Metastatic Papillary Thyroid Carcinoma Presenting as Abducens Palsy Complicated by Ocular Neuromyotonia

Gamma knife radiosurgery for clival metastasis: case series and systematic review

PURPOSE

Clival metastatic cancer is rare and has limited literature to guide management. We describe management of clival metastasis with Gamma Knife radiosurgery (GKRS). We augment our findings with a systematic review of all forms of radiation therapy for clival metastasis.

METHODS

Records of 14 patients with clival metastasis who underwent GKRS at the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center from 2002 to 2023 were reviewed. Treatment parameters and clinical outcomes were assessed. A systematic review was conducted using evidence-based guidelines.

RESULTS

The average age was 61 years with male predominance (n = 10) and average follow-up of 12.4 months. The most common primary cancers were prostate (n = 3) and lung (n = 3). The average time from cancer diagnosis to clival metastasis was 34 months. The most common presenting symptoms were headache (n = 9) and diplopia (n = 7). Five patients presented with abducens nerve palsies, and two presented with oculomotor nerve palsies. The median tumor volume was 9.3 cc, and the median margin dose was 15 Gy. Eleven patients achieved tumor control after one procedure, and three with progression obtained tumor control after repeat GKRS. One patient recovered abducens nerve function. The median survival from cancer diagnosis and GKRS were 49.7 and 15.3 months, respectively. The cause of death was progression of systemic cancer in six patients, clival metastasis in one, and unknown in four. The systematic review included 31 studies with heterogeneous descriptions of treatment and outcomes.

CONCLUSION

Clival metastasis is rare and associated with poor prognosis. GKRS is a safe, effective treatment for clival metastasis.

Clival Metastases: Single-Center Retrospective Case Series and Literature Review

Background/Objectives: Clivus metastases from distant neoplasms are uncommon occurrences both in clinical practice and the neurosurgical literature. Surgical management is debated, particularly about the role of surgery and the preferable approach. The aim of this study was to report our surgical experience and review the concerning literature. Methods: Our institutional registry was retrospectively reviewed, and patients who underwent surgical treatment for clival metastasis from 1998 to 2023 were included. A PRISMA systematic review of the literature was performed. Results: Four patients were enrolled, and all of them underwent an endoscopic endonasal approach (EEA). Three presented with cranial nerve (CN) VI palsy. The aim of surgery was biopsy in all cases. No complications were reported. Mean overall survival (OS) was 6 ± 1 months. The systematic review retrieved 27 papers reporting 39 patients who underwent the surgical treatment of clivus metastases. Most of them (79.5%) presented with CN palsies, and EEA was the preferred approach in 92.3% of the cases, to perform a biopsy in most patients (59%). Two hemorrhagic complications (5.1%) were reported, and the mean OS was 9.4 ± 5.6 months. Conclusions: Clival metastases are uncommonly observed, in most cases, during advanced stages of oncological disease. The aim of surgery should be the confirmation of diagnosis and symptomatic relief, balancing the risk-benefit ratio in a multidisciplinary context. EEA is the approach of choice, and it should be carried out in experienced tertiary skull base centers.

Metastatic Lesions of the Clivus: A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

Metastatic lesions of the clivus are extremely rare, having previously been estimated as representing 0.02% of all intracranial tumors. Owing to its close intracranial relationship with the clivus before entering the cavernous sinus, clinical palsies of the sixth cranial nerve have been classically associated with destructive lesions of this structure.

METHODS

A comprehensive search of PubMed was conducted for studies of patients with metastasis to the clivus from primary cancer at any site. Studies reported in English in the past 20 years from our last search on April 12, 2021 were included. The data collected included patient age, sex, symptoms at presentation, histopathology and treatment timeline of the primary tumor, treatment, follow-up, and mortality.

RESULTS

After the literature review, 46 studies reporting on 58 patients with clivus metastasis were included in the final analysis. The mean age of the patients was 57.5 years, and 39 were male (67.2%). The most common sites of the primary tumor were the prostate (22%), gastrointestinal tract (15%), lung (13%), and kidney (11%). In 43% of patients, symptoms of clivus metastasis had presented before the diagnosis of primary cancer was known, and 71% of the patients had presented with sixth nerve palsy. Of the 58 patients, 53% had undergone surgery, and 37% had received adjuvant radiotherapy. Of the 58 patients, 25% had received radiotherapy alone. The endoscopic transsphenoidal approach to the clivus was almost uniquely used for surgical management. Survival data were available for 31 patients. Death had occurred at a mean of 9.4 months after the presentation of clivus metastasis. A strong correlation was found between the interval from primary cancer to the presentation of clivus metastasis and mortality.

CONCLUSIONS

Although an extremely rare occurrence, clivus metastasis should be considered in patients with a history of malignancy, in particular, prostate malignancy, presenting with new-onset isolated sixth nerve palsy.