The fate of tumour rests following removal of acoustic neuromas: an MRI Gd-DTPA study

Residual tumour after vestibular schwannoma surgery

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate residual tumour occurrence after vestibular schwannoma surgery, based on intra-operative registration and magnetic resonance imaging one year post-operatively.

METHODS

Patients undergoing translabyrinthine surgery for vestibular schwannoma in Denmark between 1976 and 2008 were registered in a national database covering 5.5 million inhabitants.

RESULTS

Translabyrinthine surgery was undertaken on 1143 patients. Of these, 978 had total, 140 near-total and 25 subtotal tumour excision, as assessed intra-operatively by the surgeon. One year after surgery, 65 per cent of small tumour remnants and 11 per cent of large tumour remnants were not visible on magnetic resonance imaging. The mean pre-operative size was significantly smaller for totally excised tumours, compared with near-totally and subtotally excised tumours. Revision surgery was performed for 14 patients (1.2 per cent), of whom 2 had received total, 5 near-total and 6 subtotal excisions initially.

CONCLUSION

Most residual tumours disappear spontaneously, probably due to devascularisation. Few patients with a small residual vestibular schwannoma will require revision surgery or secondary radiotherapy.

Outcome of translabyrinthine surgery for vestibular schwannoma in neurofibromatosis type 2

OBJECTIVES

To analyse the long-term outcome of translabyrinthine surgery for vestibular schwannoma (VS) in neurofibromatosis type 2 (NF2). RESEARCH TYPE: Retrospective cohort study.

SETTING

Two tertiary referral NF2 units.

PATIENTS

One hundred and forty eight translabyrinthine operations for patients with VS were performed. Preoperative stereotactic radiotherapy had been performed on 12(9.4%) patients.

RESULTS

Mean tumour size was 3.1 cm. Total tumour excision was achieved in 66% of cases, capsular remnants were left in 24% of cases, and subtotal excision was achieved in 5% and partial removal was achieved in 5%. The radiological residual/recurrence rate was 13.9%. The perioperative mortality was 1.6%. At 2 years postoperatively, facial function was expressed in terms of House-Brackmann score (HB): HB 1 in 53.4%, HB 1/2 in 61.3%, HB 1-3 in 83.2% and HB 4-6 in 16.8%. All nine patients who underwent surgery following failed stereotactic radiotherapy had HB 3 function or better. Among 9.5% of the cases, 14 facial nerves were lost during surgery and repaired using direct anastomosis or grafting. There was no tinnitus present preoperatively in 27% of the cases, and 22% of patients developed tinnitus postoperatively. In patients with preoperative tinnitus, 61% remained the same, 17% got it resolved and only in 21% it worsened. The preoperative hydrocephalus rate was 26%, and among 15% of the cases five ventriculo-peritoneal (VP) shunts were performed. The cerebrospinal fluid leak rate was 2.5%. Fifty-six patients underwent auditory brainstem implantation (ABI) and two patients had cochlear implant (CI) sleepers inserted.

CONCLUSIONS

The management of patients with NF2 presents the clinician with a formidable challenge with many patients still presenting themselves late with the neurological compromise and a large tumour load. There is still an argument for the management by observation until the neurological compromise dictates interventional treatment particularly with the option of hearing rehabilitation with ABI or CI. The translabyrinthine approach provides a very satisfactory means of reducing the overall tumour volume.

Extent of resection and the long-term durability of vestibular schwannoma surgery

OBJECT

With limited studies available, the correlation between the extent of resection and tumor recurrence in vestibular schwannomas (VSs) has not been definitively established. In this prospective study, the authors evaluated 772 patients who underwent microsurgical resection of VSs to analyze the association between total tumor resection and the tumor recurrence rate.

METHODS

The authors selected all cases from a prospectively collected database of patients who underwent microsurgical resection as their initial treatment for a histopathologically confirmed VS. Recurrence-free survival was analyzed using Kaplan-Meier analysis. The authors studied the impact of possible confounders such as patient age and tumor size using stepwise Cox regression to calculate the proportional hazard ratio of recurrence while controlling for other cofounding variables.

RESULTS

The authors analyzed data obtained in 571, 89, and 112 patients in whom gross-total, near-total, and subtotal resections, respectively, were performed. A gross-total resection was achieved in 74% of the patients, and the overall recurrence rate in these patients 8.8%. There was no significant relation between the extent of resection and the rate of tumor recurrence (p = 0.58). As expected, the extent of resection was highly correlated with patient age, tumor size, and surgical approach (p < 0.0001). Using Cox regression, the authors found that the approach used did not significantly affect tumor control when the extent of resection was controlled for.

CONCLUSIONS

While complete tumor removal is ideal, the results presented here suggest that there is no significant relationship between the extent of resection and tumor recurrence.

Revision surgery for residual or recurrent vestibular schwannoma

OBJECTIVE

Assess the requirement for and describe the complication rates of revision surgery for vestibular schwannoma.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective case review.

SETTING

Tertiary referral center.

PATIENTS

Patients undergoing surgery for vestibular schwannoma by the Manchester Neurotology Service between 1978 and 2004.

INTERVENTION

Surgery.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

The presence of recurrent or residual tumor; necessity for further treatment; complications from revision surgery.

RESULTS

Primary surgery was undertaken on 1,037 tumors, with 866 total (19 recurred), 128 near-total, and 43 subtotal removals. Further treatment was performed for 4 recurrent, 2 near-total, and 11 subtotal excised tumors. Thirty-five revision operations resulted in 14 total (1 recurred), 8 near-total, and 13 subtotal removals. Further treatment was required for 3 near-total and 6 subtotal excisions. Poor preoperative facial function (House-Brackmann Grades 4-6) was present in 9 of the 35 patients. A further 10 deteriorated by at least 3 grades by 1 year postoperatively. Other complications of revision surgery included 3 patients with cerebrospinal fluid leaks, a postoperative hematoma requiring evacuation, 2 cerebrovascular accidents, and 2 patients with new cranial nerve deficits.

CONCLUSION

Most residual tumors after primary surgery are successfully managed with watch and rescan. Tumor fragment size is the greatest determinant of revision treatment. After revision surgery, tumor regrowth is much less predictable. Revision surgery is usually considerably more difficult than primary surgery, with a higher complication rate, particularly with regard to the facial nerve. Changing the approach for revision surgery may confer an advantage to facial nerve function.

Are Acoustic Neuromas Encapsulated Tumors?

In articles and chapters on the subject of acoustic neuroma, it is almost invariably stated that they are well-encapsulated tumors. During surgical procedures, blunt mechanical dissection defines a natural subsurface cleavage plane that leaves intact a several millimeter thick rind of tumor surface. Occasionally, as a concession to neural integrity, less than complete resection is elected, leaving behind this “capsular” remnant. To clarify the nature of the surface of acoustic neuromas and to test whether this long held description is indeed correct, a microscopic analysis of 10 surgical specimens was performed. A wedge was harvested from the free surface of the tumor in the mid cerebellopontine angle that included a large, undisturbed section of the tumor surface. Histologic analysis showed that for most of the tumor surface only an extremely thin (3 to 5 μm) layer of connective tissue envelops the tumor. Neoplastic Schwann cells, which extend essentially to the margin of the tumor, were found to be somewhat flattened and compressed in the vicinity of the surface. Although acoustic neuromas are surrounded by a continuous layer of connective tissue, it is so exceptionally thin (on average less than the diameter of a red blood cell) that its edge cannot be visualized intraoperatively by a surgeon. Because the pathologic definition of a capsule is a thick, enveloping layer of connective tissue that is both micro- and macroscopically evident, it must be concluded that acoustic neuromas are nonencapsulated, at least in the conventional sense of the term. The surface peel observed intraoperatively is surgically produced during tumor debulking by cleaving of the looser central component from the more compressed portion of neoplastic cells that lies immediately beneath the free margin of the lesion.

Unilateral acoustic tumors: how often do they recur after translabyrinthine removal?

Unilateral acoustic tumors rarely recur after total translabyrinthine removal. Review of the patient records of the House Ear Clinic revealed five recurrent tumors, for an approximate incidence of 0.3%. A questionnaire was mailed to 857 patients who were at least 9 years postoperative and failed to find any additional recurrent tumors. No preoperative or intraoperative factors were identified to predict recurrence. The average time interval from initial removal to recurrence was approximately 10 years. Flow cytometric analysis did not reveal any fundamental differences between the recurrent acoustic tumor group and a larger group of 112 acoustic tumors. Based on observed growth rates of the recurrent acoustic tumors, a single gadolinium-enhanced magnetic resonance image 5 years after surgery is advised. To prevent recurrence, a margin of normal-appearing proximal eighth cranial nerve should be removed and the nerve stump cauterized.

Repair of facial nerve after removal of cerebellopontine angle tumors: a comparative study

The results of repair of 18 facial nerves were examined by means of a modified House-Brackmann grading system. Six were repaired by end-to-end anastomosis and 12 by nerve graft. The reliability of the simplified House-Brackmann grading system was also assessed, using the kappa statistic to analyze the agreement between pairs of observers who examined the function of 40 nerves in 37 patients. Facial nerves studied had been either preserved, repaired or grafted, or divided and treated by faciohypoglossal nerve anastomosis. One nerve was not treated. The grading system proved to be somewhat unreliable, with complete agreement between observers in only 25% of cases. Facial nerve repair produced a fair return of function in just under two-thirds of the cases. The ability of an examiner ignorant of the patient's history to assess from the end result how the nerve had been managed was also estimated. Observers showed little ability to decide correctly on the previous treatment of the nerve when the patient showed moderate dysfunction postoperatively. The implications of these findings for grading systems and for management of the facial nerve in acoustic nerve tumor surgery are discussed.