A review of in vitro experimental evidence for the effect of spatial and temporal modulation of radiation dose on response

Radiotherapy in the Treatment of Subcutaneous Melanoma

Simple Summary

The non-surgical treatment of cutaneous and/or subcutaneous melanoma lesions involves a multitude of local treatments, including radiotherapy. This is often used when other local methods fail, and there are currently no clear guidelines or evidence-based recommendations to support its use in this setting. This review, collecting the retrospective and prospective experiences on radiotherapy alone or in combination with other methods, aims to provide a scenario of the possible advantages and disadvantages related to its use in the treatment of skin/subcutaneous melanoma lesions.

Abstract

Malignant melanoma frequently develops cutaneous and/or subcutaneous metastases during the course of the disease. These may present as non-nodal locoregional metastases (microsatellite, satellite, or in-transit) included in stage III or as distant metastases in stage IV. Their presentation is heterogeneous and associated with significant morbidity resulting from both disease-related functional damage and treatment side effects. The standard treatment is surgical excision, whereas local therapies or systemic therapies have a role when surgery is not indicated. Radiotherapy can be used in the local management of ITM, subcutaneous relapses, or distant metastases to provide symptom relief and prolong regional disease control. To increase the local response without increasing toxicity, the addition of hyperthermia and intralesional therapies to radiotherapy appear to be very promising. Boron neutron capture therapy, based on nuclear neutron capture and boron isotope fission reaction, could be an alternative to standard treatments, but its use in clinical practice is still limited. The potential benefit of combining radiotherapy with targeted therapies and immunotherapy has yet to be explored in this lesion setting. This review explores the role of radiotherapy in the treatment of cutaneous and subcutaneous lesions, its impact on outcomes, and its association with other treatment modalities.

Probing spatiotemporal fractionation on the preclinical level

In contrast to conventional radiotherapy, spatiotemporal fractionation (STF) delivers a distinct dose distribution in each fraction. The aim is to increase the therapeutic window by simultaneously achieving partial hypofractionation in the tumour along with near uniform fractionation in normal tissues. STF has been studied in silico under the assumption that different parts of the tumour can be treated in different fractions. Here, we develop an experimental setup for testing this key assumption on the preclinical level using high-precision partial tumour irradiation in an experimental animal model. We further report on an initial proof-of-concept experiment. We consider a reductionist model of STF in which the tumour is divided in half and treated with two complementary partial irradiations separated by 24 h. Precise irradiation of both tumour halves is facilitated by the image-guided small animal radiation research platform X-RAD SmART. To assess the response of tumours to partial irradiations, tumour growth experiments are conducted using mice carrying syngeneic subcutaneous tumours derived from MC38 colorectal adenocarcinoma cells. Tumour volumes were determined daily by calliper measurements and validated by CT-volumetry. We compared the growth of conventionally treated tumours, where the whole tumour was treated in one fraction, to the reductionist model of STF. We observed no difference in growth between the two groups. Instead, a reduction in the irradiated volume (where only one half of the tumour was irradiated) resulted in an intermediate response between full irradiation and unirradiated control. The results obtained by CT-volumetry supported the findings of the calliper-derived measurements. An experimental setup for precise partial tumour irradiation in small animals was developed, which is suited to test the assumption of STF that complementary parts of the tumour can be treated in different fractions on the preclinical level. An initial experiment supports this assumption, however, further experiments with longer follow-up and varying fractionation schemes are needed to provide additional support for STF.

Grid therapy using high definition multileaf collimators: realizing benefits of the bystander effect

BACKGROUND

In microbeam radiotherapy (MRT), parallel arrays of high-intensity synchrotron x-ray beams achieve normal tissue sparing without compromising tumor control. Grid-therapy using clinical linacs has spatial modulation on a larger scale and achieves promising results for palliative treatments of bulky tumors. The availability of high definition multileaf collimators (HDMLCs) with 2.5 mm leaves provides an opportunity for grid-therapy to more closely approach MRT. However, challenges to the wider implementation of grid-therapy remain because spatial modulation of the target volume runs counter to current radiotherapy practice and mechanisms for the beneficial effects of MRT are not fully understood. Without more knowledge of cell dose responses, a quantitative basis for planning treatments is difficult. The aim of this study is to determine if therapeutic benefits of MRT can be achieved using a linac with HDMLCs and if so, to develop a predictive model to support treatment planning.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

HD120-MLCs of a Varian Novalis TX^TM were used to generate grid patterns of 2.5 and 5.0 mm spacing, which were characterized dosimetrically using Gafchromic^TM EBT3 film. Clonogenic survival of normal (HUVEC) and cancer (NCI-H460, HCC-1954) cell lines following irradiation under the grid and open fields using a 6 MV photon beam were compared in-vitro for the same average dose.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

Relative to an open field, survival of normal cells in a 2.5 mm striped field was the same, while the survival of both cancer cell lines was significantly lower. A mathematical model was developed to incorporate dose gradients of the spatial modulation into the standard linear quadratic model. Our new bystander extended LQ model assumes spatial gradients drive the diffusion of soluble factors that influence survival through bystander effects, successfully predicting the experimental results that show an increased therapeutic ratio. Our results challenge conventional radiotherapy practice and propose that additional gain can be realized by prescribing spatially modulated treatments to harness the bystander effect.

Melanoma: Last call for radiotherapy

Melanoma is traditionally considered to be a radioresistant tumor. However, radiotherapy and immunotherapy latest developments might upset this radiobiological dogma. Stereotactic radiotherapy allows high dose per fraction delivery, with high dose rate. More DNA lethal damages, less sublethal damages reparation, endothelial cell apoptosis, and finally clonogenic cell dysfunction are produced, resulting in improved local control. Radiotherapy can also enhance immune responses, inducing neoantigens formation, tumor antigen presentation, and cytokines release. A synergic effect of radiotherapy with immunotherapy is expected, and might lead to abscopal effects. If hadrontherapy biological properties seem able to suppress hypoxia-induced radioresistance and increase biological efficacy, ballistic advantages over photon radiations might also improve radiotherapy outcomes on usually poor prognosis locations. The present review addresses biological and clinical effects of high fraction dose, bystander effect, abscopal effect, and hadrontherapy features in melanoma. Clinical trials results are warranted to establish indications of innovative radiotherapy in melanoma.

Embryos of the zebrafish Danio rerio in studies of non-targeted effects of ionizing radiation

The use of embryos of the zebrafish Danio rerio as an in vivo tumor model for studying non-targeted effects of ionizing radiation was reviewed. The zebrafish embryo is an animal model, which enables convenient studies on non-targeted effects of both high-linear-energy-transfer (LET) and low-LET radiation by making use of both broad-beam and microbeam radiation. Zebrafish is also a convenient embryo model for studying radiobiological effects of ionizing radiation on tumors. The embryonic origin of tumors has been gaining ground in the past decades, and efforts to fight cancer from the perspective of developmental biology are underway. Evidence for the involvement of radiation-induced genomic instability (RIGI) and the radiation-induced bystander effect (RIBE) in zebrafish embryos were subsequently given. The results of RIGI were obtained for the irradiation of all two-cell stage cells, as well as 1.5 hpf zebrafish embryos by microbeam protons and broad-beam alpha particles, respectively. In contrast, the RIBE was observed through the radioadaptive response (RAR), which was developed against a subsequent challenging dose that was applied at 10 hpf when <0.2% and <0.3% of the cells of 5 hpf zebrafish embryos were exposed to a priming dose, which was provided by microbeam protons and broad-beam alpha particles, respectively. Finally, a perspective on the field, the need for future studies and the significance of such studies were discussed.

Two-step intensity modulated arc therapy (2-step IMAT) with segment weight and width optimization

Background

2-step intensity modulated arc therapy (IMAT) is a simplified IMAT technique which delivers the treatment over typically two continuous gantry rotations. The aim of this work was to implement the technique into a computerized treatment planning system and to develop an approach to optimize the segment weights and widths.

Methods

2-step IMAT was implemented into the Prism treatment planning system. A graphical user interface was developed to generate the plan segments automatically based on the anatomy in the beam's-eye-view. The segment weights and widths of 2-step IMAT plans were subsequently determined in Matlab using a dose-volume based optimization process. The implementation was tested on a geometric phantom with a horseshoe shaped target volume and then applied to a clinical paraspinal tumour case.

Results

The phantom study verified the correctness of the implementation and showed a considerable improvement over a non-modulated arc. Further improvements in the target dose uniformity after the optimization of 2-step IMAT plans were observed for both the phantom and clinical cases. For the clinical case, optimizing the segment weights and widths reduced the maximum dose from 114% of the prescribed dose to 107% and increased the minimum dose from 87% to 97%. This resulted in an improvement in the homogeneity index of the target dose for the clinical case from 1.31 to 1.11. Additionally, the high dose volume V₁₀₅ was reduced from 57% to 7% while the maximum dose in the organ-at-risk was decreased by 2%.

Conclusions

The intuitive and automatic planning process implemented in this study increases the prospect of the practical use of 2-step IMAT. This work has shown that 2-step IMAT is a viable technique able to achieve highly conformal plans for concave target volumes with the optimization of the segment weights and widths. Future work will include planning comparisons of the 2-step IMAT implementation with fixed gantry intensity modulated radiotherapy (IMRT) and commercial IMAT implementations.

A mathematical framework for separating the direct and bystander components of cellular radiation response

A mathematical model for fractional tumor cell survival was developed incorporating components of cell killing due to direct radiation interactions and bystander signals resulting from non-local dose deposition.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Three possible mechanisms for signal production were tested by fitting predictions to available experimental results for tumor cells (non-small cell lung cancer NCI-H460 and melanoma MM576) exposed to gradient x-ray fields. The parameter fitting allowed estimation of the contribution of bystander signaling to cell death (20-50% for all models). Separation of the two components of cell killing allowed determination of the α and β parameters of the linear-quadratic model both with and without the presence of bystander signaling.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

For both cell lines, cell death from bystander signaling and direct radiation interactions were comparable. For NCI-H460 cells, the values for α and β were 0.18 Gy⁻¹ and 0.10 Gy⁻² respectively when direct and bystander effects were combined, and 0.053 Gy⁻¹ and 0.061 Gy⁻² respectively when the signaling component was removed. For MM576, the corresponding respective values were 0.09 Gy⁻¹ and 0.011 Gy⁻² for the combined response, and 0.014 Gy⁻¹ and 0.002 Gy⁻² for the isolated direct radiation response. The bystander component in cell death was found to be significant and should not be ignored. Further experimental evidence is required to determine how these results translate to the in vivo situation where tumor control probability (TCP) models that currently assume cellular independence may need to be revised.