Hb Tak and Hb Q-Thailand in Thai patients are S-window hemoglobin variants revealed by high performance liquid chromatography

A comparative evaluation of the analytical performances of premier resolution-high-performance liquid chromatography (PR-HPLC) with capillary zone electrophoresis (CZE) assays for the detection of hemoglobin variants and the quantitation of HbA0, A2, E, and F

OBJECTIVES

Hemoglobinopathies, including thalassemia and hemoglobin (Hb) variants, are common hematological disorders in tropical countries. Accurate and precise separation of hemoglobin types and reliable quantitation are necessary for differential diagnosis of these disorders.

METHODS

We have evaluated the analytical performances of premier resolution-high-performance liquid chromatography (PR-HPLC; Trinity Biotech, Co. Wicklow, Ireland) to assist in the presumptive diagnosis of thalassemia and Hb variants commonly found in Southeast Asian countries. HbA0, HbA2, HbE, and HbF levels were separated and quantified in 120 blood samples from unrelated adult subjects and compared with those analyzed by capillary zone electrophoresis (CZE; CAPILLARYS™ 2, Sebia, Norcross, GA, US). The Hb analysis patterns of Hb variants obtained from the PR-HPLC system were also compared to those obtained from HPLC (VARIANT II, β-thalassemia Short Program, Bio-Rad, Laboratories, Hercules, CA, US) and CZE systems.

RESULTS

The PR-HPLC had excellent precision with a coefficient of variation (CV) for HbA2 quantitation of 3.8 % within-run and 5.2 % between-run. The levels of HbA2/E quantified by the PR-HPLC system correlated well with those of the CZE system (r=0.997). In addition, thalassemia interpretation results obtained from the PR-HPLC and the CZE showed 100 % agreement. Moreover, chromatograms of the PR-HPLC were also comparable to those of VII-HPLC and CAP2-CZE electropherograms.

CONCLUSIONS

The PR-HPLC system would be applicable to diagnose common forms of thalassemia and Hb variants in Southeast Asia.

Pitfalls in the genetic diagnosis of Hb S

Patients homozygous for Hb S need to be properly identified to start as early as possible a treatment that should avoid complications. For prevention and genetic counseling, carriers of Hb S have to be screened. Hb S is easily detected by several analytical systems, but other variants, usually harmless, may behave as Hb S, leading to false positive diagnosis. Some interactions may also cause difficulties in the qualitative or quantitative interpretation of a chromatography or electrophoresis profile. These problems may result from several causes among which the simultaneous presence of an α chain variant leading to the formation of tetramers having both an α and a β chain modified, the presence of a second mutation within the Hb S allele, the existence of a compound heterozygous state leading to some "Hb S trait with dominantly transmitted sickle cell disease (SCD)", and the presence of thalassemic allele affecting the intracellular proportion of Hb S. In case of any "dominant Hb S trait" a thorough Hb study is always required. This work reports some of the difficulties observed by us, or reported in the literature, and propose how to avoid them and reach a correct diagnosis.