Progress toward the treatment of arthritis by gene therapy

Gene Therapy in Orthopaedics: Progress and Challenges in Pre-Clinical Development and Translation

In orthopaedics, gene-based treatment approaches are being investigated for an array of common -yet medically challenging- pathologic conditions of the skeletal connective tissues and structures (bone, cartilage, ligament, tendon, joints, intervertebral discs etc.). As the skeletal system protects the vital organs and provides weight-bearing structural support, the various tissues are principally composed of dense extracellular matrix (ECM), often with minimal cellularity and vasculature. Due to their functional roles, composition, and distribution throughout the body the skeletal tissues are prone to traumatic injury, and/or structural failure from chronic inflammation and matrix degradation. Due to a mixture of environment and endogenous factors repair processes are often slow and fail to restore the native quality of the ECM and its function. In other cases, large-scale lesions from severe trauma or tumor surgery, exceed the body’s healing and regenerative capacity. Although a wide range of exogenous gene products (proteins and RNAs) have the potential to enhance tissue repair/regeneration and inhibit degenerative disease their clinical use is hindered by the absence of practical methods for safe, effective delivery. Cumulatively, a large body of evidence demonstrates the capacity to transfer coding sequences for biologic agents to cells in the skeletal tissues to achieve prolonged delivery at functional levels to augment local repair or inhibit pathologic processes. With an eye toward clinical translation, we discuss the research progress in the primary injury and disease targets in orthopaedic gene therapy. Technical considerations important to the exploration and pre-clinical development are presented, with an emphasis on vector technologies and delivery strategies whose capacity to generate and sustain functional transgene expression in vivo is well-established.

EGFP gene transfection into the synovial joint tissues of rats with rheumatoid arthritis by ultrasound-mediated microbubble destruction

The aim of the present study was to explore the feasibility of enhancing green fluorescent protein (EGFP) gene transfection into the synovial joint tissues of rats with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) by ultrasound-mediated microbubble destruction. An optimal SonoVue dose was determined using 40 normal rats categorized into five groups according to the various doses of microbubbles used. At 1 week after ultrasound irradiation, the rats were sacrificed. Damage to the joint synovial tissues was observed with hematoxylin and eosin histopathological staining under a microscope. A further 44 normal rats were used to establish a rat model of RA, and were then categorized into four groups: EGFP, ultrasound + EGFP, microbubbles + EGFP and ultrasound + microbubbles + EGFP. The last group was irradiated with ultrasound for 10 min following the injection of 300 μl SonoVue and 10 μg EGFP into the joint cavity. Rats were sacrificed after 3 days and synovial tissue was collected from the knee joints for observation of EGFP with fluorescence microscopy and analysis by quantitative polymerase chain reaction. EGFP expression was observed in the synovial tissues of all groups. However, high EGFP expression levels were observed in the ultrasound + microbubbles + EGFP group. No statistically significant differences (P>0.05) were observed in the EGFP expression levels between the EGFP, ultrasound + EGFP and microbubbles + EGFP groups. However, EGFP expression levels in the EGFP, ultrasound + EGFP and microbubbles + EGFP groups significantly differed (P<0.05) from that in the ultrasound + microbubbles + EGFP group. Therefore, ultrasound-mediated microbubble destruction improved EGFP transfection efficiency into the joint synovial tissues of rats with RA.

Co-expression of IL-18 binding protein and IL-4 regulates Th1/Th2 cytokine response in murine collagen-induced arthritis

We constructed a recombinant adenoviral vector containing a murine interleukin (IL)-18 binding protein (mIL-18BP) and murine IL-4 (mIL-4) fusion gene (AdmIL-18BP/mIL-4) and used a gene therapy approach to investigate the role of IL-18BP and IL-4 in modulating the T-helper1 and T-helper2 (Th1/Th2) balance in mice with collagen-induced arthritis (CIA). Mice with CIA were intra-articularly injected with 107 pfu/6 microl of either AdmIL-18BP/mIL-4, or a control adenovirus, or with the control vehicle (phosphate-buffered saline). After intra-articular gene therapy with AdmIL-18BP/mIL-4, the serum levels of tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha), gamma-interferon (IFN-gamma), IL-4, IL-10, and IL-18 in mice with CIA were assessed by ELISA. IFN-gamma-expressing and IL-4-expressing CD4+ T cells from mice splenocytes were monitored by flow cytometry. Mice with CIA at weeks 1, 2, and 4 after intra-articular injection of AdmIL-18BP/mIL-4 showed significantly increased serum concentrations of IL-4 and IL-10 (P<0.01 at all time points) but greatly decreased serum concentrations of IFN-gamma, TNF-alpha, and IL-18 (P<0.01 at all time points) compared to both the control adenovirus and phosphate-buffered saline control groups. The percentage of IFN-gamma-producing CD4+ T cells was significantly decreased in response to local AdmIL-18BP/mIL-4 treatment. The percentage of IL-4-producing CD4+ T cells increased significantly at 1 week after local injection of AdmIL-18BP/mIL-4 then returned to normal by week 4. These data indicated the significant modifying effects on the Th1/Th2 imbalance in murine CIA produced by local overexpression of IL-18BP and IL-4. Combination treatment with IL-18BP and IL-4 is a promising potential therapy for rheumatoid arthritis.

The 2003 Nicolas Andry Award. Orthopaedic gene therapy

We review progress in the field of orthopaedic gene therapy since the concept of using gene transfer to address orthopaedic problems was initiated approximately 15 years ago. The original target, arthritis, has been the subject of two successful Phase I clinical trials, and additional human studies are pending in rheumatoid arthritis and osteoarthritis. The repair of damaged musculoskeletal tissues also has proved to be a fruitful area of research, and impressive enhancement of bone healing has been achieved in preclinical models. Rapid progress also is being made in the use of gene transfer to improve cartilage repair, ligament healing, and restoration of various additional tissues, including tendon and meniscus. Other applications include intervertebral disc degeneration, aseptic loosening, osteoporosis, genetic diseases, and orthopaedic tumors. Of these various orthopaedic targets of gene therapy, tissue repair is likely to make the earliest clinical impact because it can be achieved with existing technology. Tissue repair may become one of the earliest clinical successes for gene therapy as a whole. Orthopaedics promises to be a leading discipline for the use of human gene therapy.

IL-4 adenoviral gene therapy reduces inflammation, proinflammatory cytokines, vascularization, and bony destruction in rat adjuvant-induced arthritis

IL-4 is a cytokine with anti-inflammatory properties on activated macrophages. Rheumatoid arthritis, an autoimmune inflammatory disease, is characterized by a paucity of IL-4 and an abundance of synovial macrophage-derived mediators. Herein, the effect of a single injection of adenovirus-producing rat IL-4 (AxCAIL-4) or a control virus with no inserted gene was compared with the effect of PBS injection into rat ankles. Ankles were injected before arthritis onset or at maximal inflammation. Preventatively, AxCAIL-4 reduced adjuvant-induced arthritis (AIA)- and/or AIA/adenoviral-induced ankle inflammation, decreasing articular index scores, ankle circumferences, paw volumes, radiographic scores, mean levels of monocyte chemoattractant protein-1, the number of inflammatory cells, and the number of synovial blood vessels. Therapeutically, AxCAIL-4 also decreased ankle circumferences and paw volumes in comparison with a control virus with no inserted gene and PBS groups. After arthritis onset, mean levels of TNF-alpha, IL-1beta, macrophage inflammatory protein-2, and RANTES were decreased in AxCAIL-4 rat ankle homogenates compared with PBS-treated homogenates. Thus, increased expression of IL-4 via gene therapy administered in a preventative and/or therapeutic manner reduced joint inflammation, synovial cellularity, levels of proinflammatory cytokines, vascularization, and bony destruction in rat AIA, suggesting that a similar treatment in humans may be beneficial.

Modulation of the biologic activity of the rabbit intervertebral disc by gene therapy: an in vivo study of adenovirus-mediated transfer of the human transforming growth factor beta 1 encoding gene

STUDY DESIGN

In vivo studies using a rabbit model to determine the biologic effects of direct, adenovirus-mediated transfer of a therapeutic gene to the intervertebral disc.

OBJECTIVES

1) To deliver an exogenous therapeutic gene to rabbit lumbar intervertebral discs in vivo, 2) to quantify the resulting amount of gene expression, and 3) to determine the effect on the biologic activity of the discs.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Although growth factors such as transforming growth factor beta 1 appear to have promising therapeutic properties, there currently is no practical method for sustained delivery of exogenous growth factors to the disc for the management of certain chronic types of disease (e.g., disc degeneration). A possible solution is to modify the disc cells genetically through gene transfer such that the cells manufacture the desired growth factors endogenously on a continuous basis.

METHODS

Saline, with or without virus, was injected directly into lumbar discs of 22 skeletally mature female New Zealand white rabbits. Group 1 (n = 11) received the adenovirus construct Ad/CMV-hTGF beta 1 containing the therapeutic human transforming growth factor beta 1-encoding gene. Group 2 (n = 6) received adenovirus containing the luciferase marker gene. Group 3 (n = 5) received saline only. The rabbits were killed 1 week after injection. Immunohistochemical staining for human transforming growth factor beta 1 was performed on the disc tissues of one rabbit from Group 1. Nucleus pulposus tissues from the remaining rabbits were cultured in serumless medium. Bioassays were performed to determine human transforming growth factor beta 1 production and proteoglycan synthesis.

RESULTS

Discs injected with Ad/CMV-hTGF beta 1 exhibited extensive and intense positive immunostaining for transforming growth factor beta 1. The nucleus pulposus tissues from the discs injected with Ad/CMV-hTGF beta 1 exhibited a 30-fold increase in active transforming growth factor beta 1 production, and a 5-fold increase in total (active + latent) transforming growth factor beta 1 production over that from intact control discs (P < 0.05). Furthermore, these tissues exhibited a 100% increase in proteoglycan synthesis compared with intact control tissue, which was statistically significant (P < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

The results of this study suggest that the intervertebral disc is an appropriate site for adenovirus-mediated transfer of exogenous genes and subsequent production of therapeutic growth factors. Gene therapy therefore may have useful applications for study of the basic science of the intervertebral disc and for clinical management of degenerative disc disease.

Investigational treatments in rheumatoid arthritis

The active search for new treatment modalities of established rheumatoid arthritis have created a dynamic period for rheumatology. Both promising pharmaceutical products and targeted interventions with products of the biotechnology industry are being developed. Leflunomide and the selective blockade of the cytokine tumour necrosis factor (TNF) have recently been registered in several countries and others will follow. Like all new therapeutic strategies much remains to be learned about the optimal use of these therapies and their possible limitations. The success of these interventions have shown that a complex disease such as rheumatoid arthritis that is refractory to conventional treatment can be modulated by new therapeutic strategies. This experience has also resulted in further searches for new drugs that influence those pathogenetic pathways affected by the interventions found to be effective.

Adenovirus-mediated gene transfer to nucleus pulposus cells. Implications for the treatment of intervertebral disc degeneration

STUDY DESIGN

In vitro and in vivo studies using a rabbit model were performed to determine the feasibility of adenovirus-mediated gene transfer to the intervertebral disc.

OBJECTIVES

This study was conducted to determine whether it is possible to transfer genes to cells within the intervertebral disc by direct injection of an adenovirus and to determine the duration of gene expression obtained by this method.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Although growth factors have the potential to stimulate the regeneration of nucleus pulposus, sustained delivery of growth factors to a degenerated disc is clinically unfeasible with present technology. Novel approaches such as gene transfer should be investigated as possible solutions to this problem.

METHODS

The lacZ marker gene was used to evaluate gene delivery to cells within intervertebral discs. For the in vitro study, cell cultures were established from the nucleus pulposus tissue of New Zealand white rabbits and infected with an adenovirus encoding the lacZ gene (Ad-lacZ). For the in vivo study, the anterior aspects of lumbar intervertebral discs were surgically exposed, and Ad-lacZ in saline solution was directly injected into the nucleus pulposus. An equal volume of saline only was injected into control discs. Expression of the transferred gene was detected by staining with 5-bromo-4-chloro-3-indolyl-beta-galactosidase (X-Gal).

RESULTS

The in vitro experiments confirmed that nucleus pulposus cells were efficiently transduced by an adenoviral vector carrying the lacZ gene. In vivo injection of Ad-lacZ into the nucleus pulposus resulted in the transduction of a considerable number of cells. Marker gene expression in vivo persisted at an apparently undiminished level for at least 12 weeks. No staining was noted in control discs.

CONCLUSIONS

The results show the feasibility of adenovirus-mediated gene transfer to the intervertebral disc. Expression of the marker gene persisted at least 12 weeks in vivo. This successful demonstration of exogenous gene transfer to the disc and sustained, long-term expression suggests that the adenoviral vector may be suitable for delivery of appropriate genes to the disc for the treatment of spinal disorders.

Autoimmunity, immunologic tolerance, and gene therapy

Research in our laboratory focuses on three major themes: 1. Costimulation and cell death in autoimmunity. 2. Molecular mechanisms of immunologic tolerance. 3. Gene therapy of autoimmune diseases. We have performed a large series of experiments using T cell receptor (TCR) transgenic mice examining mechanisms of autoimmunity and peripheral T cell tolerance. A major focus of our current research is to understand the roles of costimulation and cell death in T cell tolerance and T cell-mediated autoimmune diseases. This involves studies of the TCR, the costimulatory molecules, and the cytokines. We are also exploring novel strategies for the treatment of autoimmune diseases by gene transfer.

Gene therapy of single-gene disorders: preface to the special section

Gene therapy was introduced into clinical practice with great excitement, much publicity and considerable optimism in the early 1990s. Scientific evaluation of the early clinical trials has, however, greatly reduced the initial optimism. Follow-up studies have revealed that many early gene therapy trials mainly represented gene transfer into patients, possibly with short-term effects, but not true gene therapy where the course of the disease is permanently affected. This has lead to critical re-evaluation of the approaches taken. Clearly, more basic understanding is needed of the molecular mechanisms of the diseases treated. For this purpose, better animal models for human diseases are necessary. One of the biggest obstacles for gene therapy has been the lack of adequate vector systems. Development of new vectors for efficient and targeted delivery and uptake of therapeutic genes is a crucial area where progress needs to be made. The rationale for gene therapy depends largely on the type of disease to be treated. Recessively inherited single-gene disorders represent diseases where the concept of gene therapy--addition of a therapeutic gene to restore the lost function of two mutant alleles--is easily understood and rarely questioned. However, most gene therapy protocols are focused on multifactorial diseases such as malignancies where the therapeutic approach is quite different. While gene transfer technologies are being developed into truly effective gene therapy, the fight against inherited single-gene disorders also continues at population level by carrier screening and prenatal diagnostics where rapid methodological developments are taking place.

Myoblast-mediated gene transfer to the joint

Several genetic and acquired pathologic conditions of the musculoskeletal system, such as arthritis and damage to ligament, cartilage, and meniscus, may be amenable to gene therapy. Even though ex vivo gene transfer with synovial cells has been shown to deliver genes encoding for anti-arthritic proteins into the rabbit knee joint, its success has been limited by a transient transgene expression. In this study, data were investigated regarding the use of muscle cells as an alternative gene-delivery vehicle to the joint in newborn rabbit and adult severe combined immunodeficiency mice. We demonstrated that myoblasts were transduced more efficiently than synovial cells with use of the same adenoviral preparation in vitro. After intra-articular injection, the engineered muscle cells adhered to several structures in the joint, including the ligament, capsule, and synovium. In addition, myoblasts fused to form many post-mitotic myotubes and myofibers at different locations of the joint of the newborn rabbit 5 days after the injection. In the knee of the adult mouse, myoblasts fused and expressed the reporter gene for at least 35 days after the injection. The presence of post-mitotic myofibers in the knee joint raises the possibility of long-term expression of the secreted protein. Currently, numerous tissues in the joint (ligament, meniscus, and cartilage) have poor intrinsic healing capacity and frequently need surgical corrections. A stable gene-delivery vehicle to the joint producing proteins that ameliorate these different musculoskeletal conditions may change the clinical implications of these pathologies.

Amelioration of collagen-induced arthritis by CD95 (Apo-1/Fas)-ligand gene transfer

Both rheumatoid arthritis and animal models of autoimmune arthritis are characterized by hyperactivation of synovial cells and hyperplasia of the synovial membrane. The activated synovial cells produce inflammatory cytokines and degradative enzymes that lead to destruction of cartilage and bones. Effective treatment of arthritis may require elimination of most or all activated synovial cells. The death factor Fas/Apo-1 and its ligand (FasL) play pivotal roles in maintaining self-tolerance and immune privilege. Fas is expressed constitutively in most tissues, and is dramatically upregulated at the site of inflammation. In both rheumatoid arthritis and animal models of autoimmune arthritis, high levels of Fas are expressed on activated synovial cells and infiltrating leukocytes in the inflamed joints. Unlike Fas, however, the levels of FasL expressed in the arthritic joints are extremely low, and most activated synovial cells survive despite high levels of Fas expression. To upregulate FasL expression in the arthritic joints, we have generated a recombinant replication-defective adenovirus carrying FasL gene; injection of the FasL virus into inflamed joints conferred high levels of FasL expression, induced apoptosis of synovial cells, and ameliorated collagen-induced arthritis in DBA/1 mice. The Fas-ligand virus also inhibited production of interferon-gamma by collagen-specific T cells. Coadministration of Fas-immunoglobulin fusion protein with the Fas-ligand virus prevented these effects, demonstrating the specificity of the Fas-ligand virus. Thus, FasL gene transfer at the site of inflammation effectively ameliorates autoimmune disease.

Progress in development of herpes simplex virus gene vectors for treatment of rheumatoid arthritis

Arthritis is presently incurable and poorly treatable, but there are good grounds for expecting gene therapy to improve matters considerably. Although local ex vivo delivery of anti-arthritic genes to the synovial lining of joints has shown considerable promise, intraarticular gene delivery may be desirable. Herpes simplex virus (HSV) may be a viable vector for in vivo transfer of anti-arthritic genes to joints. HSV has the advantages of high infectivity, large carrying capacity and high titer. The large packaging capacity would permit the inclusion of multiple anti-arthritic genes and necessary regulatory elements. Recombinant vectors produced by this laboratory infect synovial cells efficiently, permitting prolonged expression of transgenes in vitro and in vivo without evidence of cytotoxicity. Further improvements to this vector system include taking advantage of an endogenous HSV 'stealthing' gene, ICP47, which interferes with formation of antigen-class I complexes. Inclusion of inducible promoters to appropriately regulate expression of anti-arthritic genes should further improve this system.

Direct gene delivery to synovium. An evaluation of potential vectors in vitro and in vivo

OBJECTIVE

To assess the abilities of various vectors to transfer genes to the synovial lining of joints.

METHODS

Vectors derived from retrovirus, adenovirus, and herpes simplex virus as well as cationic liposomes and naked plasmid DNA were evaluated. Each construct contained the lac Z marker gene; and one retroviral construct, and one plasmid also contained a gene encoding human interleukin-1 receptor antagonist. Gene expression was under the control of the human cytomegalovirus promoter in all vectors except the retrovirus, where the endogenous 5' long terminal repeat was retained as the promoter. Cultures of rabbit synovial fibroblasts were exposed to these vectors and stained with X-gal to identify lac Z+ cells. Vectors were then injected directly into rabbits' knee joints, and gene transfer and expression were assessed by X-gal staining and polymerase chain reaction (PCR).

RESULTS

Adenovirus was a highly effective vector both in vitro and in vivo, with lac Z gene expression persisting for at least 28 days. However, an inflammatory response was noted in vivo. Cells infected in vitro and in vivo with herpes simplex virus also expressed the lac Z gene at high levels, but expression was limited by cytotoxicity. Retroviruses, in contrast, were effective only under in vitro conditions, permitting cell division. Liposomes gave variable in vitro results; when injected into joints in vivo, gene expression was low and was detectable for only a few days, even though a PCR signal persisted for at least 28 days. Unexpectedly, plasmid DNA was captured by the synoviocytes and expressed transiently following intraarticular injection.

CONCLUSION

None of the vectors was ideal for in vivo gene delivery to synovium, although adenovirus was clearly the most effective of those tested. Retroviruses, although poor vectors for in vivo gene delivery, are well suited for ex vivo gene transfer to the synovial lining of joints.

Evidence for insufficient chondrocytic differentiation during repair of full-thickness defects of articular cartilage

The main objective of this study was to characterize the cellular phenotypes in the repair tissue of full-thickness defects of articular cartilage by histologic and molecular biologic techniques. Healing of the defects in the articular cartilage of the knee joints of 12 rabbits was analyzed at days 3, 7, 14, 28 and 50 using histology and Northern analysis of mRNA levels for type I, II and III collagens and osteonectin. The cellular source of each mRNA was determined by in situ hybridization. Two novel cDNA clones for rabbit type II and III collagen mRNAs were constructed to obtain species-specific hybridization probes. The repair tissue of full-thickness defects consisted of two types of tissue. At the bottom of the defect, bone-derived cells with high levels of type I collagen and osteonectin mRNA were actively producing new osteoid, while superficially a slow transition from a fibrin clot into undifferentiated mesenchyme with cells containing type III collagen mRNA was observed. This tissue subsequently became fibrocartilaginous, with small groups of cells turning on the transcription of the type II collagen gene and acquiring a phenotype typical for hyaline cartilage. The data suggest that small clusters of cells in the repair tissue of full-thickness articular cartilage defects are capable of turning on an apparently correct chondrocytic phenotype. The low transcription level of the type II collagen gene suggests, however, that insufficient amounts of fundamentally important regulatory factors or progenitor cells are present in the repair tissue. In the future, such factors should be administrable into the joint by novel therapeutic means.