariamente: solução salina isolada; sucralfato a 1 g/kg/dia ou sucralfato a 2g/kg/dia. A colite foi diagnosticada por análise histológica adotando escala de validação prévia. A expressão tecidual de ambas as proteínas foi identificada por imunoistoquímica. O conteúdo das proteínas foi quantificado por análise de imagem assistida por computador. RESULTADOS: O escore inflamatório foi maior nos segmentos cólicos sem trânsito fecal e os enemas com sucralfato reduziram o escore inflamatório nesses segmentos, principalmente nos animais submetidos à intervenção com sucralfato em maior concentração e por período mais longo de intervenção. Houve aumento no conteúdo tecidual das proteínas claudina-3 e ocludina, relacionado com a concentração de sucralfato. O conteúdo tecidual de ambas as proteínas não se modificou com a duração da intervenção. CONCLUSÃO: Enemas com sucralfato reduzem a inflamação e aumentam o conteúdo tecidual de claudina-3 e ocludina na mucosa cólica sem trânsito intestinal.

Glucocorticosteroids in the treatment of inflammatory bowel disease and approaches to minimizing systemic activity

Inflammatory bowel diseases (IBDs) are a group of inflammatory conditions characterized by chronic, uncontrolled inflammation of the gastrointestinal tract. Reported prevalence is high in the United States and northern Europe, while the incidence varies greatly across the rest of Europe. Glucocorticosteroids are the standard treatment for IBD, but due to adverse events their use can be limited. However, new formulations of glucocorticosteroids have been developed to reduce systemic activation. The aim of this review was to assess and summarize the efficacy and safety of new formulations of glucocorticosteroids. A MEDLINE search identified publications focused on new formulations of nonsystemic steroid-based drugs for IBD and benefits and limitations of each of the new glucocorticosteroid formulations were identified. Budesonide has good efficacy and is an established treatment for Crohn's disease; it has been shown to be beneficial for the induction of remission in these patients, although it is not recommended for the maintenance of induced remission. Glucocorticosteroids are not recommended for the maintenance of remission in patients with IBD. However, a recent study suggested that beclomethasone dipropionate may be effective for prolonged treatment in patients in the postacute phase of Crohn's disease who were treated with a short course of systemic steroids. The efficacy of fluticasone propionate and prednisolone metasulphobenzoate in IBD is not well established given the small number of patients enrolled in the few published clinical trials. While the tolerability of these glucocorticosteroids is favourable, more research comparing these new agents with traditional systemic glucocorticosteroids is warranted.

Topical sucralfate in the management of peristomal skin disease: an open study

Dermatoses affecting the skin around stoma sites are common and difficult to treat. We have investigated the effectiveness of topical sucralfate in the management of peristomal dermatoses in adults using an open study design. Apart from forming a physical barrier to further irritation, sucralfate binds to basic fibroblast growth factor preventing its degradation and thereby promotes healing. In eight out of nine patients with faecal or urine erosions, daily, topical sucralfate treatment was associated with healing within 4 weeks. There was limited or no response to treatment in a further nine patients with traumatic ulcers, excoriated dermatitis or pyoderma gangrenosum. Topical sucralfate represents a safe, inexpensive and effective therapeutic intervention, particularly for those patients with high output or short stomas where repeated stoma leakage may be unavoidable.

A meta-analysis and overview of the literature on treatment options for left-sided ulcerative colitis and ulcerative proctitis

OBJECTIVES

Therapeutic trials in left-sided ulcerative colitis (L-UC) and ulcerative proctitis (UP) have lacked control for medication type, dose, delivery, and duration of therapy.

METHODS

All published therapeutic articles and abstracts in L-UC or UP from 1958-1997 were reviewed. Improvement, remission rates, and adverse events were recorded for all (ALL), placebo-controlled (PC) studies, and for PC studies passing quality assessment (QA) scoring. Meta-analysis was used where appropriate.

RESULTS

Left-sided UC: For active disease, 67 studies (17 PC; 10 QA) were identified. Mesalamine enemas achieved remission in a duration but not a dose response (QA), with higher remission rates than steroid enemas (ALL) and clinical improvement rates superior to oral therapies (QA, ALL). Remission maintenance: 17 (six PC, six QA) studies were identified. Mesalamine therapies had comparable remission rates at 6 months, with a possible dose but not delivery effect. Mesalamine enema dosing intervals between QHS to Q3 days maintained efficacy. Reported adverse events were most common with oral sulfasalazine and dose-independent for mesalamine. Withdrawals from therapy were less than placebo, or < or =3%. Ulcerative proctitis: For active disease, 18 (nine PC, three QA) studies were identified. Mesalamine suppositories achieved clinical improvement and remission in a duration but not dose response, with higher rates of remission than topical steroids (ALL). Remission maintenance: three (three PC, two QA) studies were identified. Remission ranged from 75% to 90% (6 months) and 61-90% (12 months) for mesalamine agents. Reported adverse events were most common for mesalamine foam (8%). Withdrawals from therapy were <2%.

CONCLUSIONS

In L-UC and UP, the efficacy and side-effect profile of topical mesalamine are dose independent and superior to oral therapies and topical steroids. Economic analysis suggests that use of these agents will also result in an overall decrease in patient costs.

A case of sclerosing cholangitis managed by a percutaneous approach

In 1992, a 61-year-old man who complained of recurrent episodes of fever and jaundice was diagnosed as having sclerosing cholangitis. In the three years that followed, the clinical picture progressively worsened; and, in 1995, the patient was hospitalized again for biliary obstruction. A liver transplantation was excluded because of concomitant severe coronary heart disease. A percutaneous transhepatic cholangiogram showed several critical strictures of the intrahepatic biliary tree and a temporary internal-external biliary drainage was placed to relieve the obstruction. After 40 days, a two-step percutaneous biliary balloon dilation was performed followed by topical steroid treatment through the catheter. After 45 days, the catheter was removed and steroid treatment tapered orally. In the three years that followed, the patient was well. He experienced only about 1-2 episodes of ascending cholangitis per year requiring antimicrobial therapy. Laboratory analysis showed a gradual improvement in hepatic chemistry, serum bilirubin, and erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR). In our patient, the association of percutaneous balloon dilation and topical steroid treatment improved both the clinical and radiological picture, without significant side-effects. This approach should be considered a valuable and cost-effective option in primary sclerosing cholangitis, mainly for patients not eligible for liver transplantation.

Treatment of radiation-induced proctitis with sucralfate enemas

OBJECTIVE

To report a case of radiation-induced proctitis treated with sucralfate enemas.

CASE SUMMARY

A 77-year-old white woman was transferred from an acute care institution to our inpatient rehabilitation unit with impaired mobility and reduced activities of daily living. Her condition was secondary to myopathy and peripheral neuropathy associated with postradiation chemotherapy and metastatic ovarian carcinoma. During her stay, she developed hematochezia and pain secondary to a diagnosis of radiation-induced proctitis. Her hemoglobin had reached a nadir of 7.3 g/dL. The patient received blood transfusions and was started on 10% w/v sucralfate retention enemas 2 g/20 mL daily for 12 consecutive days. She was symptom-free at discharge, with a stable hemoglobin of approximately 10 g/dL.

DISCUSSION

Proctitis is a common adverse effect of radiotherapy to the lower abdomen and pelvic area. Sucralfate is an aluminum complex that acts as a local cytoprotective agent against ulceration of the gastrointestinal mucosal lining. Rectal administration of sucralfate, as described in our patient and reported in published case studies, may provide an alternative therapy for patients with radiation-induced proctitis.

CONCLUSIONS

Sucralfate suspension enemas provide a viable treatment option in patients who are intolerant of, refractory to, or not candidates for standard therapy for radiation-induced proctitis.

Influence of topical rectal application of drugs on dextran sulfate-induced colitis in rats

A rat model of colitis [dextran sulfate (DSS)] was used to study the permeation of Evans blue (EB) from the lumen into the wall of proximal and distal colonic loops after exposure to the dye for 2 hr. Topical application of drugs used in human ulcerative colitis (lidocaine, mesalazine, prednisolone, or sucralfate) was given daily during induction of colitis to protect the mucosa. The mucosal changes were evaluated with special regard to peptidergic innervation [substance P (SP) and neuropeptide Y (NPY)], invasion of antigen-presenting polydendritic cells, and mucin-containing goblet cells. DSS-treatment caused a significantly increased permeation of EB. In the proximal loops a significant inhibition was obtained after treatment with lidocaine, prednisolone, or sucralfate. In the distal loops only treatment with lidocaine had a preventive effect. Immunocytochemically there was a clear hyperplasia of both mucosal SP- and NPY-immunoreactive nerve fibers in regions with crypt abnormalities. In these regions also most of the goblet cells were devoid of mucus. Like the changes in permeation, these morphological changes were most prominent in the distal loops. With induction of colitis, the mucosa and lamina propria were invaded by polydendritic cells; the visual score was markedly decreased in the proximal loops treated with lidocaine, prednisolone, or sucralfate. In the distal loops similar effects were obtained after treatment with lidocaine or prednisolone. Prevention of the influx of antigens in both loops after lidocaine treatment with reduced recruitment of polydendritic cells into the lamina propria is suggested. The nerve hyperplasia may thus be secondary to luminal challenge with antigens during induction of colitis. The discrepancy between increased permeation and absence of polydendritic cell response in the distal loops after prednisolone may reflect separate actions of steroids on the intestinal epithelium and the immune cells.

Medical management of chronic inflammatory bowel disease

In the absence of a definitive cure for Crohn's disease and ulcerative colitis, the aim of therapy must be to induce and maintain clinical remission at acceptable cost to the patient in terms of adverse effects. Despite the differences in their pathogenesis, the first-line treatments for Crohn's disease and ulcerative colitis are still based upon combinations of amino-salicylic acid derivatives and corticosteroids, although the use of enteral nutrition regimes is becoming increasingly widespread in Crohn's disease. In this chapter we attempt to provide reasonably didactic guidance for the management of most cases of chronic inflammatory bowel disease. However, we have tried to go beyond this brief, motivated by the recent explosion in knowledge of inflammatory mechanisms, to suggest a rational approach to the choice of newer and less well tested therapeutic approaches in the affected child who is not responding effectively. The relative failure of cyclosporine therapy in Crohn's disease has been particularly disappointing in view of its ideal theoretical suitability. However, the encouraging early reports of treatment with anti-CD4 and anti-TNF alpha monoclonals suggest that the shift from broad spectrum immunomodulation to the targeting of critical components of the inflammatory cascade may yet field important dividends.

Medical management of severe inflammatory disease of the rectum and distal colon: non-nutritional aspects

Rectal bleeding is the cardinal symptom in patients with inflammation of the rectum, and initial management must be directed at establishing an underlying diagnosis. In many patients in the Western World this will be idiopathic inflammatory bowel disease, although in all cases other causes such as infection must be excluded. Idiopathic proctitis is usually due to either ulcerative colitis or Crohn's disease, and in both conditions corticosteroids, either systemic or topical, provide the mainstay of treatment. The 5-aminosalicylic acid drugs are helpful in both acute and maintenance treatment, again given either systemically or topically, while metronidazole is of value in patients with Crohn's disease. In those with refractory proctitis alternative agents such as azathioprine, immunomodulating drugs and barrier agents may be useful. Severe inflammation of the rectum secondary to pelvic irradiation will also usually respond to topical steroid therapy, although sucralfate enemas may be equally successful; in resistant cases other treatments may be needed. Infective proctitis, when diagnosed, may require treatment with specific antimicrobial agents.

Inflammatory bowel disease: medical therapy revisited

The chronic or recurrent immunologic and inflammatory response in ulcerative colitis and Crohn's disease may be initiated from the gut lumen. Deviation of gut contents away from the inflamed area, bowel rest, or the use of liquid diets appears to benefit Crohn's disease. The relative effects of complete bowel rest, or an elemental, hydrolysed, or polymeric liquid diet have not yet been established. Measures to alter the lumenal bacterial flora, including antibiotics, require further study. The use of corticosteroid drugs can be improved by the use of poorly absorbed or rapidly metabolized compounds. Amino-salicylates are effective in ulcerative colitis but require further study in Crohn's disease. Immunosuppressive drugs are valuable not only for a steroid sparing effect but also for control of chronic inflammation. New treatments designed to reduce inflammation are promising but will need to have high potency and an effect at the earliest stages of inflammation before a large number of different inflammatory mediators are released.