Treatment of Malignant Testicular Tumours: A report on 355 patients

Long-term morbidity of adjuvant infradiaphragmatic irradiation in patients with testicular cancer and implications for the treatment of stage I seminoma

Long-term abdominal or urological morbidity and second malignancies in 289 surviving patients with infradiaphragmatic adjuvant radiotherapy (RT) for testicular cancer between 1950 and 1988 are analysed by retrospective chart review. After RT with single doses between 1.5 and 2.0 Gy and a total dose between 30 and 35 Gy, we did not observe any peptic ulcer nor other abdominal or urological long-term morbidity, except second tumours. The cumulative incidence of 16 second extratesticular malignancy was (in years after RT): 0.4% (4 years), 1.3% (9 years), 4.5% (14 years), 6.3% (19 years), 7.5% (24 years), 15.6% (29 years) and 23.6% (35 years). The ratio of observed to expected incidence of extratesticular malignancies did not differ significantly from unity; only the frequency of penile cancer (n = 2) was somewhat higher than expected. The cumulative risk of bilateral testicular cancer was 4.8% with no difference between patients with seminoma or non-seminomatous germ cell tumours. In a recent group of 128 patients with a stage I seminoma staged and treated between 1978 and 1988 by modern standard, there was no recurrence.

Staging, treatment, and results in testicular seminoma. A 12-year report

Sixty-one patients with histologically confirmed seminoma of the testis were treated by radiotherapy at The Johns Hopkins Hospital from 1975 to 1987. Fifty-seven patients remain disease-free, three patients died of intercurrent disease, and one patient (Stage IIB) died of widespread seminoma. Median follow-up for these patients is 5.5 years. Using a modified M.D. Anderson Hospital clinical staging system, 42 (69%) were Stage I, 16 (26%) were Stage IIA, and three (5%) were Stage IIB. Radiologic staging included both lymphangiogram (LAG) and abdominal computed tomography (CT) scan. Among Stage I disease, nine patients had false-positive CT scans, determined by negative LAG. Six patients had false-negative CT scans and were upstaged to Stage IIA by LAG. Treatment portals were altered in 15 of the 39 patients (38%) who had both LAG and CT scan. Overall actuarial survival (Kaplan-Meier method) was 97% at 5 years and 92% at 10 years. Five-year survival corrected for intercurrent disease was 100% for Stage I, 100% for Stage IIA, and two of three in Stage IIB patients. There were two distant treatment failures among the entire cohort. One patient who had Stage I disease was salvaged with local-field radiation and chemotherapy and is now without evidence of disease for 6 years. The second patient with Stage IIB seminoma receiving the same treatments disseminated and died. There were no significant acute toxicities or serious complications. In summary, proper staging with information gained from LAG and adequate radiation dose led to a 92% 10-year disease-free survival.

Controversies in management of stages I and II testicular seminomas

The general success in treating seminoma (Stages I and II) of the testicle has prompted questions regarding the extent of treatment that these patients require. We reviewed 79 patients treated at NYU/Bellevue Medical Center from 1965 to 1984 to establish a data base from which the controversies surrounding this disease can be viewed. Standard treatment involved a radical inguinal orchiectomy as primary therapy. Stage I patients received adjuvant radiation to para-aortic and ipsilateral iliac nodes, with additional radiation given routinely to the mediastinum of patients with Stage II disease. No major complications were observed. All Stage I patients remain free of recurrent tumor with a median follow-up of eight years. There were 4 deaths from seminoma among the Stage II patients. The use of prophylactic mediastinal radiation for Stage II patients, and observation only for Stage I patients are reviewed in light of our results and other published series. While early evidence suggests that both approaches may be reasonable, their adoption awaits confirmation by prospective trial.

Stage I testicular seminoma: rationale for postorchiectomy radiation therapy

The cases of 163 patients with Stage I seminoma of the testis treated by orchiectomy and adjuvant radiation therapy (XRT) were retrospectively evaluated to document outcome and to determine the prognostic significance of age side or primary, cryptorchidism, prior ipsilateral herniorrhaphy, status of the contralateral testis, history of prior testicular cancer, scrotal incision, postorchiectomy beta- human chorionic gonadotropin (BHCG) level, invasion of the epididymis, spermatic cord involvement, vascular invasion in the primary and mediastinal XRT. Of the prognostic factors evaluated, only spermatic cord involvement proved to be a significantly adverse factor. However, the true significance of cord involvement is unclear because the para-aortic regions were not irradiated in 2 of the patients in whom there was this finding, and in 1 of these there was failure in the retroperitoneum. Spermatic cord involvement was not a prognostically significant finding in patients whose para-aortic region was treated. For all 163 patients who underwent XRT, disease-free survival was 95% at 5, 10, and 15 years. Total survival corrected for intercurrent death was 97% from 5 through 20 years. Seven patients relapsed (4%) and 4 died of seminoma (2%). The XRT technique described is simple to implement and is extremely effective. Of 161 patients whose para-aortic region was irradiated, none developed subdiaphragmatic nodal recurrence. Only 1 patient developed acute leukemia. No patient developed any of the recognized delayed XRT-induced complications involving small bowel, large bowel, bladder, kidney, liver or spinal cord. The virtues and limitations of surveillance in Stage I testicular seminoma are discussed, and it is concluded that routine postorchiectomy XRT is the treatment of choice.

Radiotherapy of testicular tumours: an analysis of patients treated in Scotland between 1950 and 1969

The results of treatment of 838 patients who were irradiated for germ cell tumours of the testis between 1950 and 1969 are presented. The overall 10-year survival rate was 61.8%. For seminomas alone it was 75.3% and for teratomas 37.7%. No increase in survival was found which could be attributed to the introduction of megavoltage beams.

Metastasis of cancer in the cryptorchid testis to the sigmoid colon

A 20-year-old male with bilateral cryptorchidism and malignant change of the right testicle developed a metastatic tumour in the sigmoid colon.

Bilateral testicular germ cell malignancy

The other testicle was involved in 6 of 235 patients (2.69 per cent) with a history of testicular germ cell tumor. It occurred more often following seminoma (4 of 113, 3.5 per cent cases). The mean age at occurrence of the first tumor (twenty-five years) was earlier than expected, and the mean interval between tumors was 8.8 years. Accurate clinical staging of second tumors is impeded by alteration in the routes of metastatic dissemination, and treatment options are limited by previous therapy for the first tumor.

Lymphography as a guide to prognosis in malignant testicular tumours

Lymphography was performed in 130 patients with malignant neoplasm of the testes. The patients were treated by irradiation, supplemented by chemotherapy when lymph node metastases were present. The survival rates of the various pathologic subdivisions were analyzed according to the lymphography. The following 5-year survival rates were observed: seminoma: normal lymphography 94%, pathologic lymphography 69%; teratocarcinoma: normal lymphography 86%, pathologic lymphography 14%; embryonal carcinoma: normal lymphography 64%, pathologic lymphography 33%.