The role of proliferation in the origin of mutations in mammalian cells

Quiescent murine cells lack global genomic repair but are proficient in transcription-coupled repair

The majority of the cells in the body, including stem cells, exist in a quiescent state, so it is in quiescent cells where most DNA damage occurs. It has been uncertain whether or not this damage is repaired or fixed into mutations during quiescence or if proliferation is required for both. Prior to the development of transgenic mice, it was difficult to distinguish between these two possibilities, as cells had to proliferate to form colonies before mutations could be detected. Transgenes, however, can be shuttled out of quiescent mouse cells directly, and the level of DNA damage and mutation can be measured. Such measurements show that both mutation and repair are absent at a non-transcribed transgene in quiescent cells, although both are initiated when these cells are induced to proliferate. Conversely, the repair of transcriptionally active genes proceeds independently of proliferation in the same cells, as shown by the differential survival of wild-type and XPA-/- cells. We infer from these results that global genomic DNA repair (GGR) is not active during cellular quiescence but that transcription-coupled repair (TCR) is, suggesting that GGR is restricted to S, whereas TCR remains active throughout the cell cycle.

Chemically induced renal tubule tumors in the laboratory rat and mouse: review of the NCI/NTP database and categorization of renal carcinogens based on mechanistic information

The incidence of renal tubule carcinogenesis in male and female rats or mice with 69 chemicals from the 513 bioassays conducted to date by the NCI/NTP has been collated, the chemicals categorized, and the relationship between carcinogenesis and renal tubule hyperplasia and exacerbation of the spontaneous, age-related rodent disease chronic progressive nephropathy (CPN) examined. Where information on mechanism or mode of action exists, the chemicals have been categorized based on their ability to directly or indirectly interact with renal DNA, or on their activity via epigenetic pathways involving either direct or indirect cytotoxicity with regenerative hyperplasia, or exacerbation of CPN. Nine chemicals were identified as directly interacting with DNA, with six of these producing renal tubule tumors at high incidence in rats of both sexes, and in some cases also in mice. Ochratoxin A was the most potent compound in this group, producing a high tumor incidence at very low doses, often with metastasis. Three chemicals were discussed in the context of indirect DNA damage mediated by an oxidative free radical mechanism, one of these being from the NTP database. A third category included four chemicals that had the potential to cause DNA damage following conjugation with glutathione and subsequent enzymatic activation to a reactive species, usually a thiol-containing entity. Two chemicals were allocated into the category involving a direct cytotoxic action on the renal tubule followed by sustained compensatory cell proliferation, while nine were included in a group where the cell loss and sustained increase in renal tubule cell turnover were dependent on lysosomal accumulation of the male rat-specific protein, alpha2mu-globulin. In a sixth category, morphologic evidence on two chemicals indicated that the renal tumors were a consequence of exacerbated CPN. For the remaining chemicals, there were no pertinent data enabling assignment to a mechanistic category. Accordingly, these chemicals, acting through an as yet unknown mechanism, were grouped as either being associated with an enhancement of CPN (category 7, 16 chemicals), or not associated with enhanced CPN (category 8, 4 chemicals). A ninth category dealt with 11 chemicals that were regarded as producing increases in renal tubule tumors that did not reach statistical significance. A 10th category discussed 6 chemicals that induced renal tumors in mice but not in rats, plus 8 chemicals that produced a low incidence of renal tubule tumors in mice that did not reach statistical significance. As more mechanistic data are generated, some chemicals will inevitably be placed in different groups, particularly those from categories 7 and 8. A large number of chemicals in the series exacerbated CPN, but those in category 7 especially may be candidates for inclusion in category 6 when further information is gleaned from the relevant NTP studies. Also, new data on specific chemicals will probably expand category 5 as cytotoxicity and cell regeneration are identified as obligatory steps in renal carcinogenesis in more cases. Additional confirmatory outcomes arising from this review are that metastases from renal tubule tumors, while encountered with chemicals causing DNA damage, are rare with those acting through an epigenetic pathway, with the exception being fumonisin B1; that male rats and mice are generally more susceptible than female rats and mice to chemical induction of renal tubule tumors; and that a background of atypical tubule hyperplasia is a useful indicator reflecting a chemically associated renal tubule tumor response. With respect to renal tubule tumors and human risk assessment, chemicals in categories 1 and 2, and possibly 3, would currently be judged by linear default methods; chemicals in category 4 (and probably some in category 3) as exhibiting a threshold of activity warranting the benchmark approach; and those in categories 5 and 6 as representing mechanisms that have no relevance for extrapolation to humans.

Proliferation is necessary for both repair and mutation in transgenic mouse cells

Proliferating cells are often presumed to be more mutable than quiescent cells because they have less time to repair DNA damage before DNA replication. Direct tests of this hypothesis have been confounded by the need for cell division before a mutation can be detected. We have avoided this problem by showing that the Big Blue mouse cell line permits the dynamic quantification of both lesions and mutations in the complete absence of cell division. These cells carry the bacterial lacI gene in a lambda shuttle vector. Mutant plaques recovered by in vitro packaging of the mouse DNA can arise from mutations sustained either in mouse cells or in the bacteria. The proportion of mutant phage contained within a mutant plaque can distinguish these two types of mutation. Mutations formed in mouse cells yield >90% mutant phage because both DNA strands are mutant. On the other hand, mutations formed in the bacteria from adducted DNA yield </=50% mutant phage, because one of the DNA strands is wild type. Immediately after exposure to a test mutagen, ethylnitrosourea, all induced mutations were formed in the bacteria, but after approximately one cell division, the reverse was true and all mutations arose in the mouse cells. Only one-fifth as many mutations were recovered from quiescent cells and all arose in the bacteria, showing that the mouse cells made no mutations in the absence of proliferation. Surprisingly, the mouse cells did not repair any of the premutagenic damage during 4 days of quiescence. When these quiescent cells were induced to proliferate, however, both repair and mutation fixation ensued.

ENU induces mutations in the heart of lacZ transgenic mice

The use of transgenic mouse models as somatic mutation assays allows determination of mutation in all tissues of the mouse, including non-dividing tissues. In this regard, these models can be used to study the possibility that mutations can be induced in mitotically quiescent organs such as the heart. Mutations are generally thought to be associated with mitotic processes of DNA replication. Mutations, however, are also postulated to occur in the absence of mitosis as the result of DNA repair. In order to determine whether or not mutations could be induced in the heart, we analyzed the mutant frequency in the hearts of F(1) (Muta Mouse X SWR) mice that had been treated acutely with 250 mg/kg ENU and sampled at days 10, 35, and 70 post-treatment. A significant increase in mutant frequency at day 70 shows that mutations can be induced in the heart. Since the heart contains small numbers of non-muscle cells, additional mechanisms that could explain these results were also considered. The effect of ENU-induced cell proliferation or a sub-population of rapidly dividing cells is ruled out by C(14)-thymidine uptake studies which showed minimal proliferation. By the same token, the influence of ex vivo mutations (i.e., DNA adducts fixed as mutations during replication in the bacteria) is ruled out by the observed time course of mutations, as well as experimental evidence showing that such mutations are not detected in the lacZ assay.

Through a glass, darkly: reflections of mutation from lacI transgenic mice

The study of mutational frequency (Mf) and specificity in aging Big Blue lacI transgenic mice provides a unique opportunity to determine mutation rates (MR) in vivo in different tissues. We found that MR are not static, but rather, vary with the age or developmental stage of the tissue. Although Mf increase more rapidly early in life, MR are actually lower in younger animals than in older animals. For example, we estimate that the changes in Mf are 4.9x10(-8) and 1.1 x 10(-8) mutations/base pair/month in the livers of younger mice (<1. 5 months old) and older mice (> or =1.5 months old), respectively (a 4-fold decrease), and that the MR are 3.9 x 10(-9) and 1.3 x 10(-7) mutations/base pair/cell division, respectively ( approximately 30-fold increase). These data also permit an estimate of the MR of GC --> AT transitions occurring at 5'-CpG-3' (CpG) dinucleotide sequences. Subsequently, the contribution of these transitions to age-related demethylation of genomic DNA can be evaluated. Finally, to better understand the origin of observed Mf, we consider the contribution of various factors, including DNA damage and repair, by constructing a descriptive mutational model. We then apply this model to estimate the efficiency of repair of deaminated 5-methylcytosine nucleosides occurring at CpG dinucleotide sequences, as well as the influence of the Msh2(-/-) DNA repair defect on overall DNA repair efficiency in Big Blue mice. We conclude that even slight changes in DNA repair efficiency could lead to significant increases in mutation frequencies, potentially contributing significantly to human pathogenesis, including cancer.

Paracelsus to parascience: the environmental cancer distraction

Entering a new millennium seems a good time to challenge some old ideas, which in our view are implausible, have little supportive evidence, and might best be left behind. In this essay, we summarize a decade of work, raising four issues that involve toxicology, nutrition, public health, and government regulatory policy. (a) Paracelsus or parascience: the dose (trace) makes the poison. Half of all chemicals, whether natural or synthetic, are positive in high-dose rodent cancer tests. These results are unlikely to be relevant at the low doses of human exposure. (b) Even Rachel Carson was made of chemicals: natural vs. synthetic chemicals. Human exposure to naturally occurring rodent carcinogens is ubiquitous, and dwarfs the general public's exposure to synthetic rodent carcinogens. (c) Errors of omission: micronutrient inadequacy is genotoxic. The major causes of cancer (other than smoking) do not involve exogenous carcinogenic chemicals: dietary imbalances, hormonal factors, infection and inflammation, and genetic factors. Insufficiency of many micronutrients, which appears to mimic radiation, is a preventable source of DNA damage. (d) Damage by distraction: regulating low hypothetical risks. Putting huge amounts of money into minuscule hypothetical risks damages public health by diverting resources and distracting the public from major risks.