Head and neck cancer: present status and future prospects of adjuvant chemotherapy

Clinical trial design limitations in head and neck squamous cell carcinomas

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The present article reviews the randomized trials contributing to the establishment of current standards for the treatment of head and neck cancer. It provides critical analysis of their methodology in order to facilitate future trial design.

RECENT FINDINGS

From a prognosis perspective, head and neck cancers are a heterogeneous group of diseases. Following a number of randomized clinical trials evaluating the role of chemotherapy in the induction, concomitant and adjuvant settings, there has been considerable improvement in the treatment of locally advanced head and neck cancers during the last decade. It is, however, difficult to interpret and compare the results optimally and to build on efficient trial designs as most of the trials included patients with different levels of essential prognostic factors.

SUMMARY

All key randomized trials will be reviewed according to eligibility criteria, subgroup issues, trial power and historical controls. Methodological interpretation and possible plans for the next generation of clinical trials will be presented.

[Epidermoid carcinoma larynx in stage IV]

OBJECTIVE

To determine the survival, loco-regional control, distant metastases and second primary in stage IV laryngeal carcinoma treated by surgery and radiotherapy.

MATERIAL

Retrospective study of 147 patients treated with surgery and radiotherapy with a 5 year minimun follow-up.

RESULTS

Overall and cause specific survival at 5 and 10 years was 42%, 35% and 49%, 45.8% respectively. Loco-regional control was 57.7 % and 54.7% at 5 and 10 years. Local recurrences presented in 25.7%, regional recurrences in 74.2%, and distant metastases 10.9%. Second primary tumors developed in 12% of the patients, 50% of the cases in the lungs. Factors related to survival are evaluated.

CONCLUSIONS

In our experience, surgery with postoperative radiotherapy in N+, controls 45% of stage IV laryngeal carcinoma. Regional recurrencies are the main cause of failure, more frequent in N+ patientes, present in the first 36 months after treatment.

Adjuvant Therapy in Patients With Resected Poor-Risk Head and Neck Cancer

In patients with locally or regionally advanced head and neck carcinomas, postoperative radiotherapy has historically been the adjuvant therapy applied for patients with prognostically worrisome pathologic features. Any improvement in therapeutic index achieved by adding cytotoxic agents to postoperative radiotherapy remained controversial. However, two recent randomized trials, conducted in parallel in Europe and the United States, produced level I evidence regarding improved efficacy in this setting for the concurrent administration of chemotherapy and radiotherapy. High-dose cisplatin and irradiation can now be considered the standard therapeutic approach for resected poor-risk disease. The presence of positive margins and/or nodal extracapsular spread in the surgical specimens are the subgroups that appear to benefit in the most significant way from the addition of chemotherapy to radiation. Many questions regarding the optimization of adjuvant treatments still remain unanswered, especially with respect to improvement of patient compliance, integration of novel drugs targeting both locoregional and systemic control, and modulation of treatment intensity according to risk levels.

Adjuvant chemo- and radiotherapy for poor prognosis head and neck squamous cell carcinomas

The treatment of squamous cell carcinomas of the head and neck is multidisciplinary, especially when the disease is diagnosed at an intermediate or advanced stage. Very often the clinician chooses between surgery, chemo- and radiotherapy options on the basis of the most recent data from the literature, prior experience in head and neck oncology and patient preferences. Nevertheless, for operable tumors, primary surgery, combined in poor-risk patients with radiation, is traditionally considered as the approach offering the best opportunity of cure. Randomized controlled trials and meta-analyses conducted in the 1990s have demonstrated major improvements not only in loco-regional tumor control, but also in terms of survival when chemotherapy is added to radiotherapy in the post-operative setting. The therapeutic index yielded by the co-administration of cytotoxic agents and ionizing radiation following primary surgery as compared with radiotherapy alone has nevertheless been at the center of many debates recently. Notwithstanding the fact that two randomized trials have recently provided new evidence that adjuvant chemo-radiation in poor-risk patients improves loco-regional control and disease-free survival, a number of questions regarding the optimization of the post-operative approaches remain unanswered. There is remaining need for further research efforts that would enable scientists and clinicians to improve, in the next decade, the management of this complex entity of diseases.

Outpatient weekly 24-hour infusional adjuvant chemotherapy of cisplatin, 5-fluorouracil, and leucovorin for high-risk nasopharyngeal carcinoma

BACKGROUND

Distant metastasis rather than locoregional recurrence is the major site of failure after adequate radiotherapy in nasopharyngeal carcinoma (NPC). The aim of this study is to evaluate the toxicity and survival of outpatient weekly 24-hour infusion adjuvant chemotherapy for NPC patients with high-risk of distant failure.

METHODS

Our definition of high-risk NPC included patients with (1) 1992 AJCC staging system of N3, T4N2, or N2 with one of nodal size > 4 cm; (2) supraclavicular node metastasis; and (3) residual disease after radiotherapy or neck relapse. From August 1994 to August 1997, 41 NPC patients matching the preceding criteria agreed to receive weekly PFL (cisplatin 25 mg/m(2), 5-fluorouracil 1250 mg/m(2), and leucovorin 120 mg/m(2)) adjuvant chemotherapy for a total of 18 weeks. Clinical data of another 88 patients with similar disease status who did not receive adjuvant chemotherapy during the same period were collected and analyzed for comparison. Survival analysis was investigated by the Kaplan-Meier method and the Cox proportional hazards model.

RESULTS

A total of 700 weekly chemotherapy doses was delivered to 41 patients. The ratio of actual/planned dose delivery was 94.9%. Grade 3-4 toxicity of adjuvant chemotherapy included leucopenia (7.3%), anemia (2.4%), thrombocytopenia (2.4%), and nausea/vomiting (2.4%). After a median follow-up of 70 months, 26.8% (11 of 41) and 47.7% (42 of 88) of patients in PFL and no adjuvant chemotherapy groups had distant metastasis (p =.0247). The 5-year metastasis-free survival rates were 71.9% for the PFL group compared with 48.4% for no adjuvant chemotherapy patients (p =.0187). The 5-year overall survival rates were 53.7% (PFL group) and 38.3% (no adjuvant chemotherapy group), respectively (p =.0666). Multivariate Cox analysis showed PFL adjuvant chemotherapy was the independent factor that predicted metastasis-free survival after adjustment for other variables.

CONCLUSIONS

Outpatient weekly 24-hour continuous infusion PFL adjuvant chemotherapy is a well-tolerated regimen with promising results in high-risk NPC patients and merits investigation in phase III studies.

Nd:YAG laser therapy for palliation of recurrent squamous cell carcinomas in the oral cavity

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

The objective of this study was to evaluate the outcome of laser photo-thermoablation for palliation of recurrent squamous cell tumors of the oral cavity.

STUDY DESIGN/PATIENTS AND METHODS

Seventeen patients were treated with the Nd:YAG laser (power output was 50 W) delivered through a curved oral handpiece.

RESULTS

Ten patients are alive, 7 with tumor remission, and 3 with persistent disease with an average follow-up of 16 months (range = 2-36). A total of 29 tumor sites received laser treatment with 17 (58%) completely ablated. Stratified by tumor site Nd:YAG treatment led to complete local response in 8/10 buccal mucosa, 2/5 retromolar trigone, 2/2 tongue, 2/5 gingiva, 1/2 floor of mouth, 2/4 hard palate.

CONCLUSIONS

Nd:YAG laser treatment of recurrent oral cavity squamous cell carcinoma can be performed safely and repeated as needed to achieve tumor palliation. However, extended follow-up may be needed before convincing evidence of long-term therapeutic benefits is obtained.

Treatment of locally advanced head and neck cancer: historical and critical review

BACKGROUND

Advanced squamous cell cancers of the head and neck have traditionally been associated with high rates of morbidity and mortality. Advances in management have improved outcomes for most of these patients.

METHODS

The author reviews the historical progress in management of these difficult tumors and adds his own wide experience to describe and evaluate newer approaches to management.

RESULTS

Over the last 10 years, overall survival rates for patients with head and neck cancers have improved as has quality of life. New standards of care have been defined for patients with nasopharyngeal cancer and for those with advanced unresectable disease. Organ preservation is more commonly achieved.

CONCLUSIONS

Newer targeted therapies are likely to add to the progress that has already been achieved in the multimodality management of patients with head and neck cancers.

High rate of clinical complete response to weekly outpatient neoadjuvant chemotherapy in oral carcinoma patients using a new regimen of cisplatin, 5-fluorouracil, and bleomycin alternating with methotrexate and epirubicin

BACKGROUND

A Phase II trial was initiated to evaluate the response to and toxicity of a new regimen of weekly outpatient neoadjuvant chemotherapy in patients with oral carcinoma.

METHODS

Patients with previously untreated squamous cell carcinoma of the oral cavity were eligible for this trial. The neoadjuvant chemotherapy was comprised of cisplatin, 25 mg/m2, 5-fluorouracil, 1000 mg/m2, and bleomycin, 10 mg/m2, mixed in normal saline as a 24-hour intravenous (i.v.) infusion, alternating with methotrexate, 30 mg/m2, and epirubicin, 30 mg/m2, as an i.v. bolus (PFB/ME) on a weekly schedule for 8-12 weeks. In patients with American Joint Committee on Cancer Stage IV disease who completed neoadjuvant chemotherapy, surgery was preferred to radiotherapy, unless patients refused surgery.

RESULTS

A total of 40 patients (82.5% with Stage IV disease) with previously untreated oral carcinoma were enrolled. The median size of the primary tumor was 7 cm (range, 3-13 cm). Fifty percent of patients had tumor penetrating through the oral mucosa to the cheek skin and 62.5% had bony destruction. Detectable cervical lymph nodes were noted in 77.5% of patients. After neoadjuvant weekly chemotherapy, 22 patients (55%) showed complete response (CR) and 15 patients (37.5%) showed partial response, for an overall response rate of 92.5%. World Health Organization Grade 3/4 toxicity included mucositis (7.5%), leukopenia (25%), anemia (10%), and thrombocytopenia (2.5%). Eleven of 33 patients with Stage IV disease underwent surgery, and pathologic CR (2 patients) or microscopic residual tumor (4 patients) was noted (54.5%).

CONCLUSIONS

The results of the current study indicate that a weekly PFB/ME neoadjuvant chemotherapy regimen is highly effective for the treatment of patients with oral carcinoma. In addition, this regimen has low toxicity. The authors believe that implementation of this regimen into a multimodality therapy protocol deserves further study.

Palliative laser therapy for recurrent head and neck cancer: a Phase II clinical study

OBJECTIVES

Laser therapy is becoming a more precise, minimally invasive alternative for tumor ablation. Recent reports confirm successful palliation of pain and functional disabilities in patients with advanced deep carcinoma of the head and neck using interstitial laser phototherapy (ILT).

STUDY DESIGN, PATIENTS, AND METHODS

The current study describes an ongoing Phase II trial of neodymium/yttrium-aluminum-garnet (Nd:YAG) laser therapy for palliation of advanced head and neck cancer. A total of 40 advanced cancer patients have been entered into this protocol (25 men and 15 women).

RESULTS

Nineteen of these patients had no evidence of recurrence after ILT with an average follow-up of 11 months (range, 2 to 24 mo). Currently, 19 of these patients are alive, 14 with tumor remission and six with persistent disease. A total of 79 tumor sites received ILT with 43 (54.5%) completely ablated. Stratified by tumor site, ILT led to a complete response in 21 of 24 in the oral cavity, eight of 28 neck tumors, four of 10 in skin, and 10 of 17 in other sites. The procedure was well tolerated in most cases and was repeated at intervals in patients with residual disease or recurrences for a total of 118 laser treatments (average, 2.95 treatments per patient).

CONCLUSIONS

The results suggest that ILT can be performed safely and repeated as needed, and may be less costly than conventional surgery for head and neck cancer. However, additional follow-up is needed to obtain convincing evidence of long-term therapeutic benefits.